News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by jmull on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:54PM (#39412865)
It probably is these days.

A while ago we passed into a dystopia where the constitution protects corporations from the imposition of the interests of the citizens.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:06PM (#39412996)
"The constitution protects you against the government" is pretty much the entire point of having a constitution.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by 0xEF on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:22PM (#39413163)
That all kinda falls apart when you change the rest of rules to treat corporations like people, though, which was the point of the 14th Amendment.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:26PM (#39413218)
In what sense does it fall apart?

Corporations are treated like people because they're made up of and owned by people. You don't lose your right not to be subject to arbitrary fines just because you incorporated. And a lot of corporations are owned by millions of different individuals, so instead of having millions of people take the government to court, it's easier to have the corporation's officers do it on their behalf. That's all "corporations are people" really is.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eropple on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:33PM (#39413292)
> You don't lose your right not to be subject to arbitrary fines just because you incorporated.

One: NLRB rulings are "arbitrary" only if you somehow believe that a regulatory body, whose rulings can be appealed to an Article III court for redress, are intrinsically "arbitrary". Which is a quiet little hide-the-ball attempt at rhetoric.

Two: your fictive person provides the real people who've bought into it limited liability, which actual humans cannot avail themselves of. This is a superpower of your fictive person exists at the literal beneficience of the society that granted its charter; its bad behavior should be more readily addressed than the due process afforded to actual humans.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:08PM (#39413581)
> NLRB rulings are "arbitrary" only if you somehow believe that a regulatory body, whose rulings can be appealed to an Article III court for redress, are intrinsically "arbitrary". Which is a quiet little hide-the-ball attempt at rhetoric.

They're arbitrary not because of the ruling (although putting judicial functions in the executive is scarcely better than putting legislative functions there), they're arbitrary because the rule you're being fined for violating was created by the administrative agency fining you rather than Congress.

> your fictive person provides the real people who've bought into it limited liability, which actual humans cannot avail themselves of.

It's typically the actual humans who avail themselves of it. Limited liability means that if you own shares of Exxon (or the S&P 500, which has contained shares of Exxon) and then they get sued and go bankrupt, the plaintiffs don't get to take your house. It's about protecting the investors (commonly ordinary human individuals) rather than the corporation which can still be sued into bankruptcy.

It's also not obvious what one has to do with the other. So you can't sue the corporation for more than what it has, why does that mean you should be able to take their stuff under rules never passed by elected legislators?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by 15457345234 on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:29PM (#39413717)
> they're arbitrary because the rule you're being fined for violating was created by the administrative agency fining you rather than Congress.

This is a weird argument that seems to be being put about recently and it's one of the weirdest legal arguments I've ever seen. Of course rulemaking can be delegated. The rules and rulemaking body remains under oversight, the rules can be overridden by the elected body, etc.

Just a totally strange argument; delegation of authority by elected bodies to specialist subgroups is basically how government works without having 100,000 elected positions, and if your proposed solution is 'okay let's have 100,000 elected positions' you get the local government situation in which people run unopposed because nobody really gives a damn and the local coroner is the town drunk - or people just vote straight ticket.

Just weird. Seems more about destroying the system - which isn't perfect, but works - than about actually solving a problem.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:07PM (#39413990)
> delegation of authority by elected bodies to specialist subgroups is basically how government works without having 100,000 elected positions

The way you do it is that the specialist subgroup proposes legislation and then the generalist legislature votes on it. And maybe they defer to their proposals 95% of the time, but it means that the unelected specialists can't push through a controversial change without having it approved by the elected legislators.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by tzs on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:37PM (#39414196)
> And maybe they defer to their proposals 95% of the time

Have you looked at Congress lately? It would be more like less than 1% of the time. The rest of the time there will be some group that blocks action to try to get concessions on some unrelated issue of theirs.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:18PM (#39414807)
They don't need this for that, they already do it with whatever is on the agenda and then get their concessions. Do tell if you know of a way to get them to stop, but just adding another bill to the roster doesn't seem likely to change it one way or the other.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by flir on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:33PM (#39413748)
> They're arbitrary not because of the ruling (although putting judicial functions in the executive is scarcely better than putting legislative functions there), they're arbitrary because the rule you're being fined for violating was created by the administrative agency fining you rather than Congress.

