News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by jmakov on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:01AM (#39960180)
If anybody just gets a speeding ticket and includes that in the price of their product, how can the system self correct?
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by wouldbecouldbe on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:33AM (#39960320)
For these cases of gross misconduct affecting health of people, criminal charges should actually be made against individuals who made the decisions.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by elaus on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:47AM (#39960388)
Are you talking about the _responsibility_ that is the justification for paychecks in the millions? It seems to end somewhere before jail sentences for most execs...
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by backwardation_b on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:28AM (#39960293)
The system self corrects by companies moving to a different supplier. If 3M has to increase prices (they will) to offset the settlement costs, then other suppliers will be comparatively cheaper. 3M share price and profit will decrease which incentivizes the board and or shareholders to encourage safer (read: legal) business practices.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by rolandog on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:40AM (#39960348)
The people affected by these "corrections" are the workers that would be laid off due to decreasing revenue,... In order to maintain the expected profits that result in dividend payments to shareholders.

So, one could make the case that the workers get punished by the board of directors' bad decisions.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by thayne on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:48AM (#39960398)
That clearly doesn't work. The fines are often less than the profits made. And the individuals and shareholders have already made a fortune by the time the payments come due, and can just move on to the next company and do the same thing there.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by checkyoursudo on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:57AM (#39960799)
How does your model account for the probability that cheaper competitors are simply bad actors who have not yet been caught?

In fact, without something like criminal penalties, why would the board encourage safer/legal business practices? Seems like they might equally say, well that was a good run now find us another dastardly product that can bring our prices back down to our competitors.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:39AM (#39960342)
You are selling a fantasy, a spherical cow.

As the OP said, The original people responsible made bank and retired. The original shareholders cashed out. this does not encourage anything.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by int_19h on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:59PM (#39962897)
And those "other suppliers" will be 3M - same owners, same board, same executives - under a different name.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by xyst on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:29AM (#39960297)
Executives serving actual jail time. Prohibited from joining the boards of public/private companies. Personal liability.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by lumb63 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:42AM (#39960722)
I’ve thought about this a fair bit. The idea of companies being a firewall for liability to protect individuals seems…off? Companies don’t make decisions, individuals do. Certainly there is some utility to the idea of limiting liability, but our current system seems to me to afford too much benefit to those running corporations.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by appplication on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:53AM (#39960785)
It feels off because it makes no sense and is a completely biased system towards a small group of people. Ultimately this is just more class divide. Corporate entities and the legal protection they provide are accessible to only the wealthy and elite. They are another mechanism behind which the wealthy can run afoul of the law and the entity absorbs the negative repercussions while passing through all of the profits.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by andrewpolidori on Sunday April 07, 2024 @11:12AM (#39961289)
This just isn't true though. Do you mean to say thay legal remedies are more accessible to the rich? Every single small business owner benefits from the liability protections of corporations. If my business burns down and it's not fraud or something then I am not personally liable, nor should I be.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by yau8edq12i on Sunday April 07, 2024 @12:00PM (#39961607)
Your business burning down isn't the same as you, as (I assume) ceo of your company, acting knowingly in a way that causes death and illness to other people. This thread is about the fact that limited liability shouldn't protect you from the second scenario. Your comment is off topic.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by andrewpolidori on Sunday April 07, 2024 @12:26PM (#39961799)
> Corporate entities and the legal protection they provide are accessible to only the wealthy and elite.

This is the part of the previous comment to which I was responding, giving just one example of how it's not the case. Limited Liability corporations protect business owners of all wealth levels. Just correcting a patently false claim.

I understand your concern about thread topic, but it's just not really applicable to my point above.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by asadotzler on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:18PM (#39963527)
Your point above was not topical and only served to derail the conversation or gaslight the people who you mislead with it.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by NoPicklez on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:17PM (#39965378)
I don't think so, I think it was topical just perhaps not in favour of your view.

The person they were replying to and to which their point related to, was very much narrowing down and exaggerating corporate entities to a "small group of people" of the "wealthy and elite".

While these larger corporations limit larger amounts of liability, most people can create a business and have it as a company, giving them limited liability. Yes, large corporations have the money and resources to better limit their liability than a smaller corporation.

They weren't disagreeing with that person, but providing a more balanced view in which liability limitations benefit companies of all sizes, not just larger ones.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by stonogo on Sunday April 07, 2024 @01:35PM (#39962294)
Why would anyone believe that legal remedies are not more accessible to the rich? That's the foundation of the cash bail system, among many, many other differences.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by generic92034 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @12:26PM (#39961800)
Is that limited liability in the US really that general? Why were James Robert Liang and Oliver Schmidt serving a sentence in prison?
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by andrewpolidori on Sunday April 07, 2024 @12:44PM (#39961941)
In general, it's not a protection from gross negligence and/or fraud.

