News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Friday February 02, 2024 @01:19PM (#39232175)
No we overcomplicate it with overly complex regulations. It’s pretty simple, don’t dump chemicals in water or on land period. Assuming chemicals are totally fine until proven otherwise is backwards as hell and clearly corrupt.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by krisoft on Friday February 02, 2024 @01:45PM (#39232524)
> It’s pretty simple, don’t dump chemicals in water or on land period.

Everything is chemicals. You just described 2/3 of all industrial activity and proposed we should stop them. Are you willing to take the consequences which follow from that proposal? (And somehow forgot the 1/3 “dump chemicals in air”)

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by legulere on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:51PM (#39233296)
Chemicals are shorthand for synthetic chemicals. We co-evolved with natural chemicals which means that they're usually not too harmful to us and get easily biodegraded.

In this case it's about PFAS, a subgroup of organofluorine compounds. There's only 5 known organofluorine compounds produced by organisms.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#39233845)
> We co-evolved with natural chemicals which means that they're usually not too harmful to us

There are plenty of counter examples to this (and also pretty unclear what is meant by "natural")

Lead is natural. Mercury is natural.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:31PM (#39235351)
Jesus this is a stupid argument.

"Don’t dump chemicals in water or on land" is a perfectly logical and defensible statement.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Friday February 02, 2024 @07:10PM (#39236263)
Is water a chemical? How about nitrogen, which comprises 3/4 of our atmosphere?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @09:54PM (#39237172)
Is Bose–Einstein condensate a chemical? How about Neutronium?

See how that works?

Real productive mode of conversation, huh.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Saturday February 03, 2024 @01:10AM (#39237950)
I’m just trying to understand what “don’t dump chemicals in water or on land” even means. If nitrogen and water are OK, then the directive is plainly wrong. What else would be OK? And how would we make that decision?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by Bluecobra on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:22AM (#39238208)
Well for starters, maybe it was a bad idea to dump 27,000 barrels of DDT in the ocean near Los Angeles.

https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-05-18/heres-w...

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by paulmd on Saturday February 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#39242645)
> I’m just trying to understand what “don’t dump chemicals in water or on land” even means.

classic bad-faith interpretation, using the classic bad-faith slogan. No, you’re not “just trying to understand” anything, and GP is absolutely correct about that.

We are not dying for content here without your “hurr durr don’t you know water is a chemical posts, and we generally try to maintain a higher level of discourse here. Maybe try Reddit instead.

Please see the site rules about using the most generous possible interpretation of a comment, and if you actually have something to contribute then maybe try again.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Saturday February 03, 2024 @04:12PM (#39244796)
How about anhydrous ammonia? Or phosphate? I’m sorry, but there is no generous interpretation of “don’t dump chemicals on land.” It’s an empty statement that amounts to little more than value signaling. And it was presented with righteous indignation. I thought it best to counter that extreme position with obvious and irrefutable exceptions in an effort to open the door to a more thoughtful conversation. Unfortunately, on environmental issues, it seems for some there is only dogma.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by amarant on Saturday February 03, 2024 @01:42PM (#39243359)
The comment that spurred this conversation did claim that the problem was overly complicated legislation to a simple problem. "Don't dump chemicals" is about as good a solution as "don't do bad things". You can't oversimplify a complex issue like that and expect to get anywhere.

I'm being plenty charitable in assuming you're arguing in good faith, at first glance your comment comes off as anti-intellectual value signalling, which will never ever solve anything. Ever.

But this is HN, so I'm going to assume you've simply misunderstood the concern, as anti intellectualism has no place here.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by epcoa on Sunday February 04, 2024 @08:34AM (#39250068)
This is completely uncalled for. You should be ashamed. Ok so dump water. How about detergents with phosphates. Those were fine until they weren’t.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:44AM (#39248172)
Nah you’re playing stupid in bad faith.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:44AM (#39248169)
You know what was meant and this question is the perfect example of someone who is bad faith actor and we should jail for pretending to not get it. Water is a necessity to life and what humans drink, toxic chemicals aren’t. It’s simple, if it isn’t water don’t dump it, period.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by thereisnospork on Friday February 02, 2024 @07:27PM (#39236373)
No its not. Its an absurd statement that doesn't adequately define chemicals, water, or land nor does it address the very necessary industrial processes wherein 'chemicals' are and need to be dumped on water or land. A trivial for instance:

Okay, no more fertilizer on the crops then. Enjoy the famine.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @09:18PM (#39237023)
Obviously it's broad and there will be many exceptions. The exceptions are often the interesting part of the discussion.

Words have different meanings in different contexts. Pretending that "chemicals" can only ever be used to refer to all material substances equally is just intentionally trying to sabotage productive discussion.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Friday February 02, 2024 @10:40PM (#39237343)
> Words have different meanings in different contexts

Well define it then.

