News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by xianshou on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:40PM (#39297235)
If Waymo is truly as much better than Cruise as the statistics claim, this is a perfect opportunity to release the full video of the incident. Most collisions are avoidable, but a few are the result of a perfect storm of conditions that would be difficult to navigate for even the most skilled human driver. To know whether the truck's occlusion of the cyclist is one of those cases requires the actual footage.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:02PM (#39297933)
They have no reason to release it to the public. They don’t want to set a precedent. They will show the video to the regulators (CA DMV) and if they’re not happy, they will take action. It’s regulation working as intended.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by fprog on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:07PM (#39297973)
Public trust is a pretty good reason.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by shuckles on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:28AM (#39298591)
It’s a motivated audience in San Francisco. Data will not change their mind.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:17PM (#39298057)
There’s enough to establish public trust with their voluntary release of safety data and regulators closely overseeing their operations.

Setting a precedent for releasing footage means fault is automatically assumed when they don’t voluntarily release it.

It’s a problem if they’re not even releasing it to the regulators, but that’s not happening here.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by causal on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:32PM (#39298172)
Not to mention that no matter how compelling the footage, people will argue who is at fault.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:35PM (#39298197)
Yup. Also people using edited footage out of context for nefarious purposes. Really zero benefit for Waymo to release footage, only things to lose.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zone411 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:52AM (#39298729)
And that's exactly why regulators must compel them to release the footage immediately if they wish to continue operating on public roads.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lolinder on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:26AM (#39298911)
They will release the footage to the regulators, likely without having to be asked.

The regulators don't want the footage released to the general public any more than Waymo does—the last thing they need is a bunch of armchair traffic accident investigators telling them how to do their jobs.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zone411 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:51AM (#39298725)
So what? People can argue about many things, that's not a valid reason against it.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by PeterisP on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:39AM (#39298980)
It's not enough, because at least for me and a few others (e.g. the neighboring comment "If the footage is not released to the public I'm going to assume it makes Waymo look bad.") being able to judge the event personally can establish much more trust than anything they do with the regulators, because we also don't necessarily fully trust the regulators and their political motivation, and want to see if we would agree with the regulators for such major cases.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:16AM (#39302147)
Unless you’re willing to watch millions of hours video of every Waymo vehicle driving and judge them in aggregate, watching a one-off incident will tell you nothing about their safety. At that point, you might as well trust their aggregate statistics reported to the regulators because they capture everything.

If you’re not an expert, it’s best to let the regulators and insurance adjusters do their job.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by PeterisP on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:24PM (#39304737)
Your argument is much less effective at making me trust Waymo than the accident video could be.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mint2 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:02PM (#39306053)
Esp if one considers it’s the same argument cops make when trying to suppress incriminating police shooting footage.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mint2 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:00PM (#39306033)
Sounds like the same argument bad cops claim after questionable police shootings

Public trust requires building it first. As one of the first instances of a waymo crash, yes the public needs to see it. If after reading the footage in the first 99 crashes and in each time waymo’s assessment was valid, that’s when Waymo has public trust and can credibly not release every single video but only do it on a case by case basis.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:09PM (#39306143)
How do you get to "bad cops" from here? Bad cops are "investigated" by their own units. So that analogy doesn't work.

Waymo is regulated by independent agencies (CA DMV and NHTSA). They are watching the videos and assessing if Waymo is telling the truth. Their permit is pulled if they get caught lying (like Cruise). How are you and thousands of SF residents more qualified than them? Why should I take your assessment more seriously than that of the regulators?

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by dmix on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:50PM (#39298319)
PR 101 is usually to say the bare minimum re bad press. And maybe release it later when it's out of the news cycle.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by fortran77 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:25PM (#39298121)
You’ll never win the trust of the bicyclists, who think that everyone else is evil, and that laws don’t apply to them.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by zone411 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:51AM (#39298724)
Good, they should be forced to set a precedent.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by smt88 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:00AM (#39298777)
> They have no reason to release it to the public.

