News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by Barrin92 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:51PM (#40182878)
>we change the way the government is intimately entangled with our lives?

I've lived in Sweden where taxes are not just automatically filed but every citizen can trivially look up anyone's tax returns and nobody ever saw it as the government being intimately entangled with anyone's life.

Privacy violation would be to look into how and on what you spend your money, not that everyone pays their share of taxes. That tells you nothing about what people spend their money on. Merely that they aren't avoiding paying their part. I don't see the problem with the government automatically doing my taxes or anyone being able to see that.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by RiceRichardJ on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:58PM (#40182960)
Swedish views on privacy don’t necessarily apply outside of Sweden.

Are income levels not deserving of privacy?

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:31PM (#40183221)
Is your address? Your ssn? Your phone number? In Sweden, anyone can look it up.

https://ratsit.se

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by dantheman on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:36PM (#40183791)
of course your address, phone number, income, etc should all be private just because the phone companies shared this didn't mean it's a good idea; and they always provided a way to be unlisted
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by throw0101c on Sunday April 28, 2024 @08:04AM (#40187985)
> of course

"Of course" makes it sound like it is obviously / objectively true, but it is a sentiment that is not necessarily true, either in the past, or even in the present everywhere on the planet.

> your address, phone number, income, etc should all be private just because the phone companies shared this didn't mean it's a good idea

This information was public in the past before the phone companies existed. May I introduce you to the concept of city directories:

> A city directory is a listing of residents, streets, businesses, organizations or institutions, giving their location in a city. It may be arranged alphabetically or geographically or in other ways.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_directory

> City Directories were created for salesmen, merchants, and other interested in contacting residents of an area. They are arranged alphabetically giving lists of names and addresses. These often list the adult residents of a city or area.

* https://www.familysearch.org/en/wiki/City_Directories

They can date back to (at least) the 1800s and continued into the twentieth century:

> City directories were published yearly. The Archives has them from 1834 to 2001 (except for a few years in the 1830s, 1840s, and 1850s, and in 1987, when they were not published).

* https://www.toronto.ca/city-government/accountability-operat...

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by ForHackernews on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:51PM (#40183905)
> Are income levels not deserving of privacy?

... No? I don't think so, anyway. Maybe if people understood how obscenely unequal our society is, it would go part of the way toward fixing that.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by XorNot on Saturday April 27, 2024 @09:27PM (#40185183)
The idea that they are is a construct for the benefit of employers, not workers.

Even your sense that you should hide it is in service of this and the effort to get people tearing each other down is also just a good way to depress salaries.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:11PM (#40183050)
Uh plenty of Sweden see that as a huge invasion of privacy

Sweden also doesn’t have secret ballot

In Sweden, anyone can look up your address, phone number, social security number, your car registration etc etc

This is not cool or desirable

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by ghaff on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:08PM (#40183564)
If you own property in the US, I can look up your address, your landline if you still have one, probably not that hard to find SSN, etc.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by ImJamal on Saturday April 27, 2024 @10:53PM (#40185623)
If you own property in your name you could look up your address. Some people do not directly own their house though.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by thfuran on Sunday April 28, 2024 @02:07AM (#40186382)
Approximately 0% of people have property in a trust instead of in their own name.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by nxm on Sunday April 28, 2024 @05:25AM (#40187227)
The SSN is not something you should be able to find easily
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bananskalhalk on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:15PM (#40183628)
Secret ballot was introduced 1866 in Sweden. I think we were the third country in the world to do so.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:51PM (#40183899)
Sweden has never had secret ballot. The “Valmyndigheten” election authority themselves have criticized the lack of secrecy and general chaos with Sweden’s ballots. But what do they know? They only administer the elections.

Swedes have a highly developed superiority complex and ability to perform mental gymnastics about the flaws of their country and ways of doing things. No sane person from any other country in the world would consider a system where voters must, in public and under the active scrutiny of other voters and local election officials (who are themselves politicians and party members) pick ballots for the party you intend to vote for and then bring it into the “secret” booth. Any child or idiot can see that’s not secret other than in the most distorted and disingenuous sense of the word.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by AshamedCaptain on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:21PM (#40184124)
Can't you just pick ballots for more than one party before going into the "secret" booth?
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:38PM (#40184223)
This is the most common counter, but it doesn’t change the fact that the ballot is not secret. Again, you’re picking ballots in public and under the active scrutiny of other voters and election officials, and there is a strong and palpable disincentive to pick ballots from the “wrong” parties, and a strong and palpable incentive for showing your neighbors and friends you pick only the correct ballots before going into the booth. Smaller parties have to come up with nationwide ballots themselves, which is often impossible. People can and do also vandalize, hide, throw away and illegally modify the ballots such that voters who show up can not vote according to their wishes. I have personally experienced TWICE having to ask the election officials out loud to restock the ballots for the party I intended to vote for, and so have countless others. I could go on. These are all known problems that the election authority themselves have pointed out should be rectified, but they never will be, because the system is working as intended. (discouraging votes for the wrong parties)
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bananskalhalk on Monday April 29, 2024 @02:26PM (#40202062)
Yeah, and blank ones if you want to write down the party of your choice. You could bring your own ballot if you so choose, or vote pretty much anywhere else than were you live during a ~ three week long period.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @02:55PM (#40214771)
yeah... or you could just implement secret ballot like all sane countries have

