News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by protastus on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:55PM (#40093554)
This argument is however not on solid ground.

It's not OK to cause pain and suffering to a creature capable of intelligence and emotions just because it's less intelligent than an arbitrary, conveniently chosen threshold.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by TehShrike on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:02PM (#40093611)
We raised chickens when I was a kid. They had a pretty good life, plenty of room to roam plus I fed them every day. When their time came, we gave them a quick painless death. No regrets
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by 000ooo000 on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:54PM (#40093929)
There's always one of these in these discussions. "We thought we were nice to them so bringing them into existence simply to consume them feels ok"
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:11PM (#40094036)
What is the issue with it? If they lead fairy nice long lives, I don't get it?

You must fundamentally have a problem with existence because nearly any creature that lives in the wild is going to have a very gruesome, painful lonely death.

If the worst thing that can happen is a chicken is protected, fed, given medicine when sick, have offspring and then eventually slaughtered in a rather human way after adulthood, I don't really see how it's so terrible.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by anonzzzies on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:07PM (#40094402)
But where does that stop: I can replace chicken here with your kids; still ok? What’s the difference? Dogs? Chimpansees? Dolphins? Why chickens ok and the rest not in the same example?
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:37PM (#40094574)
If a much more intelligent species comes to earth and says, we'll kill you all now , or we'll farm you for organs, at age 70; However, we'll help your species have a fairly good life and chance of survival overall ? I'd take it. Even if my kids were impacted.

Then imagine if they said: "it's likely that due to advancements in science, in 50 years we won't need to do this anymore because we'll have lab grown organs so we'll just leave you guys alone when we have what we need". I would double take that deal. This is likely where we are now.

The major difference with all of this discussion though is that obviously, animals are conscious, I don't believe they're capable of reasoning where they would be disturbed or troubled by such a deal. We're capable of understanding that our kids will be slaughtered for organs in 70 years from their birth. We also have strong emotions tied to this. So we'd be upset about it so I think that makes it a worse deal. Not the worst possible deal in such a theoretical circumstance, but it would be better than annihilation.

Definitely not saying this means this is ideal for anyone, animals or humans, nothing is perfect, I just don't think it's catastrophic.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by 000ooo000 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @12:25AM (#40094801)
>If a much more intelligent species comes to earth and says, we'll kill you all now , or we'll farm you for organs, at age 70; However, we'll help your species have a fairly good life and chance of survival overall ?

This line of reasoning begins with a false dichotomy.

>I don't believe they're capable of reasoning where they would be disturbed or troubled by such a deal

There are humans with significantly reduced cognition that one could also argue would not be troubled by such a deal; suddenly the rationale seems a little flimsy when we consider taking mentally disabled people and 'harvesting' them simply because they don't understand it's a raw deal for them.

I wish I could articulate it generally (newborn, low on sleep atm) but there's something here about mixing levels of consciousness when determining morality that seems flawed.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Saturday April 20, 2024 @10:10AM (#40097462)
or there isn't and you're just looking for things to argue about?

There are humans with significantly reduced cognition that one could also argue would not be troubled by such a deal;

Families would care

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by anonzzzies on Saturday April 20, 2024 @12:00AM (#40094692)
From some intelligent specifies like squids we don’t know: maybe they are disturbed by it and fear and hate humanity and plan their lives to be far away from them. They do plan and they remember things over generations. Not believing they can reason or proving they cannot reason are different things.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Saturday April 20, 2024 @12:12AM (#40094746)
I was fishing once, and I saw squid maul the face off a small yellow tail fish, I think the thing was still alive, it was a hideous way to go either way. It was one of the first times I realized how cruel the world can be. I used my sharp knife and made sure the little thing out of it's misery. But yeah, imagine that, being hugged by a squid and having your face chewed off by it's beak ? When I take the same fish, I use a fish spike, it's instant.

Anyway, if Squid are conscious and have such high levels of thought as you describe, then they understand the game and are likely undisturbed by it. If squid went vegan, then I'd feel worse.

