News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by Aloha on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:30AM (#39043789)
Speaking in general terms, not to the specifics of Hans Reiser's crimes - I dont see why it wouldn't allow for redemption, people do stupid things and get blinded easily.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by masklinn on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:44AM (#39044004)
There’s “Stupid thing”.

And then there’s murdering your ex, hiding her body over two days, lying to your children that she’d left for russia and they’d been abandoned, and only revealing the location of the body so you could plea down to second degree murder (a good 18 months later mind, we’re not talking quick change of heart).

Oh and then filing a civil suit against pretty much the entire legal system, including the trial judges and your attorney.

And when sued for damage by your children’s grandmother (on their behalf) assert that you killed your ex to protect your kids (which you had basically never been there for, which was the entire reason your wife left you).

I’m not saying redemption is not possible, but I’d think some reflection and atonement would be the baseline, and I’m not aware of Hans Reiser having done any such work.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by dlandau on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:08PM (#39044341)
That he still wrote "in prison for killing my wife Nina" when she wasn't his wife anymore at the time indicates IMO that he still doesn't get it.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by 0x457 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:03PM (#39045126)
Legally speaking, she was, since the divorce wasn't finalized.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by jacquesm on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:23PM (#39045464)
I don't think that matters much. To all practical intents and purposes she was no longer 'his wife' and given that he killed her the fact that the divorce was never finalized shouldn't give him extra rights.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by 0x457 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:52PM (#39045948)
How is he supposed to refer to her? ex-wife is incorrect. By name doesn't provide enough context for people that don't know about him.

The fact is - he killed his wife.

> To all practical intents and purposes she was no longer 'his wife'

It doesn't work like that, though. My soon-to-be-ex-wife is still listed as spouse on our health insurance because I can't remove her until the divorce is finalized. I still have to specify her in many legals documents as my wife.

Even outside the legal field, many in my personal life consider her as my wife, go "call me when it's finalized".

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by jacquesm on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:00PM (#39046061)
That's besides the point, the question is whether you still think of her and refer to her as 'your wife'. And then extrapolate to the - obviously hypothetical - situation in which you murdered your soon-to-be-ex-wife and still refer to her as 'my wife' many years later. It's bizarre that this needs to be spelled out. This isn't a legal issue, it's a bit of insight in how Reiser feels about the person he murdered.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by 0x457 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:56PM (#39046768)
Well, in my mind, he is referring to the state at the point of murder. The fact that they were going through the divorce process isn't important here (to us bystanders, to the investigator it's a motive).

I think this is just bs for his next parole hearing tho.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by bombcar on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:11PM (#39046195)
I'd say that saying "my wife" makes it worse for him than saying "my ex-wife", maybe that's just me.

Doubly so because she's, you know, dead.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by jacquesm on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:16PM (#39046265)
That's how I read it as well.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by foxyv on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:38AM (#39043915)
Redemption requires that a person change and provide restitution. What Reiser did wasn't a stupid mistake, it was a calculated action that he took. His only mistake was getting caught. He didn't accidentally kill someone, or do so in the heat of a unique moment in his life. He decided that he could make his life easier by killing someone else and did so with no intention of facing the consequences of his actions.

While I won't say redemption is impossible. He is going to have to serve his time and dedicate the rest of his life to helping others to even come close.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hollerith on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:40AM (#39043951)
Since the prosecutor's office offered him a sentence of 3 years if he'd lead investigators to where he buried the body, the burden is on you IMHO to support your assertion because obviously if the informed professionals in the prosecutor's office thought it was a pre-planned murder they wouldn't've been that lenient. (In the US, pre-planned murders are routinely punished by life in prison without parole; California might be a little more lenient than the rest of the country, but not that much more lenient.)
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by masklinn on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:48AM (#39044058)
What sentence of 3 years are you talking about? The judge offered (and prosecutors agreed to) a plea guilty of second-degree murder (down from the first degree murder he was convicted of) if he revealed the location of the body and gave closure to her Nina’s children and family.