Rule-making cannot be devolved at the legislature's discretion?

So the legislature can't write a law that says "within bounds X, org Y has the power to manage the rules around thing Z"?

(It would work in the UK, where these powers are most often delegated to the executive via Henry VIII clauses, so this is a genuine question, not a rhetorical one).

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:04PM (#39413966)
This is basically the question at issue. Administrative agencies have been acting as though they can for a while now but there isn't really anything in the constitution that says that they can, and some pretty good logic for why they shouldn't. What's the point of electing legislators and setting up balance of powers if you're just going to put the lawmaking authority in the executive?

Suppose during a lame duck session that the government passed a law delegating rulemaking authority to the Senate, so they could pass new laws without them being voted on by the House or signed by the President, right before the House and Presidency switched parties. Does it make sense for that to be allowed? If not, how is it different when it's the executive the authority is being delegated to, which isn't a part of the legislature at all?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by flir on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:38PM (#39414589)
First item on the incoming legislature's agenda would be to knock that on the head and to walk back any harm that was done.

In theory the electorate should also punish a stunt like that, but you know what modern elections are like.

Where I am, it's simple: Parliament (the legislature) is sovereign, and everyone else's power flows from theirs. That puts a hell of a lot power in Parliament's hands (eg general elections were suspended between 1935 and 1945). This is a blessing (agility) and a curse (more vulnerable to bad actors). You've got some laws that are harder to change than others, which puts some brakes on bad actors.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomic

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:14PM (#39414787)
> First item on the incoming legislature's agenda would be to knock that on the head and to walk back any harm that was done.

They can't. They control the House, not the Senate, and they'd need both in order to change it back. Or, under the new rule, at least the Senate by itself, which is the part they haven't got.

> This is a blessing (agility) and a curse (more vulnerable to bad actors).

Agility in central government is overrated. If it does nothing you can still take a crack at the problem at the state level or in the private sector, whereas if it does something bad, you're screwed.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by RandomLensman on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:36PM (#39413315)
Can people have limited liability like a certain forms of incorporation? Corporations are not just collections of people but they also enjoy certain privileges as well as having some obligations.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by flir on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:41PM (#39413350)
Owned by, but not composed of.

Your dog doesn't get the protections of personhood because you own it. If it attacks someone, there's not going to be a trial.

(A moral view not a legal one, obviously. No comments about the merits or otherwise of this case).

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sudosysgen on Saturday February 17, 2024 @10:13PM (#39415830)
This isn't true. We already have a legal structure for a bunch of people working together, that's called a general partnership.

Corporations are shielded from the vast majority of criminal penalties and essentially make truly punitive damages non-existent. This is something no person has - I can't discharge fines in bankruptcy and I can't decide that the only punishment I'll ever have are fines.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by gweinberg on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:26PM (#39413217)
Corporate personhood isn't some reason invention, it's older than the United States. Blackstone talks about it.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by jmull on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:44PM (#39413845)
I think a lot of people understand the legal justification, but the question is whether it's right. Blackstone and other legal ancient history is hardly relevant though, since modern corporations bear little resemblance to companies of the past.

The original purpose of the constitution was to protect the interests of the people from the tyranny of the government.

And, of course, there's no reason people can't band together and pursue their interests as a group.

Well, corporations are composed of people. So far, so good.

However, publicly traded corporations are specifically designed to allow only a profit motive to be shared by the group. By design, shareholders do not have other shared interests and anyway the board and executives have a legal duty to the financial interests of the shareholders, not other shared interests. The people working at the company below the executives are constrained by them, of course.

