News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by sebastos on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:00PM (#39126048)
It's kind of astounding just how absolutely useless top-level communications are in publicly traded companies. My company is far smaller and less important than Google, but I can still recognize the exact same brand of vacuous crap being passed off as leadership. How is it that as a people we've come to just accept this as table stakes?

Those 7 goals that he gave the company are... nothing. It's so painfully inclusive that there's nothing left to not be a goal. "Build the most helpful personal computing platforms and devices"? What the fuck is that? What activity could possibly be ruled as conclusively in or out of conformance with that goal?

It reminds me of the brain-dead training modules the whole world is required to click-through as fast as possible. Everybody knows it's pointless, nobody complains. I'm left wondering who the hell is driving all of this corporate theater? What is this reality distortion field that makes us feel like it is an inevitable fact of life that these leaders can only communicate in banal, unactionable platitudes? How is it that the entire corporate world has agreed that the liability of slipping up or saying something too opinionated outweighs _actually communicating_ with the damn employees?

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by code_biologist on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:31PM (#39126206)
I'm left wondering who the hell is driving all of this corporate theater? What is this reality distortion field that makes us feel like it is an inevitable fact of life that these leaders can only communicate in banal, unactionable platitudes?

At risk of shilling a bit, Whatifalthist posted an interesting video today "Understanding Modern Civilization" [1]. It's a longer critique of modernity, but I particularly liked the discussion of why the managerial elite came to power. In modernity, the lack of life or death pressure, social mobility, plus the gameability of metrics / systems used to determine who has power (ie. ivy league and big 4 consultancy pedigree vs inherited power back in the day) has made our leadership subject to the same foibles that affected Chinese mandarins historically: corruption and a focus on appearances over the details of actual execution.

So yeah, Sundar is one of our modern mandarins.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-SjMVJrmhh8

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by esperent on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:24AM (#39126463)
Interesting take, I'll watch the video later.

One important note is that there's a big difference between our culture and historical Chinese culture - and basically all powerful cultures that have existed before now. That is, the flexibility and rapid change of the system itself. It's not just upward mobility of people, it's upward mobility of companies and rapid systemic change, driven by technology and cultural shifts. Think about the difference between our society, and the 80s, the 50s, the 30s. There's never been a period like this before, so making comparisons to previous cultures is of limited utility and that needs to be noted when making the comparisons.

We might think of Google as a never-ending behemoth with incredible power because in our recent lifetimes it's been that way. But the reality is that the company has only existed for ~26 years and if it truly slips up it could be a shadow of itself in another five years. Something else would jump into the power vacuum and our society would barely blink, except for a million articles with titles like "What happened to Google?" being written.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by sifar on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:41PM (#39133056)
I believe bureaucratic structures at scale are the same irrespective of cultures.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by redrove on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:13AM (#39128699)
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-SjMVJrmhh8

I've watched the whole thing with great attention.

There's some thoughts about "modernism" drawn from other books that the author cites that are worth exploring if you have an interest in history/anthropology. Somewhere in the middle the author's own theory starts protruding through.

I'll save everyone the 66 minutes: at the end of the video the author claims the CIA conclusively proved you can travel to the spirit world. This is really all you need to know.

I would rate this as a crock of shit, go read the books if you're interested in the topic, but skip the video.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by cpeterso on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:35PM (#39138636)
For those downvoting, the video really does cite the CIA’s 1980s research into astral projection and the “Gateway Experience”, asserting it is “all correct”.

https://www.vice.com/en/article/7k9qag/how-to-escape-the-con...

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by xyst on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:49PM (#39126293)
The current ceo is cut from the same cloth of generic Wall Street b-school flunkies. What do you expect?

Their pay is often determined based on the performance of the stonk. An easy way to pump their $$$ and meet whatever OKRs are required to satisfy bonuses, is to layoff staff. Use vague excuses (ie, blaming remote work) for poor performance. Rinse and repeat as needed every quarter until they can sustainably compete or until they are 86’d.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by Gibbon1 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:53PM (#39126316)
> but I can still recognize the exact same brand of vacuous crap being passed off as leadership

