News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by ricardobayes on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:56AM (#38949588)
Layoffs are always counter-productive as going forward employees take fewer risks, to evade being the one laid off. Layoffs kill innovation.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by faeriechangling on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:59AM (#38949602)
Intel is only around today because the leadership was decisive enough to lay off most of the company early in its history, and they then proceeded to release a whack of innovative microprocessor products after these massive layoffs.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by kqr on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:03AM (#38949625)
I don't know whether your comment is true, but the way to do layoffs while keeping innovation as high as possible is to do one round that is big enough that you can and do give guarantees to the employees that are left behind that they have jobs for life. Multiple rounds of layoffs is what really takes your innovation to zero.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by faeriechangling on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:06AM (#38949655)
Well it is true and there's a book which goes into the details, Andy Grove's "Only the Paranoid Survive", and it's a fantastic page turner.

https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/66863

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by hirako2000 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:15AM (#38949727)
Dell has a talent to do the exact opposite. HR should hire your service. But they would fire you since they wouldn't like your advice.

For the defense of big corp, finance is often told a figure as to how many in percentage to layoff. Not much more, not much less or you get added to the list.

CEO? He also has to follow orders.

Who's to blame then? I wonder.

The practice and coordinated moves in the tech industry, and beyond, consistency in the pattern observed (and attested so broadly) led me to believe it is well intentional. Instill fear and anxiety to those who are left so that they stop claiming they deserve a significant raise. Will figure out how to innovate once we've regain control over the main cost: wages.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by kqr on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:00AM (#38950094)
From what I understand, the modern Dell (much like many airlines, for that matter) is in a sort of weird banking/finance business rather than technology and innovation. They are really good at managing capital and that is how they derive much of their profits.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by hirako2000 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @04:03PM (#38984537)
Yes. And while Starbucks offers a decent service, Dell's has rather become absolutely mediocre.

I'm not even sure Dell has been that good at capital management as of late. His last good shot, and an amazing one, was to buy out his own company at a much undervalued price, with plenty of financing support from investment banks. 10 years ago already.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by al_borland on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:34AM (#38950366)
I’ve been through dozens of rounds of layoffs. That part I almost got used to. Staying innovative, and being seen as innovative by my boss, was the way to ensure I wasn’t on that list.

What killed it for me was when new management came in, refused to talk to anyone internal, brought in outside hires to be the innovators and change agents, and then shut down any of the legacy employees who tried to speak or bring ideas to the table. A lot of really talented people have left, and maybe that was the goal, as it avoids having to pay severance.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by trashtester on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:41AM (#38950418)
I wonder if those new coworkers came from the same place as the new management, and were already their "loyal wingmen"....
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by al_borland on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:24PM (#38960246)
Most of them.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by ChatGTP on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:07AM (#38949661)
How is this comparable to Intel? Is Google struggling financially ?
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by andsoitis on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:31AM (#38949843)
Their profit has been declining rapidly the last two years, so they’re cutting costs to turn things around. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38949755
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by faeriechangling on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:49AM (#38950001)
Funny. Here I was abandoning their products because they don't SUPPORT them. I dare say Google could have easily used their laid off staff to better maintain their existing products and through that restore confidence in their products and be able to achieve higher sales and profit margins.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by andsoitis on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:59AM (#38950088)
Maybe. Of course it is up to them to decide strategy.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by oblio on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:15AM (#38950710)
Compared to Covid boom years... let's normalize the Covid years to their past trend and add the 2022 and 2023 data points as regular years. I'm sure they'd look just fine.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by bdd8f1df777b on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:00AM (#38949612)
Is that sarcasm?
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by pavlov on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:04AM (#38949641)
It's what happened. Intel was primarily a manufacturer of DRAM memory chips in the early 1980s. They pivoted hard to CPUs instead when it started looking like the IBM PC clone platform is a winner and their 386 chip could define the industry.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by pi-e-sigma on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:16AM (#38951223)
So what is Google pivoting from? They are laying people off from various divisions, it's not a strategic shift
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by hajile on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:46PM (#38960545)
Intel pivoted because they couldn't keep up with Asian RAM makers in the race to the bottom.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by ffgjgf1 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:04AM (#38949643)
What do you mean?
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by UncleMeat on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:45AM (#38952077)
There are definitely cases where companies have true existential risk and layoffs can help get them through that.

