News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by gipp on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:45AM (#39289167)
So, maybe someone here can explain this to me. I anyways hear about how the entire semiconductor industry is completely dependent on TSMC, and nothing can operate without them, thus their geopolitical importance.

But then what are Intel, Arm, etc in this picture? I don't understand semiconductor manufacturing in enough detail -- I assume TSMC occupies a different part of the supply chain? But chip manufacturing seems like a pretty integrated process top to bottom; what's the division between them? In concrete terms, what is it that TSMC is doing that nobody else is?

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by CitizenKane on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:05AM (#39289423)
Currently TSMC has the only leading edge chip fabrications plants (fabs) on the planet and they're all located in Taiwan. They account for all new chips for all new Apple products, all new AMD products, most new Nvidia products, etc. Most companies design the the chips, but then outsource the manufacturing of them to TSMC as building a fab has astronomical upfront costs.

TSMC has acquired a lead in this area through a number of different methods. One of the main things is that they focus deeply on manufacturing. Another is that they work 24 hours a day in R&D, running 3 shifts so they basically have the lights on all the time. And as mentioned above, the upfront costs are incredibly high with a fab costing on the order of 20+ billion dollars to construct.

Intel is attempting to catch up, but it will likely be another 3 to 5 years before they are able to do so. Honestly just having R&D up and going all the time is probably a huge advantage for TSMC and probably a big reason behind their success. Regardless, suffice to say basically all cutting edge product shipments would cease in a matter of months if TSMC fabs were destroyed.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by toephu2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:51PM (#39291694)
Actually TSMC has 2 fabs in Mainland China (a 12" fab and an 8" fab), and one in the USA (8" fab) [1].

[1] https://www.tsmc.com/english/aboutTSMC/TSMC_Fabs

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by CitizenKane on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:37AM (#39298965)
They do, but they don't produce any of their leading edge chips in mainland China, just as they won't be in the USA either. Looking at the wording of my post I should have made the leading edge part more clear. My mistake there!
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by marcosdumay on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:36AM (#39289807)
Multi-shift R&D is a weird proposition. Is it for best using machinery?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by biztos on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:06AM (#39290205)
According to this, it has something to do with the movement of the wafers:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35667282

It also has to do with competitive boasting: theirs goes to eleven.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by marcosdumay on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:44AM (#39290765)
I'd translate "move wafers" as run test batches. What I understand from that is that he can run more tests on his machines.

Honestly, I'm not sure anything of that is real. I can't believe other fabs don't run tests 24/7, and I can't believe they have people that rarely meet changing the same machines instead of only running tests without changing anything.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by ambrose2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:21PM (#39292139)
I used to work in R&D for leading edge node development and we had a couple night shift technicians to unblock long running high priority tests. However, we could have iterated much faster if we had dozens of engineers running additional tests at night. Some tests require you to be there at the tool to change temp and so on. And there are ton of possible tests you can do. If you get a result back in the middle of the night and have engineers to review the results and configure a new test then and there, that’s a much faster learning cycle time.

Another advantage of TSMC is how they have enough fab space dedicated to R&D that they can run prototypes through quicker because they aren’t competing with manufacturing to get processed.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by azinman2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:03PM (#39293534)
So if it’s so successful why doesn’t Intel etc just copy this process?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by marcosdumay on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:55PM (#39294204)
Worse yet, Moore's law was basically an automatic monopoly for anybody that had a much more productive R&D than the others. But we are only noticing the gains now, that the law is gone for years already.

Maybe the culture thing is really pervasive. It wouldn't be a first.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by foota on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:28PM (#39293844)
Cost and culture? I don't know that most 20 year intel employees in Beaverton are going to be willing to do night shifts.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by pests on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:10PM (#39294965)
Some things are hard.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by CitizenKane on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:01AM (#39299484)
To add to what others said here, another salient factor is that in Taiwan it's pretty possible to get late night food, drink, and other things. These things are almost non-existent in the US which would make working night shifts extra rough.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by yurishimo on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:48AM (#39300492)
Depends on where the fab is. I agree if we're talking about rural Arizona, but if the demand is there, I guarantee you that someone will open a franchise (or six) down the street and operate overnight to meet that demand. In and around larger cities though, it's not really a problem. There is usually _something_ open, even if it might not be a long list.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by kyawzazaw on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:55PM (#39306790)
apart from NYC (and maybe Las Vegas), I don't know any other US cities that has functioning food places that operate throughout the night abuduntly

do you have examples?

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by yurishimo on Monday February 12, 2024 @01:35PM (#39348534)
Are we discounting fast food? I can't speak for everywhere, but in Dallas, many chains are open 24/7. Whataburger is a Texas franchise that has been 24/7 for basically it's entire history in all locations. They are closed for Christmas and Thanksgiving only. McDonalds is 24/7 in most major cities. In Dallas proper, there are some smaller (local) chains that are frequently open until 2 or 3am but admittedly they mostly cater to the bar crowd who wants something to eat before heading home after drinking all night. Café Brazil is a local Denny's/IHOP type diner that is open 24/7 including major holidays!

