News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by ksec on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:21AM (#39066492)
I seriously seriously doubt the UK government has anything to do with Google's investment decision. But I do wonder why UK. Post Brexit every one was expecting Finance and Tech will all moved to Germany or the Netherland. This hasn't happened.

Despite all the noise most company have stayed where they are. And in many cases they even invested more in UK.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by SilverBirch on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:27AM (#39066995)
The problem with debating anything to do with Brexit is the promises that were made to win the vote were, by and large, total lies. There was an argument that we didn't have control of immigration because of the freedom of movement, a big part of that was an insistence that the immigration rate was unsustainable. Post brexit immigration has massively increased. So sure, the predictions about all the negative effects of clamping down on immigration were wrong. But that's because we didn't.

Similarly, the arguments about companies leaving the UK were based on the premise that UK regulation would diverge from EU regulation. But it hasn't.

In a few cases where real regulatory hurdles exist the UK has lost out. I worked for a company that started up an Amsterdam office directly because they needed to be within the EU, and that has genuinely drawn talent away from the UK to the EU. B

So far I think the biggest impact of Brexit has actually been state sector not private - suddenly the UK had to replicate the entirity of EU shared beauracracy. So now for example, we have to independently evaluate all drug approvals in what is basically a pointless waste of time replicating something the EU already did.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by graemep on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:35AM (#39067032)
> Similarly, the arguments about companies leaving the UK were based on the premise that UK regulation would diverge from EU regulation. But it hasn't.

The Treasury forecast shortly before the referendum predicted a huge drop in investment, leading to a severe recession, starting as soon as there was a vote in favour of Brexit, before it even happened.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by hnhg on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:46AM (#39067108)
Also, there have been a shortage of good outcomes attributable to Brexit. Go through the headlines here, for example (although you the FT could be biased, I have no idea): https://www.ft.com/brexit
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by concordDance on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:23AM (#39067336)
In general headlines are not a place you find good outcomes. It's an unfortunate fact that bad news sells and there are a lot of different aspects one can focus on and measure.

Disclaimer: I have no idea on the net effects of Brexit.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by barrkel on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:59AM (#39066783)
I didn't expect tech to significantly leave London unless it became a lot harder to hire foreigners in the UK, and as far as I know it hasn't - non-EU immigration has increased hugely since Brexit. Unlike e.g. food or manufactured goods, software and related services don't have tight regulatory borders and the services are generally sold globally, not into discrete markets.

Finance is deflating like a slow puncture. There's fewer listings in London[1]. Open positions[2] is another early indicator. I believe the US is generally a bigger beneficiary than any EU competitor city. There is no emerging EU alternative to London, instead other cities are consolidating in specific verticals. It's a bit tricky to split out finance industry trends from the broader economy of course.

[1] https://www.standard.co.uk/business/peel-hunt-london-listing...

[2] https://www.efinancialcareers.ch/en/news/2024/01/brexit-bank...

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gambiting on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:01AM (#39067208)
>>and as far as I know it hasn't

>>non-EU immigration has increased hugely since Brexit.

Both things can be true at the same time.

If you run a British business it has become vastly more difficult to hire someone from the EU(where there is a lot of high skilled talent, especially in IT). Before Brexit if you found a candidate say in Spain, they could start working for you the next day, with the same paperwork as any British employee. Now if you wanted to hire the same candidate the hoops to go through to get them a visa are crazy and it takes minimum of 2-3 months to sort it out, not to mention the extra cost.

But since now the expense and effort for hiring EU candidates is roughly the same as hiring non-EU ones, is that really a surprise non-EU immigration has increased? Not to mention that EU candidates don't want to move to UK, and who could blame them - why accept a job on a 2 year visa that gives you and your family zero stability, when similarly paid jobs are available within the EU. And again - if you were going to bother with the whole visa nonsense why not go straight for US and get a much higher salary for the same job.

Just my 2c as an immigrant to UK.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by ProxCoques on Sunday January 21, 2024 @03:46PM (#39082868)
I seem to have noticed engineering teams I deal with having a bigger proportion of people from the Indian subcontinent now. Before Brexit there always seemed to be a couple of Polish, Hungarian, Spanish or Italian people in there, but they seem a lot rarer now for sure.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by kmlx on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:15AM (#39066896)
> Finance is deflating like a slow puncture.

i think that’s just a snapshot of the current economic situation around the world, not a long term trend:

https://www.morganmckinley.com/uk/article/london-employment-...

charts 15 and 16:

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/64ad6d32fe36e...

this has a bunch if interesting stats:

https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN06...