So a corporation specifically does not share the general interests of the individuals of which it is composed, except where it comes to money (also, that interest in money tends to be in the short term).

To the extent we treat corporations as people with the protections of the constitution, the constitution now works for the (short term) financial interests of corporations.

Not the original purpose. And probably not a very good idea for society at large.

(However, with the money spigot wide open, it's very unlikely to change.)

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:29PM (#39414879)
It seems like the problem here isn't corporate personhood, it's widely-held conglomerates whose owners are too diluted to express any coherent preferences outside of a desire to make more money.

What you want is for smaller companies to make up a larger proportion of the economy.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sudosysgen on Saturday February 17, 2024 @10:47PM (#39415997)
No, the problem is that corporate persons, having an intent which is specific, limited and legally divorced from the intent of its shareholders should not be able to inherit the individual rights of its shareholders, especially since it enjoys privileges individuals do not.

In fact, even in US law, corporations do not have all of the rights human persons have. They specially have the right to free speech as it pertains to political finance.

Corporations in the US still don't have the right to vote, they do not have general freedom of speech, specifically they have much weaker protections against compelled speech than people, they do not have fifth amendment protection against self incrimination, they do not have rights under the comity clause, they do not have freedom of religion, etc...

Indeed, in no country in the world do corporations have the rights of their shareholders or individual rights in general, not even in the US. In the US, corporations only have very specific rights, and judicial fiat determines which ones it has and which ones it doesn't based purely on political expediency (and indeed the courts flip and flop on which rights they do have as the political reality changes).

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:47AM (#39417665)
> should not be able to inherit the individual rights of its shareholders

Why not? It seems like you should be making the argument the other way. Why is a company's owner exercising their freedom of religion through a corporation any different than their exercising it through a church building or an unincorporated gathering of people?

What's really going on here is that the government is violating these rights when it's politically expedient, using corporate personhood as a fig leaf to excuse their violations.

Notice that if you try and come up with arguments to excuse this, they'll tend to be something like "because it's a business" rather than "because it's a corporation" even though that would imply it should also apply to a sole proprietorship or general partnership where there is still a business but no limited liability. There is no apparent reason why having limited liability in particular should require the waiver of unrelated rights.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sudosysgen on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:26PM (#39422204)
The issue with corporations is the corporate veil. The corporate veil separates the rights and responsibilities of the corporation from the rights and responsibilities of the owner.

If the owner tries to use a corporation in such a way that it is merely an extension of their own person, the corporation is then subject to losing the corporate veil.

So why then, if the rights and responsibilities of the corporation are legally distinct, and the law enforces a separation of intent and personalities, should the right of the individual get through to the corporation?

The answer is that it shouldn't. The entire point of the corporation is that the rights and responsibilities of the corporation are not the rights and responsibilities of their owners. There is no reason why any right at all of the owner should percolate to the corporation.

Sole proprietorships, partnerships, and general associations do not have this separation. The rights and responsibilities are the same. So of course the rights of the owners should be available to their entity.

There is nothing arbitrary here. It's perfectly sensible, it's how every other country in the world does it, and it's how it was intended in the US as well. On the contrary, the idea that there is no such separation for some rights but there is for others is bizarre.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:21PM (#39422761)
> So why then, if the rights and responsibilities of the corporation are legally distinct, and the law enforces a separation of intent and personalities, should the right of the individual get through to the corporation?

Because the two things have separate purposes.

In one case the corporation will commonly have multiple owners or have employees other than the owner(s), and then an owner isn't fully in control of all of the corporation's actions and so shouldn't have personal responsibility for everything it does.

In the other case the corporation wants to do something, which may not be the will of all of its owners and employees, but is the will of some of its owners or employees, who each individually have the right to it, so why shouldn't the corporation?

> Sole proprietorships, partnerships, and general associations do not have this separation. The rights and responsibilities are the same. So of course the rights of the owners should be available to their entity.

