News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:14PM (#39298031)
I'm assuming nothing. I'm simply posing a question, not answering it.

It's your post that is nonsense, as it appears you've read about half of what I wrote before you replied.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:11AM (#39298474)
Perhaps it's not what you intended in your mind, but it's what you happened to type out in ASCII. You asserted that:

> What was the state of the gas and brake, what was the steering angle, how long was it from detection to action. Those things concretely answer the question of "would a human have done better or worse in this situation?"

No, "those things" you just identified in "the telemetry" can not "concretely answer" the question of "would a human have done better."

In particular, that's because "better" includes detecting the obstacle or risk sooner than the computer did. (Not merely time between detection and braking.) To answer that, other humans must scrutinize the video, which means the video is important.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by jtriangle on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:03AM (#39298801)
Did I at any point say the video wasn't important? I don't recall doing so. I did assert that the telemetry was more interesting than the video, but the telemetry being more interesting than the video feed doesn't mean the video, itself, is not interesting. You missed that in favor of being pedantic, that says something about you, and if I thought it had any chance of helping, I'd tell you to take a long look in the mirror and wonder why you are the way you are.

That'll be my last reply though, I'm watching a youtube stream of a guy trying to get gentoo to boot off NTFS, it's not going well, but it is more interesting than providing detailed analysis of simple language that you've misunderstood.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Terr_ on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:02AM (#39299133)
Imagine an alternate universe where everything was cut short by: "Oops, yeah, video would be important for that case, I was focused on a different failure-mode."

> Did I at any point say the video wasn't important?

Sounds like Motte and Bailey time.

The expansive Bailey: "We don't need raw video to concretely answer whether the machine did better or worse than a human, the telemetry is sufficient."

The defensible Motte: "I never said the video was unimportant..."

> pedantic [...] detailed analysis

Step 1: Casually dismiss the other person as having not read your post.

Step 2: When they lay it out in detail, whine that they read your post too closely.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mlyle on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:49AM (#39299039)
The issue that people have is you stated that you'd compare time from detection to action.

What most people want to compare is time from when the bicyclist could have reasonably been detected to action. This requires looking at the video frames to decide when we think a human would have figured it out.