News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by rcthompson on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @06:39PM (#39845466)
For me at least, it will also make driving to Manhattan and parking actually more expensive than taking the train, which it should be. The fact that both options are currently about the same price for me has had me thinking that something somewhere is deeply wrong.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bogota on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @06:59PM (#39845631)
Better/cheaper train solutions would seem to be the desired fix though not just raising prices to random high numbers.

I agree that this will likely have a good outcome in the end but something about it just seems wrong to me.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by KptMarchewa on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:05PM (#39845680)
It's hard to exactly tax externalities.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bobthepanda on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:07PM (#39845715)
The high tolls are going to subsidize the trains.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by exegete on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @08:11PM (#39846247)
Subsidize which trains? Not the ones from NJ (NJTransit). These tolls will only be used for MTA (NY).

I’m for congestion pricing but NJ trains and buses are not going to benefit from this.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by emeril on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @08:51PM (#39846527)
NJTransit will benefit by increased ridership

I will benefit personally as a NJTransit bus rider by, I hope, having a shorter bus ride (more time to do work and see family) since I sit in 1-2 hours of commuter car induced traffic several days a week

As an NJ resident, I very much look forward to this congestion pricing and wish it were $50 instead of $15...

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by DaveExeter on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:21PM (#39847090)
I wish it were $500!

Keep the poors off the roads.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by cqqxo4zV46cp on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:20PM (#39846722)
For obvious reasons, the vast majority of public transport systems long for increased patronage above all else.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bogota on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:15PM (#39845779)
So are train tickets going down in price or more seats being added?
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Reason077 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @08:08PM (#39846221)
> "So are train tickets going down in price or more seats being added?"

You can answer this question by looking at the existing service.

Are the trains crowded, unreliable, and/or running over capacity? In that case it would be better to spend the extra money on upgrading the service. Or is the service good but not enough people are using it? In that case it may be better to use the money to reduce ticket prices.

Whatever gets more people to ride the trains is going to be the best solution.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:46PM (#39846905)
It's actually "neither of the above": the congestion funding is simply going to replace federal funding (mostly Covid relief stuff) that is due to roll off.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by lkbm on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:40PM (#39847196)
The article links to another article[0] (way down in the final paragraph) about how some transit upgrades were put on hold because they were 50% funded by the congestion pricing:

> The MTA said money from congestion pricing makes up more than 50% of funding for the agency’s capital program

Presumably, those specific things can now get back underway:

> Projects that rely on the funding include modern signaling on the A train to Far Rockaway, more ADA-accessible stations and phase two of the Second Avenue subway.

[0] https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/transit/2024/02/16/mta-halt...

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:32PM (#39847496)
I mean, sure, that's obviously the way the MTA wants you to look at this; and indeed the congestion pricing funds are restricted to be used on the capital budget.

But that's meaningless; since capital funding from the congestion pricing lockbox will just displace debt issuance, so it's effectively just taking pressure off the operating budget, which is where the current federal funding is going.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bradleyjg on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:46PM (#39846020)
They’ll be six workers standing around not doing anything while one works, up from five.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by roywiggins on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:49PM (#39846049)
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by selcuka on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:48PM (#39846038)
Nothing goes down in price. Ticket prices will remain the same, but salaries will increase because of inflation, so yes, they will become more affordable. At least that's the theory.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by anotherhue on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:31PM (#39845909)
More bag searches obviously.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by moate on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:13PM (#39847378)
Nah. Those tolls go to new york. The people being taxed are predominantly from NJ. Our gov just raised the gas tax to help fund the transit system here, and he’s also suing NY over these tolls. Feel however you want about this, it’s a complicated issue because of our patchworks of states vs federal control.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by harimau777 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:23PM (#39847431)
If the people paying the tolls work everyday in New York, then I think it would be reasonable to consider them to effectively be New Yorkers as much as they are New Jersiers (New Jersites?).

Like you say though, it's complicated. Especially when you have New York and Jersey City that in a lot of ways are almost one city that happens to be in two states.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by r00fus on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:38AM (#39847844)
Income tax is often divided into where you live AND where you work (ie unemployment is typically work-state dependent).

However the where you live part is over-emphasized IMHO.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bobthepanda on Thursday March 28, 2024 @01:50AM (#39848143)
I mean this also hits anyone coming from an outer borough. It’s hardly only a tax on NJ residents
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:53PM (#39846095)
Car congestion fees are touted but they are rarely effective, except at keeping poor people from moving around. It's just another dial the lazy can inflict on the population to pretend like they're solving the issue.