I googled a bit and found he has an MBA from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. So that's probably the answer.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:29PM (#39126197)
what kind of goals would you set if you be Pichai?
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by sebastos on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:12AM (#39126401)
Well, I'm no CEO of Google or anything, but if the company is so broad, then shouldn't he be giving an audacious but concrete goal to each of his segments separately? It's just supposed to be scoped for the year 2024, after all. What's the point of having your 2024 goal be "make the world a great place for Googlers"? What about that starts or ends in 2024? In his shoes, I'd feel pressure to devise specific high-level strategies that compliment the different segments and then throw down the gauntlet. So you know, you'd have high level strategies, like "AI all the things = synergy" and "Regain public trust on our bread and butter products" and then you'd break it down more:

- Self-driving car people: Make me a giant dataset of multimodal data for the AI people

- AI people: Show me a demo of Gemini driving the self-driving car people's car by end of year

- Nest and assistant people: Real-time Gemini assistant

And then over on the pure software side you'd be saying:

- Youtube people: Expand premium membership by foo, reduce negative ad sentiment by bar

- Google Drive people: Close gap with M$ Office features in GSuite

- Search people: Radical crackdown on dark SEO patterns

- Gchat people: pointlessly re-imagine the entire look and feel of the web app for the fifteenth time

etc. etc.

No?

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:49AM (#39127240)
You can read "most helpful personal platforms" as personal platforms(chrome, android, bard, search, drive) being more helpful than competitors. I guess defining specific benchmarks and metrics should be included into the goal. Then it looks very specific without 10 bullet points like in your proposal.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by xiphias2 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:30AM (#39126498)
10-20 years ago it was always the same (before Amit Singhal was kicked out): precision +X% / recall +X% for Google search
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:52AM (#39127255)
now they have many more surfaces including actual search(lots of different panels)
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by xiphias2 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:11AM (#39127351)
The point is that OKRs are good only if anybody from the company can track if / how much they are contributing to the company goals. It only works if the key results have a clear metric.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:18AM (#39127385)
Those from Pichai are some global "goals" not "OKRs".

Also, that's if you have some quality improvement you can use some metric. For launching new products you just have: launch new product, and then next year you can claim user growth, features adaptations, track engagement metrics, and this works for specific surface.

For multiple complicated surfaces you likely can't come with single integrated metric. I even don't know how they could measure precision/recall for search, there are likely so many slices/skews/verticals/corner cases.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by operatingthetan on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:35PM (#39126226)
Make the public trust Google more than any other FAANG again. People like Microsoft more than any of those companies now, which is a hilarious flip from how people felt about them in the late 90s early 2000s.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:37PM (#39126250)
HN crowd may be not trusting google, but I am not so sure about general public. You probably don't have any hard data in your hands.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by readthenotes1 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:38AM (#39126537)
Hold my beer while I Google for it...
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:45PM (#39126281)
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:50AM (#39127242)
Looks like that poll checks specific topic: "trust in data handling", not trust in general. Also #2 is Ok position.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by operatingthetan on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:39PM (#39126256)
>You probably don't have any hard data in your hands.

Okay? I bet you don't either.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:41PM (#39126265)
I don't, but you are supposed to provide evidence based on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(philosophy)
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by operatingthetan on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:44PM (#39126278)
I didn't say something that goes against the status quo. I'm not interested in a pedantic tangent thanks.

Just as we can see from OP, the goals don't need to be based on data, they are goals, not arguments.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by shmerl on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:34PM (#39126221)
Deploy Google Fiber everywhere?
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:36PM (#39126237)
I think this is something with low reward/risk ratio for google, given where they have moat and expertise.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by ukuina on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @04:01PM (#39195764)
This is high risk, actually. Google has peering agreements with all major ISPs... the same ones that dislike the existence of cheap, fast fiber.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by paulddraper on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:05PM (#39126089)
> It's so painfully inclusive that there's nothing left to not be a goal.

To be fair... it's Google.

There's nothing computing-related that isn't Google.

ISP, cloud, web, personal hardware, IT security, OS, autonomous vehicles, social media, thermostats, mapping...

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by throwaway914 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:32PM (#39126211)
I work in a very large organization with 50,000 people. It's painful and discouraging listening to the person at the top, or their close deputies, because the documents they publish for mission goals are so abstract and boundless. Nothing I want ever seems directly addressed in these documents that get passed to all of us.

However, I've learned that the middle managers below C suite are looking at these objectives and justifying their own plans in alignment with this. Whatever the people who actually "do" want to do in 2025, must be in support of this abstract crap that frustrates me.

