Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by fauigerzigerk on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:00AM
(#40085276)
It's a good demonstration of what Apple's sideloading ban means.
With sideloading, Apple customers could make their own decision on whether or not to make a stand. The sideloading ban takes that decision away from them and hands power directly to authoritarian regimes.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by toast0 on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:52AM
(#40087577)
I guess it's up to the device makers. Afaik, sideloading is popular in China, so I'd be surprised if it were disabled.
Phones made for the Mainland China market usually don't have Google Play or other Google stuff and there's lots of stuff that doesn't get published to Chinese app stores but isn't prohibited. You've got to sideload those apps, if you can find an apk.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by paeb72 on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:56AM
(#40085251)
I hope India does the same. The number of scams and fake businesses proliferating via WhatsApp, targeting the most vulnerable is totally out of control. Its like half my day is spent blocking spammers and scammers.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by chrisfinazzo on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:19AM
(#40087152)
Not for their Chinese users, that's for sure.
Not because they don't want to -- although as an American, I don't see what kind of goodwill this produces -- rather because they can't, the government simply won't allow it.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by chrisfinazzo on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:15AM
(#40087105)
Not so much in China.
Don't act like they had a choice to make here -- as much as I loathe intensely everything Apple does to appease the Chinese, refusing to act would likely prompt the government to ban them entirely.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by intexpress on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:36AM
(#40087359)
Actually Google under Sundar’s leadership desperately wants to re-enter China, to the point of already building in backdoors for the Chinese government to spy on Chinese users. See Google’s maybe-cancelled, maybe-not-cancelled project called “Dragonfly”
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by intexpress on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:17AM
(#40087894)
It wasn't just planning. Google had/has hundreds of people working on a surveillance system for the Chinese government. The team's mission was to build a prototype quickly and then to be ready to launch for real within 6-9 months.
As far as I know Apple isn't forcing anyone to work for them in China. It sucks if they are a bad employer, but if people still want to work for Apple, then I guess they must be better than most alternatives.
Re:Apple removes WhatsApp and Threads from China store under...
by intexpress on Friday April 19, 2024 @12:20PM
(#40088692)
> Apple has a choice just like Google: leave China.
> It's about Apple bending to China government for money.
I just think your implication that Google is a more moral actor than Apple is wrong.
Google left China due to cyber attacks and the risk of ongoing cyber attacks.
Google leadership wants to return to China and is happy to "bend to the China government". But Google employees are unhappy about this and are slowing the return.
With sideloading, Apple customers could make their own decision on whether or not to make a stand. The sideloading ban takes that decision away from them and hands power directly to authoritarian regimes.
Phones made for the Mainland China market usually don't have Google Play or other Google stuff and there's lots of stuff that doesn't get published to Chinese app stores but isn't prohibited. You've got to sideload those apps, if you can find an apk.
https://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?d=4083611549407&w=8Kzpg-EbO8...
Also low trust societies. You do not want to have that anywhere.
This is like banning phones because robots keep are calling me.
Not because they don't want to -- although as an American, I don't see what kind of goodwill this produces -- rather because they can't, the government simply won't allow it.
There's the Apple example, and the Hololive example.
lol
Don't act like they had a choice to make here -- as much as I loathe intensely everything Apple does to appease the Chinese, refusing to act would likely prompt the government to ban them entirely.
Bet a lot of youths would react to loss of their dopamine device.
Also iphones are really only ‘good’ inside the us. Everyone else in the world sees them for what they are.
Incredible that Google managed to be less evil than Apple.
As far as I know Apple isn't forcing anyone to work for them in China. It sucks if they are a bad employer, but if people still want to work for Apple, then I guess they must be better than most alternatives.
It's about Apple bending to China government for money.
Even Google left China when they saw the inhuman demands. Apple stayed and is still going strong there at the cost of human rights.
I don't know how can people handwave and relativize these horrors with whataboutism.
> It's about Apple bending to China government for money.
I just think your implication that Google is a more moral actor than Apple is wrong.
Google left China due to cyber attacks and the risk of ongoing cyber attacks.
Google leadership wants to return to China and is happy to "bend to the China government". But Google employees are unhappy about this and are slowing the return.
Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40083409