News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by jph on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:32AM (#39589652)
The Apple press release response is here: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2024/03/the-app-store-spotify...
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:42AM (#39589750)
From the article:

> Spotify Pays Apple Nothing

This sound like a child not getting their ice-cream. Why does Apple feel entitled to get anything from Spotify? There has never been any precedence that application developers owe the platform they publish their applications on anything.

Also, Spotify never asked for an app store. They have been imposed an app store. And now Apple feel entitled to payment for that service? You have to be a government to set taxes.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by wil421 on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:29AM (#39590207)
How’s this so much different than Nintendo? I’ve never been able to play any game I want to and I’ve always been forced to go through Nintendo or Sony to play games on consoles. (Or Xbox)
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:14AM (#39590732)
You house hold AI is your friend:

So in summary, in 2021: - Number of Nintendos sold in EU: Over 7.1 million game consoles were sold total, and Nintendo Switch was the best-selling console. - Number of iPhones sold in EU: Around 56 million iPhones.

Another commenter mentioned in another discussion something that is very much applicable here:

    I'm under impression that Americans freak out because they tend to go full technical on laws, that is, they don't care much what the governments are trying to achieve with the laws but work within the limits of strict technicality. So a lot of Americans were freaking out here on HN when GDPR was introduced, some shutting down personal projects because were afraid to get in trouble with the EU laws and find themselves in huge and expensive lawsuits.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:21AM (#39591493)
So Americans freak out because they believe in rule of law?
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:26AM (#39591555)
That is not what the quote says, so no.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:34AM (#39591646)
Yeah the quote says Americans freak out because they interpret the law as written. Implicitly, the Europeans defer interpretation to various bureaucrats leading to absurd situations where, eg, member states are retroactively punished for facilitating tax schemes that were allowed by the laws on the books at the time. You might argue that’s a better system with better outcomes, but it’s not rule of law.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:47AM (#39591792)
I don't know what or who you are debating?

This was merely a commentary on why it might be that we haven't seen any reactions to Nintendo's way of doing business but do see actions on Apple.

The truth is that we might very well see actions towards Nintendo when the dust has settled.

And don't tell me that the US doesn't try laws on some cases in order to copy/paste results to similar cases.

That said, yes. The EU is first and foremost not a country. It is a union that spans several countries with different legal frameworks and traditions. So of cause writing and interpreting laws is different. That should not be too difficult to understand.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by bjornlouser on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:27PM (#39593097)
"That should not be too difficult to understand."

Also not difficult to understand Brexit.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:53PM (#39593535)
> Also not difficult to understand Brexit.

Please enlighten me. My own perception is that most brits do regret leaving the EU, which data supports:

https://www.statista.com/statistics/987347/brexit-opinion-po...

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by criddell on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:47AM (#39589796)
There's more than 45 years of precedent if you want to count video game consoles.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by grishka on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:04AM (#39589958)
Video game consoles are seen by most people, and marketed by their manufacturers, as appliances for playing video games. iPhones and iPads, on the other hand, are seen and marketed as general-purpose computing/communication devices. It's unprecedented for such a non-appliance to be locked down like this.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by nozzlegear on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:46AM (#39590396)
I’d contend that it’s not unprecedented, given that the iPhone is now 17 something years old.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by grishka on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:28AM (#39590896)
I mean, no other platform did that neither before nor after the iPhone came out. To my knowledge, all other smartphone OSes ever made had some way of sideloading apps.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by nozzlegear on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:07PM (#39595313)
True, I guess what I was trying to say is that everything's unprecedented until somebody makes the precedent.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by criddell on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:20PM (#39598721)
Checkout the i-mode. Something like 50 million people were using them in 2001 and they were even more locked down than the iPhone. This was the era when ringtones were $2.99 and cell phone networks were trying their hardest to hold on to that revenue. Closed was definitely the norm back then.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by grishka on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @01:32AM (#39600083)
I don't know about i-mode, but the main difficulty with custom ringtones in early 00s was that it wasn't easy to load them into your phone. Most of those phones (in my own experience) came with a ringtone editor where you entered them note by note. They could also be sent and received via SMS, but that in general only worked between phones of the same brand (try sending a ringtone from a Nokia to a Siemens and you get three screens of garbage characters, ask me how I found out). Later ones could be connected to a computer with a "data cable" that was a somewhat rare accessory, but you could then just load MIDI files. Oh, and IR ports. People used them all the time to share ringtones and images and games.

