News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by tw04 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @04:04PM (#39729026)
Apple’s business model isn’t selling your personal information. In fact they go out of their way to protect your personal info. Requiring an AppleID is significantly less concerning than requiring a Facebook account.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by timschmidt on Saturday March 16, 2024 @06:08PM (#39729921)
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by tw04 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @06:52PM (#39730179)
>In the meantime, Apple continues to work with ad tech vendors it trusts — or rather, those with stated policies it approves of — particularly when it comes to a cornerstone of the iPhone maker’s brand: user privacy.

>However, a key question remains: how will Apple ensure user privacy as its ad ambitions expose the iOS ecosystem to a sector of the media landscape with a chequered record when it comes to a cornerstone of its brand promise?

>Earlier this year, it unveiled a tool it will use to police user privacy in the guise of Privacy Manifests (see video above), a measure that many interpreted as Apple’s attempt to (finally) stamp out illicit user-tracking, a.k.a. fingerprinting.

Apple has a vested interest in user privacy and talks about it constantly. Facebook has an interest in selling every piece of information they have about you to the highest bidder and has talked about how stupid users are to give them personal information.

They are not the same.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by timschmidt on Saturday March 16, 2024 @07:05PM (#39730243)
> Apple has a vested interest in

Shareholder profit.

> and talks about it constantly.

Must be true then. Definitely not marketing.

> Facebook has an interest in selling every piece of information they have about you to the highest bidder

Nothing you've said suggests any different of Apple.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by tw04 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @07:23PM (#39730348)
>Shareholder profit.

This is a tired trope. They have a clear interest in user privacy, as evidenced by their actions. You're either just trolling or being intentionally ignorant to the state of the market if you're claiming their only focus is "shareholder profit". Apple isn't Boeing.

>Must be true then. Definitely not marketing.

I mean, there are countless examples. From the default encryption in messages, to the ability to double encrypt icloud backups, to a literal lockdown mode in IOS to protect against nation state actors.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/105120

>Nothing you've said suggests any different of Apple.

You've provided absolutely nothing of substance beyond a link where Apple literally states they have hard requirements around user privacy for any advertising partners.

I'm done engaging in the conversation unless you've got something of substance to provide. The low effort one liners don't really have a place on HN.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by timschmidt on Saturday March 16, 2024 @07:40PM (#39730443)
If you pay attention to the marketing, Google, and Samsung, and Qualcomm, and Sony, and Microsoft make most if not all the same claims. I haven't seen one that operates in a way that can prove it. All have some level of custom silicon involved. All could provide hardware documentation, source code, and installable or transparent keying. Barring the legal agreements between them, of course. I commend Apple for their amazing effort to uniquely ID each individual sensor and storage device in the world and tie it permanently to phone's unique ID, but again, it would be nice if the details of how that worked were published such that folks like Louis Rossmann could repair folks broken phones and laptops.

> The low effort one liners don't really have a place on HN.

Maybe you just didn't think about them long enough.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by ekanes on Saturday March 16, 2024 @11:41PM (#39731752)
You're both right. Apple believes (as do many) that one way to achieve great shareholder profit is to differentiate yourself and perhaps get some pricing power is by truly prioritizing consumer privacy. They're both true.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by novok on Saturday March 16, 2024 @09:48PM (#39731193)
Apple's "privacy" is really privacy from people that are not Apple. Apple has access to location logs via maps and location services, the contents of your photos, iMessage contents, the history of every app usage, etc as the default settings set for most things via iCloud backup, which the vast majority of users leave on. They were almost going to deploy on device scanning that you couldn't opt out of with the few photos that don't end up on iCloud.

All of their devices don't work if they don't constantly phone home to Apple. For the devices to be anywhere near useful, you need an apple id which requires KYC payment methods attached for them or a KYC phone number.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by imoverclocked on Sunday March 17, 2024 @12:01AM (#39731834)
> Apple's "privacy" is really privacy from people that are not Apple.

Sort of, but misleading…

> Apple has access to location logs via maps and location services

There are published policies about how this data gets aggregated+anonymized and then used. Care is taken to ensure data is not linked to individuals.

> The contents of your photos, iMessage contents, the history of every app usage, etc as the default settings set for most things via iCloud backup

Most people want these things backed up. Apple doesn’t just dive through data. Anything that even approaches the description of dealing with user data is carefully vetted. A big difference between Apple and other large tech companies is the internal boundaries for access to any data. It’s strict and limited by design. Apple has fought back against law enforcement for access to personal data or technology to allow governments to carte blanche access devices.

> They were almost going to deploy on device scanning that you couldn't opt out of with the few photos that don't end up on iCloud.

You are referencing the CSAM scanning for known child pornography based on international databases that was tuned for highly unlikely false-positive rates with a small group of reviewers to further reduce any chance of false-positives? Yeah, total travesty… wouldn’t want to do anything about THAT problem. (/s)

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by victor106 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @10:08PM (#39731317)
this.

One of Apple’s biggest selling points is privacy.

