News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by hubraumhugo on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:23AM (#38892142)
It's hard for foreigners to grasp that our comprehensive public transport network connects even the most remote areas of Switzerland. My parents are living on a farm in the countryside and still I can get there easily by train and bus. If I need some more flexibility (moving stuff, skiing, ...), there are electric car rentals available at any major train stations. It's my ideal version of mobility.

PS: The Swiss federal railways also have a large set of open data to enable such cool projects: https://data.sbb.ch/pages/home/

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by sandworm101 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:55AM (#38892424)
Compare me visiting my parents who live in a "remote" town of in BC about 200km from Vancouver. After a ferry and a bus I found myself outside a grocery store asking strangers for a ride north (no taxi service). A kind soul drove me to the highway turnoff. I walked the last five miles. That's what most of North America is like once you step slightly outside of the major cities: No car, no get there.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by pnw on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:13AM (#38892599)
Is that surprising given that you could fit over 200 Switzerlands into Canada and another 200 into the US? BC alone is over 20 times the size of Switzerland. Cars are the best possible option in that case surely?
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by Mordisquitos on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:23PM (#38893243)
Talking about the overall size of Canada is dodging the issue. The scale of the country does provide a justification for not being able to access any arbitrary spot across Canada (or the US) using public transport, but the previous commenter is talking about accessing a town a mere 200 km away from British Columbia's largest city and urban agglomeration — 3rd largest in Canada as a whole.

How many Switzerlands can you fit within a 200 km drive from Vancouver [0]? My eyeball guess is that the area is half the area of Switzerland, maybe less than a third if we exclude US territory covered in the map. And what's the population density of that area? Again, ignoring the US, just counting Vancouver's [1] and Victoria's [2] metropolitan areas alone adds up to 3,000,000 inhabitants (more than a third of the population of the whole of Switzerland), so this area's population density is very likely to be similar or even greater than that of Switzerland as a whole.

[0] https://www.smappen.com/app/map/802yt

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vancouver

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victoria,_British_Columbia

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by alamortsubite on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:12PM (#38893130)
Comparing all of the U.S. or Canada is meaningless, but when you look at regions with similar population densities, then yes, it is surprising. Switzerland only has about half the density of the U.S. East Coast, for example.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by johannes1234321 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:18PM (#38893195)
And in addition Switzerland has challenging terrain with hills and mountains all over, making train service complicated and even busses non-trivial sometimes
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by ant6n on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:54PM (#38893498)
Pn the other hand, the geography forces people to live in valleys. so population is effectively distributed along corridors —- very conducive to being served by rail and bus lines.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by sandworm101 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:20AM (#38892657)
That is correct. Cars are certainly the best option in many circumstances, even from an environmental standpoint. The reason I couldn't get even a taxi was that the taxi company didn't want to drive 30miles just to pick me up, then drive maybe 60miles back after dropping me off. When a small population is spread over a large area, personal vehicles become the most efficient means. That is a large part of why Alaska has the highest rate of private aircraft ownership on the planet. BC rides the literally middle ground between Alaska and the densely populated southern states.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:13PM (#38893139)
The size in itself of is a meaningless metric. I'm baffled that comment like this still get made even on HN. I guess this must be that American just have such a fundamentally distorted view of public transport.

The area of Greater Toronto Area has far denser population then Switzerland with far worse public transport. So by any rational metric it should dominate Switzerland in public transport modal shares and convenience. But it doesn't. So when looking for explanations, we need to look deeper.

Looking at BC, Vancouver is a city of 675,218 people. The Metro area is 2.463 million. Calgary metro is 1.4 million. Edmonton is another metro area of 1.3 million. And the distance between Edmonton and Calgary isn't even very far. Those are 3 cities that are bigger or comparable to Zürich.

I'm not suggesting the population of 'Liard River' of 100 people in the north of BC should have a high speed train to Vancouver. Of course BC as a whole will never have Swiss like public Transit. But if you actually look at where people live, take into account the particular details of the location, you can design a public transport system that is useful for people.

But the comment said '200km' from Vancouver. And he also said there was highway 5 miles from the parents house. So somehow they seemed to think it was reasonable to able to build a highway. Highways are expensive infrastructure, and usually you don't built them the middle of nowhere. So it seems from the comment we are not talking about some place that is at least between two places the somebody connected with a highway. If you have enough money for a highway, you can finance a bus route along it. Most people do live reasonable close together and not just a single house in the wilderness.

If we look at the density map:

https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2006/as-sa/97...

It seems to me that Vancouver is perfectly placed to have an amazing transport system connecting its city to its metro and its metro to the more outlining towns and villages. There is no reason the great Vancouver area couldn't have Swiss like public transport very every village

Then you have a higher speed train connecting Vancouver to Calgary to Edmonton and all the larger towns in between. Then have regional trains or buses going out from that trunk connecting smaller towns and villages. I suspect these town were all originally built because there was railroad there.

