News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by I_am_tiberius on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:51AM (#39395732)
Everything we can.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by ed_balls on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:00AM (#39395784)
There isn't much more we can do. NATO could end Russia with more weapons and making a defence deal with Saudis in exchange for price dumping of oil and gas[1].

But no one wants a nuclear state to fail. Moscow must be terrified of another coup d'etat, hence Navalny's death.

[1]extracting, insurance and delivery cost for Saudis are about $17 and for Russia it maybe as high as $40 now.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by KingOfCoders on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:16AM (#39395932)
When Russia invades Poland to create a land connection to Kaliningrad, just as they invaded Ukraine to create a land connection to Crimea, Europe will wish it had done 10x as much as it did.

Western countries could deliver planes, Germany could deliver Taurus cruise missles, countries could give submarines in the atlantic to target Russian oil rigs etc.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:31AM (#39396077)
Exactly this. They're slow-walking this thing when they should be decisive. Kick Orban and Hungary out of the EU if they keep playing silly games, make a real stand and stay the course. This dumb half-assed stretching the line is going to end up in misery.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by ben_w on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:01AM (#39396380)
> When Russia invades Poland to create a land connection to Kaliningrad, just as they invaded Ukraine to create a land connection to Crimea, Europe will wish it had done 10x as much as it did.

If it invades Poland. Finland joining NATO makes such an invasion less likely, because (I'm told) that membership gives NATO enough logistics to encircle Kaliningrad without going through the Suwałki Gap, and this in turn changes Kaliningrad itself from an asset into a liability. No, I'm not sure why Latvia/Lithuania/Estonia were not already sufficient for this.

> Western countries could deliver planes, Germany could deliver Taurus cruise missles, countries could give submarines in the atlantic to target Russian oil rigs etc.

Yes, though I've heard convincing arguments that part of the current Russian strategy is to keep NATO sufficiently worried about escalation that they focus on building up their own forces instead of donating those same resources to Ukraine.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by sesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:37AM (#39396811)
Why Poland instead of Lithuania?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by justsomehnguy on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:16PM (#39399933)
Because the OP can't into maps.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by alangibson on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:16AM (#39395923)
To be fair, a nuclear state did fail. The US launched a program to help secure nuclear material and it more or less worked out.

You could argue that if the Russian state failed then a group of nations could literally just buy their nukes from whatever gangsters ever up in charge.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by ed_balls on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:11AM (#39398054)
I'd argue USSR collapse was a messy dissolution. A failure would be: Tatarstan declares independence, regular fighting in the streets of Moscow for months.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:30AM (#39396060)
Russia has already failed. The mob controls the nukes, that's the only reason why they managed to get as far as they did in Ukraine. If not for that it would have been long over.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by tasuki on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:30AM (#39396732)
I'm not sure I understand, can you elaborate please?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:00AM (#39397088)
Russia is a nuclear kleptocracy, it is ruled by a mob that seized power in a country that was already very fragile but that still had a massive arsenal. If you think about Russia in terms of a large gang run empire it starts to make a lot more sense. I know plenty of absolutely great Russian people, the country however is giving me the creeps and I don't see any of it ending well.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by actionfromafar on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:36AM (#39396793)
The mob is Putins gang. And they have access to nukes, which is why they dared start this expedition into the Ukraine in the first place.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by tryauuum on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:31PM (#39403863)
hm.... Maybe the real solution is proving that nukes don't work
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:57PM (#39404145)
Even if 98% of them don't work that's still a big problem.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by mamonster on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:06AM (#39395834)
Why would Saudi go against Russia for doing something they do themselves, i.e murdering opposition(Khashogi)? Similarly, why would this be the trigger when the Saudi experience shows US is fine with it?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by lukasm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:25AM (#39396008)
In the grand scheme of things it doesn't matter. The number one problem for SA is security. The state is fragile. Wahabi, Muslim Brotherhood, tribes that hate House of Saud. Secondly, Iran possess a direct threat, Houthi could destroy critical infrastructure. $$$$ spent on military doesn't help - they lost the war in Yemen.

SA is on a lookout for allies: Defence partnership with Pakistan which probably end up in a nuclear technology transfer or purchase of atomic weapons.

If USA would give better security guarantees to SA (similar to Jordan) with some tech transfer, SA would increase the output by 2x, which would result in $45 per barrel.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by mamonster on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:44AM (#39396203)
Wahhabism isn't an internal threat to Saudi, like at all. It's their export ideology and it is not at all appealing to the citizens of one of the best welfare states in the world. Wahhabism in actual Saudi is completely different to what gets exported.