Same with Java games when they became popular. The hardest part was getting them onto your phone. You either used a data cable, or had GPRS set up in "internet" mode (as opposed to "wap"), or someone else shared them with you via IR port or Bluetooth.

Yes, there were paid ringtones/images/games, or course. But carriers themselves never sold them. It was third-party companies. A ringtone usually was $1.

Carrier-locked phones never really caught on in my country. It always worked such that you bought a phone for the full price and provided your own sim card. Some carriers tried the US model early on as an option, but people just weren't having it.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by aeyes on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:41AM (#39590337)
No there is not, one example would be the yellow tab EA cartridges for the Sega Genesis. EA reverse engineered the Genesis to get around the high licensing cost and Sega knew that they wouldn't be able to challenge this in court.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by westhanover on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:14AM (#39590731)
The yellow tab was nonvolatile memory so season progress could be saved. This comment is a complete lie and should be disregarded.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by aeyes on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:05PM (#39596775)
You could at least spend 1 minute on the Genesis Wikipedia article which includes several sources to verify my claims.

There you'll also find another case where Sega lost in court against similar reverse engineering done by Accolade to run their games on the Genesis without a license from Sega: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by matwood on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:10AM (#39590023)
> Why does Apple feel entitled to get anything from Spotify?

Apple has argued they do not sell a piece of hardware, but a platform. It includes hardware, software, and a marketplace (like a video game console like others have said). Apple will also say that they have cultivated the platform to have the most affluent users (like a console again). This shows up in the stats. Even with iOS having a minority marketshare in the EU, all developers want to be on it because that is where the money is. What is access to a market and platform like that worth? Apple thinks 15%-30%.

Yes, it has been symbiotic between Apple and devs, but Apple has done something that differentiated it from Android wrt the type of user. Otherwise, all the devs could have left and Apple would have been forced to change long ago.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:33AM (#39590259)
This is a really good answer.

> Apple has argued they do not sell a piece of hardware, but a platform.

This is exactly where the EU goes in and say that responsibilities follow when you sell a platform and you need to act responsibly in the market - Apple just acts up instead of accepting that they did not behave correctly, like a child.

The EU has even specified what it means to act reasonably in the market through DMA.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by xvector on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:53PM (#39609047)
The DMA is bizarrely protectionist and kind of a farce. Why doesn't it apply to Spotify? Ask any artist if Spotify should constitute a monopoly under the DMA.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by smoldesu on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:19PM (#39611488)
> Why doesn't it apply to Spotify?

Their infographic explains it nicely: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/image/conten...

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by xvector on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:28PM (#39611557)
Spotify is absolutely a market-making monopolistic platform all on its own. The DMA has been gerrymandered to conveniently exclude it.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by smoldesu on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @10:56PM (#39612122)
You're not entirely wrong, but the DMA isn't a response to the existence of music streaming apps. It's a direct and targeted remediation to Apple's uniquely oppressive behavior, and would apply to Spotify too should they do the same thing. It doesn't protect Spotify from future litigation in any way, and in many ways limits their business prospects.

We might see legislation against Spotify someday, but it would have to be drastically different to account for Spotify's own unique damages. Plus, compared to Apple's impact on the market at-large, they're literal magnitudes smaller.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by EMIRELADERO on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:24AM (#39590152)
> Apple has argued they do not sell a piece of hardware, but a platform. It includes hardware, software, and a marketplace (like a video game console like others have said).

Can this even be quantifiably measured? Usually when selling something you describe, itemize and bill for it.

The Apple developer agreement offers the developer tools and access to Apple's App Store and related services. The dev's argument is that Apple is forcing them to enter into that contract to distribute apps to iOS users even when they explicitly wish to opt out of using Apple's developer tools and services.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by matwood on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:04AM (#39591303)
> Can this even be quantifiably measured?

Apple thinks it's worth 15%-30%. While app developers may complain, most still stay on the platform.

Or are you talking about how much the market is worth?

A new analysis has shown that iPhone users spend seven times more on apps than Android users, far higher than the 4x rule of thumb suggested by purely anecdotal data.

