News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by boxed on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:43AM (#38949940)
That the international community hasn't recognized Somaliland is a travesty.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by christophilus on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:28AM (#38951323)
Aside: Sincere question: I see travesty used in this manner a lot, and I'm never sure what it means. Did you mean tragedy? Is there some common meaning to travesty, like maybe it's a truncation of "travesty of justice" or something?

From Webster's dictionary, travesty means:

1. a debased, distorted, or grossly inferior imitation (example: "a travesty of justice")

2. a burlesque translation or literary or artistic imitation usually grotesquely incongruous in style, treatment, or subject matter

Anyway, I'm not being pedantic-- I really feel like I'm missing something, since I frequently see it used without any subsequent qualifications, and I never know what it's supposed to mean when it's a standalone word.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by toyg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:30AM (#38951936)
It's your n.1, although the object is assumed. In this case, it stands for something like "a travesty of justice in international relations". The writer assumes that certain processes should work in certain ways to produce certain outputs, and sees the current situation as something that a working system should not produce.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by boxed on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:07AM (#38952329)
I mean, it fits both honestly. It's a mockery of the ideals international cooperation should stand for. The word is used like this a lot and that's why I use the word like this. Just like I use "chair" for the thing I sit on :P
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by genieyclo on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:01AM (#38950105)
Nothing to recognize, just 3 towns in north Somalia with a weird fetish for their old colonial masters. The territory Muse Bihi wants to give away to Ethiopia is famous for their Somali patriotism and is holding huge daily protests against this nonsense from Hargeisa.

Ethiopia will stay landlocked, no matter what war criminals like Muse Bihi or Abiye Ahmed desire.

[dead]
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by ffgjgf1 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:10AM (#38951740)
Is there is other way to describe what was going on in Tigray?
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by genieyclo on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:04AM (#38950616)
Yes, Muse Bihi is a war criminal who has the blood of tens of thousands on his hands from wars stretching back to the 90s in north Somalia. His indiscriminate bombing of Laascaanood over the last year is just a continuation of the failed tribal Somaliland project.

Abiye Ahmed is a war criminal who has committed crimes against humanity in his attacks across Ethiopia, including genocide in Tigray. All of this is well-documented.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by rashthedude on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:58AM (#38952220)
Let us not throw around baseless claims and tarnish the image of individuals who you deem to view in a certain light.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by DialMarshalls on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:10AM (#38950170)
Why? Whether historically right or wrong, Somaliland is officially a part of Somalia. Granting diplomatic recognition to what is essentially a breakaway region seems counterproductive when Somalia is still recovering from decades of civil war.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bawolff on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:01AM (#38951661)
I think we should recognize the reality of the situation not what whatever group wants it to be.

Does somaliland have independent control of the land they claim? That should be what matters.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by inglor_cz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:46AM (#38952093)
"I think we should recognize the reality of the situation not what whatever group wants it to be."

I am not so certain. Do we recognize Crimea or Mariupol as Russian, because they are de facto under Russian control?

In case of pure self-determination, which is the case of Somaliland, there may be an exception. But a totally realistic approach gives bad actors one more incentive to conquer their neighbours by force.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by boxed on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:03AM (#38952270)
> Do we recognize Crimea or Mariupol as Russian, because they are de facto under Russian control?

The situations are quite different though. Somaliland is a real functional country in every reasonable definition of the word (unlike Somalia!).

Somaliland is also an established military fact of self determination, not an occupying external force.

East Timor is a much closer and more reasonable comparison.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by edgyquant on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:17AM (#38952438)
Russia is also a real country
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by mcv on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:20AM (#38952477)
But their control of Crimea is conquest, not requested by the people of Crimea.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by inglor_cz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:27AM (#38952578)
Well they try very hard to assert the opposite, using that fraudulent referendum as a cover.

Even within Russia proper, "we just crushed them with our might and so they are ours" would be unpalatable to the population. Folks must believe in the rightneousness of their Tsar.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bawolff on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:49PM (#38957876)
Unpopular opinion, but i kind of think yes.

I might not like that russia controls crimea, but wishful thinking isn't going to change that.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by inglor_cz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:33PM (#38959440)
It is not that much about facts on the ground, rather than about diplomatic consequences thereof.

Currently, there are sanctions and other punishing measures enacted against Russia because it occupies someone else's territory. Once you say, well, they conquered it, its theirs, there isn't really a reason why not to normalize the relations. It's theirs, end of story.

