News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by aestetix on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:40AM (#38892290)
> while the bits posted to social media could be interpreted as “inflammatory,”

Did anyone actually find them inflammatory, or was the justification that "someone" "might" find them inflammatory? If some individual raised a complaint that's one thing, but sounds like a massive overreaction.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by gotoeleven on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:33AM (#38892785)
Why does this distinction matter? It only takes one hypersensitive nut to find something inflammatory which is quite a low bar. This kind of nonsense needs to be dismissed on the merits regardless of how many blue hairs find it inflammatory.

Remember a few years ago when there was one of these woke dustups about using the word master for git branches?

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by aestetix on Saturday January 06, 2024 @01:33PM (#38893875)
The distinction matters because it is the difference between random hypotheticals and real world events. To draw an analogy: should the TSA assume everyone might have a weapon and do a "special" search on every airline passenger, or wait until there is evidence that someone has a weapon (such as using an x-ray) and then escalate?

I'm sure you could potentially find someone to be offended by even the most tame Dad joke, but that doesn't mean you should stop telling Dad jokes.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by krsrhe on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:15AM (#38899510)
The term "dad joke" is already promoting a stereotype.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by praptak on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:20AM (#38899533)
Is it a harmful stereotype though?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by danmur on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:22AM (#38899546)
I remember having to rename all our branches but when I asked whether the term 'master data' should also be retired there were crickets. No that one's different
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by pydry on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:38AM (#38899859)
Microsoft pulled that branch bullshit to deflect from the flak it got for wanting to keep ICE as a customer from its employees.

Ever since then Ive kind of considered renaming master to main to be a symbol not of one's sensitivity to "problematic language" but of trying to be "woke" while refusing to boycott concentration camps.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by ttyprintk on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:07AM (#38901267)
Their job descriptions still say Masters Degrees rather than something like Better Degrees.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by blipvert on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:49AM (#38899657)
It’s always useful to remember Mike Godwin’s (of Godwin’s law fame) analysis of the use of the word “woke”:

“Drawing Bayesian inferences after extensive sampling, I've determined that it's 99-percent certain that anyone who uses "woke" as pejorative will turn out to be a fuckhead. Please don't blame me for pointing this out--it's just science.”

https://twitter.com/sfmnemonic/status/1504687870006620163?la...

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by istultus on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:58AM (#38899694)
Two fallacies in one, nice.

First an appeal to authority. And then Godwin himself with a salience bias - since the socials have a tendency to present only the extreme voices, it's not a good place to sample, no matter what statistical framework you use.

But since the word itself is controversial (including what it means) it makes perfect sense never to use it, as Ackman for example successfully did in his spiel, only referring to DEI by name.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by andrepd on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:15AM (#38900608)
Humour is not your strong suit, that much is clear :)
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by MeImCounting on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:32AM (#38899826)
I remember when the term "woke" used to refer to taking too many psychedelic mushrooms and having a "transcendent experience"

How far we have fallen

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by leereeves on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:21AM (#38900647)
Calling people who disagree with you 'fuckheads' is really not appropriate here, and doing so by quoting an intermediary doesn't make it better.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by blipvert on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:28AM (#38900683)
I shall pass on your sentiments to Mr. Godwin
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by leereeves on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:32AM (#38900707)
He posted that on X, the ex-Twitter, where that kind of behavior is entirely appropriate (for better or worse). You posted it here, where that behavior is not appropriate. If you really want to engage in childish snark, there are lots of sites that welcome it.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by blipvert on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:38AM (#38900745)
Duly noted. I shall add a trigger warning next time for the snowflakes who are offended by inappropriate words.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by leereeves on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:41AM (#38900765)
Why not just read the guidelines, try to follow them, and help raise the signal to noise ratio of discussion here?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by chongli on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:41AM (#38899623)
The courts rarely use such a low bar. The test is usually the reasonable person or “the man on the street.” Does a reasonable person find them inflammatory?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by imadierich on Sunday January 07, 2024 @05:02AM (#38899946)
the average person was not this unreasonable just 7 years ago
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by chongli on Sunday January 07, 2024 @06:58AM (#38900507)
The "reasonable person" from law is not an average or typical person. It's an idealized person who doesn't change very much over time because the concept is rooted in common law. The average or typical person can change dramatically as social norms and movements go, but common law moves very slowly by accumulation of precedent.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by ttyprintk on Sunday January 07, 2024 @08:58AM (#38901215)
I think that’s his point: the legal fiction goes back to Roman law and is specifically invariant when used for questions of constitutional equality or egalitarianism.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by andrepd on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:14AM (#38900597)
Ah the classic view of history that ends with the speaker's personal experience... :)

Where to begin? Not that long ago black men were lynched for looking at white women wrong, in (supposedly) the country of freedom.