I've had more success in the last 2 years aligning my wants and interests with those of my middle managing-leadership, as they orient toward the executives.

Executives are often trying to enable with vapid bullshit, and really it just shows they shouldn't talk to the people who "do". I think a better way of approaching the workforce and inspiring loyalty to the org, is to trust a deputy to read you into their particular program area so the high-level executive can come in and speak "to you" at an unexpected/encouraging moment. I've seen that done well, but not all hands messaging - ever.

(All blanket statements have exceptional circumstances where they should be disregarded.)

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by gorbachev on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:03AM (#39127930)
Could be worse. The people at the top could be spending their time planning organizational reshuffles.

Ask how I know.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by posguy on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:29PM (#39126192)
There is plenty of computing related stuff that Google doesn't do, has stopped doing or outsources nearly all of, whether it be ceasing to be a Domain Registrar, providing voice & texting services (Google Voice being just another Bandwidth.com frontend, Google Fi being an alternative onramp to the T-Mobile network, with identical roaming).

You mentioned social media, what social media happens on Google's platforms? Google Wave is long dead, Google Talk was broken so badly everyone I know stopped using it. Google Groups is a wasteland that just spams up Usenet, so everyone ignores it. Where is Google in action when it comes to social media?

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by paulddraper on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:10AM (#39126391)
> what social media

Little thing called "YouTube"

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:31PM (#39126203)
> what social media happens on Google's platforms?

youtube/youtube shorts have a lot "social media" going on

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by spartanatreyu on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:39PM (#39126254)
Youtube is currently full of attention-bait, rage-bait, spam, scams, and AI noise.

It takes work over months of time to find youtube channels with value and a few more months to vet their worth.

While it IS a social media network, the majority of user content on the website is low-value spam comments.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:50AM (#39127247)
> Youtube is currently full of attention-bait, rage-bait, spam, scams, and AI noise.

there is a chance youtube ML gives you recommendations based on your interests.. I find a lot of good quality content on youtube.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by spartanatreyu on Sunday January 28, 2024 @06:47PM (#39171131)
The problem is that one wrong video leads to a cascade of bad suggestions.

Opening one video that looks legit but is really AI noise leads to your recommendations filling with other AI noise.

Opening one video with a completely misrepresented title leads to your recommendations filling with attention-bait, rage-bait, etc...

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by riku_iki on Sunday January 28, 2024 @07:04PM (#39171263)
If I would be youtube ML engineer, I would use some engagement metric as a label in loss function: for example how many % of video you actually watched, not just fact that you clicked on it.
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by paulddraper on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:09PM (#39133626)
"Plenty of computing related stuff that Google doesn't do, for example all of this stuff that Google does or is involved in"
Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by neilv on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:47AM (#39126577)
I agree with your general idea. This particular example looks mixed to me.

> 1. Deliver the world's most advanced, safe, and responsible AI.

For a company with Google's resources, this could be a good mission.

> 2. Improve knowledge, learning, creativity, and productivity.

What?

> 3. Build the most helpful personal computing platforms and devices.

This could be a good mission, or a disposable platitude.

> 4. Enable organizations and developers to innovate on Google Cloud.

If they want to keep a cloud business, I guess they have to mention it in the goals, though this one sounds like they haven't given it any thought, and just cribbed some disposable copy out of sales materials at the last minute.

Maybe it's alluding to some innovation-enabling AI technology push (like focusing on meeting the demand for some kinds of AI compute capacity, through proprietary hardware and software)? Why not say that?

> 5. Provide the world's most trusted products and platforms.

If they wanted to make this a cornerstone, I'd say they have to be more specific. Does it mean making things work better? Respecting people's privacy and security in some way other than what they currently say they do? Start focusing on products and services in which canceling isn't an option, so people can depend on them?

> 6. Build a Google that's extraordinary for Googlers and the world.

Needs elaboration for what this means, and how they're going to do it.

> 7. Improve company velocity, efficiency, and productivity, and deliver durable cost savings.

They sure to have a lot of goals that would be tricky to solve for simultaneously, if these were all real top-level-ish goals.

