News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by jimbob45 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:51PM (#38956862)
Really need the government to start heavily penalizing companies who lay people off. Layoffs can't be a tool for a company to get ahead financially. We're ruining lives and triggering suicides with these layoffs.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by HammadB on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:59PM (#38957016)
I don't think its the role of the government to penalize layoffs. If a company needs to do a layoff to remain viable it must be allowed to - the downside (everyone loses their job) is worse. And trying to apply some mechanism where the government decides if its ok or not seems too intractable.

I think the approach of things like the WARN (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_Adjustment_and_Retraini...) act are more plausible. Use legislation to make the workforce more informed, resilient and ahead-of layoffs. You don't want mass layoffs crippling your economy because people are unable to plan.

It's a direct consequence of the WARN act that most tech layoffs have extremely generous severance.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by wombatpm on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:10PM (#38957221)
So should companies be prohibited from doing stock buybacks or paying dividends for some period of time if they do a layoff. Or should they be required to rehire laid off workers before doing any new hiring? When it’s truly about maintaining company viability, I have some sympathy for the corporate position. But companies reporting increasing or record profits AND doing layoffs smells of financial engineering and socializing costs while privatizing profits.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by tonystubblebine on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:28PM (#38957519)
Isn’t it net good that tech companies regularly overhire? I’d be afraid that too much regulation would end up making companies hesitant to hire in the first place. And why are we asking companies to act as charities here. That’s so against their nature. Tax them instead and have government improve the safety net.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by mathiasgredal on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:26PM (#38957497)
Why not just tax stock buybacks the same or higher than regular profits? This would force companies to either increase R&D/CAPEX spending or lower prices.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by Madmallard on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:35PM (#38957653)
That’s because it is. It is degenerate inhumane latestage capitalism garbage.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by lorstic on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:26PM (#38957486)
> If a company needs to do a layoff to remain viable it must be allowed to

What makes you think that's why most of these tech companies are laying people off?

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by HammadB on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:10PM (#38962162)
I don't think that - I am speaking generally.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by davidw on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:58PM (#38957005)
Or, instead of the government dictating those kinds of company decisions, put in place a system so that you're ok if you do get laid off, like a real health care system that is not linked to your place of employment.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by Barrin92 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:57PM (#38958047)
>put in place a system so that you're ok if you do get laid off

the being laid off part itself takes a huge mental toll, regardless of material circumstances. There's a reason the mental health of phd candidates and a good chunk of white collar workers in nominally lucrative professions is in the gutter. The hire and fire hamster wheel is in itself completely pathological. The industry just has done a really fantastic job of marketing permanent insecurity and precarity as individual choice.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by fwip on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:40PM (#38959557)
Sure, but the threat of losing your house, and the ability to feed, clothe, and care for your family, is also a pretty big stressor.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by davidw on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:54PM (#38962007)
Yeah, you have a point... it's trickier to figure out a good way to create stability without also creating genuinely harmful rigidity too, though. I lived in Italy for a long while and you do see a lot of negative effects. People stay in jobs they hate because they have landed a permanent position. Companies reticent to hire because they're stuck with you.

I agree that a lot of US companies have behaved very poorly and casually with people's lives.

I guess I just see stuff like health care as easy wins. The rest of it is trickier.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by paxys on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:34PM (#38957635)
The question we really need to ask is – why are people driven to bankruptcy and suicide because of their employment situation? Why can't everyone have a cushion so they aren't reliant on their next paycheck to have food and shelter? Why can't everyone have healthcare? Why can't we have reasonable vacations, sabbaticals, maternity/paternity leaves? These are the issues government should be solving. And when they do, companies should happily lay off as many people as they want as frequently as they want.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by milanvrekic on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:55PM (#38958006)
That severance package is quite generous. "Why can't everyone have a cusshion" = because someone has to pay for it.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by paxys on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:13PM (#38958308)
Not everyone is getting laid off from Google. Most people are handed their last paycheck and shown the door.