The problem is that in cases like these it's extremely difficult to prove such a thing, especially considering it's over many decades and potentially dozens of people.

There's also a bit of practical concerns where criminal prosecutions don't want to pick cases that are tough to win as it'll be resource intense to pursue them.

Of course like the Volkswagen situation you reference (in Germany) where the corporation operates may impact criminal prosecution.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by konschubert on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:54AM (#39960429)
But this would have to be limited to cases where you can prove personal intent or personal gross negligence by the executive.

Otherwise you’re effectively making companies illegal.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:11AM (#39960527)
> Otherwise you’re effectively making companies illegal.

It's more like making illegal behaviour by companies to be illegal.

There's a disconnect where behaviour that would result in jail time for people, doesn't result in jail time if performed by companies and that seems wrong to me. If an individual poisons a water supply, they're not going to be getting just a fine.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by konschubert on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:20AM (#39960573)
I don’t think a lot of ppl would want to take a job where they are liable for the actions of others.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:36AM (#39960670)
Isn't that exactly what is required of CEOs and executives?

If a company doesn't have liability for upper management, then where's their incentive to not instruct employees to behave illegally?

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by Wolfenstein98k on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:50AM (#39960768)
Instructing employees to behave illegally is illegal
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday April 07, 2024 @12:10PM (#39961680)
That doesn't appear to be well enforced as otherwise companies wouldn't be able to get away (or at least maybe receive a fine at some point) with illegal activity. If a company is illegally dumping chemicals into the water, then there has to have been at least one instance where a higher up instructed employees to do so.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by user_7832 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:09AM (#39960889)
In some (not all of course) of these discussions, the CEOs/other decision making executives have said things that were fairly explicitly "dangerous"/illegal. I'm not talking about "hold ceo responsible for something s/he wasn't aware of", I'm talking "hold them responsible when they instructed something even though they knew people would die" (eg see Ford Pinto).
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ryandrake on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:55AM (#39961179)
It would be better for the world if those people do not take that job and tell/incentivize their employees to do illegal things. So win-win.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by littlestymaar on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:23AM (#39960594)
Don't underestimate the appeal of a 7 digit salary and the position of power you get with it.

There a orders of magnitude more candidates for CEOs positions than there are jobs, so it's not like we would run out of people to do the job if we increased the responsibilities.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by int_19h on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:47PM (#39962806)
It depends on the risk/reward ratio.

It would certainly make megacorps non-viable, but I don't see why that is undesirable. If the average company size is scaled down to the level where such liability is actually manageable, it would also largely solve the problem with monopolies, so it's a win-win.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by panta on Sunday April 07, 2024 @11:24AM (#39961375)
If you develop or sell something that has even a remote potential to kill someone, it's your responsibility to apply a cautionary principle and gather enough evidence that the probability of that outcome is negligible. Otherwise that IS gross negligence.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by sp332 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:29AM (#39960301)
If they could have raised prices, they would have already done it.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by mattmaroon on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:01AM (#39960828)
Right, they aren't the only manufacturer. There are a dozen major ones. People always miss this about competitive markets. They are already charging the highest price they believe they can.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by cfiggers on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:13AM (#39960221)
I dunno man, $12 BILLION is a pretty serious speeding ticket
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by skrebbel on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:24AM (#39960269)
I think the argument is that people doing crime go to jail, so when a company does crime, maybe the same should happen.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by konfusinomicon on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:24AM (#39960271)
not when you have 3M billions
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by idiotsecant on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:27AM (#39960290)
3M sells about 1.3 billion USD of the stuff yearly at about 16% margin, so figure about 200 million USD in profit per year. 12 billion represents about 60 current profit-years of production.They invented the stuff in the 30s but have been churning it out in quantity since the 50s. 12 billion isn't a speeding ticket but it also isn't even all the profit they made on it.

In addition to that, is their obligation to pay their profits or to make whole a world soaked in forever chemicals? Because the latter would be way more than 12 billion.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by tome on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:43AM (#39960366)
I'm not entirely sure what you're saying. Are you saying that 60 years of profit on a product that's been churned out in quantity for 70 years is a small fine?
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by justinclift on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:19AM (#39960947)
> 12 billion isn't a speeding ticket but it also isn't even all the profit they made on it.

They literally said "it isn't even all the profit they made".