Now this used to be the international norm prior to the Briand and Kellogg pact: might was right and conquered territories were ruled by the right of the conqueror. We would just revert to that previous standard, which was fairly ancient.

I would, nevertheless, consider such reversion unwise. It rewards aggression against neighbours and thus increases the likelihood of wars. Combined with current weapons, which are far more destructive than 100 years ago, it is a game with fire where the entire globe is at stake. In a world where might makes right, runaway nuclear proliferation is well possible.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bawolff on Friday January 12, 2024 @12:48AM (#38964429)
The other side of this though is it leads to frozen conflicts that never resolve. The aggressor side can never take the land so the conqoured side has no incentive to negotiate a peace as that can only diminish their position. (As a random example, take the golan heights in israel vs syria, its been in limbo for 57 years now and shows no sign of ever being resolved)

I mean, i dont know if its worse for the conqouring side to just win the land, but having stuff stay in limbo for decades also seems counterproductive to healing conflicts and moving forward. closure can be beneficial even if its towards a result we don't want.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by mcv on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:18AM (#38952463)
What should really matter is what the people who live there want. From what I understand, they've had a referendum about that a long time ago, and the vast majority supported independence.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by resolutebat on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:48AM (#38950475)
(British) Somaliland was briefly independent before it chose to join Somalia. I don't see why they can't just choose to leave again.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bawolff on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:04AM (#38951687)
Even if it wasn't, regions secede. Its not like the set of countries and borders is permenently fixed and its impossible to make new ones.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bombcar on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:21AM (#38952494)
The only universal thing countries seem to agree on is that they’re really really really don’t like to encourage secession.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by bawolff on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:47PM (#38957851)
They agree they dont like it when it happens to themselves. They typically don't mind when it happens to other countries (see for example the UN's position on self-detrrmination)
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by baud147258 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:22AM (#38951860)
I think international institutions are wary of recognizing any breakaway state, because they want to avoid encouraging copycat attempts elsewhere.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by toyg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:37AM (#38951999)
Correct. The Wilson Doctrine has never been popular among established powers, for obvious reasons. Every country has some wannabe breakaway group, from Texas to Catalunya, from Scotland to South Tyrol, from Corsica to Bavaria, from Kosovo to Kurdistan etc etc. Some claims are somewhat-justified but many (most?) are not.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by DialMarshalls on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:05AM (#38950624)
> (British) Somaliland was briefly independent before it chose to join Somalia.

A valid point. The unification of British and Italian Somaliland is itself a controversial topic.

> I don't see why they can't just choose to leave again.

If it was as simple as separating the two into co-existing countries, then sure Somaliland would have gained international recognition at some point in the last thirty years.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by mcv on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:22AM (#38952504)
So what's the real reason the international community won't recognise it? What reason do they have to keep it part of Somalia?
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by alexey-salmin on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:27AM (#38950304)
> Granting diplomatic recognition to what is essentially a breakaway region seems counterproductive when XXX is still recovering from decades of civil war.

This seem to happen fairly often though

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by knallfrosch on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:50AM (#38950496)
Civil war means that you get shot by "your" "government." I guess it's quite normal to want to break away then. And it's only called a "civil war" because the government can't extend its control to the breakway region. So recognizing that region doesn't actually change that much facts on the ground anyway.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by edgyquant on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:19AM (#38952469)
That’s the definition of a failed state, not all civil wars are fought between with break away territories.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by samus on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:33AM (#38952666)
By gettings its independence recognized, a region becomes a subject of international law though. It can become part of the UN and officially enter alliances and such with other states. The civil would become an international matter and can't be declared a purely domestic affair anymore.

It becomes vastly more easy to bring money into the region and get an independent economy going. It would have its own exterior politics and officially opens it up to the influence of other countries. The state the region seceded from might not be friendly with some of them.

Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by boxed on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:59AM (#38952231)
They have had a democratic government, and controlled their claimed territory for decades. Longer than East Timor has existed for example. And East Timor broke away from a functioning state, while Somaliland is breaking away from a FAILED state, which cannot militarily control even the non-somaliland parts of its claimed territory.
Re:Ethiopia's controversial quest for access to the sea by mcv on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:16AM (#38952428)
Why? South Sudan has also been recognised. Why is Somaliland different? From what I understand, it's been operating independently from Somalia for decades and stayed out of the civil war that wrecked Somalia.