If your doubts are true, why did you have to introduce an analogy?
I feel I have a pretty open view.
And, there's no definition of a 'valid' comment. I'll address points, raise points or whatever. Sorry, I'm not in the realm of 'valid' comments, never was.
Re:Is A.I. The Death of I.P.?
by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:14PM
(#39036653)
> why did you have to introduce an analogy?
GP made a comparison! How do you refute a comparison without criticising the comparison?
> I'm not in the realm of 'valid' comments, never was
Claiming misdirection is an argument about validity.
Someone compared treatment of X 20 years ago to treatment of Y today -- seems pretty natural to bring up treatment of X more recently. You can't just say "the original comment didn't mention it so you can't mention it either".
I don't see how your accusations of bad faith are warranted.