News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:30PM (#39120013)
I like Johnny Costa but always found Mr. Rogers himself creepy and never more so than when he was singing.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by wharvle on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:58PM (#39121246)
It might be the very-long takes without cuts (it’s nuts, he does the jacket-to-cardigan and oxfords-to-loafers getting-home routine and launches straight into his first segment all as one shot in at least most episodes, the craft and skill on display is really impressive) plus lots of looking straight at the camera, which are intended to avoid confusion (people aren’t born understanding the “language” of film editing) and make kids feel like he’s addressing them personally. Some folks find that kind of direct attention uncomfortable, and the avoidance of film/tv editing artifice might make it feel even more so.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by mandmandam on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:40PM (#39120176)
You found Mr. Rogers creepy?

... I guess that proves you can't please everyone.

Mr. Rogers is literally seen as the incarnation of wholesomeness, part of the holy secular trinity of positive male role models with Levar Burton and Bob Ross.

You might consider not casting aspersions based on absolutely nothing. If there were any allegations of creepiness they'd have come out by now, so like... Keep his name out yo mouth.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:51PM (#39120336)
Sorry, man, just my personal reaction. I'm with you on Levar Burton and Bob Ross though.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by jjulius on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:23PM (#39120788)
Have you ever considered learning about Mr. Rogers and what made him the way that he was? There's extensive documentation about how his childhood experiences basically shaped him into the person that he became. I'd wager it would perhaps alter your viewpoint a bit if you were to understand the "why" behind Fred.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by mlyle on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:23PM (#39122814)
I loved Fred Rogers as a kid, and I am still in awe of everything he did.

I can also understand how someone could find the direct, intense way he communicated with the camera uncomfortably intimate and offputting (even though it was an important part of his success). That's OK.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:51PM (#39121179)
Yeah, I've seen a few things and listened to the Fresh Air interview way back when.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by doublerabbit on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:11PM (#39120636)
There could be worse.. Jimmy Savile here in the UK. /shudders
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by esafak on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:52PM (#39124287)
Jim'll "fix" it!
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by waynesonfire on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:53PM (#39120380)
What kind of response did you think you were going to get?
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:49PM (#39121154)
I didn't have any expectation at all, just contributing my opinion. I value all the feedback I'm getting and totally willing to agree that he was a fine person and I'm an outlier. Doesn't change my gut reaction, though.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by turtlebits on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:10PM (#39123258)
The comment probably says more about you than Fred Rogers, but why post something irrelevant to the article?
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by ta8645 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:04PM (#39120546)
There's a difference between having a negative personal reaction, and sharing it publically. It's causing a public harm based on nothing other than some vague internal feeling. It's unproductive and irresponsible.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:46PM (#39123020)
What about publicly sharing positive personal reaction, is that okay? If you answer yes to that and no to the other then you've got a problem on your hands.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by ta8645 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:14PM (#39123931)
We'd have a problem on our hands if we all followed the admonishment to show more respect to people in public? To not besmirch someone, with no reason other than our own personal bias and prejudice?

You're worried about the world being too kind and positive? You shouldn't. There are enough people actually doing things worthy of scorn -- enough to wear out your keyboard -- without besmirching someone for the flimsiest of reasons.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by zwieback on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:04PM (#39124400)
I believe when talking about a fictional character different rules apply than when talking about a real person. Otherwise criticism of creative output would be considered rude.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by qwertthrowway on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:12PM (#39123279)
Theo problem is when you say bad things about someone that isn’t true it’s called slander and if it’s true then it’s backbiting. It’s not good in general to malign people or put a negative look on them without a good reason.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by aidenn0 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:29PM (#39124088)
The original comment said nothing about Fred Rogers. It was "I ... always found Mr. Rogers himself creepy"

Furthermore it induced a few interesting replies about his style of looking directly into the camera and long-takes, and parasocial relationships (to be fair, it also induced a single reply with someone implying that while Mr. Rogers probably isn't a pedophile, "better safe than sorry").

