But they were asking about its effectiveness in northern climates during winter (which I also live in). It sounds like your answer is: "it doesn't work there". If so, that's fine, we can focus on other approaches in such climates.
What seems like an emerging shortsighted opinion (on HN at least) is: "it's so cheap, just use more". That doesn't really work when: - you're in a place that gets a small fraction of solar radiation during the winter - it's often overcast - the requirement for electricity for heat pumps goes up drastically during this time - the nighttime requirement is even higher, as temps can get to -20 C or lower
I can't imagine the system you'd have to build to satisfy such demand with solar and battery (or similar) storage in the worst case, but I don't imagine it's "cheap".
"I don't get why solar is so popular" based on the fact it doesn't work as well in extreme Northern regions where only a tiny fraction of the world's population lives.
That's sort of like saying I don't get why boats/ships are so popular because they can't drive on land.
And yes, I think we can all agree that Solar works well where .. it works well.
The issue is many folks are pronouncing it as some kind of a panacea. The reality is that there's a lot of places where it's marginal (and needs effective dispatchable fallbacks) and others where it's just not suitable. Luckily there's comparatively few people that live in those places, so it won't make much of a difference on the environmental bottom line. But for folks like me, these distinctions are important.
And "just add more solar" actually isn't a great idea, as it reduces the ROI on each panel, and there's a minimum amount of dispatchable capacity you need to keep online anyway. Sounds like it really does come down to storage at that level, most of which is still progressing to full productization.
There are three ways you can have winter power with PV when you're close to but south of the arctic circle:
1. more cells, which is basically fine because of the very low population density and the cheap cells.
2. storage, which you have to be careful about regardless, because (no matter how you actually store it) a month's worth of energy supply in stored form is an industrial accident waiting to happen, even if you're storing it as a petrochemical that we already have standards for.
3. transmission, which is basically fine for everyone except Russia and North Korea, because everyone else far from the equator has decent trade relations with someone closer, sometimes (US, China) it's another place inside the same country. And yes, although it would take a while to build, the losses from HVDC are low enough that this makes sense on paper.
> I can't imagine the system you'd have to build to satisfy such demand with solar and battery (or similar) storage in the worst case, but I don't imagine it's "cheap".
Correct, but this is why so few people live in those parts of the world in the first place: getting stuff there, and staying warm there in winter, is and always has been harder.
I have a dynamic energy contract, I pay spot prices + taxes and markup. What solar energy I sell in the summer, I can buy in the winter. With our heat pump, I need to generate about twice as much as I did before we had the heat pump, to match it in money (summer is cheaper than winter at the moment). Watt for watt is not a useful measurement IMO, since I can't store Watts, but I can store euros.
We're talking aviation industry as a reasonable equivilance here, not magical anti-grav machines.
Reddit is really the venue for eponymous comments.
Just like anti-gravity machine, neither breaks the laws of physics, and neither has any known method for an engineer to implement.
Currently, you either need preposterous quantity of batteries, or you are stuck creating synthetic/green fuels at efficiencies of ~20% or less.
> In more northern regions, you get much less light in the winter. You effectively can only generate around one tenth of the energy you can in the summer - this is from experience talking to others who monitor their solar installations.
When we looked at installing solar on our house in Sweden the calculations showed that in winter we'd produce about 20% of the power IIRC. I just had a look for a source and I could only found this [1] which might be more like 10%. That said Sweden is quite extreme, all of the US save Alaska get much more sunlight in winter.
[1] https://adelsfors.se/2022/12/29/solar-vs-wind-power-in-swede...
Every kWh from solar is one kWh less from fossil fuels. It seems inevitable that electricity becomes free when there's sun, because of solar.
Electricity demand in summer in the US is far higher than winter due to air conditioning.
Moreover, most of the utility-scale solar generation capacity isn't in the Northern US.
Though that would be putting all your eggs in one basket.
Furthermore Arizona could be too hot and dusty to be ideal. Solar panels work best when they are unobstructed and not too hot.
Northern areas tend to use fossil fuels for heating at higher rates, and less heat pumps.
One point of disagreement is that you are saying "you need more energy in the winter". Right now, for example, tomato paste is made in a facility that runs year round. The main cost in converting tomatoes into tomato paste is in the thermal cost of energy. Having abundant cheap energy at one time of year will shift the way such industrial processes work so that we use more energy when supply is the highest rather than using the most energy when demand is the highest.
That would require leaving a lot of capital idle, while is itself wasteful from both an economic and environmental perspective.
It's a little complicated because of time of use, and it's unclear if net metering or feed-in rates will continue.
While Ireland has a good chunk of renewables, mainly wind, our electricity rates are still driven by gas import prices, so they're 2x what they were a couple years ago.
In more northern regions, you get much less light in the winter. You effectively can only generate around one tenth of the energy you can in the summer - this is from experience talking to others who monitor their solar installations.
But, you need more energy in the winter. People are in more, using electricity for heat cos it's colder. I'm pointing out that there is a supply/demand reversal. Sure there are sweet spots in spring and autumn, but when you really need energy, you have less.
You can mitigate some minor fluctuations with batteries.... Ie you can smoothen things a bit, but you can't really take the summer's excess, to use in the winter.
It just seems like a fundamental mismatch, that leaves you exposed, when you need the most amount of support.