That seems pretty clear.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by tome on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:32PM (#39963142)
It's not clear to me!
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by asadotzler on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:22PM (#39963554)
If you rob a bank for 100 dollars and get caught and have to give up 90 dollars and walk away with 10 in your pocket, it's hardly a fine for the robbery, now is it. That's a win and you should repeat it until you're rich. This is corporations who literally profit after the fines for the bad thing they did to generate that profit. Sure the profit is cut some, maybe even a lot, but it's still profit and it sends the signal that it's good to break the rules because you will at least profit some. That should not be the case. You should forfeit 100% of the ill gotten gains and then pay a fine in addition to that so that your total gains become negative and you are disincented to repeat. That this simple idea seems a stretch for you might be a signal to you that your reality is distorted in this area and could use a re-examining.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by justinclift on Sunday April 07, 2024 @07:05PM (#39964736)
> That this simple idea seems a stretch for you might be a signal to you that your reality is distorted in this area and could use a re-examining.

That seems pretty unwarranted. :(

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by justinclift on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:46PM (#39963757)
They're being fined less than the profit they made.

Surely they should be getting fined more than how much they profited?

Preferably (at a minimum) several times the amount, so they (and others) aren't keen to do it again.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:40AM (#39960350)
Indeed, the real justice would be to make them pay for cleanup efforts for the next 200 years
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ben_w on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:10AM (#39960519)
How are you planning on enforcing that given:

1) bankruptcy is a thing, and

2) that period exceeds the lifespan of not only those responsible, but also any kids they might have conceived in extreme old age, and people can just… choose not work for (or invest in) a company that's been stuck with a long-term obligation.

I can see how it would be possible to make criminal liability stick on all members of a chain of command, corporate or otherwise, responsible for some decision. I can't see how setting a multi-lifetime punishment could possibly work.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 07, 2024 @09:21AM (#39960580)
> 1) bankruptcy is a thing

Students loans, famously, can’t be discharged in bankruptcy, and follow you your entire life.

Should we have one set of law for the capital class and another for mere peasants?

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by mattmaroon on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:09AM (#39960884)
When you sign up for student loans, you are aware (or at least should be) that they can't be discharged in bankruptcy. They aren't dischargable in bankruptcy because if they were, far fewer would be made, and far fewer non-rich people would go to college, and we don't want that. Nothing would perpetuate class divisions more than restricting education to those with money. Nobody would ever get a student loan for an anthropology degree again.

I don't necessarily agree with this system, as an 18 yr old probably does not have the life experience to make such large financial decisions, and I think perhaps far fewer people should go to college for things of no economic value, but the system has logic to it. It's meant to benefit the "peasants". Rich people don't need student loans and can pay for their kids' degrees.

Fines aren't the same. A company only has so much money. Many of the owners of the company are pensions funds, etc., that are held by the middle class. You can't reasonably squeeze money from everyone who had an ETF that contained 3M. You need to allow corporations to file bankruptcy to have a healthy economy, in fact, America's bankruptcy laws are (according to some economists) one of the reasons we have such a strong economy.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by int_19h on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:57PM (#39962877)
What you can do is liquidate the company and set up a non-profit fund with that money with explicit mandate to do the clean-up. Let the non-profit invest said money ethically to fund its operations.

Ideally, of course, the initial capital should also include the personal wealth of all the top management personally responsible for this.

> Many of the owners of the company are pensions funds, etc., that are held by the middle class. You can't reasonably squeeze money from everyone who had an ETF that contained 3M.

And why not? Do you not see how this kind of system is deliberately engineered to produce pushback under just such a pretense by, effectively, diluting and spreading responsibility wide enough across society? OTOH if we stop taking the "ohnoes, it will hurt all those middle class investors" argument seriously, it would actually encourage people to invest ethically instead of just blindly giving their money to whichever random sociopath offers the highest return.

(And yes, I do have considerable personal investments of my own.)

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ben_w on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:16PM (#39963518)
> And why not?

Because the biggest voting block in many democracies is the pensioners, so this being possible is a good way to lose elections.

> Do you not see how this kind of system is deliberately engineered to produce pushback under just such a pretense by, effectively, diluting and spreading responsibility wide enough across society? OTOH if we stop taking the "ohnoes, it will hurt all those middle class investors" argument seriously, it would actually encourage people to invest ethically instead of just blindly giving their money to whichever random sociopath offers the highest return.

