News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by silveira on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39032906)
I find it revealing that some decades ago when teenagers were copying mp3s in their rooms for their own enjoyment it was piracy, crime, reprehensible, police, prisons, etc. When corporations are doing mass copyright infringement, we are talking about death of IP or changing the copyright laws to accommodate them.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by shredprez on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:27PM (#39032986)
This is the right take — whatever your position on the future of this technology or its costs and benefits for humanity, the hypocrisy mentioned here shouldn't go unacknowledged.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by mwhitfield on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:46PM (#39034662)
It's only "hypocrisy" if it's the same people saying it. The media zeitgeist is not a person.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by Intralexical on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:39PM (#39035839)
Idk man; I think our values and the enforcement of those values should have some moral self-consistency to them on a cultural level too.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by mwhitfield on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:51PM (#39035961)
There are hundreds of millions or billions of us, though, depending on how broad a brush you use. Any given issue or value is going to have someone, in fact quite a lot of someones, on every conceivable side of it. Even if you limit your scope to the people who have a substantial voice in the culture.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by Intralexical on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:04PM (#39036593)
Yeah, but it's not a good look when the influence-weighted average of all those people applies double standards for different groups in similar situations. I mean, even when you take just a single person, they're probably going to have a couple conflicting feelings towards any one topic. And yet, if the emergent result of that internal conflict doesn't produce some level of self-consistency in resulting opinions and actions, then something's not quite right.

Like… the entire idea of words like "society", "culture", "zeitgeist", etc. is that they imply a greater level of organization, shared values and ability to act as though one autonomous entity or whatever, than if you merely took "hundreds of millions or billions of" people and dumped them all in one place.

A society or zeitgeist can absolutely have 'hypocrisy'. If it can't, then it's not a culture, just a mass of hominids.

Plus, though it's hard to track, there's probably some degree of hypocrisy aggregated from an individual level too, where people who took one side before are taking the other side now.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by nsagent on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:18AM (#39041313)
Microsoft has a very long history of fighting piracy and they are one of OpenAI's main funders. It's definitely hypocrisy.

Former Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer: "Piracy reduction can be a source of Windows revenue growth." [1]

Current Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella: "Well, we’ve always had freemium. Sometimes our freemium was called piracy." [2]

[1]: https://www.zdnet.com/article/only-consumers-pressure-can-cu...

[2]: https://www.cnbc.com/2014/10/20/cnbc-exclusive-cnbc-transcri...

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by mcmoor on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:21PM (#39035052)
I see the exact hypocrisy from the opposite side too. Praising pirating while treating AI as crime against humanity.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:35PM (#39035794)
Depends on your lens. If you view it as "crime", sure. If you view it as "obtaining quality content", you can see why and where these users' priorities are. The web is already this riddled SEO optimized spam-Festa that makes it hard to find what you want or desire, now AI comes in and increases the spam tenfold.

AI for those people just make their jobs of seeking what's worth pirating that much harder. Especially for those that can now fire half their staff and put most of that remaining money into said SEO optimization for their spam.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:31PM (#39035763)
In a vacuum this shouldn't be an issue at all. We make stuff, we honor and benefit the creators, we share as needed and progress humanity as a whole. So I can understand the more optimistic approaches to AI as a tech revolution.

But in reality, everytime small entrepreneurs always thnk this will be the tech that let them usurp the big boys, and they end up selling out (not necessarily blaming them. I'd do it too). They have more resources, can scale up faster, produce more, and hire more people. It's a hopelessly risky gambit to think you can topple such advantage. And if you get an edge in, they just take it in for themselves and you're back at square one.

But you may not even get that far. They try to make use of this new commons and the Big Boys will litigate the gates back closed for them specifically. They got their value, made the next iteration, and then decided not to give back to the commons (a tragedy, if you will). They may even seem benevolent at first, but time goes on, priorities or leaders change, and the focus on market capture eclipses any public goodwill.