As an aside, I'm somewhat surprised nobody's mentioned the puppets yet; lots of people find puppets creepy.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by pimlottc on Thursday January 25, 2024 @09:19AM (#39129787)
> The original comment said nothing about Fred Rogers. It was "I ... always found Mr. Rogers himself creepy"

That’s pretty passive aggressive. Wouldn’t you be offended if someone said that about you? “I never said you were stupid, I just /think/ of you as stupid.”

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by aidenn0 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:14PM (#39136785)
Firstly, I can say that I definitely would not be offended, since people have said that about me, and I wasn't offended.

Secondly, we are talking about a performer while performing[1] Sharing personal reactions (both positive and negative) to public performances is, IMO, well within the bounds of polite discourse.

1: This is harder to distinguish when the actor's name is "Fred Rogers" and the role is "Mr. Rogers," but the original comment referred to "Mr. Rogers" rather than Fred Rogers and used the phrase "especially while singing," so I think it's a safe assumption here.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by cwillu on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:35PM (#39124136)
Sorry, are you really saying it's bad to communicate your feelings? On a thread about Mr Rogers?

I'm _deeply_ uncomfortable with eye contact, and find Mr Rogers to be deeply disturbing to watch. And being able to _talk_ about that without it being implied that it means either of us are bad people is an important lesson.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by ta8645 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:45PM (#39124222)
Nobody is telling you not to discuss your feelings, but there's a difference between taking adult responsibility by saying something like:

  "I was not emotionally equipped to watch Mr. Rogers; I had a very hard time dealing with the feelings that arose when I watched that show".
And shifting the responsibility to him, by implying that he was a creep of a person.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by dylan604 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:02PM (#39120522)
To me, any adult that was that friendly towards kids probably had a panel van. It definitely comes across with that vibe to me. It's a very fine line, and better safe than sorry. I can get the ick vibe and make decisions on that without making any possibly incorrect disparaging remarks about someone. It's just the internal alarms do go off when grown men are attracted to children that are not their own. Yes, I'm painting with a very broad brush, but again safe than sorry.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by lupire on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:23PM (#39122812)
Avoiding human friendship is a large cause of the division and unsafety in our modern world.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by sbuttgereit on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:18PM (#39122767)
Your position sounds like the result of too much media consumption and giving the media, the press, and activists far more credence than they really deserve.

Are there bad guys in the world? Yes. But not nearly so many nor as brazen as everyone wanting to yell their story in your ear would have you believe.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by jjulius on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:27PM (#39120854)
>... any adult that was that friendly towards kids...

Treating children as people with basic love and respect is all that he asked for, and all that he demonstrated.

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by klyrs on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:46PM (#39121100)
You say "adult" and then later "grown men." Which is the actual problem?

Also, in what way did Fred Rogers demonstrate "attraction" to children?

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by toast0 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:28PM (#39122241)
I mean, I also found him creepy, so I don't think zwieback is that unusual.

Like who is this guy who always wanted to have a neighbor just like me. and always wanted to live in a neighborhood with me. And with all the eye contact, it doesn't feel like a hypothetical you, it feels like me. Stranger danger signs.

I mean, watch this episode[1], and tell me that opening monologue doesn't feel creepy?

When I was young, this show felt a lot different than some of other shows in terms of speaking to the audience directly so much. Plus, it didn't have a cool pinball animation, I'd rather watch Sesame Street and learn my numbers, thanks ;)

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yujaPRM1PQo

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by lupire on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:21PM (#39122796)
It's not for everyone. Mr Rogers was for children who needed attention from a caring adult but didn't have it. He was the original parasocial relationship, but he was relentlessly focused on making it a healthy and rewarding experience for children who had the television as a babysitter.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by gjvc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:21PM (#39125503)
for children who had the television as a babysitter

and that's the difference, as I think he explains in his statement to the Senate Subcommitte on Communications in 1969

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA

Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by timschmidt on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:54PM (#39122515)
Statistically, strangers were never the danger they were presented as. Most terrible things which happen to children happen at the hands of friends or family.
Re:Mr. Rogers' Music Was Intricate (2020) [video] by aklemm on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:01PM (#39125780)
Mister Rogers exhibits the most radical interpersonal philosophy I've ever witnessed: he mastered taking everyone for who they are.

It's the most profound kindness I've ever seen practiced as a way of being.

So, yeah, it's a little uncomfortable.