News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by zizee on Saturday March 02, 2024 @11:57PM (#39578530)
The Northern Irish population voted to stay in the European union, with 55.8% voting to stay. Could this trigger a vote for leaving the UK, and uniting with Ireland?

https://metro.co.uk/2017/12/06/northern-ireland-vote-brexit-...

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by leereeves on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:07AM (#39578574)
If Northern Ireland did vote to leave the UK, what would happen? Would the UK actually let them leave? Would the EU allow it?

When Catalonia voted for independence from Spain, Spain arrested the people who organized the vote, and even the EU said they would not accept an independent Catalonia.

Despite police violence meant to disrupt the vote, there was about 42 percent voter turnout, and about 90 percent voted for secession. Nonetheless, Catalonia is still part of Spain.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by kennywinker on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:21AM (#39578638)
I believe as part of the Good Friday agreement, england has committed to permitting irish unification if a majority supports it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Friday_Agreement

Now, would they find a way to contest any vote to unify? Maybe

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by adastra22 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:12AM (#39578856)
Just a simple majority? I hope that the Brexit disaster has shown that it is essential such decisions have a supermajority backing.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by sharlos201068 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:19AM (#39579607)
I don't think being a simple majority was the issue with brexit, it was the fact people were voting on a vague question with no clear outcome.

Politicians were promising a brexit that could never happen.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by lucubratory on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:12AM (#39579103)
Oh that's a really good point, that might be the logic they use to try to deny the Irish people their independence.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by adastra22 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:23AM (#39579151)
Or it might avoid a disastrous reversion to the violence of the Troubles.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by chgs on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:45AM (#39579239)
There seems to be this American view that the U.K. wants NI. Nobody wants NI, it’s just that any change from the Good Friday status quo is a disaster for one side or another, both of whom have used violence for their cause.

Democracy is shit when 40% of your country have major everlasting change thrust upon them against their will.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by adastra22 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:15AM (#39579353)
Huh? No assumption was made in my statement about what the UK wants or doesn’t want. Just that a significant, irreversible change from the status quo should probably require a supermajority vote. This prevents outcomes like Brexit where you get a deeply divided nation, or issues related to voter turnout causing an actual minority side to win.

I think we’re saying the same thing.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by chgs on Sunday March 03, 2024 @06:45AM (#39580244)
What’s important is that no matter if it’s 52:48 or 92:8, the losing side don’t lose everything. In the case of NI leaving the U.K., all NI citizens who want to should be able to retain their U.K. citizenship, in the case of the U.K. leaving the EU the same should have applied, and the same with Scotland, Catalonia, Texas etc.

I would be no happier with brexit had the result been 80:20 to leave, but if the 20% could have retained their EU citizenship it would have made things far more palatable.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by nixass on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:41AM (#39578985)
are you really comparing reunification of ireland with brexit?
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by behringer on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:02AM (#39579061)
Yes. Why not?
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by jakderrida on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:17AM (#39578880)
> I hope that the Brexit disaster has shown that it is essential such decisions have a supermajority backing.

LMAO! That's a great freaking point! Obviously, simple majorities are perfect recipes for the shitshow they're currently in.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by desas on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:19AM (#39579371)
Why would we want to?
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by ivandenysov on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:21AM (#39578635)
I guess one big difference is that Northern Ireland would probably vote to join Ireland instead of just being independent from the UK. Not sure if that could impact EU’s stance.

‘Getting’ new territories from a non-EU country sounds even worse than allowing a chunk of a member state to become an independent country.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by wkat4242 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:56AM (#39578803)
Yeah almost nobody there wants independence. It's either joining Ireland or staying in the UK.

Also if the UK permits the vote as part of the good Friday agreement the EU won't have an issue with it. Don't forget they also had no issue with the Scottish independence referendum when the UK was still in the EU.

There was a bit of doubt whether an independent Scotland could join the EU however, which I believe was mostly why they voted to remain part of the UK (ironically due to the Brexit vote that came after they had to leave the EU anyway, they probably would have been able to stay in the EU if they had voted to leave the UK!)