That's not Google. Instead, this means that now I need to go have a fire drill where I figure out who has been fired on all the teams I collaborate with and figure out how that fucks with my team's 2024 plans that are getting reviewed and finalized basically right now. I need to deal with the morale killer that is another layoff at just about the one year anniversary of the big one last year when memories of layoffs were on just about everybody's mind anyway.

I don't know anybody in Assistant, but when I read this headline I assume that the reason there are layoffs there is because Google wants more people working on new LLM hotness and is unable to naturally transition people from Assistant onto Bard or whatever so they are just firing a bunch of people in Assistant to free up budget to hire people working on LLMs. That's not a mechanism for saving the company. That is covering up for shitty management and incentive structures that can't get people working on the stuff they want without this sort of extreme action.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by htrp on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:09AM (#38954113)
> I don't know anybody in Assistant, but when I read this headline I assume that the reason there are layoffs there is because Google wants more people working on new LLM hotness and is unable to naturally transition people from Assistant onto Bard or whatever so they are just firing a bunch of people in Assistant to free up budget to hire people working on LLMs. That's not a mechanism for saving the company. That is covering up for shitty management and incentive structures that can't get people working on the stuff they want without this sort of extreme action.

Which makes absolutely no sense because a ton of the DialogFlow data would make google's version of an llm much much better than whatever was offered by anybody else.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by tgma on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:34AM (#38949873)
This is patently false. Tons of empirical evidence of organizations that have improved and innovated much more effectively.

The world’s most valuable company comes to mind.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by oblio on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:17AM (#38950729)
The world's most valuable company (Apple, I assume?) wasn't the world's fifth most profitable company in ANY field when they did that, though.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by okokwhatever on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:43AM (#38949941)
The guy is talking about slow dead. The kind of company dead IBM or Oracle? are facing since decades.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by steveridout on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:30AM (#38949839)
Interesting point but I don't think it's that clear cut. Twitter/X seemed to increase the pace of product changes directly after laying of the majority of its employees after Elon Musk took over. Also, when Steve Jobs returned to lead apple in 1997 he fired a significant fraction of the company before starting an incredible period of innovation. So I think a lot depends on the leadership and incentive structures.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by kalleboo on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:46AM (#38950456)
Both of those examples started with laying off basically all of top management.

If you’re just laying off engineers to meet some profitability measure for Wall Street then you’re not going to fix innovation. You need to replace all of management who are the ones who are in charge of what the engineers are doing.

Google is completely lost and doesn’t know what it does. Management launches new products just to look good and shuts them down a year later, and still the only thing making money is search and ads. That’s not going to be fixed by laying off engineers.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by sabellito on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:34AM (#38949872)
Twitter has lost 70% of its value since Elon took over.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by baq on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:00AM (#38950589)
Which it only had because Musk thrown out a number and people fought very very hard to make him stick to it. If he wasn't such a dumbass and forfeit due diligence, this wouldn't be the story.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by infotainment on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:56AM (#38950070)
Important business lessons from Twitter: try not to antagonize your biggest customers, because they might stop buying your products.

In addition, if this occurs, make sure to blame external factors or wide-ranging conspiracies.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by trashtester on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:44AM (#38950435)
Another lesson: Don't ignore the users, as one of them may get angry enough to buy your company and fire you and most of your peers.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by baq on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:01AM (#38950599)
Another important lesson: do your DD when you buy a company
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by tgma on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:27AM (#38950299)
According to rando analysts who don't have a stake. Note that Twitter pre X as a business was unsustainable and I don't think it ever made a net profit in aggregate over its lifetime. It was all selling the dream even before the acquisition.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by oblio on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:20AM (#38950748)
> According to rando analysts who don't have a stake.

