News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by TrueGeek on Friday February 23, 2024 @10:48AM (#39482054)
I'm the opposite. In movies (and real life to an extent) I have trouble telling people apart. I'd love a closed caption like service that just put name tags over everyone.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by ryandrake on Friday February 23, 2024 @10:53AM (#39482128)
That's one of the perpetually-SciFi use cases of Augmented Reality: You're walking around with AR glasses and whenever someone comes into your field of view, your display hovers over them their name, their job, when you last talked to them, what their hobbies are, and so on. A huge privacy nightmare, but useful for people who can't recall names and details about people they've met.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by egeozcan on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:04AM (#39482308)
I don't think it'd be a privacy nightmare if it used private databases created by the user. Like a personal CRM, something like Monica, but with a real-time touch.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by avarun on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:40AM (#39482835)
Wouldn't be from a legal sense, but the societal implications of technology like that becoming commonplace are still immense. The limitations of human memory provide safety in a way today that would quickly erode if everybody could remember exactly everything that's ever been said or seen around them.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by chambored on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:53AM (#39483041)
Safety from what exactly?
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by avarun on Friday February 23, 2024 @02:58PM (#39485364)
"You said X 3 years ago, but now you said, which is the opposite of X. How dare you?" is one class of problems. Another is that you can learn quite a bit more about a person than they wished to actually divulge to you if you're able to capture and study their exact behaviors over a long enough stretch of time.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by twerkmonsta on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:50PM (#39487160)
Wait, why are people not allowed to change their mind on something? If anything this would make it more explicit and understandable when people did change their mind on something.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by ziddoap on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:08PM (#39487322)
>Wait, why are people not allowed to change their mind on something

I don't think parent comment is suggesting that people aren't allowed to change their mind.

They are pointing out that many people yell "hypocrite!" when someone does change their mind. It's already a phenomenon on social media where people will dig through someone's post history and drag them through the coals, using previous stances on a topic in an attempt to discredit the current stance. Parent is suggesting that this problem would be exacerbated.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by int_19h on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:56PM (#39488434)
I think that people will stop yelling "hypocrite!" once they themselves get repeatedly get called out on the same by others.

Our reactions to stuff like that are defined largely by our cultural expectations, but those are in turn constantly shaped by what is made possible or impossible by technology. Back in the pre-voicemail phone era, for example, people would routinely call someone and expect them to be available for a half-hour chat - you could turn it down, sure, but in many cases it would be considered impolite to do so as a matter of social convention. Then voicemail appeared, and SMS was the final nail in that coffin.

So I think that this problem will exist for a while, but if the tech that enables it persists long enough, it will eventually go on as conventions change to adapt to it.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by true_religion on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:27PM (#39488575)
I disagree. People would instead become like modern politicians and never give an opinion.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by int_19h on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:56PM (#39489236)
They won't have that option, because AI will happily infer their actual opinions from things they do say (and how they say them).
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by justahuman74 on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:19PM (#39489084)
Politicians are trying really hard to show a particular public image, their job depends on it.

In my job you could call me a hypocrite all day and it wouldn't matter (though I'd find the uncreative repetition annoying)

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Viliam1234 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:30AM (#39491716)
> Wait, why are people not allowed to change their mind on something?

In theory, changing your mind should signal that you are capable of thinking about things, and changing your mind based on what you learn.

In practice, most people's opinions are determined by peer pressure. You believe X because the important people around you believe X.

From that perspective, changing your mind means that your loyalty has changed. Previously you tried to be friends with people who believed X, now you are trying to be friends with people who believe Y. No one likes a traitor.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Cyph0n on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:06PM (#39487773)
For an interesting exploration of this, I suggest watching the Black Mirror episode “The Entire History of You” (S1E3).
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by nindalf on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:06AM (#39490235)
Honestly one of the best episodes of TV I’ve seen, simply because it challenged one of my core beliefs. I’ve always struggled with a poor memory and I’ve tried all kinds of systems to improve retention and recall. This episode challenged the benefits of remembering everything pretty well and made me reconsider.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Breza on Friday March 08, 2024 @09:22AM (#39641269)
I agree with you. I had a bit of a falling out with a friend and wanted to check in on her a few years later. The immediately preceding messages in Messenger were the largely-forgotten unpleasantness. Quite awkward. It really drove home how much of a blessing forgetting every little slight is.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by groggo on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:41AM (#39482856)
Still privacy nightmare and creepy. There's plenty of public info on people, that once collected and assembled into one place is basically stalking. Not saying it's not a cool idea though :)
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Aeolun on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:26PM (#39487890)
This is no different from my photo’s app automatically labelling faces right?

