Most of my frustrations come from the challenge of having 2 older (not toddler) kids, plus multiple Google devices (phones, tablets, Google TV's, PCs signed into Google Accounts). Google imagines parental control to be in the context of supervision, ie. this is Billy's phone and I'm going to physically hand it to him to use until he's done. And it's fundamentally device-level rather than account level, making it very cumbersome and easily circumvented -- let's say Jill has access via her account to 3 different Google TV's in the house. Family Link makes you say how much time she's allowed to spend on each TV per day. But to Jill, TV is TV, so if you leave her home alone unsupervised she'll just watch her quota on the first TV and then move on to the next.
My prevailing theories, mind you I have no evidence at all for this:
- These disparate product teams don't actually work closely together (and are probably incentivized to NOT work together)
- These are dead-end teams at Google. If you end up on one, your goal is to nominally ship something so you can go somewhere else.
- The product and engineering people who end up on the Family Link team don't actually have kids (they're too young), or if they do, they have like, one young kid.
> Most of us had full control of our devices growing up, right?
Devices, yes. Internet connection: not at first. With the AOL app (not a separate appliance or OS feature) responsible for establishing the dialup connection, it only bridged internet access to the OS when the current AOL user had no parental controls. As a 10-14 year old whose AOL account was set to "young teen" (DNS allow list) and then "mature teen" (DNS deny list), I was free to use non-AOL apps but they had no internet access. Solution: download a keylogger* and subsequently use a parent's AOL account for the next few years until they removed controls from mine, giving full Internet access to the whole computer, without being found out.
*The free version had a "pay for this" nag popup every few minutes. I opened the exe in a hex editor, typed over that nag string, and managed to corrupt it just enough that it would crash (with a totally generic fatal error) instead of nag. Launched it right before finding mom or dad to help me do some safe but blocked activity, which they were always happy to do, with increased supervision.
Here are things you cannot do:
- Create a global screen time limit across all devices regardless of how that time is used.
- Create a PIN for Google TV that prevents kids from switching to an adult account in order to access more apps. Right now it's the other way around, you can set a PIN that prevents a kid from accessing their own account (again, because supervision!) but that kid can easily switch over to the adult account if they want.
- Require that when an idle Google TV exit to the 'user selection' screen after a timeout. Right now a kid can just walk up to the TV and start using my profile and apps because I was the last one to use it.
As for nostalgia, I think that's overthinking it.
(Although they do have different fine grained features, like time limits and web site approval specifically aren't enterprise things.)
Yes, but the devices could do a lot less.
Like, I had full control over my bike too. But not an automobile.
I dunno about you but we had one computer, one TV, and one phone line. If by "full control" you mean "constant negotiations" then yeah we had that. By the time I was able to drive and earn enough coin to build my own computer, I was practically an adult.
What? Apple's successfully made it very hard for adults to get into their own devices. This claim is absurd.
90% of the time product lays out a minimal rushed vision, engineering huffs and puffs that it might be impossible, then people work about 20-30 hours a week complaining that the designers didn't tell them exactly what to do and the teams they need to integrate with won't help, and you deliver 80-90% of the original minimal "vision" and slap eachother on the back.
And that was _before_: A) spent 18 months firing people, while some managers took advantage of that situation to punch down. B) they nuked the performance review system, 80% are exactly the same with their Significant Impact, another 10-15% have scarlet letters, and 5-10% get rewards.
Any deviation from that and someone perceives you as being on their turf and finds a way to punch down.
And good luck getting management to care, just like the real world, no one wants to get within 100 feet of trouble.
Then you're faced with the invitation to appeal to a VP, a coin flip where you have to guess at if they're going to back you, and even if they do, facing the fact you nuked your career anyway because you broke omerta.
Microsoft has e.g. actual child Hotmail accounts, where the parent can whitelist who they can email and who can contact them. Gmail does not and has no intention adding such a thing. They did eventually add child accounts as part of the Family Link effort, but there's really no controls at that level. I recall seeing internally at Google that instead of adding such facilities to Gmail, they just preferred to a) cover their eyes and pretend that <13 year olds didn't have accounts by tossing that into the agreement and asking for a birthday b) proposing some blue sky alternative communication system for children (I forget the name of this effort, but it was I think 2016ish time frame?), but it had mock-ups and hand waving and big discussions and PRDs etc but was guaranteed to go nowhere because it was a giant vision parallel to y'know... actual-reality...
Microsoft also has global time limits across all devices. And far more granular control.