Says another rando who doesn't have a stake.

It was starting to be sustainable: https://www.businessofapps.com/data/twitter-statistics/

I don't know exactly what they did in 2020 to mess up their numbers, but 2017 - 2021 shows a company that was stabilizing at ok profit margins.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by tgma on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:42AM (#38954644)
You state that as if your link does not substantiate what I said earlier. For the benefit of the people who don’t click on the link you cite, it simply proves as I said, that they never made an aggregate profit over their lifetime and you are linearly extrapolating the past (“starting to become…”) coming into the high interest rate environment where peers like $FB and $SNAP crashed and Twitter would surely have too.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by lapcat on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:23AM (#38951280)
> Twitter/X seemed to increase the pace of product changes directly after laying of the majority of its employees after Elon Musk took over.

Changes? Yes. Often superficial changes. Change "Twitter" to "X", change blue checkmarks to yellow or gray or whatever, and sell blue to the lowest bidders. As for improvements? No, I haven't seen Twitter improve much if at all since the acquisition. In fact, the removal of third-party clients for example was a gross vandalization of the service.

> Also, when Steve Jobs returned to lead apple in 1997 he fired a significant fraction of the company before starting an incredible period of innovation.

This quip misses the biggest part of the story, which is that Apple didn't cut its way to success but rather acquired NeXT for over $400 million, a massive investment at the time, and Steve was merely replacing the old guard with his people.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by nusl on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:05AM (#38950128)
Twitter laid most of their staff off then Musk gave them an ultimatum of: commit every day, all day, sleep at the office, to Twitter, or get fired. I wonder why there was more work produced in that period.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by fifteen1506 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:59AM (#38950568)
Maybe because most are on H-1B and thus have no other option than to sacrifice personal life to have a job and not be deported?
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by ndepoel on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:32AM (#38949853)
Not just innovation, but layoffs are also devastating to the morale of the employees who are allowed to stay. This I feel is a factor that managers tend to grossly overlook when planning mass layoffs.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by tarruda on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:07AM (#38949660)
> employees take fewer risks

Like going to the masseur during working hours?

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by rrr_oh_man on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:18AM (#38949746)
Like working on things for internal visibility and ad revenue, not because it’s a good idea
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by cqqxo4zV46cp on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:47AM (#38949978)
That is an issue of maligned incentives, not layoffs. This community is utterly insane sometimes, and I say that as a staunch unionist. This is literally Google, a company with an insanely large number of engineers, doing an insanely large number of different things, due to massive and clearly-net-bad-for-society consolidation, and there’ll still be hoards of people that’ll claim that the layoffs were the wrong thing to do.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by karmarepellent on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:48AM (#38949990)
I am not advocating for this but you could turn that argument easily around: Not laying off people makes them feel very secure which does not incentivice them to take risks and innovate either. At least when they are no inherently driven to push their careers forward.

Edit: To expand on my comment: At my company the problem with missing innovation is not related to layoffs (which do not happen, thankfully). But rather that hiring is very slow as management thinks teams need to "earn" those additional resources by innovating instead of the other way around: hiring people that are willing to innovate.

Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by zensayyy on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:44AM (#38950438)
must disagree. A bloated company is the killer of innovation. Job security is no indicator for innovation. In fact, the most unsecure job produce the most innovative Tech (see Startups).
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by lobsterthief on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:44AM (#38950955)
This viewport is very misleading. Startups don’t produce the most innovative tech _because_ they’re less secure.
Re:Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions by trashtester on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:13AM (#38965437)
In a way, it's natural selection that drives evolution, by removing the unfit genes from the gene pool. This is arguably more important than mutation, and mutations would accumulate to be catastrophic over time without natural selection.

Startups that survive tend to be more innovative than other companies because other, less innovative startups were less secure than comparable departments within larger corporations that were also low on innovation.

The death of all replicators is unchecked random entropy.