Nobody is complaing that there might be an alternative definition of chemical.

The complaint is that you're not using any widely known definition of "chemical" and not providing your own definition.

You can shut everyone up by just defining how you are using the word. I doubt you will since i think you are lying about there existing some other definition that makes sense in the context you are arguing, and you lack the knowledge/ability to make up your own definition that would fit your argument.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:09PM (#39237472)
Here you go, here's one plain vanilla dictionary definition, absent context.

Now would you like to discuss which "substances produced by chemical processes" are likely to be the most impactful upon the environment, or would you like to continue quibbling over semantics?

chemical [ kem-i-kuhl ]SHOW IPA

noun

a substance produced by or used in a chemical process.

chemicals, Slang. narcotic or mind-altering drugs or substances.

adjective

of, used in, produced by, or concerned with chemistry or chemicals: a chemical formula; chemical agents.

used in chemical warfare: chemical weapons.

https://www.dictionary.com/browse/chemical

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Saturday February 03, 2024 @12:02AM (#39237666)
Well given this is in response to the statement:

> "It’s pretty simple, don’t dump chemicals in water or on land period."

Then i still maintain anyone using that definition of chemical in the context of that statement is an utter idiot.

> Now would you like to discuss which "substances produced by chemical processes" are likely to be the most impactful upon the environment

Why? There is already a government department tasked with that, that can probably do a better job then you or i could.

If you're trying to argue that the status quo is fine and we shouldn't change anything, then you have a weird way of doing so.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by thereisnospork on Friday February 02, 2024 @10:14PM (#39237236)
The usage of chemicals is so broad and incorrect as to be inane in historical context and rhetorically useless, as demonstrated previously. If there's something to discuss regulating, then is necessary to describe it, otherwise all that's been said is 'BAD THINGS' shouldnt be put on the ground. A: duh B: meaningless, because "bad things" doesn't create a basis for a rule or judgement of aforementioned exceptions be because here 'chemicals' are already being assigned the negative connotation. No true chemical (Scotsman fallacy) could be put on the ground and so forth.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:10PM (#39237478)
So how would you say it instead?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by legulere on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:47PM (#39244054)
Notice the word usually I used. It's about probabilities, and with vastly different probabilities come different burdens of proof. If you had the choice to put something random from the forest in your mouth or something from a chemistry lab?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:42AM (#39248160)
Neither lead nor mercury are chemicals that naturally exist in large quantities in a typical human habitat.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by defrost on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:48AM (#39248186)
Aside from the evidence of > 2,000 years of lead and mercury poisoning, of course.

Humans have been naturally digging these things up and refining them since at least the Roman Empire [1] in the west and the earliest Chinese Dynasties in the East [2].

[1] https://sites.dartmouth.edu/toxmetal/more-metals/lead-versat...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mausoleum_of_the_First_Qin_Emp...

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by sitkack on Friday February 02, 2024 @01:54PM (#39232647)
> Everything is chemicals.

This is a thought terminating cliche and pedantically destroys the conversation.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by lazide on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:12PM (#39232864)
What is the difference between lye (dangerous), sand (not dangerous unless it suffocates things or gets crushed and inhaled), water (can cause flooding or drowning, otherwise harmless), and sodium bicarbonate (quite basic, generally harmless), and hydrazine (mutagenic, highly toxic, highly flammable)?

All of these have hazards in specific circumstances, and huge benefits in others. All are chemicals.

All are well known and characterized. Many other compounds are too new for that level of knowledge and characterization. They are chemicals too.

If we allow someone to make new chemicals (it’s hard to stop, frankly!), either we say ‘no, not until they are fully understood and characterized’, or ‘yes, unless we learn it’s too hazardous’.

Saying no first is a bit of a catch-22 since how are you going learn anything and characterize the dangers if you don’t make and use it a bunch?

If you say ‘yes, unless we learn it’s too dangerous’ then we learn a huge amount quite quickly - but inevitably have something too dangerous causing problems.

It’s a fundamentally conservative vs liberal development strategy debate.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by naremu on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:04PM (#39233502)
>What is the difference between lye (dangerous), sand (not dangerous unless it suffocates things or gets crushed and inhaled), water (can cause flooding or drowning, otherwise harmless), and sodium bicarbonate (quite basic, generally harmless), and hydrazine (mutagenic, highly toxic, highly flammable)?

The MSDSes will elaborate on this and you probably know that.

This thread chain has gotten impressively disingenuous very fast. We aren't arguing the colloquial definition of chemicals which if we're not being pedantic, we know brings up ideas of substances damaging to other substances or life itself.

