Re:US regulator considers stripping Boeing's right to self-i...
by keenmaster on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:07PM
(#38971611)
Self-regulatory bodies are usually centralized and separate from any individual corporation. They also tend to answer directly to a government agency and cannot be disciplined by a corporation. While there can still be issues such as a strong revolving door and potential indirect pressure to be nice to the regulated entities, it’s not as terrible as what Boeing and other airplane manufacturers get to do (inspect themselves in lieu of regulatory inspections). That’s strange, because lives are literally on the line, more so than some other industries with more independent examinations.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US regulator considers stripping Boeing's right to self-i...
by emarsden on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:20PM
(#38973421)
Historically, the fact that lives of the public are clearly on the line was part of the argument for allowing partial delegation of safety oversight. The idea has been that any engineer/manager making these decisions will be regularly flying themselves/loved ones, so is going to be suitably cautious. This differed from the situation in coal mines for example, where the miners exposed to the risk were socially/culturally disjoint from engineers/managers.
Re:US regulator considers stripping Boeing's right to self-i...
by keenmaster on Friday January 12, 2024 @08:44PM
(#38976549)
Right, that’s just bonkers logic though. When the stakes are higher, controls should be stronger.