The public is allowing them to borrow govt-built roads to test their products and potentially endanger the public. That's more than enough reason for Waymo to be transparent here.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by darkwizard42 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:19AM (#39298878)
No, the regulators (who are indirectly appointed through the public) are allowing them to use govt-built roads to test their products. They don't have a direct obligation to you or any other citizen.

I'd like them to release the video, but just be clear what you want, and best not to act like it is required of them.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by smt88 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:17AM (#39299558)
The roads belong to taxpayers, not regulators. The regulators are supposed to work for us.

Anyway, I'm talking about a moral or PR obligation, not a legal one. Waymo is using roads that taxpayers pay for, and that raises the bar for transparency for them.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by SllX on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:38AM (#39300060)
You would think so but no. Roads and highways belong to the State or Federal government (basically whoever built the damn thing).

States and the Federal government are managed by an Elected government and their appointees, and are empowered to levy taxes.

Taxpayers foot the bill, and some taxpayers are even citizens with the right to vote in elections.

The whole “X belongs to the taxpayer” is crap rhetoric you and many many many Americans were raised on, but which does not accurately convey anything about your relationship with the roads and highways you use. We pay for them, we elect the people who are charged with managing the entity that does own them and employs people to build and maintain them, but we do not own them.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by smt88 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:54PM (#39306762)
Yeah, again. I'm not talking about the legal framework, I'm not poorly educated on this subject as you condescendingly claim, and nothing you wrote affects my point.

I'm saying that we pay for the roads, and the entities that legally own/maintain/control the roads are supposed to be under the control of our elected representatives. We own the roads in the sense that they are public spaces that we pay for.

There is a moral obligation to transparency when benefitting from public resources, whether or not there's a legal one.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by SllX on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:26AM (#39299295)
You are 100% correct.

Waymo reports to the DMV, they do not report to you or me.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rsynnott on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:31AM (#39300388)
> They have no reason to release it to the public.

I mean, if it reflects positively on them, they have huge reason; they want to put as much distance between their response and Cruise's as possible, and show that they're acting in good faith.

A large part of what killed Cruise was, well, either the cover-up or its employees' amazingly persistent internet connectivity problems, depending on how cynical you want to be.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:11AM (#39302095)
The positive PR is so negligible it’s not worth it. This is an incident where no one was even injured.

If they want to put as much distance between themselves and Cruise, they just need to be transparent with the regulators and not play games with them.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by rsynnott on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:32PM (#39306453)
Eh, if I want to be as upfront and "look how open we're being" as possible. They have a marginal basically-prototype product, in a limited market where a lot of people are already very annoyed about them, and the main competitor has just vanished in a puff of poor crisis management. They should really be leaning on demonstrating to the public that they're different.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by hx8 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:11PM (#39297540)
If the footage is not released to the public I'm going to assume it makes Waymo look bad.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by belltaco on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:02PM (#39297936)
They did say that the Waymo only braked after the cyclist was 'fully visible'. They won't be releasing the footage on their own.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mint2 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:03PM (#39306069)
Yeah that was an interesting weasel word. It raised a lot of questions.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ikiris on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:06PM (#39306117)
Based on actual experience driving and living in SF, I just assume any cyclist involved in an accident was ignoring the traffic laws and found out why they exist the hard way.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 1024core on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:00PM (#39297924)
What about the privacy of the bicyclist? What if it was his/her mistake and they don't want to be ridiculed by the entire world?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by userbinator on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:44PM (#39298273)
There is no expectation of privacy with what happens on a public road.

See all the dashcam videos on YouTube.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:43AM (#39298683)
> There is no expectation of privacy with what happens on a public road.

There's a common misconception that there is not an expectation of privacy in public but this is not supported by the law. The notion does not help people but does help those that wish to surveil. Be careful with this claim.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by BHSPitMonkey on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:46AM (#39298695)
The question isn't about the cyclist asserting a right to privacy, it's about whether it's a decent thing for Waymo to do regardless. There are more downsides than upsides (to the company) if they did do a public release of footage.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by 1024core on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:10PM (#39305383)
Counter: see all the blurring in Google Maps Streetview.