He got 15 to life, the maximum for second-degree murder, and his first request for parole was rejected so he’s doing at least 20 for now.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hollerith on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:00PM (#39044237)
What you describe happened after the trial. The offer of 3 years happened before the trial:

>An Alameda County Superior Court judge confirmed today Hans Reiser was presented a deal last year in which the convicted murderer would have only served three years in prison. During what was supposed to have been Reiser’s sentencing hearing – which has been delayed due to this week’s events – Judge Larry Goodman, in an effort to clear up what he called inaccuracies in the media, said that Reiser was given the opportunity last September to plead guilty to voluntary manslaughter. While voluntary manslaughter can carry different prison terms, Goodman said he agreed to give Reiser three years – the lowest possible term – to spare Nina Reiser’s family the turmoil of going through a trial and having the couple’s oldest son testify. Goodman pointed out in court if Reiser had accepted the deal, he would have been released in May 2008. However, Goodman said Reiser chose to “roll the dice,” and a jury convicted Reiser April 28 of first-degree murder in the killing of his wife.

https://www.mercurynews.com/2008/07/09/reiser-rejected-volun...

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by andai on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:07PM (#39045191)
Remarkable. Would it really have been 3 years if he'd accepted? That seems far too low.

On the other hand, the first degree homicide seems absurd given the evidence. Did they just give him that because he refused to cooperate, and not because it was actually an accurate verdict?

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by bombcar on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:13PM (#39046217)
Everything I've seen indicates that the "court" seemed to think it was a case of "murder in red blood" or whatever they call getting angry and killing your wife these days, with a dose of "very intentional coverup afterwards".

Had he driven the car with her dead body directly to the police, he probably would have received the three year sentence or even less.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by jacquesm on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:21PM (#39046322)
More has come out since the trial (and mostly on account of Reiser himself making very hard to walk back claims on the record in another court case).
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by bombcar on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:12PM (#39046982)
Not saying they were right, but that's likely what they were feeling (and maybe even the family was pushing for - they clearly knew she was dead, and just wanted the children out of the whole thing).
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by account42 on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:47AM (#39053958)
Did more come out or did Reiser make up claims that he though would help his case? That would make him an idiot but doesn't really give any real evidence towards the murder being pre-meditated considring all his other bad decisions in court.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by etc-hosts on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:09AM (#39087411)
> Would it really have been 3 years if he'd accepted? That seems far too low.

The prosecution offered the deal because historically convicting someone of murder when you can't find the body is nearly impossible. But Hans found a way!

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by themerone on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:38AM (#39043903)
Drunk driving is a stupid thing people do. Murder is an act of evil.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by auntienomen on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:01PM (#39044241)
Drunk driving is worse than stupid. It's up there with shooting a gun into someone's house.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by TomK32 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:50AM (#39044092)
I don't understand and can't accept why crimes committed while drunk get you a lesser punishment than a crime committed while sober.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:11PM (#39044376)
"Impaired judgement". I'm not supporting it, just stating that's the claim.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shadowgovt on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:31PM (#39044675)
So, this is a reasonable thing to be confused and frustrated about. It's worth remembering that the underlying philosophy of justice, crime, and punishment isn't actually something a society agrees upon. Ask five different people a question about the law, the courts, or the prisons and you'll get five different answers. And the system we get out of that is a hodgepodge of extremely path dependent features based upon who was in control of what levers of power at the time a given law was passed or a given punishment decided to be cruel and unusual (or not).

Broadly speaking, there are two independent axes the judicial system is trying to satisfy:

- punitive punishment. There are some actions that cannot be undone and some catastrophes for which there is no "making whole" the victim. Our system factors in a certain amount of eye for an eye retribution in these cases that dates all the way back to Hammurabi. If you're looking for a justification based on societal structure and survival and not just "vibes" (and make no mistake, there's a huge amount of just vibes in the way law, crime, and punishment come about)... It is believed a general understanding amongst the people that committing irrevocable transgressions on their neighbors will cause society to inflict transgressions upon them keeps the society from degenerating into infliction of individual violence on each other in the common case. Does it work? Depends on who you ask. But that's the idea, at least from the Machiavellian "stable society" standpoint. In that context, it doesn't matter if Reiser completely overhauls his philosophy of life in jail; he took something that he cannot give back, he took something no one can give back, and a certain amount of punishment is necessary to inform everyone else this is not acceptable ("thus always to the enemies of the country," etc).

