Self regulation of the industry is common as you say. It tends to involve one central body enforcing the standards on the members, and acting as a central point for agreement of the standards.
This is not the case with the Aviation regulation. The FAA is the regulator, and has delegated the testing to the people it is meant to be regulating.
I used to work at an organization that was governed by multiple of the SROs you list there. Here's how it worked: They set rules, we followed them, they monitored and audited us. There were also governmental organizations monitoring both them and us.
I think that the key distinction here is not actually public vs. private. It's more of a "sunlight is the best disinfectant" situation. The simple knowledge that you have some external agency that doesn't have moral hazard concerns to compromise its interests that is keeping an eye on you, and that you know is keeping an eye on you, does a lot to incentivize better behavior. Is it perfect? No, far from it. But, at least in the specific case of the financial industry, it's not clear to me that a 100% governmental regulatory system would actually fare any better. I think that the unstated major premise of such an idea is that the people in charge of the governmental regulators - elected officials - are uncompromisable ethical paragons. And if you believe that, I've got some hot penny stocks that I'd like to tell you about.
Or do they just get tarred with 'Well, they work in finance, of course they are all crooks' brush?
Much easier to just go by gut feeling though isn't it.
What now? I'm sure you are going to say that they settled because they were innocent, right? And that they halted trades 'by mistake', not on a purpose
I'm not going to waste my time sifting through it to find evidence for a claim you're making.
Make a specific claim of corruption, and provide evidence for it.
There’s also a clear tolerance of securities fraud as long as you subscribe to certain ideologies — eg, NYSE allowing Disney to trade when they’re clearly stealing/destroying shareholder assets to advance the ideology of a cabal of executives and fiduciaries.
Something like notaries, guilds or unions that can speak the truth without retribution ...
No, we need independent regulation. We don't have the societal norms to pull off self regulation.
Why? How does this incentivize effective self-regulation?
> No, we need independent regulation. We don't have the societal norms to pull off self regulation.
We do though. This thread even points them out.
Those that self-regulation have a greater duty to be truthful and in good faith, attempt to remain in compliance. If they cheat, not only should they lose the right to self regulate, but they should face stiffer penalties for breaking that trust.
Inspecting the self is a bit bonkers.
One can even argue the tax office is sort of like it.
Except if the "people who run the SRO" are in fact employees of the very company they're supposed to be regulating... ?
Then they surely have an even greater incentive to keep quiet in order to keep their jobs?
Maybe, maybe not. But I do know that I don't have much faith when companies "regulate" themselves. There's just too much conflict of interest there. A third party doing it is, on its face, more trustworthy.
It's similar to how income taxes work. You self-report all the figures, and then they are sampled and spot-checked and occasionally audited. The possibility of being caught by an audit, then prods people to generally submit truthful reports, because of the risk of penalties.
And then, if that incentive ceases to work, the self-report/self-regulate status gets revoked.
We can easily publicly fund over-sight committees to oversee these industries instead of relying on SROs who take tax-payer money and are in the perfect financial and power position to do some really corrupt and immoral things.
Look at the National Association of Realtors, another SRO— On October 31, 2023, a federal civil jury found that the NAR had conspired to inflate commissions paid to home-buyers' real estate agents, and determined that NAR and its codefendants owed damages of almost US$1,800,000,000.
Zillow and NAR have anti-trust lawsuits coming their way too. Relying on SROs is just asking for corruption, imo.
Easily, really? Why is the default position that industry players are corrupt and immoral, but the government overseers will act independently and altruistically and have no financial stake in the outcome? That doesn't jibe with my experience. People in government seem to do some of the most immoral acts out there.
A private corporate overseer cannot be voted out or forced out. Only a CEO or board can decide that. It's undemocratic.
The public has an actual voice in government while having absolutely no voice in a private corporation.
What's funny about this is that if you were to ask a group of brokers (IE: the ones with authority over the business - terminology is inconsistent between states...), they would probably tell you that the state has a great deal of oversight, but I'd agree with you - by and large no one is actually watching them. I was with a group of fellow brokers not long ago and it came as a clear surprise to them that the state would no longer be actually auditing them. The state wouldn't make it official policy, but it was a wink and a smile that they wouldn't. There were gasps around the room and it was really rather an insightful moment. While I am new in this role, it was obvious to me the state wasn't actually auditing anything - and frankly, why should they unless they've had a consumer complaint? But the fact that very experienced brokers were surprised by this was interesting.
Self-regulation (especially at the industry level rather than delegating to individual companies) doesn't seem completely broken. Actually it can work quite well. You keep some oversight, and reserve the right for the state regulator to step in if the SRO goes bad. The people who run the SRO have an interest in perpetuating their organization, so they if anything have an incentive to be stricter than the government would. If things do go wrong, the government demands direct oversight. That's what's happening here.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-regulatory_organization
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/sro.asp