Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by altdataseller on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:56AM
(#40265789)
This problem is exasperated by the fact that recruiters are often the ones getting laid off first in a downturn or cost effiency initiative. So there’s even less humans filtering through applications.
Even though it’s an issue I really don’t see companies spending a ton of time and energy fixing it. As mentioned in the article, they could simply stop posting jobs on LinkedIn or rely only on inbound candidates. It’s not rocket science. Just like dating, if you get bombarded with peoole knocking on your door, simply stop putting yourself out there.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by mathgeek on Sunday May 05, 2024 @06:02PM
(#40268913)
Correct, although IMHO it’s also fine to use exacerbation in this specific example (if you see the problem from a process standpoint instead of the frustration faced by job seekers and recruiters).
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by datadrivenangel on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:42AM
(#40265664)
To summarize the article though: Online hiring continues to be overwhelmed by huge numbers of low quality applications, now with some extra AI tools that make it easier to lie about your experience.
Same issue as before, now wrapped up in OpenAI API calls.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by mistrial9 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @12:29PM
(#40266069)
you forgot the second part -- a rush by industry management to open the gates to low-skill people for lower pay, while specifically and exactly firing or replacing more experienced people who ask for higher compensation and employee rights (for example working parents or a slower pace over a long time)
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by Simulacra on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:48AM
(#40265731)
Serves them right. Employers have been using AI and algorithms to weed out resumes/applications for years. To the point that the only way to get seen by an actual human is the game the system.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by bastawhiz on Sunday May 05, 2024 @12:01PM
(#40265834)
Exactly, I came here looking for this comment. Many companies have been using AI tools for years to power recruiting. Now they're upset that candidates are using the same technology. The recruiters turned their profession into a tit for tat arms race.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by ToucanLoucan on Sunday May 05, 2024 @12:38PM
(#40266137)
Hard agree. It’s infuriating that automation is continually added to human centric processes that it is ill-suited and anti-social to be used in, very much including most LLM applications, always in the name of more bloody cost-cutting that almost never leads to lower prices for consumers, just more yachts for the executive class.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by LikelyABurner on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:31PM
(#40266573)
The thing that especially infuriates me is recruiters in this article turning around and trying to throw LinkedIn under the bus.
No one likes the nightmare dystopia of a platform that is LinkedIn. The only reason most people I know have LinkedIn accounts in the first place is because HR types have outsourced so much of their job to LinkedIn that it's viewed as professional suicide to not have a LinkedIn profile with 100s of contacts in this industry.
Recruiters don't like the GenAI and Easy Apply features on LinkedIn, it makes their jobs more difficult? Then stop making LinkedIn a mandatory account for tech workers. You have NO ONE to blame but yourselves.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by surfingdino on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:22PM
(#40267924)
What gets me is that they request a CV even though my whole work history is already on LI. My CV is just a reformatted LI profile. But then again, recruiters are mostly sociology, political science, or philosophy grads who chose an easy degree thinking they were clever and found themselves being used as a mop in the Victorian sweatshop that is the recruitment industry.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by rad_gruchalski on Sunday May 05, 2024 @08:32PM
(#40269958)
They require your cv for at least two reasons: 1) to figure out how serious you are, or do you expect they send a screenshot of your LinkedIn profile to their client? if you want to talk to their client, do your homework, if you can’t be bothered, well, will you be bothered when you join? 2) due diligence-are you who you say you are? is your cv in line with your LinkedIn, or are you just one of those AI generated clowns?
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by IshKebab on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:46PM
(#40268180)
I like linkedin. It got me my current job. I get a constant stream of recruiters looking for people in my field; if I want a new job I'm pretty sure I can just reply to a few of them and not have to actually apply at all.
Just don't read any of the nonsense that people post.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by KallDrexx on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:47PM
(#40268191)
Two wrongs don't make a right.
AI being weaponized on the application side hurts us all, and leads to an environment that's extremely difficult to get noticed in as a job seeker. Yes, networking helps but that's not always possible, especially if you are trying to change industries or have generally worked with smaller companies where your networking doesn't expand out much.
It also leads to less diverse environments where hiring managers only look at resumes given by friends or friends of friends.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by neilv on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:56AM
(#40265787)
> That came after LinkedIn began rolling out a new set of generative AI tools for recruiters to source candidates in October. With the sourcing tool, recruiters can search a phrase like “I want to hire engineers in Texas,” and profiles of people that may meet those criteria appear, as do other specific skills that may be related to the role. They can also send messages written with generative AI and set automatic follow-up messages.
What are better alternatives to LinkedIn, for people who want to get that rare serendipitous message from a recruiter?
(Not just another company that wants to behave like LinkedIn when they can get away with it, but that wants to be and is a lot better.)