https://9to5mac.com/2023/09/06/iphone-users-spend-apps/

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by EMIRELADERO on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:18AM (#39591461)
I'm talking about the goods or services that are sold.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by matwood on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:34AM (#39591647)
One of the goods that Apple sells to developers is the market of users. Attention of high value users is one of the most valuable items for sale today.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by EMIRELADERO on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:25AM (#39592200)
Legally speaking, there is no such thing. iOS is not a service, it is a good.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:20AM (#39591482)
It is not possible to run software on iOS, an Apple software product, without running Apple’s developer tools. Are you thinking Spotify wants to opt out and build its own software stack for iPhone from kernel and baseband up?
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by EMIRELADERO on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:27AM (#39592235)
It's fully possible, much like it's possible to compile Windows programs/libraries on Linux today.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:15PM (#39592921)
It’s possible to run Spotify on Android but that has nothing to do with running it on iPhone.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by EMIRELADERO on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:37AM (#39599824)
I think you missed the argument. Since it's technically possible to compile an iOS app that uses iOS APIs without using Apple's developer tools, Apple would not have a claim that the developers "used their IP" in that situation. Calling APIs is not an exclusive IP right.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by gorbypark on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:50AM (#39589834)
I agree with the sentiment, but that's not entirely true. Video game console have pretty much always relied on this model to make money.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by izacus on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:53AM (#39589865)
Then let's kill that too. We don't need rent seekers killing free market competition.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by quesera on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:40AM (#39590332)
It is not rent-seeking when you built the house and perform the services for which payment is demanded.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by izacus on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:38AM (#39591040)
It's literally the definition of rent seeking and it's toxic to free market society.

We don't want your landlord to get a cut of every thing you buy in their apartment. We don't want them to get a cut of every service you order. We dont't want them to get a cut of every single thing you buy while living in that apartment.

We don't want those things for digital landlords either just because they deigned to put together some eletronics they were already paid for.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:22AM (#39591500)
Landlording is rent seeking because the landlord did not create the primary value of a property: place. This is not the same at all.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by izacus on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:58AM (#39591915)
Neither did Apple, Sony, Nintendo or Microsoft. They already got paid for their iPhones, Xboxes, PS4s and Switches (consoles have stopped being sold with a loss around PS3 generation). Apple earns fat profits and margins on their hardware especially.

Primary value is created by game developers, app developers and other people building things on top of those platforms.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:14PM (#39592901)
If you believe this, then clearly you should believe that Spotify should be free after initial payment. After all, the recording artist was already paid, the mp3 exists, and the incremental cost to stream a song approaches $0.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by izacus on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:32PM (#39594882)
No, I don't clearly believe that. Don't strawman.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:41PM (#39594988)
It’s not a strawman. It’s an application of your claim that up front payment gives rights to perpetual and arbitrary use of a product. Content DRM is as arbitrary and artificial as any iOS limitation.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by quesera on Monday March 04, 2024 @01:56PM (#39594411)
The "primary value of a property" (place), then, does not keep you warm or protect you from rain or theft, has no amenities nor facilities to store your belongings. It does not supply water or electricity, and has no responsible party to keep it maintained.

You might instead choose a open field, or under a bridge, which would require no rent payment.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shuckles on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:37PM (#39597083)
The locational value of most property far outweighs the value of improvements on it. This is not a particularly controversial statement among economists. A 1000 ft. high rise in Antarctica is not very valuable. A lord who extracts taxes from peasants that grow crops on it does little to improve the ground.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by quesera on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:23PM (#39598307)
Only correct if you choose the extremes.

Regardless, open fields and under bridges in, e.g., San Francisco are lousy places to live. Without the improvements, you do not have a home.

So most people choose to pay for the "places" with improvements.

The primary value of a property is therefore not the place.

Location is sometimes the most significant variable in the value of a property. But that is not the same thing.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by GardenLetter27 on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:52AM (#39590470)
They should be able to opt-out though.

E.g. sell games but use no Xbox services on Xbox.

I wonder if the DMA will bring Steam to consoles.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by mopsi on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:17AM (#39590767)
Thankfully, that's dying on under its own weight now. Games have become so expensive to develop that sales from a single platform struggle to support many of them.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by madsbuch on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:08AM (#39590003)
Video games are not general applications, but a niche set of applications.

The tradition I look into when downloading Spotify is WinAMP, VLC, FileZilla and the like.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by nozzlegear on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:49AM (#39590438)
That seems like an arbitrary distinction. I could say that iOS apps are not general applications, but a niche set of applications.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by Aloisius on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:56PM (#39593588)
Video game consoles run things besides video games.