More interesting would be if they said (off-the-cuff) "Our sole top-level goal is to deliver the world's most advanced, safe, and responsible AI. We actually really, really mean it. To that end, adtech is now a subgoal in support of short-term funding the AI goal, adtech will disappear in 4-8 years, and until then will be staffed at minimal sustaining level. Information services and devices are solely to provide data and user access points for the AI work. Cloud services are refocused on AI-based solutions. We don't need 70% of our current employees, and we need to replace some of that freed headcount with different kinds of thinking. And we need to get the remaining and new people to be motivated by the mission, despite 20 years of hiring and incentives that would naturally lead most to focus on career rather than mission."

Probably neither they nor any other huge company could pull off a serious goal focus like that, and they'd basically throw away a cash cow machine that could've been milked much longer. But it would still be interesting.

It's really an exercise in what it might mean to take stated corporate goals very, very seriously, rather than the default, which is a behemoth lumbering on pretty much as before, while some costs get cut, and people spin their metrics and reports a little differently.

Or try "Our sole top-level goal is to maintain adtech dominance and revenue, through..." That's not as big a mission change, and maybe you can get by with just nudging huge hierarchies of career-directed people with broad platitudes and KPIs&OKRs.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by sebastos on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:32AM (#39126835)
>More interesting would be if they said (off-the-cuff) "Our sole top-level goal is to deliver the world's most advanced, safe, and responsible AI. We actually really, really mean it. To that end, adtech is now a subgoal in support of short-term funding the AI goal, adtech will disappear in 4-8 years, and until then will be staffed at minimal sustaining level. Information services and devices are solely to provide data and user access points for the AI work. Cloud services are refocused on AI-based solutions. We don't need 70% of our current employees, and we need to replace some of that freed headcount with different kinds of thinking. And we need to get the remaining and new people to be motivated by the mission, despite 20 years of hiring and incentives that would naturally lead most to focus on career rather than mission."

>Probably neither they nor any other huge company could pull off a serious goal focus like that, and they'd basically throw away a cash cow machine that could've been milked much longer. But it would still be interesting.

Yeah, that's interesting, I had almost the same exact sequence of thoughts myself. If _I_ were running google, I'd probably be tempted to bet the farm on the AI aspect, just as you say. But at Google scale, there's an almost crippling responsibility to not kill the cash cow, since you're talking about throwing away hundreds of billions of dollars. If we're being honest, that would probably be a unilaterally bad idea for the health of the company.

Still, Google is so disassociated and somnambulant right now. There's got to be a lot of daylight between "complete, laser focus on AI" and what we're getting now. Evidently the current goal is "just keep durdling with whatever we seem to already be doing".

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by GrooveSAN on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:15AM (#39127060)
I don’t think those company goals should be looked at face value. What is interesting to watch is the dynamics (what was there last year and isn’t there anymore), read between the lines (what is not mentioned as a goal) and the ordering (what is left at the end, what is more important than what).

You can’t expect such an exercise to be treated with transparency (#5. Lay off 20% more of those guys) as there’s just too much to lose by doing so. On the other hand, those goals are subtle but clear enough for the top managers of the company to inspire themselves and define their own - more concrete - yearly ambitions.

And the lower you go in the org, the more concrete the goals (assuming there are any at all). No yearly goal is worse to me than unclear ones, as it gives red flags of management not giving a shit and cruising.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by tim333 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:00PM (#39133440)
>Those 7 goals that he gave the company are... nothing

Goal one is something - world's most advanced AI. There's an actual competition there with OpenAI which seems ahead a little.

The rest, yeah... it's all let's keep doing what we were doing.

Re:A Leaked Memo from Google CEO Sundar Pichai Comes Amidst ... by MyFedora on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:14AM (#39140888)
I don't get what's so hard to understand here. Vision and mission statements are sanity checks for employees to see whether they help move the company towards or away from the desired direction.

For example, if a company aims to develop and deliver affordable and innovative healthcare solutions that enhance the well-being of individuals worldwide, an employee may realize that whatever they're working is too expensive and therefore inaccessible to many people around the globe.

You may correctly point out that a concrete goal for how much a given solution can cost is preferable, but the statements cover that as well: Management derives operational goals from these statements. Since healthcare solutions must be affordable, management can commission research on what the average person can afford in a given field, and use that research to inform how much a solution can cost.

Values dictate the morale boundaries: Sure, our goal is to to develop and deliver affordable and innovative healthcare solutions that enhance the well-being of individuals worldwide, but don't use child labor to achieve that.