Unfortunately it's not true that we are living in a particularly exceptional time.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by atlantic on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:28AM (#38900682)
Personal experience is useful. All kinds of groups were mistreated, historically speaking. If we keep pulling up old grievances, society remains perpetually divided. How many lynchings did you witness yourself? Or hear from first-hand witnesses?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by drabbiticus on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:11AM (#38902349)
I think you have a point, and I have often felt the same way. However, it gets very murky when deciding where the line of "currently relevant" gets drawn versus what is just "historical". There are so many factors, including whether or not it feels that an injustice was ever addressed in a meaningful way by a population that continues to identify with and evangelize the perpetrators of that injustice.

How many firings for presumed inflammatory conduct have you witnessed or hear from first-hand witnesses? Personally, I've been fortunate not to have experienced any of these, but I do believe they exist and reading about them is useful for informing my worldview. It's helpful to understand how corporations and institutions are ingesting and digesting societal trends around evolving cultural awareness of injustice in order to protect their commercial interests.

Very serious injustices have occurred within the recent past. Take, for example the 1985 MOVE Bombing, in which Philadelphia police bombed a house in a predominantly black neighborhood during an armed standoff with the MOVE group. Whether or not you feel the bombing of an armed group was a justified use of force by police, the subsequent 61 homes that were allowed to burn down are harder to justify. This was followed by the ethically fraught decision by the Philadelphia Health Commissioner to cremate/dispose of any human remains without contacting family members, with the ultimate result that those remains were used in UPenn and Princeton "forensic anthropology" courses without any chance for their families to reclaim their remains.

More recently, I personally witnessed Philadelphia police corral Black Lives Matter protesters into an enclosed space on the side of the highway with no exits and fire tear gas into the crowd. On the news, I watched a number of similar confrontations take place in multiple cities in the nation.

When inequality continues, I have come to appreciate that the ability to feel that a grievance is historical is a privilege. A significant motivation for people to turn to history is to better understand the struggles through which they are currently living. For these people, understanding the historical context is not a way to bring up old grievances, it is a lens through which they can properly understand how systematic disparities in due process and access have produced today's injustices. It is an aid to better identify how currently extant systems create unfair conditions at a large scale.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by atlantic on Monday January 08, 2024 @06:19PM (#38919874)
Nobody is privileged in absolute terms. Everybody has their own troubles. Groups (racial, social, whatever) are a useful abstraction, not a reality. And if anyone has to compensate anybody for anything, that's what the justice system is for.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by drabbiticus on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:58AM (#38922901)
I agree that nobody is privileged in absolute terms, and do not feel that your statement conflicts with anything I have written. We seem to also agree that abstractions can be useful, but perhaps disagree on whether or not the "realness" of a concept must necessarily be related to the capacity for that concept have effects on society and on real people that may be beneficial or harmful.

The justice system is ideally intended to provide fair and impartial justice, but I think it's also fair and reasonable to point out when it falls short of that ideal. In fact, in a democratic society, I would argue that an informed and vocal public is a necessary component of keeping institutions accountable to the people.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by drabbiticus on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @01:07AM (#38922950)
Shout out to the downvoters by the way.

Very odd that people who want thicker skin in our culture would find it so distasteful that I've simply shared some recent history and some first-hand personal experience without any particular name calling or inflammatory remarks. Can't a person share their thoughts anymore? Really didn't mean to offend anybody and somewhat surprised that I have seemed to.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by shermantanktop on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:15PM (#38903013)
IMO, human nature has not changed, culture at large has not radically shifted, and the world is not coming to an end. This is just wide-tie/skinny-tie stuff.

But many people have said essentially the same thing, over the course of many years. I think there’s a moment for each of us when we realize that our worldview isn’t substantially similar to that of others anymore, especially younger people.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by op00to on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:15AM (#38901336)
If you read the source document, you’d understand why the bar is set at that particular level.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by ttyprintk on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:23AM (#38901397)
I see the role of the arbitrator a little differently here: the workplace definition is geared for an employee who posts inflammatory things and then hides behind the “just kidding, you uppity types have no sense of humor” with a wink. They tried to use it on a comedian and got slapped down-independent of whether he was funny, he was foremost a comedian, not just an asshole hiding behind the defense that a reasonable person understands his trolling post-hoc attempt at comedy.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by redcobra762 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:52AM (#38902216)
Yeah but the classic lawyer joke in response is, “have you ever met a reasonable person?” More often the “reasonable person” is the judge plus half a degree of leeway.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by alpaca128 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @05:09AM (#38899985)
The company found an interpretation that could be inflammatory enough to fire him, which is the only thing they care about. Also their social media policy is not that great apparently:

> The arbitrator said that he read this policy as not incorporating a “reasonable person” standard, meaning that workers “must be vigilant not to post anything on social media that could conceivably be interpreted as inflammatory even by highly sensitive and thin-skinned individuals without an appreciation for irony or satire.”