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by blibble on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:13AM (#39066881)
> It's a bit tricky to split out finance industry trends from the broader economy of course.

that didn't stop you from trying though

"79% fewer job listings" is not the same thing as "79% fewer jobs"

yes, fewer people hiring at the moment because the cheap money has dried up

none of this is specific to the UK

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by barrkel on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:26AM (#39067363)
I'm not sure how I could have been more clear than explicitly saying "open positions".
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gardenhedge on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:32AM (#39067017)
The obvious alternative to London is Dublin which is HQ for a lot of tech companies already - so maybe it doesn't fall under 'emerging'
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by barrkel on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:31AM (#39067405)
The alternatives to London are Paris (the closest competition as a city qua city), Frankfurt, Amsterdam and Dublin, and I believe they specialize differently.

When I buy EUR-denominated ETFs, they're almost invariably listed in Dublin with IE ISINs. Euronext stock exchange, the largest stock exchange in the EU, is in Amsterdam (domiciled - it's got multiple market places). For financial services, Frankfurt just overtook Paris[1] but they're pretty close.

[1] https://www.euronews.com/business/2023/10/21/europes-top-fin...

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by modernpink on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:47AM (#39067117)
London's population is almost double all of Ireland. Dublin is not an alternative at all. The annual production of new STEM graduates in the UK is half the population of Dublin alone.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by mrtksn on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:09AM (#39067259)
Google has many datacenters in Europe and I'm actually surprised they don't have one in UK yet.

Take a look: https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/

Brexit or not, these things are sensitive to distance and infrastructure availability. There are certain hotspots, for example Egypt is one. Maybe the next one will be in Cairo, Istanbul or Sofia.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by blibble on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:26AM (#39067364)
there is a London region in GCP, but presumably that's just a floor in someone else's data centre
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by jdietrich on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:53AM (#39067156)
One: London has an exceptionally high density of connectivity, with fast, low-latency connections across most of the western hemisphere. It's easy to recruit a lot of good technical staff at comparatively low cost. Power isn't particularly cheap, but it's relatively low-carbon and is moving quickly towards net-zero.

Two: The British government is desperate to cultivate the appearance of a thriving high-tech, high-growth economy and is willing to offer very generous terms for inbound investment. The current Prime Minister Rishi Sunak fancies himself as something of a tech bro and is eager to grow the British tech sector, even if that involves a lot of flexibility on things like tax and regulatory compliance. A large faction within the governing Conservative Party are keen to reposition the UK along the lines of Singapore or Hong Kong, acting as a low-tax, low-regulation bridge between larger international markets; there's a lot of movement in that direction that isn't particularly transparent.

Ireland used to be the benchmark in that respect, but it has become a more difficult environment due to persistent intervention by the EU and domestic discontent. Britain's post-brexit position as EU-adjacent imposes a lot of costs on SMEs, but it's attractive if you have the legal and lobbying resources to creatively navigate the ambiguity and uncertainty of that position.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by bananapub on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:21AM (#39066946)
> But I do wonder why UK.

eh? because there are lots of customers there, including rich businesses who want to pay for cloud hosting in the UK legal jurisdiction with low latency.

Google already has datacentres in neighbouring countries - Ireland, Belgium, Netherlands, Finland, etc - and already has a cloud region in the UK so it's not very surprising to do some infill.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gumballindie on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:31AM (#39066551)
If you look into the job market a lot have moved to the Netherlands. The UK is gradually becoming irrelevant. A 1 bil $ investment is negligible in the grand scheme of things. If you spoke with people in finance then you’ll learn things are bad. Really bad.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by blibble on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:01AM (#39066798)
in terms of employment: more people are employed in UK financial services than before brexit

https://www.standard.co.uk/business/city-jobs-boom-brexit-ex...

the simple fact is most of these jobs serve the domestic market and were never at risk

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:38AM (#39066603)
Netherlands which has an acute housing shortage? And not just in Amsterdam.

Maybe not the best idea to crowd the Eu's tech sector in an already crowded county. Why not a country with more free space, like France?