But if NI joins Ireland there won't be any issue from the EU side I think. The situation will be very different to Catalonia.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by Tsiklon on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:01AM (#39578812)
The scenario is different compared to Catalonia, the Catalonia scenario is more like the Scottish independence referendum, a new country would be created in that scenario.

The Good Friday agreement permits Northern Ireland to leave the UK and to join the ROI, there is no path to independence here.

Reunion can only happen by mutual consent of all people in Ireland, and the document demands two simultaneous referenda to occur to fulfil this, one in NI, the other in ROI.

The referendum in NI, can be called at any time the UK’s Secretary of State for NI, deems that it would be likely that it would prove to be successful. This stance is shared by the Tories and Labour in Westminster.

Unlike Catalonia, there is also likely to be wider support for reunion from other important third parties - namely the US and EU - The United States, both from her people and government, proving to be key mediators in the Good Friday negotiations, and subsequent important negotiations like the Richard Haass talks.

The EU, prior to the UK’s withdrawal from it, funded large regeneration and reconciliation projects within NI. I believe this would continue forward post reunification.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by bruce511 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:21AM (#39578903)
Some years ago I predicted to a Northern Irish acquaintance that Ireland would unify by 2035.

I based this on various things, but primarily because it's the "obvious thing to do". It brings NI into the EU, and that would appear to be a long-term good.

Seeing the UK economy suffer from Brexit, the treatment of NI by Westminster (who mostly pretend if doesn't exist anyway), and ultimately the aging of the UK support in NI, the end result is "obvious".

Ultimately its hard to predict time lines with geo-politics, but I expect to see real movement in this direction over the next decade.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by disgruntledphd2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:10AM (#39579848)
It's an identity thing rather than an economic thing so predictions based on the economy are unlikely to prove correct.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by biorach on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:38AM (#39579963)
It will play a role tho
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by jakderrida on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:15AM (#39578874)
> The Good Friday agreement permits Northern Ireland to leave the UK and to join the ROI, there is no path to independence here.

Which, despite what most people think, isn't the utopian goal of the Catholics there, afaik. More like something they might settle for, if it's pragmatic and generally beneficial to the people. I've been told it's not exactly the golden ticket to the promised land outsiders seem to think it is.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by bradley13 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:33AM (#39579195)
Given a contiguous region large enough to make sense, which Catalonia clearly is, secession should be an option. Denying this is just politicians protecting each other's power.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by chgs on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:43AM (#39579234)
It course it would. Unlike Spain the U.K. population is happy with the principle of self determinism (Chagos islands are somewhat special as is an American base with no population for the last 50 years, historical claims to land are somewhat different)

Realpolitik sometimes gets in the way of this - why doesn’t the US recognise Taiwan as a country? Why doesn’t Brazil recognise Kosovo?

If Scottish people want to be independent, or northern Irish, or Cornish, or Yorkshire, or Falklands, or Gibraltar, or Ceuta, or Catalonia, or Crimea, or Texas, or Kosovo. or North Cyprus, then that’s upto the people who live there.

Northern Ireland had a referendum and one side decided as they wouldn’t win they wouldn’t take part. Scotland had a referendum too and decided to stay. There’s been no real change in opinion in Scotland, despite the travesty of the EU vote.

The problem with NI, Scotland and the EU is the opinions is roughly 50/50, whatever you do half the country are losses off.

In reality if the people of Northern Ireland wanted independence they would only want it if they could join Ireland, and joining Ireland would require the Irish government to accept a basket case of an economy, not to mention the continued partisan issues that have plagued the country for centuries, nobody wants change, but as predicted in Trek, an act of terror (brexit) may well lead to it as brexit changed the status quo.

Catalonia wanted complete independence, although as you said though, less than 40% of the adult population wanted it in that vote. Certainly they should be allowed if the majority want it, as long as Spanish citizenship is not removed from any resident who doesn’t want it removed and every resident got Catalonia citizenship as well if they wanted it (my view would be you would only grant independence if over half the adult population agreed to forfeit their Spanish citizenship).