> blank ones if you want to write down the party of your choice

this can and does risk resulting in the vote not being counted (due to alleged illegibility, a tiny spelling error or whatever)

> You could bring your own ballot if you so choose

same thing, your own ballot could be considered illegitimate + even in the best case that you obtain a real lawful ballot, only a tiny fraction of people are willing and able to go through the trouble of doing so + again, by requesting a ballot, secrecy is out the window

> or vote pretty much anywhere else than were you live during a ~ three week long period

the suggestions just keep getting more and more ridiculous - no one should have to do any of this! everyone should be able to just rock up and vote with secrecy preserved, without having to prepare or use all these hacks

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by AshamedCaptain on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @04:35PM (#40215980)
Which country has "secret ballot" then ? Cause what you described as imperfect is the system that is present in all countries I've ever been in, and I've been in the majority of western europe...
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bedobi on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @11:00PM (#40219067)
Almost all actual democracies have secret ballot? There’s any number of ways to ensure secrecy is preserved at all times by default. (unlike in Sweden, where virtually no votes are secret because it requires hacking the process)
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by AshamedCaptain on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @05:35AM (#40221196)
Can you point a country and how they ensure secret ballot?

France works exactly the way you have described Sweden so far.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bananskalhalk on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @03:21PM (#40228037)
Sweden doesn't even work the way he describes any longer. The changes he claims he wants are already in place.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bananskalhalk on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @03:05PM (#40227803)
I am at loss here.

As per my prior comment directed at you, you have been reminded that the improvement you asked for had been implemented into law.

As per the same comment, the situation for new parties have thereby become worse. You are sure to have experienced the same problems we experienced when getting the Pirate party into parliament when you got the Sweden Democrats through the system.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by bananskalhalk on Monday April 29, 2024 @03:18PM (#40202752)
The government agency was tasked with finding ways of improving their work. One of the things they recommended was for the selection of ballots to be hidden, which has been implemented since then.

It will probably have a negative effect on the ability for smaller parties to get started.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by noodlesUK on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:08PM (#40184037)
Party affiliation, which is mandatory in some U.S. states for voters (e.g. Oregon) is available to anyone who wants to access the registration dataset from the Secretary of State.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by ghaff on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:39PM (#40184235)
I assume you can also be independent though maybe there are implication for voting in primaries. At least in MA being on voting lists puts your address in the available registration dataset.

It takes very little to deanonymize things like healthcare records with this information as was demonstrated going back to the 1990s.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by noodlesUK on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:49PM (#40184302)
You can be unaffiliated (or a member of the confusingly named Independent Party) but you’re right, you then can’t vote in any primary elections.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by rufus_foreman on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:22PM (#40183129)
>> nobody ever saw it as the government being intimately entangled with anyone's life

Is that true? There's no one, not one person in Sweden, who sees that as government overreach?

Scary if true.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by VS1999 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:05PM (#40183006)
That you've "lived in sweden" implies you have the luxury of hopping to whatever country suits you most. Nobody wants to hear a cosmopolitan's take on how we have too much privacy and how the government should be more involved in our lives. If the government mistreats you, you can just go to a nicer country.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by xu_ituairo on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:44PM (#40183342)
Your reply feels unkind. They just said they lived in Sweden for a time. I don’t think it implies luxury or that they’re a wealthy jet-setting cosmopolitan. It could be for one of many reasons.

I also don’t know what’s wrong with hearing the opinion of a jet-setting cosmopolitan anyhow.

Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by noodlesUK on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:10PM (#40184050)
Around 500 million people living in the EU have that privilege. It’s pretty common for people to exercise it and in no way makes you part of the jet set.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by VS1999 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @07:09PM (#40184425)
I see. I'm probably wrong then. In my country only the rich or elite have the opportunity to live abroad.
Re:Claiming high user satisfaction, IRS will decide on renew... by pembrook on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:59PM (#40183496)
Except in Sweden, what this means in practice, is that you only see the income/cap gains taxes paid of ordinary middle class people.

Rich people in the Nordics hold their wealth in foreign companies as retained earnings, and thus that wealth accrues gains/dividends tax free and remains invisible until they sell off a small portion for the purpose of buying something.

It's "transparency" only for the plebs. Americans cannot do this, as they are subject to global tax and extra punitive taxation on foreign withheld earnings.

Also, Swedes don't have the same level of real estate transparency that there is in America (property tax assessments put a public value on everyone's holdings in the US). Wealthy folks holding real estate between different countries in Europe makes the whole situation more shadowy than you might think.