The same players as yester-decade are at the helm, so I don't know why anyone would want to trust them after giving decades of scrutiny as they gradually unmasked themselves. I don't necessarily fear the tech per se, I fear the same "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" playbook happening all over again, maybe in such a way to make the new gap insurmountable.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by rhystmills on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:39PM (#39033126)
There are plenty of articles from major news orgs about we shouldn't accept LLMs infringing copyright. The New York Times are suing OpenAI.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by tanseydavid on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:08PM (#39034227)
>> There are plenty of articles from major news orgs

Opinion articles.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:34PM (#39033062)
> when teenagers were copying mp3s in their rooms for their own enjoyment it was piracy, crime, reprehensible, police, prisons, etc. When corporations are doing mass copyright infringement, we are talking about death of IP or changing the copyright laws to accommodate them

It's been over a decade since an individual was prosecuted for digital piracy [1]. Longer since anyone was threatened with jail time.

When it was new, both individuals and companies were prosecuted. The tides shifted and law enforcement responded. This isn't a story of different standards, but one of evolving ones.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_v._Tenenbaum

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ricardo81 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:47PM (#39033209)
I think the GP's point was it's different rules for big co vs individuals breaching the same idea.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:51PM (#39033267)
> GP's point was it's different rules for big co vs individuals breaching the same idea

My point is it isn't. Individual copyright infringement is virtually unenforced today. To the extent it was in the last decade, the penalty was a fine. Meanwhile, OpenAI is being sued by the New York Times [1] and various writers [2].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/27/business/media/new-york-t...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/technology/more-writers-sue-openai-c...

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:09PM (#39033486)
And plenty of people are threatened with lawsuits for seeding on an ongoing basis, especially in some markets like Germany where an entire industry stalks public torrents looking for German IPs.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:39PM (#39033886)
> plenty of people are threatened with lawsuits for seeding on an ongoing basis, especially in some markets like Germany

Fair enough, I'm talking about America. To my knowledge, individuals downloading pirated content have not been threatened with lawsuits. And to the degree seeders have been threatened, it's only that--threats. When was the last distributor actually sued?

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:51PM (#39035963)
I know porn owners go after seeders in the US, I've seen news articles from torrentfreak.com to that extent.

But the fact that they're not being sued is a weird delineation to make. They're not being sued because they can't afford to defend so are settling. It's not a case that IP owners aren't enforcing copyright, they're just not escalating to actual lawsuits because they don't need to.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:03PM (#39036079)
> not being sued because they can't afford to defend so are settling

I’m asking for evidence of these settlements.

The claim is corporations are being given a free pass relative to how individuals are being treated. I’m not seeing that signal. What I am seeing is Americans becoming more sceptical about intellectual property as a result of the MPAA and RIAA overplaying their hands in the 90s.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ricardo81 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:02PM (#39033397)
I don't think you have a point, the original poster was talking about individual indiscretions (20 years ago also) vs wholesale scraping of billions of people's copyrighted work for corporate gain, today.

Some lawsuits don't change that fact.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:04PM (#39033426)
> individual indiscretions vs wholesale scraping of billions of people's copyrighted work...some lawsuits don't change that fact

Over the last decade, individual indiscretions have not been punished. Wholesale scraping is being punished. Some lawsuits do challenge the hypothesis that corporates' copyright violations are being treated more leniently than individuals'.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ricardo81 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:09PM (#39033488)
Why are you introducing this 'last decade' thing. Was the decade before not relevant? The original point was not about lawsuits anyway. Are they American lawsuits you're talking about?

You seem to be conflating a whole bunch of things, seems like misdirection.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:42PM (#39033916)
> Why are you introducing this 'last decade' thing. Was the decade before not relevant?