So if a landlord who doesn't bother to incorporate because the building is their only asset of consequence, or temporarily transfers the building to a natural person in the event of a problematic tenant, then as a result they should be able to challenge landlord-tenant laws on the basis of freedom of religion or freedom of association? It seems like this is just an excuse and the reason you might want these laws has nothing to do with whether the business has incorporated or not.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by jmull on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:06PM (#39422594)
> What you want is for smaller companies to make up a larger proportion of the economy.

Well… we could upend the foundations of capitalism to make it more likely corporations would be responsible for the well-being of society and therefore make it OK to grant them personhood.

Or we could simply not grant these things (that aren’t people) personhood.

I think it’s pretty obvious which one makes more sense.

Also, think carefully. The problem isn’t that the ownership of widely-held conglomerates is too diluted. It is that *by design* the only shared interest of the owners is the profitability of the company. This isn’t some unfortunate, unforeseen happenstance. It’s on purpose and enforced by law.

Our corporate system is designed for and the efficient allocation of capital, not the creation of good citizenal entities. Let’s recognize what it is and act accordingly.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sudosysgen on Saturday February 17, 2024 @10:23PM (#39415880)
Legal personhood is not at issue here. The question is whether legal persons are entitled to all individual rights. This isn't true anywhere, not even the US, except in a very limited fashion that is politically useful.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by propernoun on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:29PM (#39413248)
Not sure I see how giving corproations due process undermines the efficacy of the US constitution.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by ncr100 on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:02PM (#39412957)
Does this mean that we the People of the USA cannot overcome lobbying of the Corporate world, and no longer make changes to our Constitution to allow such regulation of business?
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:08PM (#39413022)
You don't need to change the constitution, all you'd have to do is pass the rules you want through Congress instead of having them created by an unelected administrative agency.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:13PM (#39413065)
SCOTUS strikes them down anyway if they don’t like them.

And we all know Congress is broken. It cannot possibly make the decisions currently delegated to agencies.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:20PM (#39413138)
If Roe was an actual law, it wouldn't have been overturned. The current Supreme Court is simply remedying years of lazy legislating from executive agencies and the bench, instead of making laws the way we're supposed to. Everyone should support this.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:56PM (#39413476)
Who said anything about Roe?

The student debt case: perfectly clear law passed by Congress and overturned by SCOTUS in very tenuous grounds with a plaintiff that never even had proper standing.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:38PM (#39413782)
If Congress actually passed a law clearly forgiving student debt, it's very unlikely they'd have overturned it.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:21PM (#39414509)
I see no reason to believe that.

There is a law. It authorized the education dept to “waive or modify” loan provisions. But somehow the court ruled that that means only minor changes are permitted. Obviously this isn’t what Congress intended - waiving entire provisions could of course result in major changes.

The entire “major questions” doctrine is a farce. It’s not in a law. It’s not in the Constitution. It’s an invention of the court.

And again: the case never should have been heard. The litigant had no standing.

The motivation here is SCOTUS striking down a policy they don’t like.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:34PM (#39414575)
> I see no reason to believe that.

Conservatives don't really like the federal Department of Education, but there is no question that Congress passed a law creating it. Why do you think they would strike down this but not that?

> There is a law. It authorized the education dept to “waive or modify” loan provisions. But somehow the court ruled that that means only minor changes are permitted. Obviously this isn’t what Congress intended - waiving entire provisions could of course result in major changes.

Under that reading they could waive the entire law and forgive everybody's loans, making any other provisions moot. If that's what Congress wanted then why would they pass a law allowing them to "waive or modify" loan provisions, implying that they contemplated the continued existence of loans, rather than just passing a loan forgiveness bill to begin with?

> The entire “major questions” doctrine is a farce. It’s not in a law. It’s not in the Constitution. It’s an invention of the court.

The Court interprets the law. The "major questions" doctrine announces how they intend to interpret the laws Congress passes. It was already a thing when the bill in question was passed. Congress therefore knew that if they intended the law to grant the power to do something like that, they would have to spell it out explicitly, and then they didn't, implying that wasn't what they intended.