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by azalemeth on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:57AM (#39066756)
The OP is right – at least according to Ernst and Young [1], who wrote in 2022 that:

> Since the UK’s EU referendum, 44% (97 out of 222) of the largest UK financial services firms have announced plans to move some UK operations and/or staff to the EU – a figure that nearly doubled between March 2017 (53 out of 222, 24%) and March 2021 (95 out of 222, 43%)

> Since the referendum, 24 firms have publicly declared they will transfer just over £1.3trn of UK assets to the EU – a figure which has remained broadly flat over the past 18 months

> In the last quarter [i.e. Q1 2022], the number of Brexit-related staff relocations to the EU has been further revised down, from 7,400 in December 2021 to just over 7,000 as March 2022 closes – significantly down from the peak of 12,500 announced in 2016

> While many worst-case-scenario contingency plans have not been enacted, EY anticipates ongoing operational and staff moves from financial services firms across Europe as Brexit increasingly becomes part of a broader conversation about strategic business drivers and operating models

There has been no post-Brexit boom in financial services [2], with a variety of "business friendly deregulation" changes either "yet to be implemented" [as of Dec 2023] and with "none so far having a substantial impact".

[1] https://www.ey.com/en_uk/news/2022/03/ey-financial-services-...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/post-brexit-big-bang-reform...

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by blibble on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:06AM (#39066827)
> The OP is right – at least according to Ernst and Young [1], who wrote in 2022 that:

> Since the UK’s EU referendum, 44% (97 out of 222) of the largest UK financial services firms have announced plans to move some UK operations and/or staff to the EU – a figure that nearly doubled between March 2017 (53 out of 222, 24%) and March 2021 (95 out of 222, 43%)

> In the last quarter [i.e. Q1 2022], the number of Brexit-related staff relocations to the EU has been further revised down, from 7,400 in December 2021 to just over 7,000 as March 2022 closes – significantly down from the peak of 12,500 announced in 2016

the number of people employed in UK FS is 2.2 million, so that's 0.3%

for comparison: last year 87,000 new UK jobs were added

structually most of these 2.2 million serve the UK domestic market and were never at risk of going to the EU

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by kmlx on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:04AM (#39066817)
> In the last quarter [i.e. Q1 2022], the number of Brexit-related staff relocations to the EU has been further revised down, from 7,400 in December 2021 to just over 7,000 as March 2022 closes – significantly down from the peak of 12,500 announced in 2016

it’s interesting that there was no mass relocation of jobs out of London:

https://www.morganmckinley.com/uk/article/london-employment-...

https://www.statista.com/statistics/385366/uk-finance-insura...

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by adhesive_wombat on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:01AM (#39066794)
There's a fairly large advanced hi-tech industry hub in the Netherlands. Philips and ASML are big names, but there are very many more. As they're all fairly near each other on the scale of things (often near Eindhoven, with more "non-physical" tech in Amsterdam), there's some Silicon Valley-style network effects at play.

Also French labour laws and norms are probably frightening to union-phobic Big Tech companies.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:18AM (#39066920)
Philips is irelevant in tech today other than medical devices. All they make today is rebadging Chinese white goods.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by adhesive_wombat on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:30AM (#39067393)
Plenty of things that used to be Philips are still in Eindhoven, like NXP (semiconductors) and Signify (lighting, including Hue). Philips has been a huge part of what made the Eindhoven area a high-tech industry hub, even if much of it is under new ownership structures.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:15AM (#39067727)
Yes, in the past. That's what I said Philips is irelevant today. You're not contradicting me.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by adhesive_wombat on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:00AM (#39068185)
It's not irrelevant to why Eindhoven is how it is today, in the same way that HP is a split-up shadow of what is former influential self, but it's partly why Google now is in Silicon Valley.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:49AM (#39068735)
Just because it was relevant in the past doesn't mean it's also somehow relevant today if it stopped innovating, and it has. Glorious history doesn't pay your bills or increase your stock.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by phil21 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:09AM (#39066854)
> Why not a country with more free space, like France?

I can't speak for everyone, but in my case it's laws, regulation, and general friendliness to business enterprises that bring income to the country.

Amsterdam is likely also the best connected area in Europe, the European equivalent of Ashburn, VA.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:16AM (#39066912)
>Amsterdam is likely also the best connected area in Europe, the European equivalent of Ashburn, VA.