- rehabilitation and rebuilding of trust. We humans broadly speaking divide other humans into two categories: those who would never and those who would. Certain transgressions bump a person from the would-never into the would category, and that opens a fissure that can never be closed. The fissure can be diminished by the transgressor demonstrating that they understand why that's unacceptable and providing reasons for the public to believe they will never commit that transgression a second time. Under this theory, crime commission is contextual; if a person can demonstrate that they will never be in the context again that would cause them to commit the crime, a certain amount of trust can be reestablished.

And here we get to the question of why drunk driving is treated less severely than, say, premeditated murder. As an individual, it's very hard to guard against premeditated murder. And people premeditating murder look like everybody else; It's hard to generate signifiers that would rebuild trust if somebody does such a thing. So the state has a large interest in discouraging it via "the olde ways," because the state has a hard time detecting it coming or defending the victims. In contrast, crimes committed under the influence of mind-alterers we generally feel would be something the transgressor would not do if the influence were removed. It's a lot easier to reestablish the trust gap in theory if somebody who drives drunk swears they will never drink again.

... That having been said, in practice, I totally agree with you. I think the numbers on drunk driving recidivism are ridiculous and it is completely unacceptable to maintain the status quo trust model on this issue; drunk driving should be an immediate revocation of the ability to use a licensed vehicle for life without extraordinary circumstances (on the order of pardon from the governor) to allow someone to retest for a license. We treat pilot licenses thusly; we should treat vehicle licenses with similar scrutiny.

... Problem is, in the US at least, we've built a society so heavily dependent upon cars in most of the country that doing this in the general case would be a sentence worse than the location constraints we put on sex offenders, and there's an upper limit on the state's capacity to actually enforce a law.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by bombcar on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:30PM (#39046429)
Someone once said that society forms laws and such mainly to prevent vigilantism, and not really for much else. The remainder is post-facto argumentation about how it was "ok" to do so.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by capr on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:35AM (#39066574)
This. The state only cares about maintaining order in order for itself to survive. Justice is a concern only insofar as it contributes to that goal. You can see this most blatantly in rape cases where the victim is better off not reporting the rape at all than going through the justice system to get restitution.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by xp84 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:01PM (#39071040)
This is a very thoughtful and insightful post. This is what makes HN a really enjoyable place. Thanks for spending your time on writing things like this, and if you have a blog or something, I’d enjoy reading it!
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hobs on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:13PM (#39044410)
tl;dr https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/mens_rea If you don't want to accept it, that's more on you, refusing to understand it is weird though.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by kwhitefoot on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:46PM (#39044870)
Recklessly drinking when you know you are going to drive immediately afterwards means that there is mens rea. Perhaps not for murder but certainly for deliberately increasing the risk of harm to an innocent party.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by HideousKojima on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:01PM (#39045102)
Which is why killing someone while driving drunk is treated more harshly than killing someone because you got distracted by something on the side of the road. Another example of mens rea.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by efitz on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:23PM (#39047129)
Because our justice system believes intent is an element of criminality, not just effect.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by frenchyatwork on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:28PM (#39047213)
> I don't understand and can't accept why crimes committed while drunk get you a lesser punishment than a crime committed while sober.

Where I'm from, most people who kill other people while driving get off without any punishment at all.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by EasyMark on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:56PM (#39051075)
and if either happened to kill someone, the person would likely receive a similar sentence for manslaughter.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by qingcharles on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:05AM (#39065141)
Except for drunk driving which specifically requires evidence of inebriation, other crimes committed while drunk or drugged are very rarely treated differently any longer.

It was true in the past that it could be used as a defense, but juries and judges no longer buy it and it generally won't get you anywhere at all in 2024.

Source: I play a lawyer on TV.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by pcthrowaway on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:26AM (#39067365)
> Except for drunk driving which specifically requires evidence of inebriation, other crimes committed while drunk or drugged are very rarely treated differently any longer

Well I would hope drunk driving while drunk would be treated differently than drunk driving while sober.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:40AM (#39043947)
Only if you believe in evil.

I'm not christian so I don't see the world like that.

He killed his s/o, like what 15 years ago now?

People change and deserves a second chance.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by nulld3v on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:58AM (#39044198)
What do you mean by "I don't believe in evil"?