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by roenxi on Sunday January 07, 2024 @06:40AM (#38900413)
These jokes are definitely inflammatory. It is a brand of humour that identifies things other people think are important then points out that they are ridiculous. His colleagues could be quite upset. I would expect being fired from most tech companies for making the observations in the "Kind of Racist" routine; although I have the wrong skin colour for it so the ice is presumably thinner for me than for him. There is some real girl from HR that was doing that in his company who is probably quite committed to the work.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by master-lincoln on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:28AM (#38900684)
One could argue the steps the HR person did in the "Kind of Racist" sketch are inflammatory themselves... At least in Germany I think it would be unacceptable for an HR person to ask if somebody considers themselves a person of color in an official context.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by op00to on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:14AM (#38901333)
You are asked to self identify race as a part of US employment. I think it’s important to ask people how they view themselves.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by busterarm on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:00AM (#38902273)
But that's to collect statistics for the US Government.

If you as an employer were to take _any_ actions based on that information it would be illegal.

So after you get hired and provide that information for government statistics collection, why would your employer ever need to ask you for it afterwards?

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by davidgay on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:01PM (#38903422)
> So after you get hired and provide that information for government statistics collection, why would your employer ever need to ask you for it afterwards?

Because your employer wants to collect statistics too.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by busterarm on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:27PM (#38906724)
That's the point. Why allow them to? They're barred from any action so there's no good purpose served by having them.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by davidgay on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:30PM (#38907906)
They aren't "barred from any action", they can, e.g., publish reports on those statistics - it sounds like you don't even want the questions to be answerable...
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by ajhurliman on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:28AM (#38902518)
Hot take: it’s not actually important, and dwelling on our differences decreases human well-being
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by andsoitis on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:59AM (#38901721)
Answering is optional, isn’t it?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by edgyquant on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:52AM (#38902214)
In theory, yes. In practice Is it really though?
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by lokar on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:11AM (#38902356)
I have declined at least once, never heard anything about it
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by barry-cotter on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:50AM (#38902193)
If you refuse to answer your employer must by law give their best guess.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by brabel on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:59AM (#38902843)
Why? Who cares about this and what's the reason they must care?? Affirmative action? Race "quotas"?? How do you know it will not be used in the exact opposite manner? It's simply better to treat everyone equally (I know, radical notion) and stop this madness.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by ezrast on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:35PM (#38903176)
What's better is largely unknowable if you're not collecting statistics to measure the impact of policy changes.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by op00to on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:08PM (#38905154)
Really? That’s hilarious!
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by hobs on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:17AM (#38901346)
Usually in the USA its for employers who want to get in on EEOC things is it actually tracked, otherwise its usually right out.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by scotty79 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:23AM (#38901394)
It sounds racist.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by rayiner on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:01AM (#38902277)
> At least in Germany I think it would be unacceptable for an HR person to ask if somebody considers themselves a person of color in an official context.

I’m regularly asked that question in official contexts in the last few years. American companies make hiring decisions now based on racial identification. Big companies even require their vendors and service providers to factor race into staffing decisions.

It’s illegal under American law, but in the last decade or so corporate HR departments have gotten some funny ideas.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by Anthony-G on Sunday January 07, 2024 @08:55PM (#38907391)
Agree. I just submitted a thoughtful - and entertaining – article on this subject by computer scientist, Les Earnest. From the sixties onwards, he identified himself as a mongrel rather than allow himself to be classified by any one meaningless and not-very scientific concept of “race”: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38907226

> in 1966 I discovered that something very good had happened: the race question had disappeared from the security clearance form. In fact, this question disappeared from nearly all government forms then. I liked to think I helped that change along.

> I have argued that all historical and present racial and ethnic classification systems for individuals are nonsensical and so are the laws, court decisions, computer applications, and bureaucratic superstructures that have been built on top of them.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by blairbeckwith on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:02AM (#38900529)
It’s certainly believable that there actually was a real girl who was doing that at his work, but we should also probably stop taking comedic storytelling as truth without question. See: recent Hassan Minhaj controversy, etc.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by tptacek on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:42PM (#38903882)
The HR person that got him fired was a dude.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by StanislavPetrov on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:58PM (#38907735)
>These jokes are definitely inflammatory.

Virtually every good joke could be considered, "inflammatory" by someone.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by andrepd on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:09AM (#38900573)
I'd say it's irrelevant whether it caused "inflammation" or whether it might do so. That in itself is no grounds for any attempt at censorship.

Not very long ago in developed countries "agitating for women's suffrage" or "kissing a person of the same sex" or "a white woman marrying a black man" would be inflammatory. In many places it still is.

Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by op00to on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:13AM (#38901320)
The justification, if you read the source document, is that it could possibly be found inflammatory to the most thin skinned person.
Re:Radio reporter fired over jokes is reinstated after arbit... by throwaway0x4 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:56PM (#38904032)
Which has been used as a bat to stamp down anything and everything. Someone out there must be offended, so please do what I demand.