Your addition of "abundantly" makes things more ambiguous, but I think the choices available in most large US cities is _decent_ after midnight. Can you get absolutely anything like NYC? No, probably, not. But burgers, diners, and fast food are all generally available. That's also ignoring 24/7 grocery stores like Walmart that can fill in the gaps if you're craving something hyper specific. Perhaps you can't buy it ready-made, but you can buy the ingredients!

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by jmartrican on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:36AM (#39290667)
> Currently TSMC has the only leading edge chip fabrications plants (fabs) on the planet and they're all located in Taiwan.

What about Samsung? I thought they also made leading edge.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by CitizenKane on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:41AM (#39290728)
They're close, but I believe they're not doing any 3nm manufacturing at the moment but I could be wrong about that.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by drozycki on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:47AM (#39300133)
NVIDIA, Apple, AMD, Qualcomm exclusively use TSMC for their best chips. Even Samsung prefers to use TSMC-fabbed Qualcomm SoCs over their in-house design and manufacturing for their flagship phones.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by tester756 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:40AM (#39290716)
>Intel is attempting to catch up, but it will likely be another 3 to 5 years before they are able to do so

According to them they will do it in next 12 months.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by greggsy on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:29PM (#39293860)
Sounds like hopeful words for investors
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by tester756 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:30PM (#39295197)
What makes you think so? I have their stocks and been following their roadmaps and it seems to not be that out of touch with reality
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by koromak on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:31PM (#39293095)
What happens if a war with Taiwan does break out? Who's poised to pick up the slack?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by tommoor on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:43PM (#39293259)
Literally no-one – the majority of high-tech consumer electronics would stop being produced as soon as existing chips run out.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by greggsy on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:28PM (#39293847)
That’s not true - with the exception of the leading edge nodes, there are other fabs.

The question is how easily could they migrate and prioritise the workload?

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by makeitdouble on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:48PM (#39295386)
There's very few of these other fabs outside China. They exist, but aren't able to deliver enough at a global scale. That's what we learned the hard way during the chip shortage a few years ago, where car production for jbstance basically came to a crawl.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by a_wild_dandan on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:46PM (#39293293)
If that happens, you won't care. You'll be concerned with your personal safety.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by tedivm on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:24PM (#39295132)
This is part of the reason why you're hearing posts about TSMC expanding out of Taiwan. As it stands today it would be a fairly large economic hit to have advanced processors stop production. Building out redundancy seems to be a top priority.

It's also worth noting that in the event of a war the US is very, very likely to bomb the shit out of the TSMC plants.

https://www.businessinsider.com/us-would-destroy-taiwan-semi...

https://www.theregister.com/2023/03/14/us_china_tsmc_taiwan/

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by makeitdouble on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:50PM (#39295413)
Perhaps Korea or Japan, but in practice nobody, and that's partly by design.

Taiwan being the core producer of the super high end chips is guaranteing them that if a war ever happens, they won't be left as sacrifice to the opponent while the rest of the world goes business as usual.

They critically need to be a strategic and non replaceable producer.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by hnthrowaway0328 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @06:37PM (#39295812)
It's very unpredictable. It might spill to the whole East Asia and then who knows.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by cyrillite on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:36PM (#39295270)
Where can someone dig into the data on this?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by throwaway2037 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:15AM (#39299226)
> Currently TSMC has the only leading edge chip fabrications plants (fabs) on the planet

No, Samsung has some in South Korea also.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by cromka on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:46AM (#39289177)
ARM does not manufacture own chips, they just design and license them. Outside of Intel, pretty much everyone else uses TSMC to build their computing chips.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by kmlx on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:04AM (#39289413)
> Outside of Intel, pretty much everyone else uses TSMC to build their computing chips.

this isn’t correct.

UMC, SMIC and TI have more than 10 fabs each.

Nanya 3 fabs.

Micron > 10 fabs.

Intel > 10 fabs.

Tower Semiconductor 7 fabs.

Rohm > 10 fabs.

Fuji 4 fabs.

Fujitsu 5 fabs.

Kioxia 10 fabs.

Renesas 9 fabs.

and the list goes on and on.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by mschuster91 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:59AM (#39290116)
Most of these are very large node sizes though [1]. In ultra-small node sizes for processors, there is basically only Intel, Samsung, Globalfoundries (ex AMD) and TSMC.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat...