Also, just think about it. If that bill had the words "including the power to forgive all student loans" appended to the bottom, do you think it would have passed? If not, it's because those words would have changed the expected consequence of the law, right?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:59PM (#39413933)
That's absolute nonsense. Biden abused a law that did not say what he said it said. If you can't get Congress to pass a law, you don't get to do the thing.

At the risk of a cliché, Biden's student debt forgiveness strategy was dangerous to democracy.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:05PM (#39414404)
Sorry but this is just plain wrong. Congress authorized the secretary of education to waive or modify any loan provision.

If you are concerned about the rule of law you should be upset that the Supreme Court even heard a case so obviously lacking standing. Nobody was harmed by this policy so conservative groups had to invent a fictional harm just to get the case heard.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:03PM (#39414746)
> Nobody was harmed by this policy

If nobody is harmed then why do you suppose anyone wanted to prevent it? Why don't we just continuously forgive all debts of any kind?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:27PM (#39414862)
Partisan politics, mostly. It was a Biden campaign promise.

The party allegedly harmed, MOHELA, didn’t think they were harmed and didn’t want to participate in the case. The court let the state of Missouri stand in for them even though it’s even harder to see how they have standing.

You tell me: who is harmed by students owing less is student loans?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:37PM (#39414921)
Whoever didn't get the money they were lent and never repaid (presumably taxpayers), and anyone holding or contracting in US dollars since forgiving the loans is equivalent to printing the money and causes inflation.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by baggy_trough on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:24PM (#39414524)
The entire “standing” doctrine is a farce. It’s not in a law. It’s not in the Constitution. It’s an invention of the court.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @07:35PM (#39414910)
It’s in Article III. There’s debate as to where the line is for something to be a “controversy” but there’s no debate that there is a line.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:30PM (#39413259)
> If Roe was an actual law, it wouldn't have been overturned

It would have been overturned at any point that the reps had both the legislature and the executive. 2002-2006, and 2016-2018.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:47PM (#39413405)
Maybe, but not by the court system. That's called a repeal.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:59PM (#39413499)
You're splitting hairs. There's not a single human being in this country who actually cares about whether it's been overturned or repealed or froozed.

All that they care about is that they've been protected from their state governments one morning, and not protected the next.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:01PM (#39413939)
Then maybe they should live in a state that agrees with them. That's sort of the entire point of being organized the way we are as a nation.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:12PM (#39414449)
Yeah that’s not how human rights are supposed to work
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @10:33PM (#39415926)
I don't have a right to self-defense in several states, either, so I left those states. It's pretty simple.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Saturday February 17, 2024 @11:41PM (#39416270)
Where is this state where you have the right to self defense? From what I can gather, the police can generally execute and otherwise harm commonfolk with impunity nation wide. Some states let you buy more equipment to go out in a blaze of glory with, but that's a pretty poor consolation prize.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:17AM (#39416679)
Mine. Guy got off last year on killing a cop who was trespassing. Didn't even get charged. Pretty epic.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:14AM (#39417493)
Try killing a cop who is threatening you at a traffic stop, and see how that works out for you.

You'll quickly discover that your state also has some hard limits on that right, they are just drawn at different points than the states that you mistakenly think don't have a right to 'self-defense'. You can defend yourself anywhere, you just can't always kill people in 'self-defense' when you have other options available to you.

(Related question: Does your state have a right to body autonomy, or is it one of those that's in blatant violation of the fourth amendment?)

Back on topic, though, it sounds like we're all in agreement that a law is just as easy, if not easier to overturn than a settled supreme court decision? Can we bury that meme already?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:29AM (#39420346)
My state extends the right to bodily autonomy to the unborn.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:16PM (#39420867)
That sounds like a euphemism for the draconian persecution of basic medical care based on a religious superstition that anything growing where a baby would must be a human baby. IMO the Democratic Party has totally screwed up with this extremist "pro choice" framing, when the reality is mainly one of non-viable fetuses and only one medically-prudent choice.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:51PM (#39422445)
> IMO the Democratic Party has totally screwed up with this extremist "pro choice" framing

100% correct.