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by xw38011 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @12:51PM
(#40266246)
> What are better alternatives to LinkedIn, for people who want to get that rare serendipitous message from a recruiter?
The only one I know of is to have a personal social network of people who know you and are directly familiar with your work. Every rare serendipitous message from a recruiter I've received resulted from a referral from someone I directly knew.
But rare is probably the correct qualifier. I have 25 years experience, I've received four, followed up on two and only one resulted in me changing jobs. None came before I had 10 years of experience. YMMV
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by joshstrange on Sunday May 05, 2024 @12:55PM
(#40266274)
Hacker News monthly threads for “Who wants to be hired” and “Who is hiring”. That’s how I got hired for my current job (2019) and that’s how I’m hiring currently.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by nradov on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:47PM
(#40266694)
Most industries have some kind of private discussion forums, which could be sponsored by a professional organization or related media company or just some guy. Those used to be email lists and web discussion forums but now some have moved to Slack or Discord. Find those forums for industries where you're interested in working and start actively participating.
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by elicksaur on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:52PM
(#40267647)
+1! think your local tech scene (my city has a general dev slack), language or framework specific chats for web or mobile dev, hackathons/conferences, etc.
Would personally stay away from anyone offering to be part of a “community” for a fee
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by neilv on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:35PM
(#40268078)
Is there an alternative we can practically move to that will turn LinkedIn into an abandoned property like MySpace?
(Ideal would be a distributed approach with semantic Web and such. But I'd settle for a centralized site that wanted to be a lot better, and was capable of that.)
Re:Recruiters Are Going Analog to Fight the AI Application O...
by neilv on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:49AM
(#40265739)
> That came after LinkedIn began rolling out a new set of generative AI tools for recruiters to source candidates in October. With the sourcing tool, recruiters can search a phrase like “I want to hire engineers in Texas,” and profiles of people that may meet those criteria appear, as do other specific skills that may be related to the role. They can also send messages written with generative AI and set automatic follow-up messages.
I should do a startup around a browser plugin that denylists people known to use LLMs like this.
The service would share information among users, so that known trash can be blocked proactively.
(Sadly, squatters are on "TrashBurner.com". Whatever the startup is named, it can later expand to also consider domain name squatters to be trash.)
Even though it’s an issue I really don’t see companies spending a ton of time and energy fixing it. As mentioned in the article, they could simply stop posting jobs on LinkedIn or rely only on inbound candidates. It’s not rocket science. Just like dating, if you get bombarded with peoole knocking on your door, simply stop putting yourself out there.
Same issue as before, now wrapped up in OpenAI API calls.
I’ve had interviews where AI use was encouraged. I’ve used a coderpad screenshare that had an LLM tab you could write with.
so in this article, where they mention some of the respondents disclosed using AI, it doesnt say if that was a “good” or “bad” thing for that company
its not accurate to assume, despite the article reinforcing a bias towards it being a problem
No one likes the nightmare dystopia of a platform that is LinkedIn. The only reason most people I know have LinkedIn accounts in the first place is because HR types have outsourced so much of their job to LinkedIn that it's viewed as professional suicide to not have a LinkedIn profile with 100s of contacts in this industry.
Recruiters don't like the GenAI and Easy Apply features on LinkedIn, it makes their jobs more difficult? Then stop making LinkedIn a mandatory account for tech workers. You have NO ONE to blame but yourselves.
Just don't read any of the nonsense that people post.
AI being weaponized on the application side hurts us all, and leads to an environment that's extremely difficult to get noticed in as a job seeker. Yes, networking helps but that's not always possible, especially if you are trying to change industries or have generally worked with smaller companies where your networking doesn't expand out much.
It also leads to less diverse environments where hiring managers only look at resumes given by friends or friends of friends.
What are better alternatives to LinkedIn, for people who want to get that rare serendipitous message from a recruiter?
(Not just another company that wants to behave like LinkedIn when they can get away with it, but that wants to be and is a lot better.)
The only one I know of is to have a personal social network of people who know you and are directly familiar with your work. Every rare serendipitous message from a recruiter I've received resulted from a referral from someone I directly knew.
But rare is probably the correct qualifier. I have 25 years experience, I've received four, followed up on two and only one resulted in me changing jobs. None came before I had 10 years of experience. YMMV
No idea which experience is more typical.
Would personally stay away from anyone offering to be part of a “community” for a fee
(Ideal would be a distributed approach with semantic Web and such. But I'd settle for a centralized site that wanted to be a lot better, and was capable of that.)
I should do a startup around a browser plugin that denylists people known to use LLMs like this.
The service would share information among users, so that known trash can be blocked proactively.
(Sadly, squatters are on "TrashBurner.com". Whatever the startup is named, it can later expand to also consider domain name squatters to be trash.)