Anyways, you're substantially right about all this. It drove me nuts that we struggled to deal with access to harmful content and had no control over it, and the worst part of it was working at Google at the time and seeing just how not--seriously this is taken or at least the level of organizational paralysis that was preventing action.
Apple's system isn't much better than Google's FWIW.
The moral here is all parental controls are crap because they don’t directly drive revenue. (Yes, you can say “but I would prefer to use a service with better controls, which drives adoption”, but let’s be honest - we are a minority there). Nobody’s getting promoted for making the best parental control suite.
That, and parents only have kids of the age that this is of relevance for, for maybe 4, 5, 6 years. So you're targeting a feature not only for a small segment, but one that is transient.
And if you screw it up, there's all sorts of potential for liability. You have to be careful about what you promise, etc. etc.
All the more reason why the answer probably comes down to: gov't regulation instead of expecting them to do this voluntarily.
Well, I was thinking of buying an XBox but now...
It's hard to quantify the difference but Kagi really feels like it's working with me instead of just trying to sell me garbage.
It was absolutely bananas that a search engine could be SO GOOD the first result would probably be the right one.
Now the first link (and second and third) are never the right one. Usually something different entirely.
I know it seemed unthinkable for most of Google's history. For the longest time Search was Google. But now...
We must consider the fact that Google is essentially a user data broker. All their products are in various proportions collecting user data and/or serving ads.
If Search quality and features keep reducing then its usage and relevance will drop too, reducing its effectiveness at both data collecting and ad serving.
I don't think Google's DNA allows them to consider radical alternatives. They were born in an era when data automation was in its infancy and they rode it all the way to the top. They abhor the human touch, the manual intervention. Their services are set to function automatically, set and forget.
But AI is changing the automation landscape, it's bringing a transformative paradigm shift. It's irresistible bait for Google but it will ruin Search. They'll deal with it the only way they know how, drop it.
I feel the same can be said about accessibility service: Once you get the accessibility permission, you have FULL control over the user's device. They could just split those permissions and expose a more fine-grained control api, but they (I suspect) have some one, verry extreme use case in mind and design the service around it (like ie. phone user being completly blind and requiring the accessiblity app to be an interface for literally all interactions with the device).
Which means that whenever you want to use some feature of that api, you have to trust an app completely and give it a carte-blanche to do whatever it wants on your device.
Which ultimately leads to gigantic whole in platforms security, for no other reason then 'this is the way and scenarios we intend people to be using it, and we give no compromises for anyone who has any other usege in mind'
Small example: On iOS 'Screen Time' you can restrict websites to a whitelist, which seems useful. But so many things break if you do that - all kinds of login screens for different apps - and you dont get given clues to as to what urls need to be whitelisted to un-break things.
Sometimes with modern tech you're using a feature and you think "this is incredibly complicated and broken, there can't be many people actually using this" and I tend to get that feeling with parental controls.
Which could very likely go undetected, therefore unpunished. It's not like it's a family-room computer that's easily monitored.
> After all, they're parental controls, not NSA-proof security. Making them technically bulletproof would arguably be worse for everyone.
It sounds like they're about as bulletproof as as screen door. I would be much better to have them as strong as an locked exterior door, maybe not "NSA-proof" (the door is vulnerable to locksmiths and battering rams) but strong enough to keep a kid out.
I think that tells me something about the actual priorities of the people building all those systems.
In the end it is surrogate of a parent. Either you care about your child and you know what it is doing, or not.
If you think that your child would be vunlerable to anything in the web, then most likely you should not give the phone to your kid.
If the kid is old enough to understand things, then it does not require software parental control, but a parent. A good parent does not need parental control in apps of their children.
Parental controls also disables ability to install apps from other sources and I prefer fdroid apps from play store apps.
The last thing is that it teaches that we are controlled by some software company, and 'kept safe from harm'. It gives that illusion. It trains that illusion. It enforces it.
Every parent can use a little help. There's so much that your child sees and hears, you want to be there to help explain it to them when they have questions.
Hand them a device that shows anything happening anywhere in the world? Maybe a little help there, limiting what they can easily stumble upon, is a good thing.
I do not say that everybody can now safely remove their safeguards.
phone has many utilities I want kids to use: make calls, check mail, maps, weather etc.
The issue is that they are using it for secretly watching tiktok for example.
Have your child hand you their phone at 10PM before they go to bed? Why do they need a phone on their person 24/7?
Because they use it as an alarm?
Because you have a late date night and won't be there in person?