> backwards religious superstition that anything growing where a baby would is assumed to be a human baby

This is absolute bullshit. I'm an Orthodox Christian, extremely conservative, particularly on abortion, and a priest's wife I know had an abortion for an ectopic pregnancy, because it was non-viable and would have killed her. It's simply a matter of believing that the unborn are human and then acting rationally based on this belief. I wish more people could get this—rather reasonable—viewpoint through their thick skulls.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:26PM (#39422822)
If this is the basis, why are the laws aimed at criminalizing abortion essentially blanket bans with narrow exceptions rather than based around medical judgement that's equitable between both parties? For example Texas's only viability test is the presence of a periodic electric signal, rather than any consideration of whether the fetus even has the right number of chromosomes.

Additionally, even a fetus that seemingly will be eventually viable isn't actually viable for the first few months. From a libertarian perspective, while arguments exist that the mother has consented to this responsibility for some cases, in other cases she has not (eg rape).

(Also FWIW your example of an ectopic pregnancy example doesn't actually meet the criteria of "growing where a baby would")

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:40PM (#39423682)
> why are the laws aimed at criminalizing abortion essentially blanket bans with narrow exceptions rather than based around medical judgement that's equitable between both parties

Because then would-be abortants would simply find a doctor who would sign the correct paperwork. Duh.

> whether the fetus even has the right number of chromosomes.

So you support eugenics?

> From a libertarian perspective, while arguments exist that the mother has consented to this responsibility for some cases, in other cases she has not (eg rape).

Abortion, if the fetus is human, violates the non-aggression principle. From a humanist perspective, it wasn't the kid's fault.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:30PM (#39424152)
> Because then would-be abortants would simply find a doctor who would sign the correct paperwork

That hypothetical doctor would be breaking the law by falsifying paperwork, and could be prosecuted for that. It seems you're arguing that it's necessary for the law to overbearingly criminalize related just behavior (and in this case medically prudent behavior), because of the possibility that law breaking could be fraudulently hidden. I don't buy that sort of argument.

> So you support eugenics?

Do you have a larger point here, or is equating the acknowledgement of chromosomal abnormalities that are ultimately incompatible with life as "eugenics" just meant to be a rhetorical cheap shot?

> Abortion, if the fetus is human, violates the non-aggression principle

By the usual framing of the non-aggression principle, I don't see how. Would you say a landlord evicting a tenant violates the non-aggression principle?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:39PM (#39424708)
> That hypothetical doctor would be breaking the law by falsifying paperwork, and could be prosecuted for that

Doctor/patient privacy is really really strong.

> equating the acknowledgement of chromosomal abnormalities that are ultimately incompatible with life ... a rhetorical cheap shot.

Depends if you're talking about Down's and related disorders or not.

> Would you say a landlord evicting a tenant violates the non-aggression principle?

Of course not, eviction is a possible outcome of the contract between the two parties.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:59PM (#39425486)
> Doctor/patient privacy is really really strong.

HIPAA already includes exceptions for law enforcement, and the new law itself could certainly mandate some new monitoring and compliance checks. This argument just feels like doubling down on the previous unsupported rationale.

> Depends if you're talking about Down's and related disorders or not.

Since you're defending blanket bans, then it's sufficient to make my point on the most extreme least compatible with life conditions. Like say from a quick look, trisomy 8. "Warkany syndrome (trisomy 8) is a common cause of miscarriage and, for newborns who survive, death usually occurs within the first months". Or trisomy 16. "Full trisomy 16 is incompatible with life. While most fetuses are spontaneously aborted by the 12th week of pregnancy, a few have survived into the second trimester". But in general I don't think knowingly bringing a child with Down's syndrome into the world is kind, compassionate, or worthwhile either.

