https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/pentagon-...
That's a dick move and a massive f.u. to AFU and Ukraine and whole Europe. His fucked up mind really did a fuck-you-all to half a billion people, I guess he likes dictators with egos even bigger than his. Expecting to be paid is normal, doing above in such a situation (and losing an unique opportunity) isn't.
But this easily goes deeper - how many hundreds of civilians were killed due to all civilian bombardment by Russia by missiles launched from the sea due to above? He at this point has blood of many civilians on his hands. If he didn't want to participate from the start that would be a completely different discussion, but his bipolar behavior is inexcusable and killing civilians in droves.
He lost all my respect I could ever give to him due to this specifically, accomplices of mass murderers were hanged in Nuremberg so western law has pretty clear stance on this.
Nothing to do with Starlink or Musk. Those orders were from the State Department.
Entirely another thing - and now I mean the US ITAR perspective - is if it's used literally as key and unique capability enabling part of a drone weapon. Now that makes it a weapon too. SpaceX doesn't have the US government's approval to manufacture weapons, export weapons or sell them to Ukraine army. The terminal or the constellation itself must not be used as a weapon according to the US law, and the operator must do everything to stop such use.
You should be angry with the US government. Biden could go live on the TV right now and say "Mr. Musk, it's fine - we allow it.". And if Musk didn't do it anyways, then you'd be right to be angry with him. But the US government didn't and won't do that.
Take it to your elected representative, not to a businessman doing what the law requires him to do.
You know what was the biggest fail, IMHO? That UA soldiers put the video online. Up until nobody knew, nobody cared. They carried out several attacks. Then they showed the world - and of course it got banned, there is no other option on SpaceX or Musk's side.
US government bought some antennas so even if he loves Putin he can't bite the USA government who gave Tesla and SpaceX a ton of money.
2) so?
1) Not dilute the horrific tragedy of a century in pursuit of my histrionic agenda
2) Try and not overfit the clean simple morality of young adult fiction onto the real world
Trying to portray this as some deeply, historically complicated and nuanced situation is pretentious, and I'd hazard a guess that anyone taking this position likely has little familiarity with the war and why it's happening.
He said he "donated $100M to Ukraine" though:
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1026872652290379776 resulted in his having to step down as Tesla board chair and have his tweets vetted by a minder. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/elon-musk-ordered-to-ab...
I wonder if that's true: Maybe he just wants to be a controversial contrarian and always tries to be on the "non-woke" and "non-mainstream" side.
Doesn't change much in this instance, but still.
He is quite clearly on the side of russia.