I think many people can agree that inherently "evil" people are very very rare. Usually people who commit an "evil" act have a reason or justification. It's portrayed in literally every movie with an antihero and spawned the "villain origin story" meme.

But even if they have a reason/justification, that does not make the antihero or villain any less evil.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:57AM (#39055477)
> What do you mean by "I don't believe in evil"?

I mean that the popular idea of evil is a childs story and should not blur our reasoning.

One can consider an act "evil", but if you saw the other side of the coin, perhaps it was done out of necessity, revenge, fear or another "non-evil" reason.

(I am not trying to rationalize away horrible deeds).

I believe in selfishness tho. That's a real thing.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by masklinn on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:50AM (#39044098)
Has Hans Reiser changed and does he deserve a second chance?

His first parole board certainly didn’t think so and decided to keep him in for 5 more years.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by themerone on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:50AM (#39044091)
Evil is not a religious concept.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:57AM (#39044185)
Dude. Good & evil is such a central concept in Christianity it is practically ingrained in your society if you live in a christian country even if you are secular.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by lupusreal on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:22PM (#39044529)
Christianity also features the premise of marriage, so does that mean no secular conception of marriage can exist? Most people think otherwise.

Christianity doesn't own "good and evil", even though it features it, and nor are these premises even owned by religion generally.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by skissane on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:41PM (#39044812)
The English words for good and evil are pre-Christian in origin. So are their cognates in other European languages. Greek philosophers were debating “good and evil” centuries before Jesus of Nazareth was born. So there is nothing inherently Christian about those words, or the concepts they describe.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:51AM (#39055405)
You are correct, but you are also ignoring the fact that we are no longer living in ancient greek time.

I did not claim that Christianity invented good & evil. I claimed that it is a central concept in Christianity.

Your way of reasoning here is often referred to as a straw mans argument.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by skissane on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:17PM (#39059752)
> You are correct, but you are also ignoring the fact that we are no longer living in ancient greek time.

Even today, people still read and are influenced by Plato and Aristotle.

> I did not claim that Christianity invented good & evil. I claimed that it is a central concept in Christianity.

You claimed you don’t believe in evil because you are not a Christian. Not being a Christian and not believing in evil have little connection with each other, given billions of non-Christians believe in evil.

> Your way of reasoning here is often referred to as a straw mans argument.

You argument was too unclear to strawman.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @05:54AM (#39066352)
In my part of the world, christianity has dominated for 1000+ years. There are no influences from eastern religion or Plato or whatever. I suspect the same is true in your part of the world.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by Tainnor on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:38AM (#39067046)
Christian theology is heavily influenced by Plato and especially Aristotle, so what you wrote is self-contradictory.

I don't know where you live but it's almost impossible to overstate the significance of Plato on Western thought.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by selimthegrim on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:19AM (#39066927)
You do realize there was a great deal of Ancient Greek influence on Christianity?
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by anthk on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:00PM (#39046054)
Goodness and evilness predates Christianity by millenia. Read about Mesopotamian religions, or the Hindic ones.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:54AM (#39055440)
It's not relevant since those religions are no longer practiced.

Christianity is, and is still influencing our world, like I wrote above.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by anthk on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:50AM (#39056137)
Hinduism it's pretty much alive, and Christianity it's just a fork of Judaism.

When Cristianity didn't even exist, the Chinese already had a good chunk of philosophy perfectly set and written, and even modernish rules for war and diplomacy: Tao Te King, and The Art of War.

Heck, America from Canada to the Patagonia didn't even know about Jesus until the Europeans arrived 1500 years later. 1500s damn years. For a huge continent mass spread over from almost the North Pole to the South pole.

So much for an 'Universal' God. So universal that Aquinas had to rip a good chunk of Greek philosophy to adapt (more like smash it down with nails and duct tape) ancient Middle East fairy tales into the less-desert bound Europe as the modern Christian canonical sources.

If any, the Western world is shaped by the Roman architecture and law, and the Greek worldview, mindset and math.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:47AM (#39056820)
>> It's not relevant since those religions are no longer practiced. >> Christianity is, and is still influencing our world, like I wrote above.

> Hinduism it's pretty much alive, and Christianity it's just a fork of Judaism

Okay, so you're a hindu or a jew.