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by adgjlsfhk1 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:18PM (#39295062)
except that GF isn't leading edge any more. Their smallest node is (I think) 12nm which is about 8 years behind.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by bonton89 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:03PM (#39291029)
Even Intel builds their GPUs at TSMC.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by hosteur on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:51AM (#39289230)
Not even amd or TI?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by whstl on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:06AM (#39289429)
AMD's main manufacturer is TSMC. They also use other companies AFAIK.

Texas Instruments has its own factories in the USA but AFAIK they make other kinds of ICs than the popular ones that TSMC is known for, they do mostly analog and embedded (still important stuff).

The sibling post to yours lists other factories. There are definitely other companies.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by snvzz on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:13PM (#39297004)
For <10nm specifically.

And it is TSMC, Samsung and Intel.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by electriclove on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:52AM (#39289247)
They focused on the manufacturing part https://youtu.be/r_8XClnnvIk
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by MangoCoffee on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:35AM (#39289794)
Intel before Patrick P. Gelsinger only made chips for Intel.

ARM doesn't make chip

on the low-end and mid-tier chip, you have plenty of fabs like Global Foundries, UMC...etc.

on the high end, you have Intel, TSMC, and Samsung

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by YetAnotherNick on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:51AM (#39289227)
> I anyways hear about how the entire semiconductor industry is completely dependent on TSMC

I don't think it's as strong dependance as many commenters assume here. Samsung is 2 years behind TSMC and intel 3-4 years behind in terms of fab capability. While losing 2 years of progress is not great, it's definitely nothing like world can't function without TSMC.

Obviously they need few years to ramp up but I assume it's not like Taiwan geopolitics situation would change in a day.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by sofixa on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:33AM (#39289756)
> I anyways hear about how the entire semiconductor industry is completely dependent on TSMC, and nothing can operate without them, thus their geopolitical importance.

This is quite hyperbolic. While losing TSMC will have a massive global impact, there are alternatives in many different market segments (e.g. Intel for CPUs and GPUs for computing, be it personal or datacenter), STMicro/NXP/Infineon/Bosch for industrial applications, etc. They may not be as advanced, or as good, or as cheap, or in enough quantities, but it's flat out false to say that TSMC is the entire semiconductor industry. Just a major portion of the bleeding edge.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by xenadu02 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:03PM (#39291882)
Intel used to have the fab lead over everyone else, generally being 1-2 generations ahead. That persisted for at least a decade. Then they had a huge whiff. Their 10nm node was due in 2016 and they didn't start volume production until 2019. That gave TSMC a huge opportunity to catch up and pass them which is exactly what they did... TSMC went volume on 10nm in 2017.

Samsung is behind a generation (or thereabouts). Not sure why exactly.

AMD spun off their fab as GlobalFoundaries. The separate company bowed out of the bleeding-edge fab business. Their 14nm node was licensed from Samsung and they completely cancelled their 7nm node.

As bleeding-edge fabs kept getting more and more expensive lots of companies decided to go fabless. They were able to do that because unlike everyone else TSMC doesn't make chips for itself so it doesn't represent a competitive threat. This is the real key to TSMC's success.

Other companies like GlobalFoundaries and ON Semi are filling volume with older process nodes like 14nm. There's a large number of chips needed by millions of manufacturers large and small. Only a small proportion of those need the power/perf you get from the latest and greatest. Manufacturing on an older node is cheaper thanks to lower capex and much much better yields.

Eventually I think we'll see litho equipment make its way into the niche market similar to 3d printers. We've seen some people hacking together stuff to make their own chips in a garage... they're tiny 5-2000 transistor affairs but it would be quite interesting to be able to churn out a custom chip with a million transistors on it.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by drexlspivey on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:01PM (#39294283)
Please explain this to me, isn't the lithography equipment from ASML that does all the hard work of imprinting the wafers? If Samsung and Intel buys the same machines why can't they make the chips with the same transistor density?
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by pests on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:13PM (#39295005)
Michelangelo had the same chisel and tools as every other artist of his time.

Why didn't they just make art with the same quality?

It's not just what tools you have, but how you use them.

You don't just go plug in one of these machines and it starts pumping out working chips.

Increasing density means better controls and processes, better knowledge of running and calibrating the machines.

Tons of processes before and after the ASML machines.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by xenadu02 on Monday February 12, 2024 @08:01PM (#39352958)
You don't just buy the machines or build a fab.

Each fab is the development of an entire "process". Furthermore how the machines are used varies greatly. Everything from exact doping and cleaning processes to metal deposition parameters, plus the masks you feed into the system which these days are all interference-based - that is you rely on the interference patterns because you can't actually make masks nor use light of a wavelength small enough to create 14/10/7nm feature sizes. The mask you make is nonsense but the interference pattern it creates results in the actual patterns you want.

How many layers, how you can intersperse metal vs silicon layers, allowed dimensions for gates, wires, distances between components, and a whole host of other things are unique to the specific process. Oh and parameters vary based on what you are making on a given process (eg SRAM vs logic). Different layers can have different requirements as well. You might not even be able to take a design to another fab from the same company on the "same" process node, let alone a competitor.