I'm arguing that policy preferences around copyright infringement have changed in general. In general, in 1990s, copyright infringement meant "crime, reprehensible, police, prisons, etc." for both individuals and coporations. In general, in the past decade, it's meant none of those things for either individuals or corporations. Yet it's meant fines and lawsuits for corporations with virtually none I can find, in America, aimed at individuals.

Also, LLMs were basically invented less than a decade ago [1].

> seems like misdirection

"Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like" [2].

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.03762

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ricardo81 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:49PM (#39034005)
Your link to the guidelines doesn't prevent me from implying you're directing away from the point, and nor should it.

>I'm arguing that policy preferences around copyright infringement have changed in general.

Perhaps they have, and I take on your take on that. In the end you were replying to me and the original poster so respect the spirit of those posts.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by vertere on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:40PM (#39035848)
You seem to have a very narrow view of what is a relevant or a valid comment. Just because a counterargument doesn't completely refute the original comment, or "introduces" new concepts, doesn't make it irrelevant or "misdirection".

Someone compared treatment of X 20 years ago to treatment of Y today -- seems pretty natural to bring up treatment of X more recently. You can't just say "the original comment didn't mention it so you can't mention it either".

I don't see how your accusations of bad faith are warranted.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ricardo81 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:24PM (#39036264)
If your doubts are true, why did you have to introduce an analogy?

I feel I have a pretty open view.

And, there's no definition of a 'valid' comment. I'll address points, raise points or whatever. Sorry, I'm not in the realm of 'valid' comments, never was.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:14PM (#39036653)
> why did you have to introduce an analogy?

GP made a comparison! How do you refute a comparison without criticising the comparison?

> I'm not in the realm of 'valid' comments, never was

Claiming misdirection is an argument about validity.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by tanseydavid on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:11PM (#39034257)
I agree -- it does seem like intentional misdirection.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by EdwardDiego on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:04PM (#39033421)
Sure, they don't prosecute, they just threaten you into a settlement. Is that any better?
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:05PM (#39033442)
> they don't prosecute, they just threaten you into a settlement. Is that any better?

Objectively, yes. Paying a settlement in private is better than being publicly prosecuted and then put in jail.

That said, it's still no cakewalk. Do you have a source for individuals settling copyright claims? I'm not finding any recent stories nor surveys.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by reedciccio on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:54PM (#39034067)
Try downloading pirated movies and see how long it takes for you to receive a letter from your ISP telling you to stop or else... It's automatic, that's why you don't hear about lawsuits anymore: not necessary, the law enforcement is semi automatic now.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by supertofu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:34PM (#39033826)
Remember those very dramatic warnings before movie trailers equating piracy to real-world theft (You wouldn't steal a car; you wouldn't rob a bank; piracy is a crime...)? Seems laughable now.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by dageshi on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:35PM (#39033066)
We're not exactly tearing everything apart to combat piracy nowadays even though piracy still exists, so I'm not sure exactly what it reveals other than attitudes change?
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by pylua on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:35PM (#39033068)
Are they training it on music from top artists or their lyrics? Maybe they haven’t poked the wrong bear yet.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:43PM (#39034632)
Did some limited testing(chatgpt 3.5).

If you ask it to complete text and give it the first line, it will sometimes continue the lyrics. Seems to work best for particularly famous stretches of lyrics, like Lose Yourself by Eminem, Bohemian Rhapsody or Hurt.

When I told it to complete the text "Obie Trice, real name no gimmicks", it said I'm sorry I can't reproduce the lyrics to Without Me by Eminem. And offered to tell me more about Obie Trice.

When I just asked it to reproduce the lyrics to Bohemian Rhapsody, it once again refused and offered to analyse the lyrics.