Are you arguing my point about christianity influencing "our" world? I guess I expressed myself rather western-centric.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by anthk on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:46PM (#39058519)
I am not neither a hindu or jew. Christianism in Europe is larguely cultural, our values shifted a lot since the Enlightenment times. The US, not much, they have a large sense of prudeness which affected even policitically left leaned people.

I mean, here people it's Christian by name only. Technically, even the Southern Spain with infamous street parades with large walks carrying a big structure with a Virgin, most of that it's just a showoff and a way to say "look how loaded we are, so much that we can build great golden clothes for our Virgin".

If any, lots of lore in Europe it's just paganism with a Christian disguise.

Even Christianism itself it's so-so Christian-wannabe unlike the original one which came from the Middle East; it was largely repurposed with Greek values so people here could assimilate better these alien customs such as not being able to eat pork or nonsense about alcohol when the risk of dehidrating in Europe was near nil.

Kinda like North Korea with Communism. Marxist? Today, in name, maybe. Because Juche it's almost a copycat of right wing fascism with Asian features. Kinda like the Japanese one, but with Koreans.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hnbad on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:19AM (#39053373)
Evil as a moral judgement isn't. Acts can be good or evil. In more secular terms we prefer to say "harmful" or "unjust" but the meaning is arguably the same.

But the idea that "evil" is an attribute a person can possess is 100% a religious one. If you're not religious, there can be no evil person unless you think there is an "evil" gene or an "evil" psychosis - "sociopath" and "psychopath" are often used this way but usually in ways that have very little to do with diagnostic criteria and more with trying to sound more profound than just calling someone a bad person; in pseudoscience this also sometimes manifests as the idea that some people are more predisposed to crime, though usually nowadays this more often manifests as vague notions of "racial culture" than measuring skull shapes, but this too is just a more elaborate way to call groups of people inherently bad.

As a religious concept, "evil" can be somewhat nebulous where people just take some wrong turns and "evilness" seeps into them making them irredeemable: many Christians (especially certain sects of American protestantism) believe "sins" (i.e. disobeying God's rules, not necessarily causing measurable harm to others in secular terms) work kind of like this where habitual sinning in one way can lead to sinning in other ways as sinfulness takes over the person's life (like an addiction spiraling out of control). It can also be a much more literal idea of outright demonic possession (e.g. the kind of thing you need an exorcist to help with) or demonic presence (e.g. evil people actually being lizard people masking themselves as fellow humans to hide among us). And yes, I'm labelling certain fringe conspiracy movements as religious as they operate on a similar framework and often have direct ties to religious traditions and concepts.

Conversely, not only are "evil people" a religious concept but so are "good people". If good is something you do that means you need to continously demonstrate your "goodness" by doing good things. But if good is something you can be then any accusations of wrongdoing are highly suspect because a good person would do no such things. This is why most people don't take kindly to being told even in the most polite terms that something they did was kinda racist (or sexist, or misogynist, or...) because "I'm not a racist" (i.e. thinking of it as an innate attribute of their character rather than one of their actions and hence something they can and need to actively control) - mind you, liberals did not do a good job with this distinction either over the past decade because as it turns out even self-professed non-religious people often have religious upbringings that stick with them (i.e. self-applied labels like "feminist", "anti-racist", etc should only ever be read as statements of intent and dismissed if they do not manifest in their actions which they rarely do).

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by lupusreal on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:33AM (#39053856)
Evil is an attribute that people may come to possess through various means (ideology is a big one), which becomes manifest through their actions when they demonstrate severe selfish disregard for the lives of others.

The above does not rest on religion. Christians/etc having their own theories about evil is irrelevant. When most people say Pol Pot was evil, they're not talking about demonic possession or some silly nonsense like that; they mean he was a mass murderer, which is evil.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hnbad on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:22AM (#39055074)
> When most people say Pol Pot was evil, they're not talking about demonic possession or some silly nonsense like that; they mean he was a mass murderer, which is evil.