As for Iran, seems like recently there has been a rapprochement(mediated by China), will need to see where it leads. It's pretty clear to me SA is on the lookout for allies, but US is low on their list, as they realised(correctly) that all the human rights issues in Russia exist there as well and might get tackled by the West in a decarbonised future.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by alephnerd on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:10AM (#39396483)
> It's their export ideology

Not anymore after MBS came to power. Wahabhi missionary worm was a King Fahd policy (and why so many foreign mosques are named after him).

> it is not at all appealing to the citizens of one of the best welfare states in the world

Not to most, but it's definetly appealing to a small subset similar to how White Nationalism is appealing to a small subset of Americans.

The religious reforms post-2017 have been massive [0], and the fact that shows like Masameer or Bait Tahrir are being openly produced is a testament to that fact

> As for Iran, seems like recently there has been a rapprochement(mediated by China)

Only limited to Yemen. The relationship post-rapprochement was still fairly shaky and went down the gutter once 10/7 happened [1]

[0] - https://carnegieendowment.org/2021/06/07/saudi-arabia-s-reli...

[1] - https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/06/12/saudi-iran-rapprochemen...

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by mamonster on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:05AM (#39397142)
I think the notion that US Defense Pact is a sign of the countries being true allies needs to be examined. It's clear what the benefit for Saudi is, but it isn't so clear what the benefit for the US is/what the cost for Saudi is(beyond spending money on US arms which they wanted to do anyway).

The reason why I say this: Around the time of the price cap on Russian oil US was already asking Saudi to pump supply so that Russian budget would suffer, and of course Saudis didn't do anything. I think MBS is going fully down the Erdogan/Orban route where he is nominally "West aligned" but is going to be playing both sides as much as he can. When I said allies I meant someone who they would have reciprocal relationships with(which IMO isn't really the case with US atm).

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by alephnerd on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:31AM (#39397507)
> Around the time of the price cap on Russian oil US was already asking Saudi to pump supply so that Russian budget would suffer, and of course Saudis didn't do anything

You're overreading into what is a fairly routine demand and response.

Saudi is in the process of implementing MBS's Vision 2030 [0], which requires a lot of financing, and oil prices have been dropping significantly over the last few years.

Most US allies outside of Europe are indifferent to Russia because the bigger bad to them is China or local rivalries.

Even in the US, Ukraine (and Israel and China) almost never comes up in conversations outside of Reddit. Adviika and much of the Russia-Ukraine war is barely mentioned in any mainstream American news because it doesn't hold much relevance to most Americans compared to domestic concerns [1]

> allies I meant someone who they would have reciprocal relationships with(which IMO isn't really the case with US atm)

Nothing you've said is proof to the contrary. Oil price decreases are always a no-go for Saudi given that 75% of state revenue is financed by oil.

[0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saudi_Vision_2030

[1] - https://apnews.com/article/2024-top-issues-poll-foreign-poli...

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by mamonster on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:46AM (#39399488)
I mean that's kind of my point. I don't really understand what the point of calling US and Saudi allies is when this clearly only extends to the Iran issue in which Saudi is only too happy to freeload on US commitments to the region/Israel as it matches their goals. Its also my more general point, US doesn't really have a lot of allies in the sense "I help you out you help me out", most of these so-called "allies" are interested in freeloading on US's back as much as possible whilst trying to get as much from Russia/China elsewhere as possible.

>Oil price decreases are always a no go for Saudi

Factually false, remember 2015? Saudis tried to kill US shale pretty aggressively.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by schappim on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:24AM (#39395995)
> Saudis price dumping

This is a nice idea but thanks to the shale revolution the US is now a net exporter of fossil fuels, and I suspect the will is not there.

> insurance

What percentage of energy is going out insured? It was my understanding that the transportation was moving to state owned vessels.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foldr on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:16AM (#39395927)
The US Congress could pass the Ukraine funding package. That's one obvious thing.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by ethanbond on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:23AM (#39395992)
You can and should blame the Republicans. Congress isn’t the problem. Republicans are.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foldr on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:26AM (#39396016)
I didn't say anything about who was or wasn't to blame. My point is just that it's weird to say "there's not much more we can do" when that funding package is still in limbo.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:32AM (#39396088)
You didn't say it, but it is the Republicans that are to blame. They seem to believe that obstruction is a form of government. And the weirdest thing is that their supporters seem to believe this is true.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:45AM (#39396210)
<< They seem to believe that obstruction is a form of government.

It may come as something of a shock to some, but US constitution effectively guarantees gridlock if the various blocks are unable to agree. It is a feature and not a bug.

In other words, obstruction, such as it is -- last time I checked there were still talks about aid package slowly making it through house with pieces being cut out -- is a valid form of political expression.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:46AM (#39396220)
Those people should open a history book or two, it might help them to see what their future image will be.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:56AM (#39396333)
History is not a set of if/then statements. It is not written in stone. My most charitable interpretation of the post is that history can be a useful heuristic, but to blindly assert 'future will be' x is inaccurate at best.