IIRC they were sued about identifying people and car plates.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by NewJazz on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:03PM (#39297941)
You can blur their face?
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:42AM (#39298675)
You can still be identified by things other than your face.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by fastball on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:57PM (#39297401)
Yes, they definitely have full footage. I would appreciate seeing it.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by babl-yc on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:12PM (#39297546)
I agree it would be good to share video if possible, but Waymo cannot realistically expect that there will never be an accident where they look bad.

There are 43,000 US road deaths per year. If all driving was autonomous, even if autonomous driving was 100x safer than humans, that would still be 430 deaths per year.

And some of those accidents will be failures that a human would not make (sensor failure, bad software update, edge cases).

What you _can't_ do is what Cruise did and hide evidence from the public and regulators fearing that the truth would impact your business.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by thereisnospork on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:34PM (#39298183)
Seriously -- automated cars are going to kill a lot of people[0] yet by every objective measure that is a good thing. There's a cognitive dissonance here that needs to be overcome else society will pay to the tune of tens of thousands of lives per year.

[0]captured in multi-angle 4k, replete with gore and blood splatter. leaked to the press, compiled into tic Tok reaction videos, etc.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by muglug on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:01PM (#39297452)
> this is a perfect opportunity to release the full video of the incident

I hope they’ve released the full video to investigators, but they’re in a tight spot — SF city government is looking for reasons to come down harshly on the company, and trying to sway public opinion ahead of the city’s verdict won’t help.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by PeterisP on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:42AM (#39299001)
Why wouldn't it help? I think entirely the opposite, if they believe that SF city government has political reasons to misinterpret the evidence, then putting the evidence to the general public can act as a check to the SF government, preventing them from any shenanigans asserting that the video shows something other than most members of the public saw there.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by aaomidi on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:22PM (#39297626)
This is one of those things that should be legally required tbh.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by CobrastanJorji on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:13PM (#39298028)
Well, maybe. It should definitely be required that they turn any accident records over to regulators, other parties in the accident, and police. But to the public? Imagine if it were gruesome. I doubt I'd appreciate video of a family member violently dying going viral.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ra7 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:02AM (#39298414)
Any accident involving a self driving car is already reported to regulators (CA DMV and NHTSA). It’s required by law. These records end up in a public database.

What’s not public is the video footage. It’s still shown to the regulators when they want to examine, it’s just not publicly released.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:04PM (#39297486)
Only way that happens is if the cyclist signs a boatload of paperwork to waive his right to litigation.

And on top of that, I'm far less interested in the footage than I am the telemetry. What was the state of the gas and brake, what was the steering angle, how long was it from detection to action. Those things concretely answer the question of "would a human have done better or worse in this situation?", which is ultimately the only question that matters.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by lmm on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:26PM (#39297652)
> And on top of that, I'm far less interested in the footage than I am the telemetry. What was the state of the gas and brake, what was the steering angle, how long was it from detection to action. Those things concretely answer the question of "would a human have done better or worse in this situation?"

You absolutely cannot answer that question without looking at the video and considering how easy or hard it would have been for a human to detect (or suspect) the cyclist in that situation.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:16PM (#39298046)
I don't think you can "absolutely" answer the question with the information that, at least could be, available. You can certainly form an opinion that's closer to agreeing with reality however, which is mostly what I'm interested in.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by bagels on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:19PM (#39297598)
It would have to be provided if the cyclist sues Waymo and reaches discovery.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:58PM (#39297894)
> I'm far less interested in the footage than I am the telemetry [...] how long was it from detection to action

It sounds like you're making a deeply unreasonable assumption that no human could have detected or anticipated the cyclist faster than the computer did.

Given the current state of the art, those times are frequently not the same, and the difference cannot be answered without seeing the human-consumable video footage of a prospective human driver.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:14PM (#39298031)
I'm assuming nothing. I'm simply posing a question, not answering it.

It's your post that is nonsense, as it appears you've read about half of what I wrote before you replied.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:11AM (#39298474)
Perhaps it's not what you intended in your mind, but it's what you happened to type out in ASCII. You asserted that:

> What was the state of the gas and brake, what was the steering angle, how long was it from detection to action. Those things concretely answer the question of "would a human have done better or worse in this situation?"