There are solutions.
E.g. parental controls.
Or "you need to put the phone down at 10pm, if I come home and see you on it you will be grounded"
Why must we use technology to enforce parenting choices
Humans predate computers.
But technology can come in handy, don't you think?
(also, we're in a thread complaining about how technology doesn't properly support paraental controls)
Or... hear me out... they don't really want adequate controls to be put in place in the first place?
And, yeah, I have many many beefs to pick with Family Link.
And of course the Play store is desperate for you to provide a credit card at every single opportunity so you can maximize the potential of kids doing accidental buying.
It is a complete scam.
I honestly don't know how television got such strict laws and regulations on children's programming, when viewed in comparison to the complete wild west, that is the modern app store.
With time and pressure.
Right now you have a fun new technology which people are still infatuated with, bought by one of the biggest companies to ever exist, in a country which openly permits business-to-politician payments through lobbying.
The wild west won't look anything like it does 50 years from now
> in a country which openly permits business-to-politician payments through lobbying.
It's actually amazing how good of a tell this is. Nobody who says this ever knows anything about politics. I'm sorry, but politicians actually genuinely believe in most of the stuff they do you don't like, and so do their voters.
If you don't, you could let them know and save them billions of USD per year.
But yes, that too, because even when they try it doesn't work.
Here's today's election results in SC where the billionaire-backed* candidate got 1.4%.
https://x.com/armanddoma/status/1753947901972418952
* morally, not financially, since you can't really do that unlike what people think
e.g. amazon in 2023, 19.8m USD https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders
it's not like america is alone in this, they just have gigantic dollar figures. australia is a country which really struggles to move away from fossil fuels, and it also has gigantic coal-mining companies paying huge amounts to keep it that way
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-16797862
https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/23/apple-ramped-up-lobbying-spe...
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/dec/09/big-meat...
Companies also spend billions on marketing. But there's no reason to believe either of these things actually /work/. And lobbying is not giving money to politicians.
Over the air broadcasts do. The broadcast spectrum is considered publicly owned and is leased to television operators.
I guess you could say the same about the cellular spectrum. But how deep do you want government regulation to go since Google operates over the internet? Do you really want the government controlling internet content “for the children”?
And if they regulate app stores, especially on Android, do they also regulate what you can distribute from your own website?
So yes, I do expect strict child regulation in it, especially since there isn't the open internet issue of a) who pays for it and b) who is the central regulatory nexus point. It is google/apple in both cases.
If the US does something like the EU DMA, do you regulate all app stores for content?
Exactly how do you do either in a way that the government doesn’t come in an regulate content that they don’t like?
You are obviously arguing for zero-regulation, or you think you are in the libertarian sense. I always like to ask libertarians if they think murder should be illegal, which they usually do. Well, guess what, you are in favor of government regulation, it simply comes down to what line in the sand you are drawing that obviously is convenient to your own self interest.
Just like Meta/Instagram, they're playing lip-service to the concept, but not really taking action.
Frustratingly, out of all the platforms & BigCorps, Microsoft's parental controls and support for child accounts seems the best.
For many parents this might be no big deal. But there are genuinely children who've ventured into self-harm, eating disorder, etc. content on account of the wild-westness of the Internet combined with weakness of this crap. And it's absolutely maddening to see how pathetic they all (including Apple) are treating this.
The Apple ones seem to have a hundred holes kids can break to extend screen time or download apps, and sometimes it takes awhile for a change to take effect. Windows was completely broken last time I checked on my son’s gaming machine. And Sony PlayStation - oh, so so painful.
So it isn’t just Android. It’s everyone.
Regarding YouTube, the YouTube Kids app lets me block videos and whole channels, and it's great. But there is no equivalent functionality in the main YouTube app. On various devices (e.g., Roku, Google Nest) the kid sometimes manages to find some YouTube channels I'd rather they didn't watch. But I have to manually intervene each time, I can't just block those channels from being watched or recommended in the future. YouTube/Google obviously know that it's valuable to block videos/channels, since that feature exists in the kids app, yet they omit the feature from the main app, even for a paying customer like me. It is obnoxious.
I have a legacy Google Workspaces account that all my family is on and now that it's considered a "business" product, I can't enable parental controls on my kids' Google accounts.
It feels like no real kids are testing the parental controls: For a long time it was trivially easy to circumvent a set YouTube time limit restriction by just opening Play Store, browsing to an app with a video in the screenshot list and head over to YouTube from there. My son actually showed me this when he discovered it.