News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by ergonaught on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:14PM (#40176813)
The idea that 400K units of this is a "big flop" requires some sort of fundamentally broken thinking (that applies to AAPL as well, if they have a similar view), wildly out of touch with reality.

The reality distortion field is dead. Perhaps the memo was missed.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @12:29AM (#40177242)
Apple is so huge, with such a large and fervent fanbase, they could literally release the MacBook Wheel per the Onion it would still probably sell a couple hundred thousand units.

It's not like they're selling at small volumes at first, i.e. to early adopters who love it and will convince their friends to be later adopters. Early adopters are mostly either returning it or saying it's basically shelfware now.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by fullspectrumdev on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:22AM (#40177998)
You literally cannot buy the AVP outside the American market at this time.

So it’s limited as hell in terms of distribution

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by philipwhiuk on Saturday April 27, 2024 @07:07AM (#40179046)
But that's because they need super specialised stuff in terms of lens.

That's not a defense of the product, it's a criticism.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by Fluorescence on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:14AM (#40178802)
For others who also didn't know this one:

https://www.theonion.com/apple-introduces-revolutionary-new-...

"It remains to be seen if the Apple Wheel will catch on in the business world where people use computers for actual work instead of just dicking around" resonates for whenever Apple/Meta claim a VR headset is a productivity/business tool.

"everything is just a few 100 clicks away"... sounds like Apple's regulatory compliance. Might become mandatory if you want to use side-loading/3rd party app stores.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by fullshark on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:56PM (#40177064)
The article says they spent 10 billion developing the Vision pro. If they sell less than a million units and no one is actually using it (so there's no software ecosystem being developed for it) then it's a flop.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by not_your_vase on Saturday April 27, 2024 @01:35AM (#40177548)

  > 10 billion
What an interesting number! The original iPhone is reported to cost only $150M (~$225M today) to develop. Sure, Apple from 2006 is not the same as today's Apple, but I find it still amusing that they try to create a new revolution with throwing money around, instead of a real new idea, like the iPhone was.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by wyldberry on Saturday April 27, 2024 @01:42AM (#40177577)
The expectation and capability of the first iPhone is a minuscule fraction of what's expected of the Vision Pro. The iPhone wasn't a new idea, there were other smart phones before it, but they hit it out of the park with the interface and understanding what customers would want, before they wanted it.

The entire computing environment has evolved dramatically since then, as have the expectations of the once scrappy underdog to the second largest company in the world. At some point, AR / VR will eventually become good enough, and it's good that they are investing in it. It forces Meta to innovate and become better as well.

I personally hope that it will get to the point that i can go anywhere and take my ideal workspace setup with me and lose little to no productivity.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by leptons on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:25AM (#40178013)
> understanding what customers would want, before they wanted it.

"relentlessly telling customers what they want, regardless of what they might need."

The walled garden doesn't appeal to most people, which is one reason why worldwide Apple has a very small market share. Price is another, and paying more for a device I have far less control over never made sense to me.

>I personally hope that it will get to the point that i can go anywhere and take my ideal workspace setup with me and lose little to no productivity.

My laptop has 3 very portable screens. I don't have to strap anything to my head to be productive. Sure, I'm not going to spread out 3 screens on an airplane, but I'm not typically going to work if I'm on an airplane (YMMV). I'm not sure how you get to be productive living inside a strap-on-bubble even with the passthrough video. It just seems so clumsy. Maybe it will improve, but that's a big maybe and I'm not sure Apple is going to be the one to perfect that experience, especially when their platform is so curated. Where am I going to run my servers and software development stack, on the Vision Pro? No. I still need a laptop to be productive, no matter where I am.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by wyldberry on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:57AM (#40178193)
> worldwide small market share

It's a premium product. Iphone has the majority of US (and thus wealthy) customers. It's seen as premium in other wealthy nations as well. Second largest company in the world by market cap means that they clearly operate with more than enough customers who matter to get things done.

I used to be a hardcore linux everything person. Over time I stepped into the walled garden and found I enjoyed not having to constantly think about the interop of everything. It's different for everyone.

> Where am I going to run my servers and software development stack?

Right now you need a laptop. Rapidly approaching a future where devcontainers and remote dev servers will let you dev anywhere you want, where you just choose the interface of choice. You may want a laptop,

I may want to have multiple screens for analyzing data, modifying code, and doing other operationsy things.

The point overall is: Apple is good at shipping products that people want and iterating and improving them. That is undeniable. It does take time to iterate and improve, and Vision will probably get there because this pattern of product is in their DNA.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by joshstrange on Saturday April 27, 2024 @06:12AM (#40178794)
> The walled garden doesn't appeal to most people, which is one reason why worldwide Apple has a very small market share. Price is another, and paying more for a device I have far less control over never made sense to me.

Take off your HN glasses for a few minutes. I don’t think the vast majority (I’m talking 80-90%+) of people could even tell you “walled garden” means. It doesn’t even start to factor into most people’s buying experiences. In fact, to the average consumer Apple and Google’s policies for the App Store are identical.

Apple could allow sideloading tomorrow and it would not make an appreciable difference in sales worldwide because the people who say they care about it (let alone the subset of that who actually take advantage of it) is vanishing small. I know people on HN will bristle at that but it’s just the truth.