There's a Spotify app for both Xbox and Playstation for goodness sake.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by Hikikomori on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:09AM (#39590007)
To reduce the cost of the gaming console, does Apple loose money on selling iPhones?
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by brtknr on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:08AM (#39590001)
Surely Spotify wouldn't be able to publish if it wasn't paying $100/year fee to Apple. I guess $100 is nothing to Apple.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by lozenge on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:53AM (#39589864)
Spotify does pay - 30% of subscription fees.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by shadowfiend on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:59AM (#39589910)
They do not. This entire case is about them not being able to use in app purchases (in which case they would pay 30%) or steer people to their site to pay for subscriptions. Spotify doesn’t sell subscriptions from the apps, and thus they pay nothing.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by CubsFan1060 on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:57AM (#39589893)
I thought that you couldn't subscribe to Spotify via the App. Am I wrong?
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by piva00 on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:01AM (#39589933)
You are correct, and Spotify can't steer people to a subscription flow outside of the app through the app to not infringe into App Store's policies either. That's one of the main issues, either you pay the 30% Apple tax or you can't even tell your users "click here to subscribe" to a checkout flow outside of the app and App Store.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by aquatica on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:43AM (#39589752)
Their response is the kind of arrogant that makes me want to see them get fined for the entirety of their cash reserve.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by t8sr on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:11AM (#39590033)
Seriously, what audience is Apple playing this to? The insinuations made in this press release should get them sued again for libel. Not to mention how off putting this kind of tantrum is for their customers.

JFC, they really need to fix their PR team here.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by geodel on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:02AM (#39590596)
LoL. Under what law? Perhaps "I don't like it Law"
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by Gravityloss on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:35AM (#39589680)
Interesting claim:

> Today, Spotify has a 56 percent share of Europe’s music streaming market — more than double their closest competitor’s — and pays Apple nothing for the services that have helped make them one of the most recognizable brands in the world.

Don't they have to pay the provision of the subscription like other apps?

EDIT: actually read the letter and they indeed don't (thanks for the responses too)

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by efraim on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:48AM (#39589806)
> Today, Spotify has a 56 percent share of Europe’s music streaming market — more than double their closest competitor’s — and pays Apple nothing for the services that have helped make them one of the most recognizable brands in the world.

And they shouldn't have to, users should be able to install whatever software they want on their devices without paying a gatekeeper for it. Spotify exists on the web as well, they don't have to pay Google or Mozilla for delivering the service to their users. They don't have to pay Microsoft when users downloads and installs desktop software for windows. So why should Apple get any money because users install Spotify on their iphones? I'm sure Spotify pays Google for their cloud services that actually helps make them successful.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by ralfd on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:43AM (#39590360)
> they don't have to pay Google or Mozilla for delivering the service to their users.

Spotify has a secret deal with Google:

https://www.theverge.com/2023/11/20/23969690/google-spotify-...

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by lutoma on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:39AM (#39589715)
Spotify does not allow you to subscribe in their iOS app. You have to do that in a browser and then log in. That way Apple does not get a cut.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by transcriptase on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:53AM (#39589868)
It’s telling that Apple would rather get 30% of 0 than lower their fees to the point where it’s mutually beneficial for Spotify and other large apps to offer in-app subscriptions.

If an app is charging users $1000 a month, what entitles Apple to $300 of that versus the $3 of a $10 subscription? It seems like more of a tax than a fee that allows Apple to profitably operate the store and infrastructure.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by have_faith on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:53AM (#39589863)
So much arrogance from them recently. The biggest threat to Apple right now are themselves.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by ankit219 on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:39AM (#39589721)
It explains it later that spotify does not allow for subscription via App store. so, all they pay is $100 per year as a dev fee which is basically nothing. Apple also claims that they flew an engineer to Sweden to help out Spotify.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by trollied on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:49AM (#39589821)
$100/year dev license. Not bad for 119 billion downloads!
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by Mindwipe on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:51AM (#39591185)
If Apple want to charge more for X-code and it's not mandatory to use it to sign the keys they should.

I think everyone knows how that would go for them in a competitive market.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by grishka on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:08AM (#39589996)
> for the services that have helped make them one of the most recognizable brands in the world

I'm pretty sure Apple did nothing for that, Spotify's own marketing did. It's not like people discover that Spotify is a thing thanks to the app store.

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by pohuing on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:41AM (#39589739)
Apparently not. Spotify sells their subscriptions on their website.
Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by raverbashing on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:40AM (#39589733)
> pays Apple nothing

Nothing? Not even the developers fees?

C'mon Apple

Re:Apple hit with over 1.8B euro EU antitrust fine in Spotif... by javier_e06 on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:45AM (#39589776)
I search Apple's response for the word cheaper and the phrase 'less expensive' which is the issue at hand, Apple insistence and not letting developer offer less expensive options in their own store. I found nothing of the sort. Apple is not a store, its a Mall. Imagine a Mall where security people enters your store to verify that you are not advertising stores at different Mall or else you get booted?