News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Friday February 02, 2024 @07:10PM (#39236263)
Is water a chemical? How about nitrogen, which comprises 3/4 of our atmosphere?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by marshray on Friday February 02, 2024 @09:54PM (#39237172)
Is Bose–Einstein condensate a chemical? How about Neutronium?

See how that works?

Real productive mode of conversation, huh.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Saturday February 03, 2024 @01:10AM (#39237950)
I’m just trying to understand what “don’t dump chemicals in water or on land” even means. If nitrogen and water are OK, then the directive is plainly wrong. What else would be OK? And how would we make that decision?
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by Bluecobra on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:22AM (#39238208)
Well for starters, maybe it was a bad idea to dump 27,000 barrels of DDT in the ocean near Los Angeles.

https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-05-18/heres-w...

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by paulmd on Saturday February 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#39242645)
> I’m just trying to understand what “don’t dump chemicals in water or on land” even means.

classic bad-faith interpretation, using the classic bad-faith slogan. No, you’re not “just trying to understand” anything, and GP is absolutely correct about that.

We are not dying for content here without your “hurr durr don’t you know water is a chemical posts, and we generally try to maintain a higher level of discourse here. Maybe try Reddit instead.

Please see the site rules about using the most generous possible interpretation of a comment, and if you actually have something to contribute then maybe try again.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by hcurtiss on Saturday February 03, 2024 @04:12PM (#39244796)
How about anhydrous ammonia? Or phosphate? I’m sorry, but there is no generous interpretation of “don’t dump chemicals on land.” It’s an empty statement that amounts to little more than value signaling. And it was presented with righteous indignation. I thought it best to counter that extreme position with obvious and irrefutable exceptions in an effort to open the door to a more thoughtful conversation. Unfortunately, on environmental issues, it seems for some there is only dogma.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by amarant on Saturday February 03, 2024 @01:42PM (#39243359)
The comment that spurred this conversation did claim that the problem was overly complicated legislation to a simple problem. "Don't dump chemicals" is about as good a solution as "don't do bad things". You can't oversimplify a complex issue like that and expect to get anywhere.

I'm being plenty charitable in assuming you're arguing in good faith, at first glance your comment comes off as anti-intellectual value signalling, which will never ever solve anything. Ever.

But this is HN, so I'm going to assume you've simply misunderstood the concern, as anti intellectualism has no place here.

Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by epcoa on Sunday February 04, 2024 @08:34AM (#39250068)
This is completely uncalled for. You should be ashamed. Ok so dump water. How about detergents with phosphates. Those were fine until they weren’t.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:44AM (#39248172)
Nah you’re playing stupid in bad faith.
Re:The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be consider... by edgyquant on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:44AM (#39248169)
You know what was meant and this question is the perfect example of someone who is bad faith actor and we should jail for pretending to not get it. Water is a necessity to life and what humans drink, toxic chemicals aren’t. It’s simple, if it isn’t water don’t dump it, period.