Reminds me of ye olde window tax.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by kelnos on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:58PM (#39846967)
Yep. I don't know the situation around NYC, but in the bay area, lower-income folks have been getting pushed out of SF and most of the peninsula, and have moved farther out. Something like this (e.g. if they were to analogously increase the Bay Bridge toll) just hurts lower-income folks even more. They have no choice: they need to drive to where the jobs are, but can't afford to live where the jobs are.

And the transit options are laughable. It's great for the people served by BART or Caltrain, but there are a lot of people far enough from a station to make it less than useful for them. So even with the traffic, they make the entirely logical choice to spend 2 hours commuting rather than 4.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by macNchz on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:31PM (#39847149)
In NYC, the overwhelming majority of low-income workers commute by public transit.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:48PM (#39847581)
It's easier to place the blame on something when you eliminate all casual or affordable use of that thing. You can stand back and say "see, it is this thing". Not mentioning the problems that eliminating and enforcing the ban of casual use brings about on required use.

Lazy weapons against problems are just barely better than sort-of-bad solutions. But if you look in the long term, the lazy weapons scorch the earth so that better solutions can't come along.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by nostrebored on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:52PM (#39847254)
This is a NIMBY induced problem. If upward construction had been allowed, this wouldn’t be the case.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by inpdx on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:06AM (#39848473)
Who to blame probably does not matter one whit to those affected.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by dlp211 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:59PM (#39847305)
> Car congestion fees are touted but they are rarely effective

Citation needed. All studies I have seen suggest that congestion pricing achieves its desired outcomes of reducing car traffic and is the most effective way of doing so.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:42PM (#39847551)
Nope. Draining the pool and filling it with more water is not an effective way of cleaning the pool. The pool ends up clean though so you can lead any study you want.

It's not effective. It's just prohibitive. Prohibiting people stops things, who would have guessed.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:25AM (#39848280)
Non-toll roadways are a common-pool resource with significant externalities. They invite overuse and push most of the harms of overuse on others (locals, pedestrians, etc).

Congestion charges or tolls are a good way to put a price on the resource and make market mechanisms work.

Then the resources can be used for whatever produces the greatest benefit (and thus is willing to pay the most for use of the resource), and the tolls obtained can pay to address the externalities.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Monday April 01, 2024 @07:55PM (#39900842)
Tolls are there to pay for the new roadwork(s) (and in some cases, line private company profits). Nothing more. Anything else is not effective, it's just prohibitive.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Monday April 01, 2024 @09:18PM (#39901341)
It's good to have any scarce common resource be bid for, rather than giving it to whomever shows up first, is willing to wait longest, etc.

If 150k people want to go, it's usually better that the 100k people who value the road the most get through quickly, instead of having a random 110k get through after a large traffic jam.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @12:55AM (#39902519)
150k people wanting to go and being able to go is better than a quarter being forced to stay home, a quarter being forced to not go and another half being allowed to go.

You seem to misunderstand the problem.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @01:51AM (#39902775)
I understand basic economics just fine; but what you say seems to be orthogonal/not understanding what the common pool problem is.

Market mechanisms allocate resources better than "whomever is willing to endure the worst conditions" does.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:27AM (#39914538)
This has nothing to do with market mechanisms. You can't look at and negotiate with the market to get to work cheaper.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:33AM (#39914570)
In many places, congestion pricing is dynamic and tries to keep roads at the highest throughput capacity.

Here, it's a pseudo-static value chosen to try and push the roads to the highest throughput capacity. (There is some variation by time of day, but not by actual demand).

It has a lot to do with market mechanisms. This is stuff that's within the capability of a high school student to perform a reasonable analysis about after a semester-long class.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @08:02PM (#39924931)
I've never seen a toll road decrease in price because no one was using it. Wouldn't that be the easiest place to test congestion if "market played a role"? Car number go up, price go up. Bing bong.

No, it might take a high schooler to read too much into it and pluck things out of thin air though.

It's okay if you genuinely think prohibiting something is effective at providing people with more effective usage of that thing. You'll be wrong though.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @08:55PM (#39925278)
> I've never seen a toll road decrease in price because no one was using it.

Have you ever seen a city with congestion charge have all traffic vanish? :P

> Car number go up, price go up. Bing bong

As already mentioned by me, to you, above: there are lots of roads with dynamic pricing with this exact characteristic. But there's a tradeoff to be made between having a simple charge and by having fancy dynamic pricing.

> It's okay if you genuinely think prohibiting something is effective at providing people with more effective usage of that thing.

Charging for something != prohibiting.

There's already a lot of costs driving into the city (including the opportunity cost of being stuck in traffic). Adding a charge can make driving cheaper for people who have a high value on driving (because they value their time).

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Thursday April 04, 2024 @12:52AM (#39926667)
You seem to think the government charging for something is them understanding the market. It's not.

It's just another way to prohibit. That's the whole basis of fines in traffic violations. Not to discourage, but to prohibit most people.