This is why I think hunting is a much more fair way of obtaining protein. We're playing a much fairer game, factory farming and raping the ocean with super trawlers isn't.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by anonzzzies on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:53AM (#40095152)
But if we have to hunt our food then all those ‘ma meat must have ma meat’ dudes living in shitty small overcrowded city apartments wouldn’t be able to get their meat and they would get very angry. Probably to the point of them starting to eat other humans as those are perfectly hunt-able in big cities.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:02PM (#40099997)
Squids don’t have the option and we, admittedly, do. Nature is intrinsically and deeply cruel, but we could choose not to contribute. I think that if we do contribute, we should admit we do it for the pleasure of eating nice tasty meat and just call it worth it. I do agree with the whole hunting is better thing, but I don’t think there’s any objective reason, just vibes. I also think that, if we can grow like lab meat in the future, we should switch to that. It’s not gonna be viable for a long time tho.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Monday April 22, 2024 @08:47AM (#40113847)
Some people do:

1. If you have the time to cook the required amount of vegetarian food (not easy from experience).

2. If you can digest legume based protein without issue.

3. If you want to participate in social or culture events where eating meat is part of having a social life.

Are you a full time vegan / vegetarian? I did it for 2 years, I actually would call it a "luxury".

I moved to a country where it's not yet "hip to be vegetarian" and it's virtually impossible to survive in that place. There is no "Whole Foods" in many parts of the world.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by pcthrowaway on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:26AM (#40095036)
What we have in animal agriculture is more like if the organs were farmed at age 20, and humans bred at puberty to produce more babies to feed the organ farm. Not sure why you chose age 70 in your example.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:00PM (#40099315)
They don’t know, that’s the difference. A human would be haunted by that for their entire life, in the same way that humans suffer because of fear of death. Chickens, dumb or not, don’t seem capable of knowing that that’s going to happen, so they enjoy their constructed lives more than a human would.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by brigadier132 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @11:41AM (#40098182)
Everything dies, dying in nature is never free of suffering for these animals.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by timeon on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:47PM (#40093881)
> When their time came

Were they mature?

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by TehShrike on Saturday April 20, 2024 @04:23PM (#40100711)
Yeah, they were mostly for eggs and pest control, most of them lived 2+ years. They didn't make the best meat to be honest
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by felipeerias on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:23PM (#40093739)
Whether it is OK or not is in itself an arbitrary decision.

I don’t necessarily disagree with you, merely pointing out that ultimately every moral system rests on non-observable abstract principles. Metaphysics, in other words.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by luqtas on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:49PM (#40093895)
empathy isn't abstract, it's in our brain as a mechanism that promoted survival... now if you are telling me that modern people (knowing that modern nutrition already stablished that in 99,9% of the cases, it's perfectly possible to live off a plant based diet, with B12 [livestock is also supplemented ]) don't feel empathy for animals in the ballpark of birds/mammalian is pretty naive... considering that people are actually aware of what takes to kill an animal & what's the state of stuff like "battery cages" when raising eggs at commercial scale; i think either you are one of those rare meat heads that can kill stuff, butcher and eat or you aren't aware (go watch Dominion or whatever)... because most city people buying fancy fatty meat or cheap burguers, would feel nausea/sorrow by killing anything & probably would stop if they need to kill to eat meat
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by felipeerias on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:05AM (#40095450)
The basic mechanisms of empathy are probably biological, but everything else is cultural. Consider that different civilisations in the past even engaged in systematic cannibalism.

I grew up in a farm. In my experience, the people less likely to feel empathy for animals were those who actually worked with them every day. This does not mean that they were cruel, at all, but rather that they understood rising and killing animals as fundamental for their livelihood.

This reality is very remote for many urban dwellers, for whom animal products come into existence in the supermarket aisle, and who mostly only see live animals as pets.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by WalterSear on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:16PM (#40098880)
>This does not mean that they were cruel, at all, but rather that they understood rising and killing animals as fundamental for their livelihood.