No, "those things" you just identified in "the telemetry" can not "concretely answer" the question of "would a human have done better."

In particular, that's because "better" includes detecting the obstacle or risk sooner than the computer did. (Not merely time between detection and braking.) To answer that, other humans must scrutinize the video, which means the video is important.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:03AM (#39298801)
Did I at any point say the video wasn't important? I don't recall doing so. I did assert that the telemetry was more interesting than the video, but the telemetry being more interesting than the video feed doesn't mean the video, itself, is not interesting. You missed that in favor of being pedantic, that says something about you, and if I thought it had any chance of helping, I'd tell you to take a long look in the mirror and wonder why you are the way you are.

That'll be my last reply though, I'm watching a youtube stream of a guy trying to get gentoo to boot off NTFS, it's not going well, but it is more interesting than providing detailed analysis of simple language that you've misunderstood.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:02AM (#39299133)
Imagine an alternate universe where everything was cut short by: "Oops, yeah, video would be important for that case, I was focused on a different failure-mode."

> Did I at any point say the video wasn't important?

Sounds like Motte and Bailey time.

The expansive Bailey: "We don't need raw video to concretely answer whether the machine did better or worse than a human, the telemetry is sufficient."

The defensible Motte: "I never said the video was unimportant..."

> pedantic [...] detailed analysis

Step 1: Casually dismiss the other person as having not read your post.

Step 2: When they lay it out in detail, whine that they read your post too closely.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mlyle on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:49AM (#39299039)
The issue that people have is you stated that you'd compare time from detection to action.

What most people want to compare is time from when the bicyclist could have reasonably been detected to action. This requires looking at the video frames to decide when we think a human would have figured it out.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by godelski on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:40AM (#39298670)
This sounds like a bad idea. I doubt people will respond with proper context, especially given that it will still be lacking in information. We already see people here making assumptions without sufficient evidence. Anything with cars and cyclists is always heated and we just get a lot of biases.

I think it is better that we distinguish that this type of event does not actually inform us about the safety of driverless cars nor does it provide enough information to adequately update our positions in either direction. It is void of so much context that it is essentially just noise. These things are hard to measure and even harder to make accurate decisions on. In an extreme case, it is possible for driverless cars to be "better than humans" at driving in the notion of accidents per mile (even normalized) while also being "worse than humans" in the notion of striking cyclists or pedestrians. "Accidents per mile" marginalizes the type of accident, but this would be important information as to making effective policy about when and where a driverless car can deploy (e.g. on average fewer accidents but most miles are on the highways. If there's a high rate of failure in detecting children in suburban settings, I sure wouldn't want that car driving in residential areas. The nuance matters). I think it's fair to say that the vast majority of us here on HN have a poor concept as to what the actual nuanced data says here and personally I feel like a video would only further sensationalize the event. I would not be surprised if a video were released which showed that Waymo could have not performed any better (without x-ray vision or omniscience) yet it also be used to further cases against them. I'm sure most people would make an accurate and reasonable conclusion upon seeing the video, but I still don't have faith that that means it wouldn't end up being sensationalized.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ExoticPearTree on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:52AM (#39299799)
> This sounds like a bad idea. I doubt people will respond with proper context, especially given that it will still be lacking in information.

Waymo has 360 degrees cameras. There's absolutely no lack of context if the video starts 2-3 minutes before the incident and stops when everything was sorted out at the scene. Bonus points if it has audio also.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ragazzina on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:06AM (#39300236)
The video would be cut to only show the most dramatic moment a minute after released, and it would be the shorter version to become popular.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by ExoticPearTree on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:31AM (#39300728)
For tabloids, yes, but the same happens with any other video of an accident. So it is not a reason not to be released.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by kjkjadksj on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:37AM (#39304073)
The public are not entitled to that video. Regulators and engineers, sure, but to release it to the armchair uninformed public because of their morbid curiosity does nothing to advance safety engineering.