Sorry if you can't understand that even after all this.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Thursday April 04, 2024 @01:20AM (#39926833)
Do you understand what an opportunity cost is?

Does the opportunity cost of driving fall if traffic decreases?

Is there an optimum amount of traffic on a given roadway for society?

Does society reach that optimum value on its own?

Does the current system (first come, first serve, best-effort) appropriately prioritize traffic with vastly different economic values and priorities appropriately?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bruce511 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:32AM (#39848316)
I'm not sure I understand your point here. If the goal is less traffic then steps that lead to less traffic are effective.

Presumably to get less traffic you need to make the choice (to drive a car into the city) less attractive. Making it cost more would seem to do that.

Of course $15 is not enough, because while that will act on the "unattractive" side, there will then be less traffic, which will the increase the "attractive" side. The toll will need to increase to find the balance where it dwarfs the no-traffic convenience.

This is how I played out in London for example. Traffic has been reduced, but the connection charge is quite high.

Which is fine, those who want the convenience, and feel it offers good value for money can use it. And public transport (busses) is faster.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Monday April 01, 2024 @08:00PM (#39900876)
Yeah you don't understand the point. Effective means it works well at the problem. Would you say chopping off an arm that is broken is an effective way of fixing a broken arm? It definitely eliminates the problem. It doesn't solve the problem effectively.

To get less traffic you need to make sure the roads are good enough to hold the amount of cars that come, or are designed in such a way that those cars don't go far or don't stop (hard). Public transport is a great way at reducing cars which may reduce traffic.

Putting a price on travel does not effectively manage traffic. It just chops traffic off. If we put a price on a bunch of stuff and stopped people enjoying the benefits of things that way, we'd also see sharp declines in whatever we wanted.... never because it is effective though.

Claiming a chopped off arm is good healthcare is a great falsehood to run with since it's easy, but it's not right. Instead of pushing that propaganda, let's actually mend the broken arm.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlyle on Monday April 01, 2024 @09:23PM (#39901370)
> Putting a price on travel does not effectively manage traffic. It just chops traffic off.

There's already a price on travel-- the opportunity cost of waiting in traffic.

Putting a congestion charge in place may reduce the total price on travel for the people who need it the most.

Not to mention the externalities of vehicle traffic, which strengthen the case for a charge even more.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by helsinkiandrew on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:46AM (#39848665)
The London and Singapore congestion schemes have been running for decades with clear, measured benefits.

https://www.intelligenttransport.com/transport-news/143883/l...

https://www.oecd.org/climate-action/ipac/practices/london-s-...

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by seoulmetro on Monday April 01, 2024 @07:55PM (#39900834)
Killing people benefits against environmental disasters like global warming and pollution too. That doesn't make it effective.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by kelnos on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:53PM (#39846940)
A better fix would be to just make transit more attractive, not make driving less attractive. Reduce the price of the train by $15 and, without this new toll, voila, your commute is cheaper by transit.

On top of that, make transit faster and more frequent so people look at driving & transit directions side-by-side and see that there's not much difference time-wise. This is already true for many trips inside NYC.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by SECProto on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:48PM (#39847232)
This is just putting them on a similar model (user pays). Currently, a train ticket has to cover the capital and operating costs of both the vehicle (train, driver) and tracks. For driving, the driver pays the operating and capital cost of the vehicle only - the road budget comes out of general revenue (of the city, state, etc).

Your suggestion of dropping the cost just means the transit agency would have to make up the cost elsewhere - any suggestions? General revenues backed by a tax hike? Shifting burden of track construction and maintenance fully to tax-funded?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Powdering7082 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:59PM (#39847304)
I agree directionally, but fares only make up 23% of MTA's operating budget

https://new.mta.info/budget/MTA-operating-budget-basics

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Eisenstein on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:07PM (#39847344)
Does that mean that reducing fares will not impact them?
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bitvoid on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:47AM (#39847881)
No? They said they agreed. They were just clarifying that tickets don't fully cover the costs as implied by the parent comment.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by londons_explore on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:19AM (#39848534)
It is common worldwide for governments to subsidize public transit. - in this case a ~300% subsidy on the fare.

However, in 'failed states', where the government presumably doesn't subsidize anything, you often find independent minibus operators zooming around town, carrying ~20 passengers each, offering in aggregate a very good public transit service, charging a few coins adding up to barely more than the fuel cost for the bus.

How come poor nations and failed states can manage to provide good public transit so so much cheaper than anyone else?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by paulgb on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:41AM (#39848645)
> you often find independent minibus operators zooming around town, carrying ~20 passengers each, offering in aggregate a very good public transit service, charging a few coins adding up to barely more than the fuel cost for the bus.