So yes, BC as a whole is big and densely populated. But that metric alone is meaningless when designing a public transport system that can meaningfully serve the population. Even if you think 'cars are the best option', that's no reason not have have decent public transport. Switzerland, has lots of people in cars and its a very viable option. But despite that, it also has other good types of transport. Sometimes its nice not to have only one option, specially for people who for many reasons can't simply drive.

This reoccurring attitude of well its a big country so why even try is so damaging. As if Canada being big had anything to do with why Toronto street cars are a abomination of planning and operations. You have a bit more of a point in regards to BC but even then its wrong for the majority of people.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by bombcar on Saturday January 06, 2024 @01:24PM (#38893787)
The cost of building a highway compared to the cost of running even a "once daily" bus service may not be exactly the ratio you think it is, especially if the bus would normally run empty.

A highway is a one-time cost, amortized over many uses, a bus is an ongoing cost.

It would be much easier to "stick a seat" on some government vehicle that already does the trip regularly, allowing a passenger or two to ride along with the mail truck.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by ahtihn on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:14PM (#38895546)
> A highway is a one-time cost

Not really, especially in places that regularly experience freezing and snow.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by currymj on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:09PM (#38894286)
a lot of the more remote Swiss bus services are "PostAuto" and got started exactly like this -- giving passengers a ride on existing mail carriages. Now they run actual buses along the same routes (which are still bright yellow like the mail trucks).
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by bombcar on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:29PM (#38894514)
This is the way to do it - solve the problem, even if “inefficient/complex” and then as things grow, adapt.

Regular rural route busses used to be common in the US before everyone got rich enough to own a car.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:16PM (#38898086)
And if you can't afford a car, can't drive, got your drivers licence revoked, aren't old enough to drive. fuck you.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by sandworm101 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:35PM (#38895735)
Highways are more important to business than passengers. That government bus isn't going to be hauling the logs, gravel, and any other resources that are the lifeblood of BCs economy.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by InvertedRhodium on Saturday January 06, 2024 @07:12PM (#38896971)
Highways require significant ongoing maintenance - I wouldn’t be surprised to find that the cost of maintenance over the lifetime of the road exceeds the cost to build it in the first place. Particularly if the country in question relies heavily on road freight.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by bombcar on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:11PM (#38897332)
Depends on how you define “lifetime” - roads last a long time (and if it’s heavily used, it’s clearly worthwhile).
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:20PM (#38898103)
If this highway is so 'heavily used' then there is clearly enough population around that asking for a bus isn't that big of a deal. You act like I asked for high speed rail connections ever 15min to some remote village northern BC.

We are talking about 200km distance from Vancouver, the major city in Western Canada.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:15PM (#38898077)
> especially if the bus would normally run empty

In Switzerland we often have bus service to tiny mountain villages where the bus has to drive incredibly complex snake roads up a mountain. These buses are often not all that full. And somehow we have not gone bankrupt as a country in the 100 years this has been going on.

> A highway is a one-time cost

That is just totally false.

> a bus is an ongoing cost

Bus has an Initial acquisition cost and an ongoing maintenance, literally exactly like a highway.

The difference is that you have to pay a bus driver.

> It would be much easier to "stick a seat" on some government vehicle that already does the trip regularly, allowing a passenger or two to ride along with the mail truck.

Yes. And that exactly how it started in Switzerland. The Mail company operates the buses. But that doesn't change the fact that they are proper buses with reliable schedules.

Today these buses don't usually deliver the mail anymore anyway. The waste majority are just normal bus routes, just painted in a cool color.

See the Old-School bus: https://artifiche.com/artifiche-images/posters_extralarge/24...

Here you see a modern Post Bus station that is above the local railway station. There are 10+ Post platforms, going into all the surrounding vallies and then to all the different mountain villages. They are all synchronized and scheduled with train arrival times.

See: https://www.bus-bild.de/bild/Schweiz~Betriebe~Postauto/13802...

The city where this bus station is located has only 35k people, it the capital of that whole mountain region. The next large town has 10k people. Many of the villages in the valley, often with population with 1000-2000 are of course connected by rail. Its only once you have to go up that you need the buses. And this city is 100km away from Zürich, a much smaller city then Vancouver.

That is much smaller then even many of the small cities in the greater area we are talking about. There are many cities of 100k+ around, and many other small cities of 10k-50k range.

So I really can't see how connecting any of village in that area can be such a hard burden.

We are talking about a pretty populated region with lots of population. And we are not in the 1920 anymore. Just do fucking run real bus service.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by drunner on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:44AM (#38892331)
One of my favorite YouTubers, not just bikes, did a video last year that highlighted this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muPcHs-E4qc
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:20AM (#38892661)
Usually locations for skiing are very well connected. Trains that go to popular skiing locations of have places to store your equipment. There are also bikes available at most stations.