Catalonia would then be free to apply for EU candidate status as a free and independent country, just like Scotland. Spain would not want that, so Catalonia would have to be a small independent country and start from scratch.

Spain doesn’t recognise Kosovo either. Their view is that territory is more important than self determination. See their view on Gibraltar. Spain would thus be unlikely to recognise an independent Scotland or Northern Ireland, and thus EU membership as an independent country would be out.

So with Ireland not wanting the economic drain of the north (only 1 in 8 Irish Republic citizens want unification if United Ireland had to pay), Spain not wanting any independence move to succeed, Northern Ireland is stuck in the continued compromise it has been since 1997. Brexit of course massively damaged everything, and far more want the U.K. to join the EU than want say Catalonian independence, but we are where we are.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by a_dabbler on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:01AM (#39579802)
Most of the recent polls show that Ireland would support reunification with NI with 60-66% saying yes. There is one poll from 2015 that asks if you would support it if it means you'd have to pay more tax, is that the one you're referring to? Even then support is over 30% https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_on_a_United_...
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by chgs on Sunday March 03, 2024 @06:49AM (#39580262)
Plurality in the north doesn’t want it. Vast majority in the south won’t pay for it.

https://m.independent.ie/irish-news/majority-favour-a-united...

“Only one in eight would vote for unity if the handover required the Republic to take on Britain’s full costs of subsidizing Northern Ireland. ”

https://www.politico.eu/article/poll-ireland-unification-sup...

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by thinkingemote on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:12AM (#39579335)
I've heard it say that Ireland isn't particularly keen on NI mainly for economic reasons. It would prove a drain and a burden. Also many in the North would lose out on certain social and economic benefits (certain healthcare costs for example). It seems these facts are stronger than the ideals of unification. These social and economic factors real and imagined (and magnified and played upon!) during the Brexit referendum played the key part, and thus it was that Northern Ireland voted for the UK to remain in the EU, not for themselves.

I've also heard it say that the old school nationalists feel unsupported. The major Irish historically nationalist party is seen to be almost compromised as they are pro immigration and open borders where historically they were more, well .... nationalist!

Indeed that's a challenge of all nationalist parties across Europe who campaign for independence seen in Catalonia for example. Should a nationalist seeking independence be pro Europe at the expense of their own nation?

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by hkpack on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:47AM (#39579478)
> Should a nationalist seeking independence be pro Europe at the expense of their own nation?

It is interesting, that from my point of view, what you're talking about has even no sense. What does "at the expense of their own nation" even mean? Do you mean that any "nationalist" government means isolationism? Have you confused nationalism with nazism? How you equalise immigration and occupation in one sentence is also interesting.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by thinkingemote on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:08AM (#39579554)
That's right it does makes no sense today as what does a nation really mean today? What does a nationalist party mean when they cant appeal to nationhood or people? There has been a change. Today one can only focus on political and social benefits of reunification rather than any traditional appeal to a people and a nation. The traditional supporters of reunification are outdated.

We see some nationalism in Europe and they generally seek to split from Europe. (It is different in Ireland however) All nationalists by definition appeal to their nation. They think that they see a weakening of their nation via immigration as it goes against their group identity. In a good way Europe acts against nationalism by every country working together.

The original Irish nationalists would not want a weaker national identity but a stronger one through unification. Is the aim of stronger national identity still allowed? I've heard that the older supporters feel that something has been compromised. I'm not saying older supporters are racist - rather that the ideals they have of an Irish people and nationhood are not being promoted by their previous political champions. They hold outdated views. It is difficult for a supporter of reunification to appeal to the idea of a national identity or an "Irish people" in today's time.

Indeed many modern people today consider the very notion of national identity as outdated and troublesome. Most of the troubles we see across the world from Ukraine to Palestine are based on the thorny issue of nation and people. Most of the troubles we saw in the Troubles was based on the issue of nation and people. Is it any wonder that the ideals of nation and people are being discounted for the good of all?

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by hkpack on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:00AM (#39579799)
I think you're just using terms loosely. Also I think Wikipedia article on nationalism is pretty good and should remove any confusion.