NYC actually has an analogue to this! (Had? I’m not sure how many of these routes survived covid)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_vans_in_the_New_York_...

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by fodkodrasz on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:36AM (#39848624)
> How come poor nations and failed states can manage to provide good public transit so so much cheaper than anyone else?

By using badly maintained, very old vehicles, with low to no enforced standards of operations for safety.

By operators exploiting themselves because of only coarsely tracked costs and low level of reserves.

By not having to conform to strict schedules and not providing service in off hours, only when good business is expected. This makes the infrastructure virtually nonexistent, hurting the general economy by limiting the possibilities of those having to take these forms of public transport.

By applying demand based pricing, for example when working off hours charging more to cover the running costs which are split among less users.

By not working for peanuts, it is your false perception because you have far more income (and disposable income) than those who have to live on incomes local to that area. If PPP adjusted it is often quite a sum.

Just to name a few factors. In general well run welfare states, or at least moderately well run authoritarian states (also having some welfare aspects many Americans would probably call communism) tend to have good public transport, for different reasons, and share taxis are generally not considered a good public transit.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by TheCapeGreek on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:41AM (#39848639)
>By operators exploiting themselves because of only coarsely tracked costs and low level of reserves.

Let's also not ignore outright gang/mob style affiliation of minibus transit organisations that will then also actively sabotage government public transport on their post profitable routes.

These private entities in the third world fill a role, but often are also rent-seeking and carve it out for themselves from a government without the willpower to A) build proper public transit infrastructure and B) defend it from bad actors.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:41AM (#39848637)
Because their labor costs nothing. I took these minibuses a lot in Ukraine, Georgia (the country), Armenia, Russian Far East and Kazakhstan. The cars work and aren't entirely unsafe, but I bet none of them would pass western technical and emission inspection. They fix it themselves using scrap and they keep it running for 1M+ km.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Powdering7082 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:30PM (#39853826)
Yeah last time I rode in a minibus (guagua (sp?)) was in the dominican republic. It was a 4 door sedan carrying ~9 people. I had shift the car into drive from park because the driver didn't want to reach across the lap of the female passenger who was also sitting in the drivers seat with him.

My memory was that the car had many warning lights on and turned off while we were driving. Somehow he was able to restart it without it being in park while we were coasting.

It was extremely cheap.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by SECProto on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:18AM (#39849761)
Yeah, it was a huge simplification to be sure. The comment was talking about cutting his train ticket by $15, so I assumed it was more of a long distance thing - amtrack has farebox recovery of 95%
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by hunter2_ on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:36AM (#39848894)
Drivers pick up some portion of the road budget through fuel tax, and NJ even recently invented a way to make EV owners pay for same in lieu of fuel tax.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Beldin on Thursday March 28, 2024 @10:51AM (#39852315)
Except that road maintenance is a bit more expensive than you'd think.

From memory, a politician claimed a few years ago that 40 km of highway was about as much as 1 JSF (~$110mln). Let's pretend that that is a rough proxy for what maintenance of NYC's streets & public parking would cost.

How often do you have to fillerup before you've spent about $100mln in fuel taxes?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by rcthompson on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:15AM (#39847735)
> A better fix would be to just make transit more attractive, not make driving less attractive.

I agree, but at least this makes them relatively correct, if not absolutely.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Larrikin on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @10:06PM (#39847006)
Would you be happy if they used the money by making driving less attractive to make taking the train more attractive?
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by teaearlgraycold on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:56PM (#39847627)
Please do it!
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by dotcoma on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:23AM (#39847777)
> A better fix would be to just make transit more attractive, not make driving less attractive

It’s a worse fix. Studies prove that you have to make driving harder. Sticks work better than carrots.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by AlecSchueler on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:29AM (#39848584)
The Dutch model is the best example of this, using "autolow" methods to force cars onto certain routes while leaving the most direct ones to people, bikes and public transport.

It's surprising whenever these conversations come up that many seem to miss the extensive body of lessons that can be taken from the research and practice already done around the world. Is it a kind of "Not invented here" sort of thing?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:43AM (#39848653)
What Dutch city looks anything remotely similar to NYC? There are very good reasons to drive into NYC for many people, due to density - much more people have much more diverse needs, and need much more workers moving around with their equipment and much more goods.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by malermeister on Thursday March 28, 2024 @05:57AM (#39849288)
The Randstad does.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad

Density is pretty similar as well.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:03AM (#39850144)
I don't think it looks like NYC. Density might be similar, but not the size. You can count the skyscrapers on your hands.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by malermeister on Thursday March 28, 2024 @10:47AM (#39852246)
Skyscrapers do not a city make. NYC has a population of 8.8M. The Randstad has a population of 8.4M.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @05:59PM (#39857877)
Look at the area. 8261 km2 of land while NYC is 300.