I’m fairly certain the vision pro could do it right now.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by rasz on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:19PM (#39487847)
Install our virtual keyboard/virtual screen saver/dancing baby/flashlight app

/small print: requires read all, send all permissions

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by HKH2 on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:14AM (#39482468)
And instead of just shrugging it off, you could tag strangers that annoy you and end up with a giant list of grudges against a whole host of people. The false positives (e.g. twins and doppelgangers) should make it interesting.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by EwanG on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:24AM (#39482619)
Which feeds into Saint Motel's song "You're Nobody Til Somebody Wants You Dead" which has a bit about how the list just grows and grows until it's everyone you've ever known...
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by dylan604 on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:35AM (#39482780)
Take it to the next step towards Black Mirror where the AR shadows out people you've blocked and then mutes their voice so you can't hear them
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by earthnail on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:42AM (#39482866)
That would make for fantastic comedic situations when you then physically bump into them after you erased them from your AR vision xD.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by pmarreck on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:12AM (#39482440)
I had a product idea for an AR app that would do this for everyone who's opted into it. So for real-world networking events, you might choose to disclose some things about yourself but only for that venue and only for some window of time for example.

I never built it, but it's perfectly possible to do.

The genius idea IMHO was the business model- If you were into certain things you wanted to keep private from most but only wanted to disclose to other people who were into those same things, you could pay a fee, and it would then show you others who were in that "market" (of ideas, drugs, sex, whatever). (It might only ask you to pay it if it found someone nearby who matched. And then it would automatically notify the other person unless you paid an ADDITIONAL fee... Not sure about the latter idea, but it was an idea.)

The only issue is everyone holding their phone up in front of their faces.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by HKH2 on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:31AM (#39482718)
How would you stop spies or undercover cops trying to infiltrate the "market"?
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by pmarreck on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:36AM (#39482786)
Or people who want to "out" gay people. I know.

That would be a good argument over not permitting a unilateral notification of a match (which, at the very least, I wanted to make very expensive and thus profitable, if it's allowed at all). If it notified both people 100% of the time, and one of you was a possible impostor, you could report them. And from a legal standpoint, showing interest in a market doesn't make you guilty. And, you could possibly also build "cred" in one of these tagged "markets" by getting cred from others who say you're legit, and that information would be revealed at the same time (possibly at your discretion).

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by HKH2 on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:08PM (#39488156)
Makes sense. You still might get honeypots though; could you make cred work more generally with trust between friends, friends of friends etc. without compromising the markets?
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by pmarreck on Sunday February 25, 2024 @06:46PM (#39506169)
Well, are there other markets where the same cred has worked? AFAIK, when Silk Road was a thing, one's cred on there was protected and valuable.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by HKH2 on Sunday February 25, 2024 @10:00PM (#39507220)
True. I didn't mean to imply that it doesn't work.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by piva00 on Friday February 23, 2024 @12:28PM (#39483539)
> The genius idea IMHO was the business model- If you were into certain things you wanted to keep private from most but only wanted to disclose to other people who were into those same things, you could pay a fee

> The only issue is everyone holding their phone up in front of their faces.

No, the genius idea is its major issue, just by paying you gain access to private data (people's preferences) without any kind of chain of trust to make sure that someone is actually part of the group ("market" in your terms) for which they want access to.

By paying you could know that someone around you is looking for cocaine, or is willing to sell sexual services, or is looking to match other people from the same gender, or holds a certain political view against an authoritarian government, etc.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by pmarreck on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:28PM (#39486339)
I answered this in a sibling comment. You could acquire credibility in a particular preference from the network over time.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39482786

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by bluefirebrand on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:23PM (#39487868)
Sounds great, I'm going to make a "credibility as a service" startup and we'll find ways to farm whatever score in whatever fields you want.