Well, no. Most people I've heard say something like that would mean that he was innately evil as a person. They wouldn't spell it out like that but the underlying assumption is that a "normal human being" couldn't do what he did and therefore he was a freak mutation in some way. Most people even struggle with the idea that there was a time in such a person's life where they weren't "evil" yet. Even when talking about Antisocial Personality Disorder ("psychopathy") they rarely know that this is often in part caused by severe early childhood trauma, e.g. sexual abuse or parental abuse and emotional neglect - most seem to believe these people are "just born evil" and any prior period where they didn't do anything sufficiently evil were just a mask.

This is easiest to see when talking about the Nazis. Instead of trying to gain a systemic understanding of how the Nazis came to power or how "ordinary citizens" could be made to commit massacres and genocides we single out the big names as uniquely evil and make up excuses for the rest. For the longest time I had been told that soldiers who participated in massacres were implicitly threatened with death or at least physical punishment but we know that this was not the case and the mere threat of social ostracization by the other members of their unit was enough. The majority of those involved in the massacres saw themselves as victims for having to carry out those commands and deal with the trauma because denying their own agency helped them cope with what they had done.

So no, they don't mean "a person who has done something evil" when they say a person is evil. They usually mean something more transcendental than that. When most people say Pol Pot or Hitler or Milosevic was evil they mean he wasn't human the same way "normal humans" are human. They may not think he was literally possessed by a demon or the physical manifestation of a demon but they will think there was some essence of evilness inside him that would inevitably manifest. He wasn't evil as a result of doing evil things, he did evil things because he was an evil person. This is called essentialism and it's extremely widespread and antithetical to a systems theory based understanding of social dynamics and behaviors.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:24AM (#39055789)
Again, well said!
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by lupusreal on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:39AM (#39055981)
Pol Pot wasn't "innately" evil and I doubt many people would say such a thing. Pol Pot is evil because he did evil things, not the other way around. For that matter, most Christians believe that all people are prone to sin and the difference between people is whether they seek forgiveness after giving into sin. The innate sense of evil exists in all people which is why Christ had to sacrifice himself to atone for that sin. Personally I am not a christian and blood sacrifice (of anybody or anything) to atone for sins doesn't make logical sense to me, but that's what their bible says and that's what most of them preach. A few, like Calvinists, are notable exceptions.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hnbad on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:18PM (#39073532)
> Pol Pot wasn't "innately" evil and I doubt many people would say such a thing.

> Personally I am not a christian

You really shouldn't extrapolate from yourself then.

I've seen this discourse repeatedly in Germany when it comes to Hitler and the Nazis:

1. Hitler did unspeakably evil things.

2. Therefore Hitler was evil.

3. However the evil he did was so uniquely evil he can not be compared to others.

4. Therefore Hitler was uniquely capable of committing such evil.

5. This implies Hitler was already innately evil prior to committing those acts.

This usually extends to falsely distinguish the evil SS from the "patriotic" Wehrmacht (who were "ordinary soldiers just following orders" and only "incidentally" ended up participating in mass murders). It's directly tied to the Great Man narrative of history: only Hitler could have been Hitler because he was innately different. The idea in the Great Man narrative usually being that a great leader emerges and changes history, rather than history changing through the conflict of material conditions (or ideas, if you're a Hegelian) and the actual figureheads being largely incidental (i.e. what Marxists call dialectical materialism).

According to demographic data, over 40% of Germans identify as non-religious whereas in the US it's a bit over 20%, so I would expect Americans to actually be more likely to think this way (if not outright going with the "demon person" idea of evil).

Also, according to most Christian faiths Jesus specifically atoned for the Original Sin (Adam and Eve disobeying God by eating the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil). The entire "redemption" thing is also a bit more complicated: in practice even Protestant and Catholic Christians generally behave as if they were following the Eastern Orthodox view of mortal sins where mortal sins are irredeemable and the separation from God they inflict on the sinner is permanent.

But this is a digression. The point is, most people view evil when it comes to person not as a mere descriptor of having done something but

- either: having a pre-existing innate essence of evil-ness that allowed them to do it

- or: having been so corrupted by the act itself that they now possess a permanent essence of evil-ness

or a combination of the two. In other words: an Evil Person™ is not just a person who has done an evil thing but a person uniquely capable of and predisposed towards doing evil things to a greater extent than a Normal Person™ would be. Pol Pot wasn't just evil because he did evil things, he did those evil things because he was Pol Pot, an evil person.