We call both "city" but we might as well use 2 totally unrelated words given the differences.

As the other commenter said, NYC metropolitan area would be more comparable - 8936 km2, 19.5M people.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by valarauko on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:40AM (#39852872)
In that case, you should really compare it to the New York Metropolitan Area, which has over 20 million people.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by AlecSchueler on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:08AM (#39850200)
I only meant that their methods should be part of the conversation, not implemented uncritically or without being adapted to local needs.

Many people in the Netherlands also need to drive and the system supports this while also offering alternatives. Many people means diverse needs indeed, so the reliance on and the defaulting of car travel runs counter to many of those needs.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:37AM (#39850484)
The point I was trying to make is that much more people need to drive in NYC and can't use the alternatives. Sure, I'm all for it - but the problems and solutions are of much different magnitude from anywhere in the Netherlands.

People in the Netherlands made it hard to drive through their cities, which led to more people not driving. In NYC it's going to lead less people driving too, but still a massive clusterfuck on the roads that will be only worse if the solution of the Netherlands is implemented there.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by dotcoma on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:51PM (#39855839)
I’m not sure why “it can’t work here”, even if it’s what every city says.

It did not work in the Netherlands either; in fact, after WW2, they imported “traffic planners”, i.e. people who want — and create! — traffic from the US, and set out to destroying their old city centers to create highways etc, until people said: enough!

To a greater or lesser degree, similar solutions work in Copenhagen, and in some German cities, and are starting to work in Paris, once one of the most car-crazed cities in Europe, and in other places.

I’m not saying it’s easy. I’m just saying that it can be done. It sure takes a lot of work, but it can be done.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:13PM (#39856744)
All these cities are very different from NYC.

To be clear, I'm not saying preserve the status quo. I just don't think the changes the cities you listed made have any chance to work in NYC. Most notably, all of these cities existed way before NYC and we're built with limitations of medieval technology. All the changes you mention are just rollbacks to last working state.

NYC is a new city built with comparatively godlike tech applied without restraint. The NYC-style solution "I guess I'll just commute by helicopter, no problem putting another skyscraper right here" was incomprehensible to the rich people who built the European cities - they had to go a little further away if they wanted their quiet comfortable life.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by AlecSchueler on Friday March 29, 2024 @04:30AM (#39861797)
Don't you know America is, like, exceptional, man.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Friday March 29, 2024 @10:57AM (#39864830)
Which European country has a city with nearly 10M people on 300km2?

America is exceptional - in the literal sense, it's an exception compared to organically grown cities that existed for hundreds of years. It doesn't mean it's better, it's just very different and so naturally the solutions are going to be very different too.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by AlecSchueler on Friday March 29, 2024 @12:50PM (#39866199)
> Which European country has a city with nearly 10M people on 300km2?

I have no idea, can you share specifically why you think autoluw only works for certain levels of population per square kilometer? To the point that the lessons couldn't be adapted and would have to be "very different?"

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by throwaway11460 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @04:08AM (#39872844)
Because much more people on that extremely small area actually need to drive - because they are immobile, because they are carrying goods, materials or tools... Reducing NYC to one lane would stop the life in the city.

You can drive through Amsterdam too in these cases - it's just that much less people need to.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by aden1ne on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:07AM (#39848753)
Ah yeah that same Dutch policy that made public transport 12% more expensive this year while simultaneously reducing service and with outages up a literal 300% from pre-covid times.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by sofixa on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:19AM (#39848815)
Isn't the 12% in line with the inflation and the rise in their costs since the last time they updated prices?
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by AlecSchueler on Friday March 29, 2024 @07:32AM (#39862796)
No, that would be a different policy.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Clubber on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:43AM (#39849958)
It's a regressive tax for poor and middle class people. People making $400K don't care about $15, so they get a pass. Typical.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlrtime on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:23AM (#39850351)
400k in Manhattan with ~50% total tax, 2 kids in private school and a 2BR condo mortgage. I bet a lot of those families care about an extra 15/day. They can pay it yeah.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Clubber on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:28AM (#39850397)
Sure but it's just an annoyance to them, not a deterrence. The objective is deterrence. This tax is targeting poor and middle class because it's a regressive tax. Pretty shitty.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by asoneth on Thursday March 28, 2024 @09:50AM (#39851435)
I'm curious what fraction of people who drive a personal vehicle into lower Manhattan on a regular basis are poor or middle class. What would your guess be?

Mine would be a tenth or less. When I lived in NYC the only people I knew who commuted by personal car in Manhattan were people who made mid-six-figures and lived in some NJ/Westchester suburb. Everyone else took the train/subway.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by Clubber on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:48AM (#39852958)
>I'm curious what fraction of people who drive a personal vehicle into lower Manhattan on a regular basis are poor or middle class. What would your guess be?