Been using the AVP every day for about 3 hours and its truly stunning for a version 1 device. I can’t imagine what version 5 will be like.

I’ve also used the oculus but returned it.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by sneak on Saturday March 16, 2024 @10:11PM (#39731332)
Selling points, not actual privacy. The fact that you have to identify yourself (and link that identity to your hardware serial number) to install apps on your own device is the opposite of privacy.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by kelnos on Saturday March 16, 2024 @10:27PM (#39731408)
I'd personally just like to see things even more separate. I wouldn't want what I do on my VR headset tied to anything else.

Sorta like how I might have a Nintendo account (or whatever they have now) for games on a Switch. It's just about my gaming activity on that one platform, and that's it.

Tying a headset to a Meta/Facebook account is just too much: I don't want my Oculus activity tied to my social media.

I agree that the Apple situation is better, but I wouldn't want my Vision Pro activity tied to iPhone, Mac, Apple TV, etc. activity.

And I get it from the "building an integrated ecosystem" perspective, and don't really begrudge them their desire to make something like that, but I'm just generally tired of being a part of some company's ecosystem.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by account42 on Monday March 18, 2024 @04:51AM (#39741635)
How about not requiring accounts for all these different gadgets at all. What's wrong with being able to run whatever software you want on your VR headset or gaming tablet.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by vagrantJin on Sunday March 17, 2024 @09:04AM (#39734221)
how exactly do you know this and why come on here and state it as a fact?

its a dubious claim at best, and if it were true would require asking the elephant sized question in the room - why collect my data if you arent going to use/sell it anyway? is collecting ny data just a fun internal project at Apple?

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by esskay on Sunday March 17, 2024 @09:25AM (#39734346)
What data are they collecting about you, and who is it being sold to?

With Facebook its an easy answer - hobbies, intererests and habbits to use for targeted advertising.

That logic doesn't quite work for Apple given they arent showing ads on your OS, only in the app store.

It's pretty obvious Apple's revenue focus is on hardware and services, not on ads.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by xibbie on Monday March 18, 2024 @07:06AM (#39742462)
This is neither obvious nor accurate.

Apple's advertising business is estimated to be closing in on $10Bn yearly, while their browser pre-load deal with Google brings them in even more than that, and data-sharing agreements are assumed to be part of the deal.

The fallacy that Apple can be trusted with your data because it makes more money elsewhere is incredibly naive and unilateral.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by theshrike79 on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @05:01PM (#39760164)
Just to put this in perspective, Apple's yearly revenue is closing around 400B. 10B is in the "other" category in the revenue chart.

The ads are still only in the App store, where you need to specifically go and look for... apps. And you'll get ads for... apps.

You're not getting personalised ads for incontinence products because Apple doesn't know nor care that you have frequently visited a doctor specialising in said issues. Your phone does and Siri will suggest you the exact place as a destination if you start up maps in your CarPlay view.

Google and FB _will_ serve you said ads and with eery accuracy and speed. (I've visited a niche product store on my desktop browser, opened Instagram 5 minutes later and received ads for that exact niche)

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by esskay on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @05:07AM (#39764214)
> data-sharing agreements are assumed to be part of the deal

You're making a massive assumption there. Unless you can back that up it is what it is - fud.

You'll be fully aware that as part of Google's anti-trust case Apple was only willing to enter into data sharing with Google if they provided data to Apple, which they refused to do.

So again, we're still in a position of the only place Apple is focused on ads is the app store, so I'll ask again. What data are they collecting about you, and who is it being sold to?

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by zaphirplane on Monday March 18, 2024 @09:42AM (#39744390)
> its a dubious claim at best

Wow I’ll bite, proof by contradiction. There isn’t a single credible article claiming apple sells their customers information

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by thefz on Sunday March 17, 2024 @07:12PM (#39738919)
They are in PRISM just like any other, stop believing this lie.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by dilyevsky on Monday March 18, 2024 @12:12AM (#39740459)
PRISM is just NSA's management systems for sending lawful (kinda) information requests for specific accounts under FISA act to the companies. If data is not leaving your device (e.g not synced into iCloud) then they can't get it.

Also if you opt-in for apple's advanced data encryption[0] they can't even get that because your data is fully e2e encrypted and the key is only stored on your phone. Which is probably why FBI had to sue Apple to get data on Bernardino terries and then worked around by hacking into their devices. Show me another big tech company that does this.

[0] - https://support.apple.com/en-us/102651

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by thefz on Monday March 18, 2024 @02:27PM (#39748044)
Don't believe their lies. They let agencies directly into their supply line. Nobody is above the law and they must comply like any other.

The Bernardino case was a stunt to get people believing this lie. All the other cases in which Apple complies are not made publi, though.

Corporations are not your friend.

Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by dilyevsky on Monday March 18, 2024 @06:34PM (#39750871)
Right and you know this because…?
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by thefz on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @05:27PM (#39760416)
Snowden.
Re:Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right by dilyevsky on Friday March 22, 2024 @04:21AM (#39788457)
i think your timeline might be a bit off here...