But that’s really beside the point. If you are like millions of other Americans filing W2s, the fact that you work for your employer isn’t a secret. Your salary isn’t a secret. Most people will take the standard deduction. There’s no reason why that can’t be the default. It’s not a privacy violation for the IRS to use that info to make peoples lives easier.
I would prefer if it was. It's even worse than that, the government has entitled itself to be a party to every transaction over $600, so even the self employed have to shoulder this unseemly burden.
> Your salary isn’t a secret
It is. It's a shared secret. Again, I would prefer if I didn't have to do this. My salary is not at all the same as my "taxable income." It puts me in a position to have to justify my filings after the fact to an entity that only has access to half my relevant information.
Before all of this unconstitutional collection of Americans information the government had to have a target and go out and collect and tabulate the information.
Now it’s a select where citizen does thing x over y threshold. How is this not changing the game?
Even the constitutionality of an income tax was in question until 1913 and the 16th Amendment.
People today assume the past was a lot more surveilled than it was. The government (at any level) often didn't even have a record of people's births until they needed to interact with the government for some reason, even in the early 20th century. That was largely changed by Social Security, and people at the time and since complained that its foothold would begin a slippery slope of government intrusion into every aspect of their lives.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_State...
I believe the IRS is even informed of things like 401k disbursement and stock sales. Meaning most people wouldn't have to submit for those either.
The gains of simplify the tax code are gargantuan, but unfortunately, the wealthy and powerful organizations benefit from the current system, and would be hurt financially by simplifying it. So, it will never be simplified.
You still had to file taxes, though, so they would know about your income, if only a year behind. I read somewhere that tax withholding only started during WWII (and it was supposed to be temporary). It's really the withholding that would give the IRS the information needed to file your taxes in advance, so it's only a fairly recent possibility.
What about rental income?
What about expenses related to rental properties?
Lots of things the government doesn’t know…
Nobody is saying filing taxes should never be necessary. Only that it shouldn’t be necessary for most people.
The flow should be… Employer and financial institutions send info to IRS (they mostly do already). Then, in January, IRS sends a “Is this correct?” notice to residents. If correct, no action is needed. If not correct, then make adjustments.
- IRS pre-fills all it knows about you
- you log into to IRS web site to check if everything is correct, and provide additional data or correct invalid data
- submit
Oh look. By implementing this you may join Sweden and a bunch of other countries in the 21st century.
free-file is estimated to cover 47% of Americans. we fund public schools even though a significantly smaller proportion of Americans are children. you would have a hard time finding any government service that applies to 100% of people
Might as well say "Maybe instead of changing the way we file taxes, we solve world hunger"
(I say this while voting for small government & making efforts to preserve my privacy)
I've lived in Sweden where taxes are not just automatically filed but every citizen can trivially look up anyone's tax returns and nobody ever saw it as the government being intimately entangled with anyone's life.
Privacy violation would be to look into how and on what you spend your money, not that everyone pays their share of taxes. That tells you nothing about what people spend their money on. Merely that they aren't avoiding paying their part. I don't see the problem with the government automatically doing my taxes or anyone being able to see that.
Are income levels not deserving of privacy?
"Of course" makes it sound like it is obviously / objectively true, but it is a sentiment that is not necessarily true, either in the past, or even in the present everywhere on the planet.
> your address, phone number, income, etc should all be private just because the phone companies shared this didn't mean it's a good idea
This information was public in the past before the phone companies existed. May I introduce you to the concept of city directories:
> A city directory is a listing of residents, streets, businesses, organizations or institutions, giving their location in a city. It may be arranged alphabetically or geographically or in other ways.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_directory
> City Directories were created for salesmen, merchants, and other interested in contacting residents of an area. They are arranged alphabetically giving lists of names and addresses. These often list the adult residents of a city or area.
* https://www.familysearch.org/en/wiki/City_Directories
They can date back to (at least) the 1800s and continued into the twentieth century:
> City directories were published yearly. The Archives has them from 1834 to 2001 (except for a few years in the 1830s, 1840s, and 1850s, and in 1987, when they were not published).
* https://www.toronto.ca/city-government/accountability-operat...
... No? I don't think so, anyway. Maybe if people understood how obscenely unequal our society is, it would go part of the way toward fixing that.
Even your sense that you should hide it is in service of this and the effort to get people tearing each other down is also just a good way to depress salaries.
Sweden also doesn’t have secret ballot
In Sweden, anyone can look up your address, phone number, social security number, your car registration etc etc
This is not cool or desirable
Swedes have a highly developed superiority complex and ability to perform mental gymnastics about the flaws of their country and ways of doing things. No sane person from any other country in the world would consider a system where voters must, in public and under the active scrutiny of other voters and local election officials (who are themselves politicians and party members) pick ballots for the party you intend to vote for and then bring it into the “secret” booth. Any child or idiot can see that’s not secret other than in the most distorted and disingenuous sense of the word.