Beats me, I haven't been there since the late 90s. If 90% of the people who drive personal cars are rich people who can afford it, it's just a tax that doesn't accomplish anything (except revenue generation and keeping the poor/middle 10% off the road) because they will most likely be annoyed but not deterred.

It will hurt the Uber drivers and delivery drivers and whatnot too. Probably tourists as well. I wonder if the city will keep metrics up to see how well it's working. Maybe I'm wrong, but it doesn't seem well thought out.

Why just Manhattan you think? I guess it's where are the businesses are.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by asoneth on Thursday March 28, 2024 @01:09PM (#39854480)
Right, I suspect that $15 will prove to be far too low to dissuade 90% of lower Manhattan drivers. Having said that, it's a reasonable (and politically palatable) starting guess, it provides funding to improve transit, makes drivers pay for at least a fraction of the negative externalities they impose on the neighborhoods they drive through, and it can always be increased over time until it has the intended effect.

> I wonder if the city will keep metrics up to see how well it's working.

Certainly they've talked about tracking travel times before and after, but I think the real test will be the long-term changes in land value. My guess is that eventually land value in car-dependent communities in the NYC metro area will decrease relative to those with transit access.

> It will hurt the Uber drivers and delivery drivers

That is a reasonable hypothesis, but I'm sure we'll find out. I would wager that the reduced travel time will allow drivers to make more deliveries which will make up for the daily $15 fee. In the end, the market will decide.

> Why just Manhattan you think?

That's where the supply/demand imbalance seems most acute. Well, there and many of the brides which we should be charging for as well. Any place that becomes gridlocked on a regular basis should probably have a price applied to ensure efficient utilization.

Finally, if we're worried that this fee is regressive, I think a better solution would be to use some of the funds to make the state income tax even more progressive. Subsiding driving for a small number of poor and middle class drivers seems less fair and efficient than letting people keep more of their money at tax time.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by bananabiscuit on Thursday March 28, 2024 @01:52PM (#39855075)
Most people commuting to manhattan are not wealthy or middle class, judging by the makes and models and visual conditions of the cars that you see on the bridges entering Manhattan.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by adrianN on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:48AM (#39847889)
Making trains more attractive takes a few decades and a couple billion dollars.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by loeg on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:49AM (#39847890)
Increasing the cost of driving is one of the best levers available for making transit more attractive!
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by skyfaller on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:38AM (#39848630)
One problem is that cars take up the space that other transit options need, or alternately, cars themselves are the reason other transit options are unattractive.

For example:

- many people are afraid to ride bicycles because they are (justifiably) afraid of being run over by cars

- separated bike lanes cannot be created because the space is already used for parking spaces for cars

- street level trolleys or buses can move people very efficiently, but when cars block their path, they are slowed to the same pace as the traffic jam

I could go on and on and on. Unless you take back the space used for cars, it is very difficult to make space for anything else.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by paulgb on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:27AM (#39848851)
The amount of cars in Manhattan also makes walking (which is usually also involved in a transit journey) much worse than it needs to be. I saw this video posted yesterday: https://x.com/philwalkable/status/1773167820487962703?s=46

This is a daily occurrence in some parts of the city. Notice how unfazed everyone is by it, but also how untenable it would be to someone with a wheelchair, walker, stroller, or frankly anyone who isn’t young and thin and nimble.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlrtime on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:17AM (#39850292)
I've done this walk 1000's of times on different crosswalks in NYC, I know exactly where this is.

Every single time I thought to myself I'm about 10lbs of foot pressure away from having my legs broken by a car.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by singhrac on Friday March 29, 2024 @11:26AM (#39865212)
I've never thought about that until now and I was better off for it... oh well I guess there's some static friction in my favor.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday March 28, 2024 @05:52AM (#39849254)
Or not 5 ft tall

Look at the height of the hood of that car, the driver would not even see a teenager trying to cross

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by vel0city on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:48AM (#39852961)
Isn't being stopped like that a violation? Why aren't people getting massive fines or their driving privileges taken away for driving like this?
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by paulgb on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:57AM (#39853125)
Technically it is ticketable, but they don’t really have a choice. The traffic often moves at a crawl so they might enter the intersection at the beginning of a light cycle and not get further than the crosswalk. If they decide not to move until there is a car length of free space on the other side, cars behind them will honk up a storm. Ticketing them would effectively just be a stochastic congestion tax anyway.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by vel0city on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:10PM (#39853406)
> Technically it is ticketable, but they don’t really have a choice.

They absolutely have a choice where their car goes. They've got a gas pedal, a brake pedal, and a steering wheel don't they?

If they can't clear the intersection they have no business entering it.

> If they decide not to move until there is a car length of free space on the other side, cars behind them will honk up a storm.