Seems like there's clearly song lyrics in the training data, and that they've at least made attempts to prevent it from regurgitating them.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by jug on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:28PM (#39035130)
Holy crap, I managed it now in POE and ChatGPT 3.5. It halts output and can't continue even if requested as JSON for a project etc

But look at this...

https://poe.com/s/Y73se7ueRrQy9xHRPuoh

I swear the chaps at OpenAI have it all as exact copies. Articles and whatnot. Why wouldn't they if they have the lyrics precisely cloned.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by weebull on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:41AM (#39041007)
ASCAP Vs Open AI in 3...2...1...
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by happytiger on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:43PM (#39034639)
Rules for thee and not for me? Perhaps V, perhaps.

I want to gently reframe the debate, for while I agree with the hypocrisy it rather misses a very key point.

Intellectual law, as bedrock principle, explicitly doesn’t recognize nonhuman creators. So at the heart of the issue isn’t changing copyright laws or the death of IP, but what to do with non-human creativity? This is an interesting issue now, but most of the debates and options being debated thus far won’t survive an AGI let alone a world full of advanced AGIs.

But it’s a critical distinction between “so now it doesn’t matter when it was theft before,” and “what do we do with non-human intelligence when our entire system of creativity protection is build around humans and non-humans now exist?”

It’s a paradigm shift that gets somewhat denied by the hypocrisy argument. Most people look at AI as “technology” we have developed, but if any science fiction writers are right it’s actually a bona fide digital intelligence that’s getting developed here — essentially the possible digital twin of human intelligence — and that’s a whole different set of considerations.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by nsagent on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:31AM (#39041451)
As an NLP researcher, I've come across no convincing research indicating LLMs are "the possible digital twin of human intelligence."

Claims certainly get made, but they are subsequently shot down by future research. This has happened for discussions of emergence [1], reasoning [2], and other human attributes people have ascribed to LLMs.

[1]: https://neurips.cc/virtual/2023/poster/72117

[2]: https://m-cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/276268-can-llms-reall...

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by happytiger on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:36AM (#39043888)
I think you’re discussing the logical extension of our current AI efforts, and I’m discussing the fully realized science fiction reality that could take decades to perfect or that would be driven by breakthroughs beyond the forecast of existing systems.

That’s the difference between seeing it as a technology vs a larger directional shift in human development. Put more directly we have been experiencing the age of miniaturization, and now we are entering the age of digital intelligences.

Very often early technology looks toy-like and lacks substantive real world application (despite the hype). It’s only later that deliver substantive applications and real-world change. This generation of AI is following the Gartner hype cycle perfectly thus far:

https://www.gartner.com/en/articles/what-s-new-in-artificial...

That said Gartner tends to be part of the hype cycle these days, but the pattern of new technology holds true.

So in short I would expect anything like a digital twin to emerge from post trough applications not the current generation, and I don't mean to imply that the current technology will create such a system but just that science fiction and futurists generally forecast or even predict this technology will generate a digital twin (in the form of an AGI) from this civilization-level line of technology exploration.

All that said, I don’t think many of us technologists were thinking we would be anywhere near this level of AI technology in 2018. In five or six years we have gone what people thought would take 10-20. So, as always, linear extension predictive and mental models of technology advancement once again fails to predict the true course of technology progress, which seems to be much more dynamic than people generally consider when talking about the future.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by leotravis10 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:48PM (#39034689)
This is the absolute correct take, especially with the uncertainty and legal actions (copyright infringment lawsuits) against AI right now.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by ddingus on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:57PM (#39036020)
Spot on.

What happens when AI systems can work around IP?

This gets done all the time now. It is going to be way cheaper.

Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.? by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:21PM (#39036242)
"The law today treats companies as "authors," and classifies things like the source code of software as "literary works," giving software a much longer period of protection than it would have if it were classified only as an invention and eligible for a patent (now good for twenty years, with some exceptions)."

Microsoft has been arguably the largest beneficiary of software copyright. Gates argued for it in the early days of MicroSoft. Microsoft's anti-piracy campaigns are unparalleled. Anyone remember the "Business Software Alliance".

Now the company wants to be the largest beneficiary of "AI".