In my opinion there is nothing outdated in the term "nation". Also, if you're from the US, you need to understand that Europe is very diverse, and there are a lot of nuances.

In the topic of our discussion - nationalism in countries which were colonies or under control of a "perceived" foreign state for a long time are pro-independence from that state first, and their flavour of nationalism is very different than in the ones which were historically "colonisers" themselves.

As an example, you can see that a lot of people which voted for Wales independence, were actually pro-EU, and Brexit actually increased the amount of people in Wales who wanted independence. So Welsh nationalism is very different than British nationalism, however the territories and people can intersect.

So there should be no surprise that Irish nationalism is about governing Ireland independent from UK first, and can be pro-EU, especially, when British nationalists can be against-EU (which may not be the case in reality or not uniformly).

Any national government tries to rule based on the values of their people. And these values can differ from one territory to another.

Also, speaking of Ireland you need to account that almost half of the Ireland population emigrated because of different hardships in the last century, so it is difficult for a county to have isolationism values when its population values moving to different countries as well.

> Most of the troubles we see across the world from Ukraine to Palestine are based on the thorny issue of nation and people.

I cannot speak about Israel-Pelestine conflict, but living in Ukraine I can assure you that you are very wrong here. There is zero issue with the question of nation and nationalism related to this conflict.

[dead]
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by dang on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @08:39PM (#39611277)
Trollish usernames aren't allowed on HN, so I've banned this account.

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Also, it's not allowed to use HN primarily for political battle, which you've been doing, so there's that as well.

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by dang on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:29PM (#39623138)
Yes, the world is full of the confused and misinformed, and commenters here need to follow HN's rules.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by kckebskal on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:54AM (#39579502)
My understanding is that Irish nationalism (as with many nationalist independence movements) are actually pretty left wing and do not share the characteristics of what we would traditionally consider nationalism.

C.f. Many nationalist movements in Africa

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by biorach on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:19AM (#39579887)
> I've also heard it say that the old school nationalists feel unsupported. The major Irish historically nationalist party is seen to be almost compromised as they are pro immigration and open borders where historically they were more, well .... nationalist

That's quite inaccurate. The Nationalist movement in the context of Northern Ireland has fundamental differences from "Nationalist" movements elsewhere in Europe, to the point where the name is somewhat misleading to outsiders. Ideologically they were until recently a left-wing liberation movement. You may dispute the honesty or validity of that, but that was the basis of their politics.

These days things are changing, of course, but still, your mention of immigration and borders is, while relevant, not based on a good understanding of the dynamics of the various movements in contemporary Irish politics.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by thinkingemote on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:26AM (#39579912)
Thank you. Sorry to have confused matters with the usual right wing nationalist associations. My intention was to highlight how the ideas and beliefs of nation and people (or tribe/group identity) towards unification have been challenged in modern times. For the better I might add in that it increases peace.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by jowea on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:59AM (#39580064)
I suspect the EU is actually what makes separatism viable. Without the EU and related treaties you'd suddenly have a hard border across a previously united country with all the social and economic consequences we have seen in the partition of India or Austria-Hungary.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by cykros on Sunday March 03, 2024 @10:51AM (#39581602)
I'd wondered a bit about this. Hard to be all that excited as a nationalist when you participate in the EU. It's more about which non-Irish authority you're looking to bow to; Brussels or London.

Biggest benefit to reunification would seem to be that NI would be able to draw in more companies who may be seeking the lower tax rate, which could help the local economy a bit more. That, and rejoining the single market, for however long the EU manages to hang on for.

Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by imbnwa on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:29PM (#39584239)
Only England was stupid enough to depart from the European Union. Catalonian separatists were actually expecting support from the EU, they had zero intention of not being an EU member state.
Re:The 'banned' Star Trek episode that promised a united Ire... by tim333 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:03PM (#39584522)
I doubt the Brexit fallout will trigger a reunification vote, however changing demographics may with time. If it got to the state where there was a clear majority in the north for rejoining it could lead to a vote.