I think I understand where you am coming from, but the post I see from you are all unnecessarily 'angry' presenting an opinion as an axiom. It may be worthwhile to take a step back and consider whether those contributions are useful to the community. Frankly, it may be detracting people from the message you intend to spread.

edit: second paragraph spelling errors

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:54AM (#39397013)
> but the post I see from you are all unnecessarily 'angry' presenting an opinion as an axiom.

Ah, ok so until things really derail you shouldn't be upset. Sorry but I'm not 'angry', I'm ANGRY and that is mostly because I spent a long time working through my various family's stories about WWII, what led up to it and how it all ended up and that nobody that could have done something about it acted when they still could. This isn't some kind of abstract mental exercise. If you're not angry that simply means you haven't thought it through yet.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:40AM (#39398467)
<< I spent a long time working through my various family's stories about WWII

I do not want to seem dismissive, but I am from the old country and, well, we all have family stories about WW2. I am not going to delve deep into into it though.

<< If you're not angry that simply means you haven't thought it through yet.

I personally think it is a common misconception. Yes, anger can be a good catalyst and may force a person to act, but I am not entirely certain anger is a good advisor. On a personal scale, I rank it just below fear in terms of usefulness.

My actual point: If you are angry, you are not thinking clearly. I tend to remove myself from conversations if I find myself so.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:22AM (#39399089)
> I do not want to seem dismissive, but I am from the old country and, well, we all have family stories about WW2. I am not going to delve deep into into it though.

Proceeds to be dismissive.

> I personally think it is a common misconception. Yes, anger can be a good catalyst and may force a person to act, but I am not entirely certain anger is a good advisor. On a personal scale, I rank it just below fear in terms of usefulness.

I don't want to be dismissive, but you are giving undue weight to your own opinion over those of others when you probably should at least give them equal weight, on the off chance that you are simply wrong.

> My actual point: If you are angry, you are not thinking clearly. I tend to remove myself from conversations if I find myself so.

What you meant to say: "If I am angry, I am not thinking clearly. I tend to remove myself from conversations if I find myself so."

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:43PM (#39404003)
<< you are giving undue weight to your own opinion over those of others

Are you sure you not projecting a tad bit here?

<< Proceeds to be dismissive.

Would you feel better if I wrote 'too dismissive'?

<< What you meant to say

Heh.

<< you are simply wrong.

What exactly am I being wrong about?

We established we share some ww2 background with its survivors and their descendants and, as a result, your opinion is, at best, as unimportant as mine.

I think we established that emotion ( anger ) may not such a great way to establish whether one is paying attention.

What did I miss?

Friend, I am trying to give you the benefit of the doubt, but so far your responses are not very inspiring. Hell, I am not even sure what you are angry about.

I mean, I can talk generalities too you know. People suck. See?

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foldr on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:40AM (#39396153)
I agree, but the person I was responding to seemed to think that I was somehow blaming Congress in general rather than the Republicans, which is reading something into my comment that simply wasn't there.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by jacquesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:45AM (#39396208)
I saw it more as a confirmation and expansion on your point than a contradiction.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by brookst on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:46AM (#39396228)
But there isn’t much we can do, given the reality that a major US party is increasingly pro-Putin. That’s a constraint on what we can do.

We might eventually get to a place where we can dramatically increase support for Ukraine, but there’s a lot that has to happen first.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foldr on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:17AM (#39396570)
The question that kicked off this discussion was "What do you want [the] world to do?" In that context it's pretty obvious what it means to say that the US Congress could approve more aid to Ukraine. Of course some people don't want to do that. That's why it remains something that we could do rather than something that we're doing.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by brookst on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:18AM (#39397327)
But the US Congress can no more approve significant aid to Ukraine than it can make pi == 3.

In a platonic ideal world, sure. But in the world as it stands, this is not possible. The constraints on the system prohibit it as surely as if the Constitution specifically forbade it.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foldr on Saturday February 17, 2024 @08:47AM (#39409362)
That's an odd take. It's quite possible that the bill will eventually get through the House.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by schappim on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:52AM (#39395738)
What is left on the table?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by bbsz on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:10AM (#39395869)
There're countless studies conducted during the Ukraine-Russia war pointing out what sectors to hit with full export ban to grind Russian military capability to a halt (e.g Austrian GFM manufacturing equipment for artillery barrels production). But this is very politicized discussion. Obviously companies will want to protect their interests and politicians prefer to make strong and visible statements in place of the working ones (like, freezing Russian assets outside of Russia does very little damage to Russia itself right now, compared to, say, decimating their heavy equipment supply chain)

Business is separate from war (see Sweden's metallurgy industry during WW2).

