Then they will sell your debt to a collections agency who will make it their business to harass you to the maximum extent legally allowed (and sometimes more than that). This may include impacting your credit score - although I think some states at least have protections against that.
https://www.consumerreports.org/money/debt-collection/fight-... ("How to Fight Back When Contacted by a Debt Collector for a Medical Bill")
The difference between honest-to-god scams, and just these meaningless me-too bills that accompany every medical procedure or test... well, is there a difference?
If a scam is some scheme or trick to get you to pay for something you never agreed to pay for and wouldn't agree to pay for if it were said up front, through deception strategies like opaque policies and maneuvering you to a point where you can no longer back out of it...
Then pretty much all of it is a scam. That the people performing the scams have professional degrees in medicine, that they're gainfully employed as hospital and medical company employees, and so on, that doesn't really change the nature of it.
Originally, the "scammy" behavior was developed (and not deliberately) to try to coerce the insurance companies into paying. But the insurance companies could afford employees to counter all those tactics. This didn't mean the experise was wasted though, they simply turned that onto the patients themselves.
The crazy thing to remember is that none of that expertise will go away, no matter what happens. Maybe they'll turn it on the government too, at some point, if we ever get universal healthcare. That could be a hoot, couldn't it?
medical billing fraud is a serious offense that can get the hospital in quitw hot water and they leverage that
The reason is that the service - the contract - is organized in that way. Between the patient and the anaesthesiologist, between the patient and the surgeon, and between the patient and the hospital. So three separate bills. The doctor and hospital will have their own contract. Legally, and in an important way when it comes to decide who to sue for malpractice, the hospital is not the provider or performer of the surgery. They just provide the venue and equipment; the doctors do the surgery.
So, since neither of us is employed by the hospital, we do our own billing. If we were hospital employees, we could indeed do unified billing. That's a better analogy; your chefs are expecting to be paid by the restaurant, so it collects the bill. I am not paid by the hospital except a stipend for taking call for them - not for any specific services I provide to patients.
It's frustrating for patients and families, it's annoying for us, but it's the price of legal independence for us. If my hospital collapsed overnight (and they sometimes do), my group could go out and start working other sources of income right away, because we already have the business setup to do our own billing.
To that point, I went to the ER a few months ago and I've probably received ten or so mailings for unpaid bills, only one of which I actually ended up owing, but my insurance didn't make the claims visible until they were settled which was months after the fact. To make matters worse, I can still log in and pay bills which were settled by my insurance. And I've received bills in the mail -- late I assume -- after they were paid by me or settled by insurance, confounding matters further.
Obviously there are some practical limits in exceptional cases, but I can't think of another industry that has high-price services where providing estimates isn't standard.
This is why healthcare should be provided for free at the point of service, paid for by the government. It works very, very well for many other countries. The only reason we haven't been able to make it work here is the rampant lobbying.
To follow the restaurant example above.
And since the topic is debt, how do you think that affects the small private practice? The hospital, that has scheduled and contracted the doctor, on site, with the hospitals equipment is more able to have a loss column than an individual.
This seems like something the IRS should fix; as all of the above makes the contractor an employee of the hospital.
Can you imagine flying on a Delta flight and you have to pay a separate bill to a 3rd party maintenance company.
Well, if you want to turn this into a rant on how incredibly backward the way things are done is, I'll agree with you that it's a terrible method. But it is the way things work. Don't believe me? Ask your insurance company. Your deductible is not payable to the insurance company; they require the billing entity to collect it themselves (and thus spread the risk onto us - they don't pay our negotiated fee, they pay the negotiated fee minus your deductible and it's up to us to get it from you).
> And you can most certainly retain your legal independence and work for multiple vendors as a subcontractor, like in any other industry.
Again, look at how health insurance in the US, as a whole, works. And, for that matter, hospitals (for- vs not-for-profit is a mostly meaningless distinction in this).
Sure, it's the way things are done. What I'm questioning is why it should even be expected to "work", apart from people's seemingly misguided sense that what essentially amounts to a request for a tip is somehow a binding debt they're obligated to pay. What you've described is the exact same set up as a waiter at a restaurant. And yet despite waiters often handling identifying information, nobody gets a post-hoc bill in mail asking for arbitrary table service fees. And if some waiter did try this hustle, the recipient would likely roll their eyes and toss it in the bin.