> It's my ideal version of mobility.

It can decently be a lot better in a lot of ways. But we have to not just complain but try to objectively criticizes so we can continue to improve.

I would like to actually do high-speed rail. Switzerland did really well improving on InterCity trains and got more people to use them. But that became almost a mantra of 'speed doesn't matter'. The actual mantra is 'not as fast as possible, but as fast as required'.

This was correct and with the Rail2035 plan, we are going further in that direction. Many InterCity trains go from every 30 min to every 15 min. Basically turning most of the country into an S-Bahn like system.

See here if you are interested: https://sbb-step2035.ch/de/personenverkehr/

But I think beyond that we should seriously consider a totally new high-speed line, right across the major population centers. That would not just make rail competitive with driving, but beat driving with a big stick. Also this would free up a huge amount of capacity from the existing lines and allow things like 15min regional and inter-regional travel. Plus it would increase cargo capacity.

Sadly its currently not in the Rail2050 plan, but there are people pushing for it.

Further, I think we can do a lot, a lot better in terms of biking. Compared to the Dutch we are utterly primitive in integrating biking in the larger transport network. In the Netherlands they have figured out that bikes are the optimal feeder system into the rail network and have taken huge advantage of that. Switzerland needs to do so much better in that.

Frankly, I think its really useful. I was able to perfectly travel around on Christmas. Getting to family in different parts of the country, no problem.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by palata on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:38AM (#38892823)
> That would not just make rail competitive with driving, but beat driving with a big stick.

Between major population centers, I believe it already beats driving by a long shot... I personally don't think it has to be faster: as long as I can work in the train, it's fine if it takes 90min instead of 75.

> Further, I think we can do a lot, a lot better in terms of biking.

Yes!

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:38AM (#38899060)
The main point is that a new main line would revolutionize local and regional transport as well. So even if you don't build a high speed one, you get a lot of benefit. But once you are building new lines, might as well make it a high-speed line.

And we also should consider longer distances. Sure if you are going from Bern to Zürich 5-10min difference isn't gone be that big of a deal (well arguably if you have millions of people doing it, it does start to matter at least a little).

But even if you look at Genf-Zürich, a new main line could cut that time by 40%-50%, from almost 3h to more like 1.5h.

But what if you want to go from Southern France to Stuttgart or Münich. From Marseille to Zürich.

We have major population density in a straight line from Genf to St.Gallen. Having a modern high speed rail connection across that population just makes sense.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by palata on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:06AM (#38901266)
> Having a modern high speed rail connection across that population just makes sense.

I guess I don't really understand the need for high speed. I can do Genf-St.Gallen without a problem. I can't do this as a daily commute, but that's fine. Maybe it's even a feature.

I don't need high speed, I just need it to be better than using the car for long distance. Though I already prefer the train for stuff like Southern France - Stuttgart.

To be frank, instead of high speed for long distance, I would rather have more night trains. And then it starts competing with planes (3/4 flights are for leisure, we need to do something about it).

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by Stevvo on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:25PM (#38893266)
Replace "foreigners" with "Americans". Functional public transport is not that special; most countries have it. The main difference in Switzerland is the hostility of the terrain to building infrastructure.

If your parents lived on a farm in rural China, you would say the same thing.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by Tainnor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @01:09PM (#38893651)
Swiss public transport is IMHO special in three respects: a) density of the network, b) frequency (even remote areas get a bus an hour), c) punctuality.

I'm not saying no other country can match this (I haven't been everywhere), but at least Germany or Italy can't.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by Peanuts99 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:18PM (#38894387)
It is bloody pricey though. Especially for those without a Swisspass.
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by panick21_ on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:51PM (#38935136)
Cheap if you can not have a car instead.

Plus if you vacation here you can get 5 day tickets for example, and explore the whole country, it covers various ships, cable cars and so on. It can be a pretty damn good deal if you take advantage of it.

For people living here that don't need a full GA (Swisspass is a car that has lots of functions). There is also Halb-Tax to reduce your price significantly, and if you use it frequently you can get even better deal with Halb-Tax Plus.

I think its quite reasonably priced for what you get. But if you are a tourist coming in just buying 1 regular ticket it can be expensive. That said lots of local transport is often included with the hotel.

Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by bwanab on Saturday January 06, 2024 @01:05PM (#38893598)
And the best part is how reliable and timely the trains and buses are. As a foreigner living there I commuted by bus into Geneva from a suburb. I don't think my bus was ever more than 1 minute late - and this was in the middle of its run. I hate to compare that to my wife's commute here in Boston....
Re:Live Map of Swiss Trains by vasile on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:21PM (#38895614)
Thanks for the link, author of the website here. For this particular #swisstrains project I was using derived GTFS dataset form this one https://opentransportdata.swiss/en/dataset/timetable-54-2024... - this portal contains public transport data from all swiss transport operators (not only SBB)