> Of course not, eviction is a possible outcome of the contract between the two parties.

That only works for tenants over 18 who've signed the lease contract, and not for say their minor children or subletees. But sure, getting the contract out of the picture entirely - would you say that a landlord evicting a squatter violates the non-aggression principle?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:40PM (#39422353)
By denying it to the mother.

Can I move over to your state, and just take a blood transfusion, or an organ from you? I will die without a kidney, and surely you can spare one... My body autonomy is more important than yours, after all, I should be able to make such an imposition on you. My life for a minor inconvenience for you.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:44PM (#39422385)
So you should live in a state that values life that way, and I'll live in a state that values life the way I prefer.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:25PM (#39422812)
The fourth amendment is universally applicable across states. Yours seems to violate it without any internal consistency.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:24PM (#39423522)
Depends on if it's applicable to the unborn. That's a consistent opinion.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by vkou on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:18PM (#39424056)
I'm asking you to apply to the born the same rights you are willing to apply to a zygote (be it viable or unviable, differentiated or undifferentiated). I need a kidney. You have two. I should be able to violate your body autonomy to protect mine.

If a zygote can make this imposition on a woman, why should you have any right to refuse me on this?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:38PM (#39424222)
This is a bad-faith argument. Say someone superglues an infant to you in public. Do you have the right to stab the infant? There's a proper equivalent.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:08PM (#39420773)
That's not really a good framing. If we allow that the police have a legitimate function to exercise justifiable violence on behalf of the state, then the right to self defense must obviously be limited by that, for duly implemented and announced state violence.

There's probably an argument to be made from a natural rights framing that the right to self defense should still be applicable to unjustifiable but duly implemented state violence, like say the war on drug users. Though I don't know how this could be applied practically. Perhaps limiting the number of cops that can carry out any arrest, such that there's an actual balance of power?

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:45PM (#39422400)
Cops do have authority to use violence, but they must not have a monopoly. If a cop encroaches on another person in an unjustified manner, they should face exactly the same consequences, up to and including death.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:53PM (#39422471)
I've certainly said nothing supporting police having a monopoly on violence in general. However, it seems unavoidable that cops have a temporary situation-scoped monopoly on violence while carrying out duly authorized functions. What other possible alternative is there that wouldn't also lead to every traffic stop being a shoot out?
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:05PM (#39422581)
Yeah, I agree with you. I'm a blue-sky libertarian, but libertarianism is an ideal, not a practical form of government.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by mindslight on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:53AM (#39420604)
Has this happened with the converse as well? Police assault a residence, resident defends themselves, police escalate and "win", and the police are charged and convicted of second degree murder? Both outcomes are implied by a right to self defense.

Do these verdicts also happen for the least sympathetic cases (eg actual criminal defending themselves against an unknowable no-knock "warrant") ? Because if you're the basic upstanding sympathetic right-looking type, it's actually most places you will not be charged for defending yourself in your home against non-police.

And has this all happened regularly enough to form a predictable pattern such that the police have actually curtailed such attacks? Affecting repeated interactions such that one doesn't need to continually dwell on the basic dynamic is the hallmark of an intact right.

Because I haven't heard of any states that are shining examples of police accountability, especially states that people tend to market as promoting the right to self defense. But I'd love to be wrong!

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eropple on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:36PM (#39413313)
> If Roe was an actual law, it wouldn't have been overturned.

Nonsense and worse words. They aren't originalists, they don't care about the executive/legislative distinction. It's embarrassing farce to pretend that there is constitutional principle behind achieving their desired political goals. Roe would've been gutted were it law and the general incoherence of Alito and Thomas would have led the way.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:56PM (#39413920)
Have you actually read Roe itself? It struggles to find any real basis for what it was doing in the constitution and the same logic should have rendered unconstitutional e.g. the Controlled Substances Act as well as any equivalent law at the state level, because the government is interfering with what people put into their own bodies in private. People liked it because they liked the outcome, not because it was ever coherent.