Best connected to what exactly? If you ask most people, Vienna is a lot better connected with the rest of europe. Amsterdam is at an edge of the continent.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by phil21 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:20AM (#39066935)
Fair. I am US-centric, so I care most about trans-Atlantic access. From a peering standpoint we still do more traffic out of Amsterdam than Vienna by quite a far margin.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by FirmwareBurner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:53AM (#39067154)
But then Ireland is even closer to the US than Netherlands.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by candiodari on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:32AM (#39067411)
Not to the internet: https://www.submarinecablemap.com/

Ireland is a satellite, not a hub. The bulk of traffic goes to UK landing stations, then to London.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gumballindie on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:03AM (#39066813)
I am not the decision maker, unfortunately. The UK is on track to solving the cost of housing, by tanking the economy, but people still won't afford said housing since they won't afford the mortgages. Hope the NL finds a better way to solve its issues.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by eastbound on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:59AM (#39066780)
Please stop using France as a trashbin. We already bulldoze enough agricultural land every year and make life impossible for farmers (wtf are we doing with our own food producers in an age of ecology), if we want to remain sustainable, we should not stay as overpopulated as we already are and we should not overexploit our resources. What do you expect, “just build 56 more nucular reactors”?

If anything, we should decrease in population.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by petesergeant on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:39AM (#39067052)
> The UK is gradually becoming irrelevant

I don’t think this is supported by the facts, as much as Brexit was a dumb idea.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by ben_w on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:44AM (#39067500)
I'm umming and erring on this one — "irrelevant" feels much too strong (even NK isn't "irrelevant"), but OTOH "becoming" implies a direction of travel rather than a state, and every impression I have is that the UK doesn't matter as much as it used to.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by petesergeant on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:41AM (#39067981)
This has been true since the early 1900s, so one’d need to show a markèd increase in the rate of derelervance
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by ben_w on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:42AM (#39068661)
Yeah, that's fair.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by tucnak on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:23AM (#39066963)
Wow, FUD again on Hacker News! So impressive. Colour me surprised.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by password54321 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:38AM (#39067458)
We just invested £2.5b into Ukraine, all while following the lead of the US into Israel and Yemen and trying to make deportation deals with Rwanda. All while we watch the news on Japan and India building (rather than destroying) and landing rovers on the moon for the first time.

Remember when the UK looked down on India? Now it even relies heavily on hiring people from there.

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gumballindie on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:41AM (#39067978)
Whoa. What’s so bad about “hiring people from there”? Now that east european skills have left it takes two to three locals to get the same job done, if they even figure out how. Have to bring people with expertise from somewhere. Only issue is that Indians are visa bound and underpaid, unlike east europeans that companies competed for and drove wages up - contrary to what the clay of the land thought.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by password54321 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:09AM (#39068280)
You highlight a problem with talking about politics online. It seems very easy for people to become emotional with responses like "Whoa. What’s so bad about “hiring people from there”?" and assume a comment is racist rather than assuming the best intentions.

My intention was to highlight how the dynamics between other countries have changed and how the UK seems less independent and less interested in progress all while spending money on war (while aimlessly following the US).

Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by gumballindie on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:11AM (#39068300)
My apologies - it was a knee jerk reaction on my part. I am sorry.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by dtornabene on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:33PM (#39074554)
you have not in anyway cleared up why "hiring people from there" is somehow a bad thing, which, yes, is a deeply racist attitude.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by password54321 on Sunday January 21, 2024 @07:51AM (#39077993)
Seems like the other commenter was smart enough to understand, if you aren't, that is your problem.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by tptacek on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:15PM (#39071812)
"Deportation deals with Rwanda"?
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by likpok on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:28PM (#39072540)
The UK is redirecting a number of asylum seekers to Rwanda rather than letting them settle locally.
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by tptacek on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:29PM (#39072555)
Ah. Thanks!
Re:Google to invest $1B in UK data centre by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:36AM (#39067445)
I feel like your post is a strawman. First, tons of especially finance jobs have left the UK. I don't think anyone ever thought "all" the jobs, or even a majority of them, would leave, especially when it's obvious huge banks can't just pack up overnight (or even in many years), but there is an undeniable deflation of finance activity. One reference: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/mar/29/brexit-fina...

And I never read anything that had people predicting tech would leave en mass. It generally seems like a mixed bag, with tech being relatively strong, but especially not reaping anywhere near the original promised benefits of Brexiteers: https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/02/01/brexit-3-years-on-t...