Which is fairly obviously the line that you're giving a good traditional "but where would we POSSIBLY STOP?!" gambit that comes out of paid lobbyist's mouths more often than hello or goodbye.

The line to be crossed is obviously at least a few blocks up the way from "what is the difference between water and hydrazine though".

And also, anything cumulative becomes "too hazardous" within years. But by then profits are made, and war chests are filled to keep the spice flowing.

The world got by for thousands of years sustainably without a lot of these "huge benefits" and I'm willing to take a hit or two within my lifetime to ensure there's still lifetimes at all down the road.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:31PM (#39233918)
> The line to be crossed is obviously at least a few blocks up the way from "what is the difference between water and hydrazine though".

Do you actually have a line? We can't make a law out of people saying "you know what i mean".

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by naremu on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:56PM (#39234262)
> the colloquial definition of chemicals which if we're not being pedantic, we know brings up ideas of substances damaging to other substances or life itself.

From the comment you're responding to. Damage is quantifiable, if it wasn't, the OP (EPA proposing hazardous substance classification) wouldn't even exist.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Friday February 02, 2024 @04:55PM (#39234979)
one presumes it is not when there is any quantifiable damage, no matter how slight. I assume nobody is proposing banning water, etc. But even plain water can result in large amounts of environmental damage in certain contexts.

If the point is just to ban things when the risks outweigh the benefits, that is simply the status quo.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by lazide on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:24PM (#39235266)
The challenge is, one can usually only make that kind of trade off when something is well known enough to know the risks and benefits in a wide variety of environments.

The first real problematic PFAS compounds were in fire fighting foam used to put out aircraft fires for example, and took decades for their problems to show up.

Which requires either extremely exhaustive (or essentially impossible economically) testing, or yolo’ng it. Or only using already known compounds.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by lazide on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:29PM (#39233873)
No, you’re just being disingenuous.

How do you create a MSDS for a chemical that hasn’t been made yet?

How do you decide it’s safe to create a large enough quantity of a chemical to figure out what even should be in that MSDS?

How can you know if something is mutagenic without exposing it to DNA? Or cancer causing without exposing it to a living organism? Or causes reproductive harm without exposing it to organisms and seeing how it impacts reproduction?

Those all are potential harms.

Traditionally, some enterprising alchemist/chemist would just try it - and if they lived, would write a paper on it. Further research and experience would then inform if a better alternative should be used.

The Haber-Bosch process that allowed the creation of artificial fertilizers has allowed for the massive expansion of the human race. Roughly 3/4 of the humans on this planet right now would starve to death without it. Assuming they didn’t get nuked first. That was in 1909.

It also allowed for the creation of modern high explosives (and propellants) at scale, and the horrors of WW1 and WW2. And the mining revolution, which has provided the raw materials necessary to build our modern economies at vastly cheaper prices than were ever possible before for humanity.

Chemistry is a fundamental building block of modern society, and removing it would literally cause its sudden and violent collapse.

Deciding if ‘freezing’ it in place, or letting it continue to develop new and interesting applications is the discussion - because no, we weren’t sustainable before (unless you count constant and ongoing genocides as ‘sustainable’), and we’ve long passed the point where trying to return to that would be anything but apocalyptic.

Literally.

And keeping in mind that just because we agree to stop research in one area doesn’t mean anyone else (competitors) will do so. Regardless of if that is in the realm of drugs, or weapons, or soaps, or foods, or whatever.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by naremu on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:52PM (#39234201)
So, let me get this straight: I've claimed reducing everything to "chemicals" is disingenuous, and in response, I'm immediately told "no, you" and then challenged with debates over topics or ideas I haven't actually talked about like

>How do you create a MSDS for a chemical that hasn’t been made yet?

What argument that I've made do you present this logical fallacy to?

> Deciding if ‘freezing’ it in place, or letting it continue to develop new and interesting applications is the discussion

This is not my viewpoint and was never mentioned by me. This is an argument you're either making in reference to another comment, a point not addressed by myself, or you're talking to your own strawman, who doesn't seem to have a significant stance other than "well, it's basically unsolveable!".

That is the discussion I was having. You're doing exactly what I mentioned, being disingenuous about the literal technical definition of chemicals and muddying waters because water is a chemical too, man!

Well watering my lawn doesn't kill it or give organisms that live mere decades cancer. That's a reasonable measurement to start.

And if you're really saying there can't be more in depth, slower research to chemicals that people will end up having in their bloodstream, then I don't even know what to say to that, other than Andrew Ryan would be proud.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by lazide on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:03PM (#39235066)
It doesn’t seem like you’re reading your comments or my replies?

The concern about the chemicals we’re talking about is that they are in the water you are using to water your lawn, anmong other things, and have been getting made at scale for over 50 years. And is a family of 6 million something chemicals, some of which we suspect now may be dangerous - including causing cancer - and some we have no idea.