The banality of evil. Enron executives' behaviour was also fundamental to their livelihood.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:06PM (#40100030)
Nature itself is evil by this standard
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by WalterSear on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:24PM (#40100215)
1. Yes.

2. That's irrelevant on multiple levels

3. Cognitive abstractions aren't beings, can't have a morality to evaluate.

"As moral as Darwinian Evolution" is not a good look, particularly in regards to livelihood rather than survival.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by luqtas on Sunday April 21, 2024 @06:34AM (#40104568)
it's not probably, it's what it's! go read where neuroscience reason about that...

and i typed _modern people_ from cities & despite city people sometimes contributing or doing great crimes for money, i don't know if that is justifiable to use as a counter argument... as we are chatting about how a modern people, who is probably empathetic/civilized enough to realize that killing an animal is unfair/horrible when there isn't a plausible reason to do it ¶ are rural people aware the complexity of a mammalian? because i can see the love for cats and dogs and some bird species... negating pigs and cows or rats feels a specie prejudice! specially, again, when we proved already that it's more economical, ecological and if done correctly more healthy (animal protein is synthesized differently and if we were black and white, plant and fungi based are easier to swallow [but just a curiosity, as that may only build up to diabetes or cancer if one eats like an average +medium-class North American or the likes]). not long ago, like less than 8 generations, we slaved and raped people in America while building churches talking about Christ love... so i don't think we can go back "the days we eat carcass and hunt mammoths" to justify stuff if we truly want to evolve

"not eating animal products is the bare minimum you can do", actually

edit: a bunch of errors, i'm sleep deprived but do you know that even FLIES suffer from indecision? fungi have the capacity of memory (tho i think we can eat those :), ants are a pretty complex organism for the amount of neurons they have... maybe the day we stop to anthropomorphizing intelligence we'll figure out the holocaust (rolling right now)

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by apsurd on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:00PM (#40093592)
a hard truth I agree with. but so very easy to out-of-sight-out-of-mind x_X ugh
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by DEADMINCE on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:23PM (#40094104)
The threshold should be self-awareness - nothing arbitrary about it.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by NewJazz on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:57PM (#40093569)
Yep. One might consider how it only takes an evolutionary moment for the veil of ignorance to be lifted slightly higher.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by tacocataco on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:54PM (#40093934)
Chop me up and feed me to the chickens when I die.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by anonzzzies on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:09PM (#40094416)
It’s a shame this is not allowed in most/all countries. So much meat wasted by cremation and burial and solid boxes. Feed me to the pigs after harvesting my organs.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by shrimp_emoji on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:29PM (#40094147)
The threshold isn't actually intelligence; it's reciprocation.

Chimps have superhuman short-term memory, but they're not granted personhood.

A tree can be infinitely intelligent. If it doesn't do anything with that intelligence and can't communicate, and we couldn't profit from that intelligence in any way, we wouldn't care about it -- even if we somehow noticed it.

If the tree can benefit us if we don't harm it, we suddenly care.

If it can hurt us if we hurt it, we care.

If other entities which can help us will do so as long as we don't hurt the tree -- or if they will hurt us if we hurt the tree, we care. (For example, this can be other humans with respect to their pets.)

If it exhibits the specific kinds of intelligence that we care about, like talking, or if it simply moves us emotionally, we'll care.

These are all reciprocations of social contracts we're forced, by our biology and by game theory, to respond to.

That's the threshold. Power grows from the barrel of a gun, not an abstract notion of intelligence or consciousness (which, spoiler: is a religious nonsense concept) or whatever.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by adolph on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:00PM (#40093596)
Reduction of suffering is part of Temple Grandin's work:

Grandin also developed an objective, numerical scoring system for assessing animal welfare at slaughtering plants. The use of this scoring system resulted in significant improvements in animal stunning and handling during slaughter. This work is described in "Objective scoring of animal handling and stunning practices in slaughter plants"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temple_Grandin