News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by 000ooo000 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @12:25AM (#40094801)
>If a much more intelligent species comes to earth and says, we'll kill you all now , or we'll farm you for organs, at age 70; However, we'll help your species have a fairly good life and chance of survival overall ?

This line of reasoning begins with a false dichotomy.

>I don't believe they're capable of reasoning where they would be disturbed or troubled by such a deal

There are humans with significantly reduced cognition that one could also argue would not be troubled by such a deal; suddenly the rationale seems a little flimsy when we consider taking mentally disabled people and 'harvesting' them simply because they don't understand it's a raw deal for them.

I wish I could articulate it generally (newborn, low on sleep atm) but there's something here about mixing levels of consciousness when determining morality that seems flawed.

Re:'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal wor... by bamboozled on Saturday April 20, 2024 @10:10AM (#40097462)
or there isn't and you're just looking for things to argue about?

There are humans with significantly reduced cognition that one could also argue would not be troubled by such a deal;

Families would care