The real problem is that a lot of people want there to be a right to abortion in the constitution but they don't have enough votes to actually put it there, and they also don't want to read the constitution's general constraints on government power to be restrictive enough to limit this using coherent logic because that would also limit the government from doing many other things they want it to do.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by rpmisms on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:03PM (#39413960)
Roe is simply a bad court decision. Congress has the right to codify Roe into law. The Supreme Court does not have the power to create law out of whole cloth. Overturning Roe was the Supreme Court taking presumptive power away from itself.

Also, the current court absolutely has an originalist majority, even if you happen to disagree with the originals. The Constitution is a very restrictive document for the Federal Government.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by pclmulqdq on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39413153)
If it were congress's job to pass these rules and regulations instead of pawning off their authority to someone else, I would assume that congresspeople would have to generally take the job a lot more seriously.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by shevis on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:28PM (#39413241)
That’s a bold assumption given they don’t even take their current responsibilities seriously…
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by pclmulqdq on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:37PM (#39413323)
For one thing, they would have a lot less time to go fuck around on Twitter if they had to actually pass laws.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by eli on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:57PM (#39413481)
It’s their job to pass a budget and yet
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sheepscreek on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:33PM (#39413294)
That’s an interesting perspective. What’s problematic is the level of corporate lobbying which can interfere with peoples’ (not shareholders, but those who work there) interest. They cannot afford lobbyists. Not without a union.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:55PM (#39413463)
> They cannot afford lobbyists. Not without a union.

All of the union's money comes from the workers. If they wanted to they could form a PAC regardless of whether they form a union. Which might even do them more good because then the PAC would be directly representing the workers instead of having an indirect layer of union leadership with potentially different incentives.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by sheepscreek on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:53AM (#39417090)
How do they communicate to form a PAC? Would a less educated blue collar worker ever fund a PAC? How do you convince them it’s for their own benefit? Will you do it again for a different agenda? There may be some merit in exploring a new approach that uses modern technology to organize workers.

Until we figure something out, the current structure is better than zero protections for workers.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:28AM (#39417574)
> How do they communicate to form a PAC?

Email? Text messages? However they want. How does anybody communicate about anything?

> Would a less educated blue collar worker ever fund a PAC?

They would do it if they thought it was a good idea.

> How do you convince them it’s for their own benefit?

How do you convince them that paying union dues is for their own benefit?

> Will you do it again for a different agenda?

People can do whatever they want.

> Until we figure something out, the current structure is better than zero protections for workers.

Most workers aren't in a union. You're proposing a change one way or another.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AndrewKemendo on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:43PM (#39413368)
It appears to me to be the case unfortunately

Just think about it from an energy use standpoint. The average citizen has very little energy they dedicate to community and social system support. This includes education, voting, lobbying etc…

This is a basic requirement for an electorate to self govern, everyone has to give input and that input should align with their well considered interests. The amount of work that takes is relatively immense for the amount of impact that people feel they have as a result.

On the other hand you have in effect every for profit entity putting as much possible energy into rent seek and increase margins for the majority owners by offloading any possible externalities of inequitable ownership or resource hoarding.

Corporate lobbies have perfectly captured the political process to the extent that nobody even questions it anymore. Including legislators.

Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by armchairhacker on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:58PM (#39413495)
Putting in the bare minimum like voting isn’t “a lot of work”. Mail-in ballots are available everywhere.
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by AndrewKemendo on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:30PM (#39414554)
Unfortunately its hard enough that almost half of the nation doesn’t do it for even the biggest election and only a minority of voters actually vote in local elections
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by bullfightonmars on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39413149)
Time to find corporations unconstitutional?
Re:Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional by csdreamer7 on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:50PM (#39413427)
They left out the part where you can appeal their findings to a federal appeals court.

https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/what-we-do/decide-cases

You do see a judge, and you can have that trial by jury.