> Your deductible is not payable to the insurance company; they require the billing entity to collect it themselves
Sure. I wouldn't call this backwards - rather inconvenient but still legally sound. The provider enters into a contract with the "insurance" company that requires this. The customer enters into a contract with the provider by requesting and using their service, so the provider can bill the customer.
What you (and most of the industry) are somehow claiming is that even though the patient already has a business arrangement with the hospital for treatment, that the hospital calling in a subcontractor means that subcontractor is somehow entitled to bill the patient directly despite having no business relationship.
Then, a month later, I receive a bill indicating a routine procedure that I assumed out of ignorance was covered by insurance (since they took my card and entered the numbers without saying anything to the contrary) for $500 (or, god forbid, more).
If I knew a salad at a restaurant were $200, I probably wouldn’t order it. There is no basic transparency in medical billing, and that needs to change.
Then you’d only have a handful of different prices you might have to pay.
Years after our child was born, I ended up getting a scary letter from a collections agency. Turns out I had missed some $20 bill from the time when we were on the PPO plan. So they say, at least - it seems equally plausible that it was a billing error on their side (of which we found many), and they never once mentioned it during any of our visits. But at that point I was not willing to fight over $20 and just paid it.
How the heck is this not criminal fraud? Why are people allowed to simply bill whatever they feel like it, and why is my mother getting 'balance billed' for random amounts? They're still doing all this dirty underhanded stuff and when they get called out on it, it's 'Oopsie! Our mistake' when they know most people they do this to will naively pay it
It may surprise you to learn criminal fraud occurs on a regular basis and the simple act of acknowledging it does nothing to address it.
> Why are people allowed to simply bill whatever they feel like it
Pretty simple economics: they have something you want (healthcare) which no one else can provide. Supply and demand - they dictate the terms.
So you got a paper that was outdated, that's it.
Its actually typical for a patient to have a huge balance, then get sent the amount, so the patient has ownership of the problem. That usually results in patients calling and correcting whatever error they (or staff) made that made balances ballon.
Unfortunately, as long as everything including a paper cut is supposed to be covered by a regulated health plan, that's what we are going to get.
All you can eat tends to increase the cost to provide it, if someone else is paying for it.
I'm of the strong opinion that the US healthcare system should join the developed world and go single payer. The system we have was clearly set up to exploit patients.
This has to be done in person, where they can't be, uh, accidentally disconnected, but I've found the rate-of-return on that time hard to beat. They discover all sorts of "mistakes" when you're taking up their billing specialists' time.
It is a bit like haggling over your car price after you already bought it; the main thing to get over is the social discomfort of being a pain in the ass, so they can't use that against you.
I called and asked how they had arrived at the numbers in the bill and the person on the phone basically told me "it looks like someone just guessed, go ahead and ignore the bill and we'll send you a correct one later."
(Resolution: Thankfully I had excellent health insurance at the time. I think I paid a few hundred bucks to the surgeon and that along with prior expenses filled up my yearly out-of-pocket maximum. I never saw another bill from the hospital)
It probably is; however, it's probably also not being enforced, since no government agency in the US seems to have the teeth or the will to protect consumer rights to the level they are elsewhere.
Also, when they do get a bit too willing, their regulatory activities get shut down or their funding cut because they become a little too visible in the public eye (who has a negative view of government agencies and federal employees in general). Very few government agencies have the courage to take actions that might end up on Washington Post etc.
1) refuse to answer if it is covered by insurance because they have so many providers they won't know.
2) a "3rd party" like a MRI tech that is not in network
I spent the better part of 5 years resolving it; I got them a check from my previous health insurer at year 1 when I got the notice, but since they had already sent it to collections - and I had denied the debt they never removed it from my file; then they changed billing 3rd party providers. So i spent 4 years calling once a year -- until I called an administrator for 2 weeks straight until she got fed up and fixed it.
Yeah, but what would you pay in taxes in a country with universal healthcare? In Maryland, I pay a similar total tax rate on a top 1% income as our German au pair did at her entry level desk job. Germany’s tax to gdp ratio is 39%. Ours is just 28%.
Recently I'm getting it with the stupid "anesthesia is billed separate from the surgery" nonsense. At least this time I noticed the bill. Why is that not a single bill, though? Imagine having to pay the cook, cleaner, server, and attendants all separately. So frustrating.