> blank ones if you want to write down the party of your choice
this can and does risk resulting in the vote not being counted (due to alleged illegibility, a tiny spelling error or whatever)
> You could bring your own ballot if you so choose
same thing, your own ballot could be considered illegitimate + even in the best case that you obtain a real lawful ballot, only a tiny fraction of people are willing and able to go through the trouble of doing so + again, by requesting a ballot, secrecy is out the window
> or vote pretty much anywhere else than were you live during a ~ three week long period
the suggestions just keep getting more and more ridiculous - no one should have to do any of this! everyone should be able to just rock up and vote with secrecy preserved, without having to prepare or use all these hacks
France works exactly the way you have described Sweden so far.
As per my prior comment directed at you, you have been reminded that the improvement you asked for had been implemented into law.
As per the same comment, the situation for new parties have thereby become worse. You are sure to have experienced the same problems we experienced when getting the Pirate party into parliament when you got the Sweden Democrats through the system.
It will probably have a negative effect on the ability for smaller parties to get started.
It takes very little to deanonymize things like healthcare records with this information as was demonstrated going back to the 1990s.
Is that true? There's no one, not one person in Sweden, who sees that as government overreach?
Scary if true.
I also don’t know what’s wrong with hearing the opinion of a jet-setting cosmopolitan anyhow.
Rich people in the Nordics hold their wealth in foreign companies as retained earnings, and thus that wealth accrues gains/dividends tax free and remains invisible until they sell off a small portion for the purpose of buying something.
It's "transparency" only for the plebs. Americans cannot do this, as they are subject to global tax and extra punitive taxation on foreign withheld earnings.
Also, Swedes don't have the same level of real estate transparency that there is in America (property tax assessments put a public value on everyone's holdings in the US). Wealthy folks holding real estate between different countries in Europe makes the whole situation more shadowy than you might think.
They cannot do everyone's taxes since what they know about many individuals is incomplete.
> should we really have that little privacy?
Put that way, the answer is no. On the other hand, virtually everyone demands services from their government and very few people want those services to be transactional (e.g. most people demand roads, few people want to pay based upon their usage of those roads). That means the government needs some form of revenue. For various reasons, it has been decided that a person's income should be a portion of those revenues. In order to ensure that people are paying their dues, the government needs to collect some information. Are there other ways the government could get revenues? Sure, but all of them are going to be problematic in some form or other.
> Of course, those ideas, liberty and privacy, small government, etc., isn't really fashionable with the latest generations and most people would gladly give up their freedom and privacy to save having to fill out some paperwork.
One has to be careful about generalizations. Even though a desire for liberty and privacy may be universally appealing, we would find that people's views on what those terms mean varies from generation to generation and from individual to individual. Note that I said the meaning changes, not a person's desire for it. As for the desire for small government, well, some people want small government and other people don't. It is a far less universal ideal.
No, just a singular reason: Prohibition.
Enter the shiny new income tax, passed just a few years before (1916). This had been sold to the public using Bernie Sanders-style "millionaires and billionaires" rhetoric, but, as is the inevitable way with such things, it was soon being applied to thousandaires and hundredaires. :-)
No, for most individuals it is complete. Most people don’t own stocks directly (only an estimated 21% do)[1], and the ones who don’t are not probable to deal with complexly taxable transactions as the norm.
[1] https://www.axios.com/2023/10/18/percentage-americans-own-st...
For the vast majority of people they have all the info needed. Hardly anyone can take any deductions other than the standard deduction anymore, so that's covered. For income, most people have W-2 jobs so that's covered and all financial institutions send 1099s to the IRS with all your interest, dividend and stock transactions so that's covered too.
Your job is it then to correct things, fix wrong ones and submit what they couldn’t get automatically
The ATO website is also veeeery nice! I was surprised how simple of a task doing taxes was
Your negative freedom and ownership of property is recognized and enforced by the tax-funded awesome power of the state. If you like small government there is no lack of countries that you can emigrate too where the internationally-recognized government is too weak to enforce its protection over much of its society. These are usually places that are too unstable to be palatable to someone from a developed nation.
> should we really have that little privacy?
As someone else mentioned, the government already has to know that to know that you are paying the right amount of tax given your means. Alternatively, consider simplifying tax laws so that it needs to know less. Also, look at regulation that limits what the government can do based on the information that it has on you; for that matter, businesses too, for privacy's sake.
Eventually, privacy was eroded away year after year to the point where the government now knows an extreme amount about each citizen.
I guess I'd refrain the question - instead of asking why do we need to do taxes when the government knows everything about us that they could do it for us, should we really have that little privacy? Maybe instead of changing the way we file taxes, we change the way the government is intimately entangled with our lives?
Of course, those ideas, liberty and privacy, small government, etc., isn't really fashionable with the latest generations and most people would gladly give up their freedom and privacy to save having to fill out some paperwork.