I don’t care what OS you use but I find it hilarious that I have some friends who are staunchly pro-Android/anti-Apple because <insert tired talking point> and then they proceed to use their phones in a way that never exceeds what they could do on iOS.

Price is a much larger factor.

As for your comments on the AVP I agree, at least at its current iteration.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by justsid on Saturday April 27, 2024 @01:44AM (#40177591)
The thing is, the original iPhone was bad. By today standards. But it came out at a time when it was leaps and bounds ahead of a good chunk of the competition. But you can’t release a product like that anymore, at least if you are Apple. People expect so much more these days.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by m_fayer on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:57AM (#40178741)
I attribute this to something else, something that’s operating across many different sectors.

Technologically, we’ve exhausted the low hanging fruit of various scientific and engineering disciplines. Energy, transportation, construction, computing devices, software, medicine, surgery and more - all these things rode enormous waves of potential in the postwar era that have now ebbed.

The iPhone was a low hanging fruit made possible by developments in compute, connectivity, and software.

The next set of fruit is much higher up the tree: see avp, development costs of.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by _heimdall on Saturday April 27, 2024 @08:14AM (#40179358)
Well there's a real world inflation number for you! The price of Apple making a new product in a new category has gone up 44x in 18 years.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by kaba0 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:20AM (#40177992)
Only if you are thinking about it on a small scale. If it will have a second iteration, which becomes a huge hit, then all that 10 billion R&D was happily spent.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by fullshark on Saturday April 27, 2024 @07:07AM (#40179045)
This is the "tech inevitability" thinking the article is criticizing.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by 627467 on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:23PM (#40176851)
Appl is not interest in niche products. they are not in biz to sell 200 products at 400K units each. they are in the biz to sell 20 overpriced products at 30M units/year each.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by swatcoder on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:34PM (#40176925)
Sort of. That's the shape of their portfolio and long-term strategy, for sure, but they clearly didn't target "30M units/year" for the launch of Vision Pro any more so than they've targeted that scale for for AppleTV or the Airport and Time Machine product lines.

It was plainly a test of both manufacturing and market. To the GP's point, I think it's hard for anyone on the outsjde to judge whether they hit their marks for it or not right now. It certainly wasn't grossly short, as there's no indication that they overshot manufacturing by an order of magnitude or something, but it certainly could have been disappointing. We really can't guess right now.

Good, traditional reporting might be able to surface some insight with real footwork and investigation. Armchair blogspam writing like the article is pointless and is really just clickbait.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by hlfshell on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:35PM (#40176936)
Innovator's Dilemma demonstrated wonderfully right here.

If VR is the next big thing, but will take years of niche smaller profit margin products to launch it, established tech companies will struggle to justify the products existence wherein a smaller player could go all in, achieve roughly equivalent results, and be quite content.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by pjmlp on Saturday April 27, 2024 @01:58AM (#40177646)
The next big thing since people were playing DOOM with headsets at conferences back in 1994.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by luyu_wu on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:16PM (#40176828)
A bit curious why you think this. How much do you think the R&D costs were?
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by ergonaught on Saturday April 27, 2024 @12:28AM (#40177238)
Because 400K units of this kind of product, at this price point, with this lack of “killer app” solving a problem people didn’t know they had, is a phenomenal success.

If they expected …that… to sell millions of units straight away, well, as I wrote.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by FredPret on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:25PM (#40176863)
Apple's sideline product, the Watch, outsells all of Switzerland (at watches only!). They only do huge products.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by Ultimatt on Saturday April 27, 2024 @01:55AM (#40177635)
How many Mac Pro's have ever sold? Or the Pro Display XDR that costs more than the Vision Pro... Apple are in the business of generating hype and a ladder of hype and glam around what would otherwise be boxes of electronics. They then sell millions at the bottom end whilst everyone aspires for debt to buy the high end.
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by ffgjgf1 on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:54AM (#40178174)
Based on some reports that’s way below their estimates and they were forced to cut production even before releasing it in other markets. That’s basically the definition of a “flop”..
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by hackeraccount on Saturday April 27, 2024 @12:11PM (#40181055)
I don't think it's really a question of how many units they sell.

It's more how quickly those units sell. How many get returned. How much activity is happening on the platform.

Apple knows all of those numbers. They also know what the potential improvements are and they probably have a really good idea what improvements would move the needle on the numbers that matter.

If Apple kill the AVP it may well look odd from the outside but they'll be well informed.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by surgical_fire on Sunday April 28, 2024 @06:43AM (#40187571)
Funny - To put things in perspective, The Wii U sold about 14M units if I am not terribly mistaken, and is considered a flop so legendary that almost ended Nintendo.

Now take in consideration that Nintendo is a fraction of the size of Apple.

400k units is nothing, less than a rounding error for a company the size of Apple. They are not in the business of selling some hundred thousand units of hardware.

Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by darnfish on Sunday April 28, 2024 @08:02AM (#40187979)
Did Wii U’s retail for $3499?
Re:The Vision Pro is a flop by surgical_fire on Monday April 29, 2024 @06:46AM (#40196702)
Does it matter?