My suggestion; Kids learn by mimicking and playing. Our Education System beats this out of us in favour of formalism/competition/goals/etc. So if you sit and "play" with her using objects/manipulations of objects (set theory/abstract algebra/formal systems), measurements (quantities/units/coordinate systems), walking across the room with even speed vs. sudden acceleration/de-acceleration (calculus) you can teach Abstractions/Mathematics/etc. This will build up their intuition and hook their interest. Then you can teach them the necessary "formal notation" using paper/pencil and textbooks. You always go from concrete to abstract with enthusiasm and a playful attitude i.e. no right/wrong answers but exploring ideas/concepts.
PS: You might find the videos of the famed educationalist Sir Ken Robinson (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Robinson_(educationalist)) useful in this regard - https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ken+robinson
But it is important to actually give the formalism and abstract algebra at this point. Unless your child is an age defining genius, they will benefit from some handholding, and theres not much of that that can be done without having access to it yourself.
Not necessarily.
Intuition (borne out of Imagination) is for understanding the domain concepts even before there is a problem to solve.
This is the reason i am against the oft repeated advice "solve a lot of problems to learn Mathematics" which merely leads to mechanical "plug and chug problem-solving" with no real understanding. Instead one should spend a lot of time trying to grasp the concepts well, map them to the appropriate notations used and then study a few fully-worked out problems to grasp the "applications".
Oh yeah, it's because we want them to get jobs. But trust me, if you make a child do a lot of something they don't love, they might get a job with it and then just quit because they hate it.
I find that people who do this to their children regret it later, life is short and the time we have to help our children forge a good foundation is even shorter.
You can very well give them a balance between a carefree, happy childhood full of love, while at the same time forcing them to discover lots of things they don't like at first sight.
It's better to fail at raising children by trying to pass something on to them than to let others do it all for you.
I don't disagree with a little pushing, but some children will just never be good at math....
Because she pushed through my complaints and bore my abuse, I now have deeply embedded musical skills that have changed the trajectory of my life experience for the better.
As an adult, I try to thank her for this whenever I can. I don’t know if I’ll be strong enough to give my own future children this gift.
Interesting, I thought we're doing it because we don't want them to be stupid.
It's like someone shoveling a big empty hole for years and years
On the contrary. They're all properly configured. It's just that, their goals are not the same as our mental health goals.
I used to be a deadbeat 30-something who got his reward of progression and a sense of achievement from winning online arguments and grinding ranks in online games. Just like our brains cannot tell the difference between a picture of a girl that doesn't exist and a girl that does and both evoke some feelings of attraction, or an image of a wild animal that couldn't possible exist and one who does and both evoke some feelings of fear, the same happens when we get upvotes on reddit or platinum rank in Call of Duty.
In healthy and balanced scenarios both are distractions in our free time. For people whose life situation is less than ideal those same tools exploit their need to be appreciated and rewarded, in return for profits from sales or/and advertisements.
And we're all pretending that these people just lack willpower, and if only they had willpower they could break away from the software whose parts are deliberately designed after consultation with psychologists specialized in behavioral addiction.
It sounds cliche, but it has worked exactly that way for me. A little more good habits, a little less bad habits, repeat x1000 and you're a whole new person in a whole new place.
I stay mindful of what it is I want, and am certain I want, and create reminders for myself to prevent my auto-pilot from going off track.
And while there are people who might have grown up to do great things after playing video games, or reading comic books or watching television, or whatever thing has horrified any given generation, I'm convinced that knowing to play an instrument, have the patience to read to a book or walk in nature, know how to approach a science paper, or dance, give much more chances to live a fulfilling life.
And if you have those things the day you become an adult, you can still choose to play video games with all your free time. But if you have spent your childhood and adolescence playing video games, it is really hard to get started with any of all those other things that life offers.
They like to run a voice chat in the background while they play, so it's not just a silent in-game chat interaction.
If removing this I don't know how we would replace the social aspect. Would probably need to find an in-person after-school program which would have its own problems.
This is such sad commentary on modern life. Why is this acceptable at all?
It was a very different internet and world though. The thought of giving a child access to YouTube terrifies me. Content is engineered extremely well to prey on children (and adults who are still children), what if they find and get tricked by this? Absolutely terrifies me.
Not allowing access is obviously wrong, they will just resent you and watch even more of it at school, a friends house, etc. So you have to allow access but teach them enough to not fall for it. It’s your parenting vs their extremely well rehearsed, metrics backed, full-time, for-profit, well disguised content, which can either be completely harmless or fuck them up for life.
So, I get it.
But this could extend to many things, e.g. the kid who likes Minecraft may get into "logic puzzles" through red stone while the kid who likes Roblox may get into creating roblox games.
Then, they will get into math once they actually need math as something useful for their "logic based hobby" as I will call it. Of course it is very hard when a kid is just hit with theoretical math and there is no real association with something they are already interested in. But there are actually countless associations, now you just need to find them and bridge your kids interests with math through them.
Probably a few months later, I was watching The Screensavers (remember that?), and they mentioned that users on the TechTV forums were drawing free art requests. The guy who took mine mentioned that he was posting it to deviantArt. "What's that?" I thought. Long story short, I hold a BFA instead of a BS now.
Community takes most people from hobby to passion. It is very difficult, if not impossible, to go it alone.
I'm sorry to hear that you had this experience. I'm sure your Pokemon battle simulator was cool!
If you start with easy math problems (but not labelling them as "math problems", but as logic, smart puzzles) you can build up from there.
Consistency and frugality of options is important.
On the other hand if the approach of the author gives a slight competitive edge, this might snowball for the reason you've given.
Roblox and reading seem different from this perspective.
Its a work in process...
I'd memorize the formulas we were being tested on right before the tests were handed out. Then I'd write them in the top of the test immediately and before I forgot them. Then I'd ace the test. Lol.
Easy. Give her access to Roblox only after she does her math for the day.
> The hard part isn’t getting by kids to do things they love, it’s getting them to do things they DON’T love.
Step 1 is defining your goal. Assume you will not change the fact that your daughter doesn't like math. What capabilities do you want her to have that will come from studying it?
Focus on those, not on trying to build a habit of math-for-its-own-sake.
(If you don't think there are any particular capabilities that she will need, then I would suggest having her study math is probably not a good use of her time.)
My kid loves Roblox. Math not so much. She’ll gladly play Roblox every day with no assistance or structure from me. Math? That’s about as easy to form a habit with as running 5 miles. How do I get her to love math (or other good things) in the first place?
The hard part isn’t getting by kids to do things they love, it’s getting them to do things they DON’T love.
I was able to get her hooked on reading actual paper books but only when she messed up in school and lost access to devices for 9 days. Boredom took over and books were the answer. Now she loves them, thank god.