That's a problem with the car behind them. You shouldn't break the law because someone is honking at you.

> Ticketing them would effectively just be a stochastic congestion tax anyway.

Good.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by asoneth on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:33PM (#39853889)
I agree we should ticket anyone who is blocking the box and I wish they still enforced those fines/points. But as drivers become increasingly lawless, especially in NYC, being the only person following the law can make you and the people around you less safe. Similar to driving in a developing country, driving safely in NYC requires learning the actual rules of the road which are not the same as the legal rules.

(Personally I avoid driving and biking in midtown these days because I am uncomfortable breaking the law, but when I do have to choose between following the law and operating safely I choose the latter.)

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by tetromino_ on Saturday March 30, 2024 @07:36AM (#39873873)
> If they can't clear the intersection they have no business entering it.

In heavy urban traffic, it is impossible to know if you can clear the intersection before entering it. You can often predict it with some degree of accuracy, but only if you are already familiar with this particular intersection; forget about out of towners being able to make that judgment.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by larkfofty on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:30PM (#39855599)
Technically yes, but sadly in practice rarely enforced. Stand on a street corner in NYC for five minutes and you will see dozens of traffic violations that go unenforced. I don't agree with it, but there is a certain amount of accepted lawlessness here when it comes to driving.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by evandijk70 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:42AM (#39848648)
Why is that a better fix? Transit also has externalities (pollution, congestion, noise), just fewer than cars.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by dragonwriter on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:35AM (#39848887)
> A better fix would be to just make transit more attractive, not make driving less attractive.

It is clearly not fiscally better, and its probably not better in terms of speed of induced behavior change. The best mix is probably some of both; make transit better and make driving more expensive so that people who have preconceptions about transit nevertheless feel that the absolute cost of driving (not the cost delta of driving vs. transit) is sufficient that it is not worth the trip without taking transit despite their prejudgement against it.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by nox101 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:49AM (#39848953)
I agree transit is the solution but NYC transit is kind of crap and it will take decades and billions to get it up to the standards of more mondern systems. Just lowering the price is not enough. More lines and a cleaner safer system would attract more people
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by addcommitpush on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:48AM (#39849573)
The issue is that there are too many cars (including pollution, congestion, noise), not that there is not enough transit - or at least this is a separate issue.

If you could multiply by 10 the number of people using public transport without changing the number of cars on the road, would the car make less noise, or pollute less, or take up less space? I don't see how.

So the two policies we are discussing really are:

- reduce the number of people using cars by making using cars directly more expensive

- reduce the number of people using cars by making using cars indirectly more expensive, by lowering the cost of the alternatives and funding this extra cost _somehow_ (taxing everyone whether they use cars or not?)

It seems to me that solution 2 is potentially less effective, definitely way more complex and basically make everyone pay rather than just car users.

Of course if the goal is either to be ineffective (just subsidy transit but don't make me abandon my car) or shield car users from most of the cost (create an expensive solution to reduce car usage by making everyone pay, not just car users); then sure, it's better.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by zdunn on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:26AM (#39850377)
> just make transit more attractive, not make driving less attractive

If ppl drive more than use transit, they won't support improvements to transit. This is the first step to improving transit. Make driving less attractive, more ppl use transit, complain about its shortcomings, and then fixes get implemented.

I also don't see why we shouldn't make driving less attractive. As the grandparent comment said, drivers should be the ones paying for the problems caused by drivers, not residents.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:07PM (#39847343)
I think instead the train ride is too expensive.

Id rather have the train ride cost be lowered. Its too high now. Have you factored the price of riding late to work? Or maybe new clothes due to a car with a homeless stink that wont go ? What about the cost of a hospital bill after getting sucker punched in the face?

Sorry. Train is too expensive. Driving is irrelevant.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by feoren on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:23PM (#39847433)
> What about the cost of a hospital bill after getting sucker punched in the face?

I'd be very surprised if the risk of an expensive injury wasn't significantly when higher driving vs. taking the train. Surely driving must be riskier? It's one of the riskiest things modern humans do. Maybe the NYC traffic is bad enough that you're never going a dangerous speed?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by scarby2 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:31PM (#39847485)
> Maybe the NYC traffic is bad enough that you're never going a dangerous speed?

Inside Manhattan this is almost certainly true. In a modern car you're going to walk away from almost all crashes under about 40 mph.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by slyrus on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:52PM (#39847607)
The pedestrian not so much, though.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlrtime on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:31AM (#39850419)
A pedestrian just had they're legs ran over 2 weeks ago by a subway train because they go pushed on the tracks.

Maybe that is a 1/1000000 shot, but it is MUCH more horrifying than thinking about getting in a car crash at 40 mph.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by vel0city on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:57AM (#39853104)
You've heard about a pedestrian who you don't even know had an accident and determine its too unsafe.