I'll shut up now before I get started on how different ideas of free will play into this.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:21AM (#39055758)
Well written and pretty much summarize what I think and tried to convey above.

I wish I was as good expressing myself like you are!

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by readthenotes1 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:57AM (#39044195)
Religion-free definition of evil: inclined to increase someone else's suffering without regard (that is, without caring enough to try to reduce that increase).
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by hnbad on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:35PM (#39045690)
If you don't believe in evil (I don't) that not only means he isn't evil but that he also didn't murder his ex because he was evil. So there must still be something to him 15 years ago that made him plan to and murder his ex, hide the body, use elaborate lies to deny his actions and then only admit to it when offered a deal to disclose the location of the body to allow the victim's grieving family to bury her.

That's a lot. The prison system is neither equipped nor designed to resocialize or rehabilitate people. He hasn't demonstrated any considerable change in his character or outlook on the value of human life that makes me believe he changed for the better.

He didn't make a mistake. He intentionally planned out the murder of his ex and how to hide the body and explain her disappearance and he did this to keep his children he neglected, which was the reason for her breaking up with him to begin with. And then he acted out that plan and stuck to it for months. Most people don't even commit to their gym memberships as long as he did to his cover story.

People aren't evil. But people also don't improve by rotting in prison. You can argue that means we need something better than prison and I would, but you can't argue that means he should be treated as redeemed or released early.

Dropping a feel-good out of context MLK quote to try and impress a future parole hearing is not a demonstration of character growth. Still referring to his victim as "my wife" when she had already broken up with him is not a demonstration of character growth. If he seeks redemption he needs to address those surviving his victim. If he wants to demonstrate rehabilitation he needs to do more than just get older and memorize meaningless platitudes.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:00AM (#39055500)
> If you don't believe in evil (I don't) that not only means he isn't evil but that he also didn't murder his ex because he was evil. So there must still be something to him 15 years ago that made him plan to and murder his ex, hide the body, use elaborate lies to deny his actions and then only admit to it when offered a deal to disclose the location of the body to allow the victim's grieving family to bury her.

For sure, there were reasons. We just don't know them.

> but you can't argue that means he should be treated as redeemed or released early.

I'm not. Was just saying people deserve another chance.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by themerone on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:54PM (#39075364)
If you don't believe in evil, then you must not believe in friendless, meanness, empathitic, or any other adjective for describing how a human acts.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by seti0Cha on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:05PM (#39046133)
Christians believe in evil AND believe in redemption. If you are looking for people who believe that positive change is impossible, try genetic determinists.
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by beepbooptheory on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:31PM (#39047237)
> The true Übermensch would never give a second thought (or the light of day) to such a piddling subject as this, one who exhibits all the frailties and animal passions of the last man! "Second chances" and "forgiveness" are just as much symptoms of christian morality as good and evil themselves. Remember always that justice died with God. Our only arbiter is the creative life, is the aesthetic domain.

Thus spoke Zarathustra..

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by rayiner on Friday January 19, 2024 @11:38AM (#39057414)
If you’re not religious, what’s the basis for saying anyone “deserves” anything? If he’s just meat, then he’s clearly a defective model. Just take him out. How is society better with him alive?
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by selimthegrim on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:18AM (#39066924)
Do you think BD was right to execute all the “war criminals” with their very flawed trial? Why so?
Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by rayiner on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:08AM (#39067247)
I’m an ex-atheist so it’s complicated. If I’m taking off my religion hat, I would say yes. It enhances national unity and in-group loyalty, and the risk of antagonizing Pakistan seems to be of no real consequence. And it’s not like BD has any lack of people.

Now if I’m positing that human beings have intrinsic worth because god made them, and that we need to turn the other cheek and all that, then no, the process is deeply flawed and shouldn’t be happening.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by tussa on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:54AM (#39044135)
> do stupid things

Yes, we've all done stupid things we regret. But this is not it. This is way to bad to fit in the "stupid things" category.

Re:Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel by kstrauser on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:07PM (#39044317)
I’ve said and done stupid things that hurt people I cared about. Anyone who’s been a teenager and yelled “I hate you, Dad!” in a moment of hormonal overload has.

Ain’t killed anyone, though.