And you can be sure government agencies will do the same.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by pmarreck on Sunday February 25, 2024 @06:45PM (#39506157)
Odd that you think this would happen for my little idea when this hasn't happened for credit cards which is possibly the largest financial incentive possible. To my knowledge, I can't buy a credit score
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by bluefirebrand on Sunday February 25, 2024 @07:42PM (#39506511)
Finance is a heavily regulated industry, so people trust credit providers with things like social insurance numbers, which are not transferrable between people

Your service would probably not be able to tie so uniquely to an individual, so there would be ways for people to transfer it.

Or just hire a company to pretend to be you for a while.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by chowells on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:52PM (#39487669)
So your genius idea is to get people to pay to put themselves on a future blackmail list when your data is leaked/stolen/sold? I have to say, it is a kind of evil genius.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by visarga on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:35PM (#39489145)
Basically the Slack experience. You don't need to remember people, you can see your past interactions right there.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by BurningFrog on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:01AM (#39482257)
I've seen scenes in movies where assistants of heads of state will discreetly whisper to them who the people in the room are.

With a service like this we could all live like Kings!

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by avarun on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:42AM (#39482873)
This features distinctively in the show Veep, where one of the main characters provides exactly this for the Vice President.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by eesmith on Friday February 23, 2024 @12:53PM (#39483872)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farley_file

> A Farley file is a set of records kept by politicians on people whom they have met.

> The term is named for James Farley, Franklin Roosevelt's campaign manager. Farley, who went on to become Postmaster General and chairman of the Democratic National Committee, kept a file on everyone he or Roosevelt met.

> Whenever people were scheduled to meet again with Roosevelt, Farley would review their files. That allowed Roosevelt to meet them again while knowing their spouse, their children's names and ages, and anything else that had come out of earlier meetings or any other intelligence that Farley had added to the file. The effect was powerful and intimate.

> Farley files are now commonly kept by other politicians and businesspeople.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Viliam1234 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:33AM (#39491734)
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by dboreham on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:22PM (#39487435)
The sad truth is that technology isn't much used to help people. Instead it's used to make money. E.g. there's all this amazing AI, buy my phone keyboard autocorrect has the intelligence of a slug.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by crooked-v on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:25PM (#39487885)
> my phone keyboard autocorrect has the intelligence of a slug

iOS 17 already uses a local LLM under the hood for autocorrect and text suggestions. Responses to the change (at least for people who actually noticed it) have been pretty universally positive.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by Turing_Machine on Monday February 26, 2024 @01:39AM (#39508224)
> Instead it's used to make money.

Most people find having more money to be helpful.

Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by gniv on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:29AM (#39482689)
Amazon already does some of this (they identify actors in a scene iirc), so they could "easily" extend it to what you're suggesting.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by esafak on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:55PM (#39487208)
Xray, they call it. It's a great feature! https://www.amazon.com/salp/xray
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by hn_user82179 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:05AM (#39490467)
I adore X-Ray. It's great for finding songs I like that are played in a video, or figuring out some actor who looks familiar but I can't tell. And of course for remembering character names. I'm honestly so surprised no other streaming services offer a similar feature.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by mncharity on Friday February 23, 2024 @01:28PM (#39484318)
Many years ago there was an MIT startup based on the idea, IIRC, that subliminally flashed names increased recall among cognitively impaired elderly when the flashed names were correct, but didn't negatively impact recall when the flashed names were incorrect. So even quite poor face recognition could be worthwhile.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by golergka on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:11PM (#39487803)
When I first watched Departed, I didn't realise that Matt Damon and Leonardo DiCaprio's characters are different people until the third act. It was very confusing.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by neltnerb on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:05AM (#39489991)
Hah, I thought I was the only one. I'm not particularly face blind either... something about the era I guess.
Re:I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic by antifa on Sunday February 25, 2024 @01:02PM (#39503082)
Loudest thing online is people complaining about minorities existing in TV shows. A much bigger, real problem, is when they regularly cast 3 characters with almost exactly the same skin tone, skin texture, hair color, hair length, hair style, eye color, clothing style, face shape, voice, body type. Then the character's name is given once (if given) and you see several scenes without the character. Several scenes with the clones. Sudden scene with 2 clones in the same scene. You really couldn't give these three white people a different hair style? Make one wear glasses?