This stuff is all extremely closely guarded by every fab. If you're a serious customer (read: $$$$) the fab will share these parameters with you so your engineers can design to that spec. Then your first run will likely have problems and need to work with the fab engineers to tweak layouts and such to get usable yields - depends on how much you are relying on the fab for design/layout. TSMC will happily license you certain blocks to use in your design along with guarantees on yield since the design is made for their process from the start. You can also license designs (eg from ARM) that are pre-customized for a given fab's process.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by greggsy on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:37PM (#39293970)
A cottage industry does seem to be within the realms of possibility, and 3D printing is an apt comparison. However, it’s likely to be prone to the same challenges - input materials (filament and wafers) will be subject to variable quality and environmental factors (moisture, heat, dust), and the machines themselves will take some time to mature (how many iterations of incompatible 3D printer ‘standards’ have cropped up in the two decades since DIY printing emerged in the scene?).

The nirvana of a household printing capability never really materialised.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by tutfbhuf on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:12AM (#39299916)
I wonder why none of the trillion-dollar club members with "infinite" money, e.g., MSFT or AAPL, are building bleeding-edge fabs in locations that are geopolitically more stable than Taiwan. If TSMC tanks, then these companies will also tank by a massive amount, much more than 20 bln.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by GuB-42 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:47AM (#39301846)
> Eventually I think we'll see litho equipment make its way into the niche market similar to 3d printers...

Won't you be better served with a FPGA? Are there any cases, besides hobby projects, where making you own silicon on a process many generations behind the state of the art would make sense?

With 3D printers, there are parts that are simply impossible to make without them, and there is no programmable plastic, so it makes sense to use them. In fact, we are starting to see entire factories churning out plastic parts from FDM printers not so different from what consumers buy. In the case of Prusa, they even make the parts using the same printers they sell to consumers.

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by throwawayai2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:15PM (#39292052)
Good answers here, but look at the book "Chip Wars" if you want to learn a lot more.
Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by gkanai on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @06:21PM (#39295671)
Asianometry has a number of explainer videos on TSMC. I recommend them:

https://www.asianometry.com/p/tsmc-briefly-explained

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by araes on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @07:02PM (#39296002)
Generally, they're not (or should not be), and its mostly hype tunnel vision (imo). Here's a link to the List of Semiconductor Fab Plants worldwide. [1] Note: This is a 1000 line table that lists production per plant at 10,000-100,000 / month for most fabs with numbers. There are a lot of other chip sources.

However, TSMC has the largest capacity worldwide. Intel's probably second for capacity. Samsung's probably third. Micron, Texas Instruments, Infineon, Epistar, and several others are lower down yet significant.

If you need small chips, out of plants already constructed, based on the data in the list, Intel and Samsung appear to have the "current" smallest node size at 7 nm. TSMC has three plants under construction with 3-5 nm node size. Intel and Samsung also have a lot of capacity in the 7-20 nm range.

Most companies are in the 20+ nm size ranges, although definite exceptions with Nanya (10 nm), SK Hynix (10 nm), nanoPHAB (10 nm), Win Semiconductor (10 nm), GlobalFoundries (12 nm), SMIC (14 nm), UMC (14 nm), Kioxia/SanDisk (15 nm).

There's also technology and product variety, although most list 3-5 for each plant, so there's a bunch of specializations.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat...

Re:TSMC to build second Japan chip factory, raising investme... by ksec on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:05AM (#39324717)
>TSMC occupies a different part of the supply chain.....

This is an interesting but not so obvious question, because it is so basic, I would thought it wont be on HN at the same time judging from comments on Hardware topic it really should have been spelled out clearly in the first place.

So first you have IP companies like ARM. They have lots of different IPs. ( Intellectual Properties ) From ISA ( Instruction Set Architecture ), think x86, ARMv8 etc to the actual CPU design, think Intel P-Core, E-Core, Skylake, AMD's Zen core etc. Along with many other IPs from GPU to Network, CPU Interconnect or even DRAM controller. ARM will work with TSMC ( or any other popular Fabs for specific market ) to have those design specific for the Fab and specific to certain Fab technology.

So in an extremely over simplified situation, you buy a few IPs, or there are even reference designs. Stitch them together. Send them over to TSMC and say hey can you print them ( or Fab ) for me.

What TSMC doing that nobody can do ( in the same time frame ) is that they could Fab it using industry leading technology, or the smallest transistor currently available as long as you are willing to pay for it.

There are plenty of chips that doesn't require TSMC to print. From Automotive to low cost semiconductor using very very old semi-conductor Fab's technology. Think about the small chips that goes into toys or electronic appliance. Or simple calculators.