Meanwhile I personally know multiple people who died, mangled in a car after an accident. I know multiple people who have survived but were in bad accidents where at least one person was injured. I know multiple people who were pedestrians and cyclists who were properly using the streets and were hit by cars requiring hospital visits, and indirectly know of several people who have died being legally in the right cycling on the streets.

You're way more likely to be seriously harmed or killed even just being around a car than you are riding a train or subway.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by dwallin on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:42PM (#39847549)
A brief search came up with trains being around 15-20x safer than driving. As with many things it matters a lot how you count but it’s a pretty huge gap.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlrtime on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:29AM (#39850404)
Your brief search is meaningless unless you take a subway line through the Bronx daily.

Statistics will not capture 10% of the harrasment people put up with daily.

New yorkers have some massive Stockton Syndrome with what they are used to. Some will argue that if you complain about human feces on the train, maybe you should go back to Ohio, I see it daily.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by valarauko on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:46AM (#39852936)
What about subway lines in the Bronx?

As someone who lives & works in the Bronx, I haven't encountered any harassment in the Bronx lines. Pretty much every negative experience I've had on any subway line has been in Manhattan.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by postepowanieadm on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:39AM (#39848350)
Preferred way would be to make trains cheaper and more effective/safer than cars. But it's also the hard way.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by lenkite on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:42AM (#39848649)
How will you take care of your personal safety ? Harassment/Assaults/Muggings/Slashings are becoming rather common in the subway there right ? There appear to be several incidents reported weekly - and these are only the ones that get views.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by hunter2_ on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:08AM (#39848757)
When you say "common," can you be more specific? I believe the actual rate, in the form of trips with an incident over trips without an incident, would be described as extremely uncommon. Perhaps there's been an uptick, and perhaps it's even more common in NY than other large cities, but probably less common than being a victim of similarly bad circumstances (plus collision risk) inside a car.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by lenkite on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:36AM (#39849515)
There are severe crimes reported weekly this year - you can simply just check the news for that along with regular assaults and hundreds of harassment cases. I am not sure I would quantify the rate as "extremely uncommon".
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by hunter2_ on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:26PM (#39853738)
This got me double checking myself, but it does seem that a typical "common versus rare" threshold is a rate of 5%, though other values like 1% and 10% are sometimes used. Based on this, I'll concede that it might be common for an incident to make the daily news (if there's one a week, so 1/7 chance) but I stand by my claim that trips with such incidents are extremely uncommon relative to all trips.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by skytbest on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:24PM (#39855530)
There's 8 million+ people in NYC. So even if there are 8 severe crimes in a period of time that is still a one in a million chance. Seems extremely uncommon to me. Though I do agree, the uptick in crime is not great.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by thedrbrian on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:48AM (#39849571)
The last few years have shown that even if something is extremely uncommon you've still got to move heaven and earth to stop it happening. Costs be damned.

Metal detectors at every station entrance , mental health screening prior to boarding perhaps?

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:06AM (#39849354)
While the level of crime is appalling, it needs to be addressed, not ignored and isolating by putting yourself into a little metal box.

This is actually the perfect example of car-brain mentality, you can totally ignore huge social issues, ugly and dirty streets, etc. because you are insulated from them and are just driving past. If you had to walk through that area, that would not work.

If wealthy and influential people could not isolate themselves from the problem, maybe they would actually fix the problem

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by lenkite on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:39AM (#39849532)
Sure, lets be the guinea pig and sacrifice one's life for the sake of some hypothetical improvement that will happen by one's death. Since other folks have died on the NY subway and nothing has changed, I doubt one's sacrifice will do anything.

Maybe the leadership of the city should daily take the NY subway - without their personal security. And then write a bond of guarantee for the public.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday March 28, 2024 @06:56AM (#39849627)
Actually a bong guarantee is a good idea, if the city had to pay damages every time someone in a victim of crime a subway, things might be solved quickly.

You are describing tragedy of individual action. Similar story to protesting in Russia. Or using a bicycle instead of a car. Or perhaps climate change, and a few others

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by mlrtime on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:26AM (#39850373)
This is a horrible idea, the city does not care about paying damages. The taxpayers pay it, not the city agencies.

NYC pays out BILLIONS every year in real and garbage claims.

Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by vel0city on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:04PM (#39853255)
Far more people are injured or die on the highway outside my office in Texas than in the subways of NY, and there's fewer people riding on the highway.
Re:MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Man... by orbisvicis on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:48AM (#39850011)
Where are you parking? Public street parking is impossible to find, public parking lots are at least $20-40/hour. I'd assume apartment parking would be at least $200/month. That leaves corporate parking garages, which are probably free.