We can only test for things we suspect are an actual issue and have a test for. And for which we actually test.

Which we don’t really have reasonable tests for ‘doesn’t bio degrade over decades+ and bio accumulates to potentially dangerous levels’ yet. Except watching nature, anyway, which is how we discovered this problem. There are millions more chemicals that this hasn’t happened either.

So what do you propose doing here besides freezing it until such tests can be put in place and developed?

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by thaumasiotes on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:37PM (#39233139)
No, it's pretty much the only appropriate response to edgyquant's demand that we do the impossible.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by krisoft on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:40PM (#39235436)
> This is a thought terminating cliche and pedantically destroys the conversation.

It is not. Quite contrary. The thought it provokes is "what chemicals do you want to ban?" Do you want to ban water? Should we throw anyone in a prison who transports it? It is a chemical after all. One which is quite dangerous in many circumstances.

But surely that is not what edgyquant meant. Should we prohibit people selling soap? It is a chemical! But that is silly. We would probably lose more by banning that than by not banning it.

Should we ban plastics? Maybe? Which types? All types? All uses?

Should we sell hydrazine in grocery stores? Oh, we better not. Can we use hydrazine in special applications like fuelling satellites? If so what do we require from people who handle/store/dispose of it?

So many thoughts provoked by that simple observation.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by epcoa on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:29AM (#39238522)
> Should we prohibit people selling soap?

I mean, there's a good example there with phosphate compounds in detergents.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by sitkack on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @03:09AM (#39272060)
> Do you want to ban water? Should we throw anyone in a prison who transports it? It is a chemical after all.

Exactly. You prove my point.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:40AM (#39248150)
No you’re being pedantic and proving my point. Everyone, every single person, knows when you’re doing something that could potentially devastate an environment and if you have to ask if it could don’t be dumping. Why should anyone be allowed to dump anything at all into the local environment?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by amarant on Friday February 02, 2024 @01:36PM (#39232400)
Do you know what the word "chemical" means?

We do need to be a bit more specific than that, or we're not gonna get anywhere.

Also, once we've specified which chemicals shouldn't be dumped, I'd like to include the atmosphere in the list of places where one shouldn't dump them. Seems to be a very popular place to dump really harmful stuff, we should stop that.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by naremu on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:11PM (#39233623)
> Do you know what the word "chemical" means?

This intentional nitpicking of the colloquial usage of the word chemicals is a favorite of both, disingenuous conversationalists who like to take a chance to feel correct rather than participate earnestly, and lobbyists.

At least one of them gets paid for it though.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by bawolff on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:39PM (#39234025)
Its hardly a nitpick, you're being so vauge that its impossible to understand what you are actually proposing.

Why not just use more specific language? If indeed everyone is acting in bad faith, using clear language would shut them up. If instead they are being ernest and cannot understand you because of the "colloquial" language, then being rigorous would further your stated goal of ernest participation. Either way seems like a win-win for you.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by naremu on Friday February 02, 2024 @04:12PM (#39234473)
I didn't propose anything, I'm just nitpicking HN's nitpicking of attempts to have a real conversation.

Which, since HN is a place for technically minded people, has resulted in people arguing that chemical contamination of PFAS is categorically the same as watering my lawn.

You are technically correct, but this is called a "gotcha": it's not about continuing the conversation in earnest, if anything, it shuts down conversation about the important details by, in the writing of mike judge, "playing lawyerball" instead.

In reality we all know that none of us are writing the technical legislation, so any of us becoming enamored with defending for profit entities against hazardous chemical classification through technical usage of language is...basically the core spirit of corporate lobbyism.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by krisoft on Friday February 02, 2024 @06:53PM (#39236134)
> has resulted in people arguing that chemical contamination of PFAS is categorically the same as watering my lawn.

I don't recognise anyone here arguing this. Let me recap the conversation: tankaiji said it is good to ban these, but expressed concern that companies will find other dangerous chemicals to replace them with. mensetmanusman responded something along the lines of this being an inevitable consequence of human technology. edgyquant responded that the problem is overly complex regulation and seemingly proposed a simpler solution.

People rightfully pointed out that his simpler solution can't distinguish between the chemical contamination of PFAS and watering ones lawn. Which is ridiculous. So clearly the problem is not that simple. In fact the problem is complex and therefore the regulations around it are complex too.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by kccqzy on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:39PM (#39237585)
This intentional nitpicking is necessary for anyone who has taken a first course in chemistry.

You do not appear to have done that. That's why you are arguing with the colloquial usage of the word. Because you can't offer a useful and precise definition.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by callalex on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:07PM (#39235104)
Do you wash your dishes and clothes? Do you shower with soap?