News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:12PM (#40015937)
America bad, native good?

All of human history, of every single people, is brutal. You have to wonder why history of a specific nature, about a specific people frequently surfaces, while you rarely see other unpopular horrifying history.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by adammichaelc on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:21PM (#40016038)
The conquerors have told their story for 2,000+ years.

Now we are telling humanity’s story, so that we all can take care of our shared home better, and learn to be wise stewards of this magnificent place called Earth, and her offspring.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:37PM (#40016219)
What happened 2,000+ years ago?
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by krapp on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:54PM (#40016968)
Christianity? It's been the engine of Western imperialism, colonization, native cultural erasure, slavery and genocide ever since Constantine.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:18PM (#40017197)
Where does Christ's teachings tell people to do those things?
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by krapp on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:25PM (#40017271)
Why are you asking me? Certainly, nothing about Christ's teachings stopped them.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:35PM (#40017375)
I'm asking you because you're the one who just laid the blame of the last 2000 years of bad things on Christ's teachings, and not on mankind's natural behavior. Somehow it was what Christ taught, because it didn't stop people from doing bad things.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by krapp on Friday April 12, 2024 @05:08PM (#40017676)
I didn't lay the blame for anything on Christ's teachings, I laid the blame on Christianity.

If you can't look back at history and see the difference between theory and practice then I don't know what to tell you.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @06:34PM (#40018371)
Christianity is Christ's teachings, and any other definition is a strawman. What you're talking about is man's sinful nature, and that is separate.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by krapp on Friday April 12, 2024 @06:57PM (#40018506)
So... you literally look at events like the Crusades, anti-semitism, slavery, the treatement of native Americans or any number of horrors done by Christians in the name of Christ and with the authority and sanction of the Christian church .... and admit absolutely no relationship between any of that and Christianity? No, Christianity isn't just the teachings of Christ, any more than any religion, or American law is just the Constitution. Christianity is also what Christians do, it's politics and government and militarism, culture and pop culture. Dogma and folklore.

What I'd like to be talking about is the relationship between the Christian religion and Western imperialism and the consequences of Christian conquest on the narratives of history (specifically the narratives of groups oppressed by that religion.) What you're engaging in is pedantry and a gross application of what I'll call the True Christian fallacy. Fair enough. We can't have a conversation about this. Good night.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @07:57PM (#40018904)
When you use circular definitions, as you're doing now, you can re-define a word to be whatever is convenient to you. If Christianity is also defined by what Christians do, then what defines a Christian? You have to ground it in a concrete definition at some point, and that definition is: the teachings of Christ. If a Christian acts in a way that is against the teachings of Christ, then that is not Christian behavior, and is not representative of Christianity. That's a pretty simple and unambiguous concept.

Your "No True Scotsman" variant just shows that you don't really grasp this idea. Ironically, what you're doing by making Christianity a grab-bag of bad behavior from people you don't like, instead of grounding it in a clear and unambiguous definition, is a clever perversion of this fallacy.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by FrustratedMonky on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:41PM (#40016270)
When you say, "The conquerors have told their story for 2,000+ years," it’s indeed a delightful insight, but brutally simplified. Conquerors never merely "tell" their story; they impose it, they embed it in the very fabric of our reality, shaping our desires, our institutions, our very notion of what is normal! And now, this idea that "we are telling humanity’s story," who is this 'we' if not a new form of a subtle conqueror, perhaps clad in the robes of ecological concern and moral superiority?

Yes, we speak of being "wise stewards of Earth," but isn’t there a hidden arrogance here? The very term steward implies a mastery, does it not? Earth becomes something to be managed, controlled, and ultimately subdued under the guise of care and sustainability. This narrative seduces us with the promise that if only we manage better, all will be well, neglecting the radical openness, the chaotic unpredictability of nature itself.

So, what is to be done? Should we then resign ourselves to passive observation? Certainly not! But we must proceed with a critical, self-reflective stance that constantly questions our assumptions and our motives. Our struggle must not be to replace one conquering narrative with another but to recognize the ideological battles hidden beneath these grand narratives. We must confront not only the stories we are told by others but also the stories we tell ourselves. This is the only way we can hope to genuinely engage with our shared home—by understanding that our narratives are not innocent, not free of power, and certainly not free of conquest.

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by huytersd on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:17PM (#40015998)
I don’t know, killing all but a handful of 30 million wild animals is pretty damn evil. Especially since they just killed them and left them to rot.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:30PM (#40016146)
That's the power of only seeing one story, minus context of what the rest of the world was like. Would you also call the history of what native american tribes did to each other evil? Or was it on par with the brutality of the times?
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by causal on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:52PM (#40016365)
I don't think you are arguing in good faith. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:08PM (#40016539)
You're misusing that fallacy here, but I don't fault you, because my point is subtle. My claim isn't that their point is invalid because they're hypocritical about native american history, my claim is that their gauge of evil is miscalibrated, because only a certain perspective of history is amplified to this degree, minus the historical context that puts it on par with the times.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by huytersd on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:52PM (#40016368)
They did regular brutality. Attack another tribe, kill like 5% of them, rape etc. everyone did that. No one really wiped out entire species.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:59PM (#40016441)
>No one really wiped out entire species.

Overkill Hypothesis[1]

1. https://people.wou.edu/~vanstem/391.W12/Overkill%20Hypoth.pd...

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by huytersd on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:52PM (#40016947)
This isn’t a hypothesis. This is a well documented event.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:21PM (#40017230)
The evidence of the overkill hypothesis stands against your lack of evidence that it never happened before.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by ThrowawayTestr on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:46PM (#40016890)
Going out of your way to indirectly genocide a people through starvation sounds pretty evil.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by dylan604 on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:18PM (#40016638)
What about killing all but a handful of mosquitoes, fire ants, or other insects? I might suggest we stopped too soon
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by huytersd on Saturday April 13, 2024 @03:38AM (#40021268)
Why not bacteria? We can kill those by the trillions.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by beckthompson on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:46PM (#40016898)
Your comment misses the point so much it makes me sad! Seeing the pictures of thousands upon thousands of dead bison skulls is honestly astonishing and I think your snide comment "American bad, native good" is extremely reductive of the article, which even points out:

> Such reliance on a narrow ecological base ultimately proved unsustainable, pushing the bison populations into a steep decline by the mid–19th century.

Showing the native Americans role in the demise of the bison population.

> You have to wonder why history of a specific nature, about a specific people frequently surfaces ...

Probably because a lot of Americans use the site and learning about their history is interesting so it gets more points :)

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by causal on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:19PM (#40016014)
You seem to be implying there is some kind of conspiracy to portray one particular group as bad while ignoring another. I don't think that's warranted, there has been plenty of media vilifying America's natives. There is perhaps an effort to correct the record: history was written by the victors, and it has taken far too long for us to realize the many injustices that were carried out along the way. Understanding what we lost (in this case, vast Bison herds) is important. These losses affect natives and immigrants alike.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:26PM (#40016102)
Be intellectually honest. Show me a single front page post "vilifying America's natives." You won't find it, but you'll find plenty in the other direction, because a large portion of HN's user base has a shameless anti-American slant.
Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by mistrial9 on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:47PM (#40016332)
polarization is already front and center -- the complaint here is "not enough polarization" ? or, "you talk bad about my side" ?

yes, intellectual honesty requires that we dig under the first superficial reading here

Re:Haunting photos of the bison extermination in 19th centur... by throwaway74432 on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:11PM (#40016573)
No, my complaint is the pervasive anti-American history. People get actually upset if you notice it and mention it. As if the default behavior should be to cheerfully self-flagellate for American history.