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by I_am_tiberius on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:58AM (#39395776)
- Europe is still consuming lots of gas that finances Russia's "defense" budget.

- There's also a lot of other business with Russia that is not sanctioned.

- Ukraine does not have enough ammunition.

- There are so called neutral countries that should not be neutral.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by schappim on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:12AM (#39395888)
I think you’ll find that even the neutral countries are providing support to Ukraine via the backdoor (eg Swiss with their armour going via DE).

I believe the strategy that the powers at be are attempting is to keep Russia occupied in Ukraine for as long as possible without major escalation. Without assigning morality, it seems like a tough balancing act to achieve.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by unmole on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:03AM (#39395809)
> There are so called neutral countries that should not be neutral.

Why?

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by Gasp0de on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:00AM (#39395788)
The US could stop Taiwan from selling ammunition manufacturing machinery to Russia
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by ed_balls on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:07AM (#39395847)
And Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Japan. Siemens CNC machines are making cruise missles instead of train parts.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by PedroBatista on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:18AM (#39395943)
And the US
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foofie on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:07AM (#39395840)
> What is left on the table?

Arming Ukraine, tighten sanctions.

The world has been treating Russia with kids gloves while it should be treating it as the drunken nuisance it is.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by lucasRW on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:49AM (#39396256)
Not so sure. I remember that pulling the plug on SWIFT was seen and talk about, as "the nuclear option" that no one thought would be used.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by thriftwy on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:39AM (#39397620)
It wasn't done to the full extent (Raiffeisenbank for starters) and does look petty.

"We are not confiscating your money from the bank but when you call to withdraw them, we will pretend we can't hear you on the phone".

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by neovialogistics on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:55AM (#39395756)
Military intervention or something else?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by comonoid on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:01AM (#39395799)
You cannot attack a country with nuclear arsenal. This is what really allows Putin to be so aggressive.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by KingOfCoders on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:17AM (#39395939)
A lot of things of "you cannot do" have already been proven to be false.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by comonoid on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:22AM (#39396632)
You have only one try in this case.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by squarefoot on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:03AM (#39396401)
You can attack a country with nuclear weapons, provided you use only conventional ones, then threaten to escalate to nuclear if they do that. Nuclear weapons are the ultimate threat which would ensure mutual severe damage if not destruction if used, therefore nobody uses them first unless they're completely nuts, or they're cornered. Putin is a criminal but he's far from being crazy, and as for now is surely also far from being cornered. Surgical attacks in Russia with conventional weapons would undermine his powers and create enough public disapproval to facilitate a coup from within, but should be done with extreme care and up to a certain point in order not to trigger a nuclear response. Sadly, even using conventional weapons, the number of deaths would be huge; it is entirely possible that Putin would sacrifice millions of innocents sending them to the front line before giving up, also because when dictators give up they usually die shortly after.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by sesm on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:47AM (#39396918)
‘Surgical attacks in Russia with conventional weapons’ using drones/rockets are already happening. They have the opposite effect of what you discribe.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by squarefoot on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:50AM (#39399550)
Black/Azov Sea aside, they're not touching the area where the power resides, which is usually needed to weaken the leader image. Last bombing in Belgorod is probably just an error, but in any case it accomplishes nothing aside giving more fuel for Russian propaganda.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by sesm on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:20PM (#39412501)
Earliest public evidence of drone attacks reaching Moscow are dated 30.05.2023
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by foofie on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:03AM (#39395813)
> Military intervention or something else?

Military intervention is not required. Just give Ukraine what it needs to repel the Russian invasion and let Putin face his Russian czar fate.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by Clubber on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:10AM (#39395870)
Manpower is what Ukraine needs.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by terafo on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:52AM (#39398609)
Wrong. Shells, artillery, drone components, engineering vehicles, tanks, APCs, jets, long-range missiles, anti-air defenses. 10x that and Ukraine starts winning again. 10x manpower won't do that.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by __loam on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:01AM (#39395801)
Congratulations, you just triggered nuclear Armageddon and ended modern civilization.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by stavros on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:02AM (#39395806)
Maybe that's for the best.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by __loam on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:13PM (#39402361)
I should clarify that I'm not defending Russian actions or trying to be a useful idiot here, there just are red lines that if crossed, a nuclear power will respond with nuclear force. The same is true for China, the US, and even smaller powers like Pakistan.

I support sending Ukraine more ammo to defend its sovereignty. Appeasement is also bad.

Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by Rapzid on Saturday February 17, 2024 @12:40AM (#39406759)
The best for who?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by stavros on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:13AM (#39407482)
For everything else on the planet.
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by Rapzid on Saturday February 17, 2024 @08:08PM (#39415122)
So, you know what's best for the planet?
Re:Alexei Navalny has died – authorities by stavros on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:29AM (#39416734)
Do you?