Everything I have seen in my life leads me to think that people are pretty blind to risks when you dangle the possibility of a large return in front of them. Ponzi schemes, Brexit, lotteries, wars, unrestricted AI — at every scale, people will enthusiastically go for all of them in the name of some hoped-for benefit and call you names if you point out the risks they're taking.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ClumsyPilot on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:37AM (#39969585)
> Because the biggest voting block in many democracies is the pensioners, so this being possible is a good way to lose elections

Imagine you would write ‘white people are the biggest voting block’ - this would be questionable as a justification for bad policy, right?

So kids are brutally held responsible for their bad decision, but pensioners aren’t.

It has become so normal to denigrate and mistreat the younger generation you don’t even consciously notice it any more. It’s a form of discrimination just like any other

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ben_w on Monday April 08, 2024 @11:21AM (#39970652)
> Imagine you would write ‘white people are the biggest voting block’ - this would be questionable as a justification for bad policy, right?

"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch" — Probably not Franklin

"[d]emocracy is the worst form of government – except for all the others that have been tried." — Churchill

The Rules for Rulers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs&t=1025s&pp=ygUNa...

If you can fix this, please go into politics, the world would be much better if someone can actually resolve this kind of issue.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by int_19h on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @07:27PM (#39985399)
I'm familiar with this video (and the book behind it). I don't know how fix it, but we can at least talk about how things should be before we can start discussing how to get there.

And here's the thing. If the overall arrangement continues to be broken - increasingly so, in fact - for new generations, and meanwhile they are repeatedly told that there's no way to fix it through the existing political system, at some point they will just get fed up and say, "fuck you and your system then", and it'll be torches and pitchforks time, elections be damned. Which is unlikely to actually improve matters on the whole - it rarely does - but it will certainly hurt all those older people with investments (and really just about anything of substantial value, including real estate) a great deal more than anything I talked about earlier.

So it is very much in their - in our! - interest to find some way forward that does not involve this kind of activity before the anger grows beyond the point where it can be contained. I would rather give up some of what I have to keep the rest of it. And then there's the very real risk of physical violence; the guys on the very top of this pyramid can afford private security and private jets as the ultimate escape hatch (and they're already digging bunkers for themselves elsewhere in droves), but I sure don't.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by ben_w on Sunday April 07, 2024 @01:47PM (#39962366)
1) That's a reason to change the student loan rules where you live.

2) When a corporation goes bankrupt, it can get dissolved. This is the corporate equivalent of the death penalty, which you may approve of, but it still isn't going to help: all the assets get sold, and all the investor groups (a) know that (b) can get the stuff cheap because it's a fire-sale, and (c) know the exact size and shape of the market opportunity created by the dissolution. And there's a workforce right there, who were all laid off and are looking for work, who have exactly the skills you need and are already conveniently located and familiar with the equipment.

The debt doesn't get fully paid off, there's just nobody to do the paying.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by jajko on Sunday April 07, 2024 @10:03AM (#39960851)
Do you see the company struggling to stay afloat, breaking up, selling parts to competition just to survive? For poisoning half of planet and killing god knows how many, yes thats a (bit bigger) speeding ticket, nothing more.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by lettergram on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:25AM (#39960279)
The fine was the 1/3 of yearly revenue, in 2023 their revenue was $32.68B, net income was -$7B (that’s a negative seven billion).

Im not sure of the payment timeline or if they have insurance, but it seems likely this will wipe out a few years of profitability and may force the sale of business units.

That said, I do think personal culpability is probably a better incentive and more ethically reasonable depending on the circumstances. Though that’d have to be criminal neglect, using laws we probably already have. In other words, this is a civil penalty, not the same as a criminal case with higher burdens of proof and motives need to be established.

Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by rahimnathwani on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:55AM (#39960435)

  this will wipe out a few years of profitability
They've already recognized most of the loss, so most of the impact on profits is in the past. From the Q2 2023 10-Q:

  During the first six months of 2023, as a result of ongoing review and recent developments in ongoing environmental matters and litigation (including the proposed PWS Settlement), the Company increased its accrual for PFAS-related other environmental liabilities by $10.3 billion and made related payments of $38 million. As of June 30, 2023, the Company had recorded liabilities of $10.9 billion for “other environmental liabilities.” These amounts are reflected in the consolidated balance sheet within other current liabilities ($0.3 billion) and other liabilities ($10.6 billion). The accruals represent the Company’s estimate of the probable loss in connection with the environmental matters and PFAS-related matters and litigation described above. The Company is not able to estimate a possible loss or range of possible loss in excess of the established accruals at this time.
Re:Court approves 3M multi-billion dollar settlement over PF... by alexashka on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:04PM (#39962481)
What makes you think the system isn't working as intended? What would 'correct' even look like? Occasional human sacrifice to appease the masses as is being called for on here?