As for "someone has to pay for it", well we already are. We have the highest per capita healthcare spending in the world, also the highest rate of medical-related bankruptcies in the world and lowest life expectancy in the developed world. We are putting 6-12% of our paycheck into social security and will likely never see a payout when we need it. Different industrial sectors are getting hundreds of billions in subsidies. The military is getting trillions.

The money is there, we just need to have the will to spend it to everyone's benefit. But no, we'd rather set it on fire instead so the wrong people don't accidentally get helped.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by fwip on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:39PM (#38959520)
The rich man points at the destitute man's donation cup, and tells the poor man, "Look! That guy's stealing your money!"
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by rqtwteye on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:39PM (#38957729)
I don't think penalizing will work. I think government shouldn't constantly inflate bubbles where companies have way too much investment money so they constantly overhire until the shit hits the fan. It would have been better to slowly more away from the low interest rates over the last decade.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by peter_l_downs on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:52PM (#38956886)
How would this work? Would companies be unable to fire people except for rule violations?
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by yladiz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:00PM (#38957052)
It’s not exactly related to the parent, but in many parts of Europe, yeah, you can’t just fire someone after the probation period, and the firing needs to be for cause (which is genuinely a high bar to cross).

To the point of the parent, in a lot of Europe it’s not so simple to just lay off some small portion of the company. It needs to be justified and a decent percentage, and employees are often entitled to some compensation (some severance) to offset the layoff.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by yreg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:13PM (#38957264)
Yeah, obviously depends from country to country, but for a layoff the company often has to be in some problems. It's difficult to do a layoff when you have record profits.

Of course there are other ways to fire employees but those have their own rules.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by yladiz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:32PM (#38957592)
Right. My point is that the company can’t just say “we’re not doing well, we need to get rid of a few people” and do a layoff with impunity. They have to lay off a pretty decent amount of people (in some cases like 30%) and they need to pay severance to the laid off employees. In most of Europe it’s basically a tool of last resort besides going bankrupt, unlike in the states where it’s easier and done somewhat regularly.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by flavius29663 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:00PM (#38957049)
maybe don't allow them to hire any visa employee for the next x years? That would make them much more careful with layoffs.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by estebank on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:11PM (#38957235)
There are already restrictions on visa and employer sponsored green card applications for 6 months after a layoff, iirc.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by flavius29663 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:12PM (#38960066)
should extend to H1b, J class visas and others, and for longer than 6 months, maybe 2 years. Give other companies a chance of getting those people, htey just proved they cannot manage them properly.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by estebank on Friday January 12, 2024 @11:24AM (#38969983)
Blocking the EB GC applications of an employer that had layoffs screws over the employee, not the employer. If anything, the employer gets to have that employee tied to them for that additional time, regardless of the desires of the employee to move on.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by anotherhue on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:59PM (#38957024)
No fault layoff == 50% salary severance would help align incentives.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by pwb25 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:50PM (#38958848)
if you have millions in cash why would you ever fire someone except that?
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by Scarblac on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:25PM (#38957466)
Simple, only allow them after top management takes a heavy decrease in compensation.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by kbd on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:56PM (#38956947)
More government is not the solution to all problems.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by symlinkk on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:51PM (#38956877)
That would slow down hiring.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:17PM (#38960158)
Maybe that's a good thing?

Companies need to stop defining growth in terms of head count and instead in terms of revenue and profit and learn that just because you have access to money doesn't mean you should go on a hiring frenzy.

Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by EA-3167 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:03PM (#38957090)
There's already a known way to combat these sorts of things... they're called unions. Tech jobs will be a lot more stable and bearable when more people understand that, and that we aren't all embarrassed millionaires.
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by r053bud on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:52PM (#38956885)
The government is totally disinterested in penalizing companies for this. How else will it keep a healthy well-supplied reserve army of labour?
Re:Discord is laying off 17 percent of employees by rchaud on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:58PM (#38959844)
It's shareholder capitalism. On one hand, you get stock options in your comp that might be worth a lot. On the other, you could get booted if it means that the company's earnings per share beats Wall St estimates.