News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by HumblyTossed on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:16PM (#38856629)
> Just goes to show what happens when MBAs run a product-centric company.

This is what happens when all you think about, all you focus on, is returns to investors. You spreadsheet the shit out of everything.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by PartiallyTyped on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:18PM (#38856661)

    - You spreadsheet the shit out of everything.
    ===
    + You spread shit into everything.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:25PM (#38856756)
Returns to investors are the only reason the company exists.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by hiddencost on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:28PM (#38856800)
That is a belief that emerged at a specific time from a specific place with a specific set of goals.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shareholder_value

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by mouzogu on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:36PM (#38856923)
> "Economist Milton Friedman introduced the Friedman doctrine..."

> "...In it, he argued that a company has no social responsibility to the public or society; its only responsibility is to its shareholders."

the demon friedman strikes again.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by soganess on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:45PM (#38857062)
This has always been his magnum opus.

Sounds neutral to the layman while legitimizing the "brushing under the rug" of all the sins possible without severe legal recourse. Then promptly followed by some hand waving that really puts the you-know-what in fiduciary, Mr. Potter.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by rchaud on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:17PM (#38859234)
> "brushing under the rug" of all the sins possible without severe legal recourse.

The invisible hand of the market seems to mostly be involved in sweeping problems under the rug.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:44PM (#38857036)
What's wrong with that statement? Other than it was spoken by a demon.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by treprinum on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:41PM (#38857875)
Friedman's assumption was that regulations work towards social/general good so a company can just focus on maximizing shareholder value within existing law and that combination would keep everything OK. However, in practice regulation was often faulty so the maximization of shareholder value often led to many negative internal and external effects. It's like applying machine learning trained at times of plenty to times of crisis.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by margalabargala on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#38858798)
Or more specifically, it assumes that those two systems remain completely separate from one another.

In reality, as the system for maximizing shareholder value can interact with the system creating the regulations. Thus:

> in practice regulation was often faulty

wasn't a coincidence of a situation, but rather was a direct result of the shareholder-value-maximizing machine working towards the removal of regulations that hindered shareholder value.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @06:40PM (#38861300)
This is a huge letting off the hook of the people who write the regulations. Companies always want regulations changed, because regulations are not handed down from on high as perfect stone tablets full of rules. They're sometimes bad. So there needs to be a mechanism by which companies lobby to have them changed.

If that is misused, the blame lies with the regulation writers. They get to take free money from people as taxes solely so they can be impartial and write good regulations. If they can't even do that, then why give them free money?

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by margalabargala on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:11PM (#38869521)
My intention is not to let regulation writers off the hook, but rather to share the blame between the regulation writers and the corporations that lobby to have regulations changed in a way that they know is bad for society but good for them.

Everybody hates corrupt government officials already, but as a society (in the US) we tend to handwave away companies doing destructive self-interested things as "oh of course they do that", when it's not actually something we need to tolerate.

Oil companies in the 70s knowing that they were causing global warming but engaging in a campaign to pretend that didn't exist? Should be jail for the regulation writers, and jail for the oil company execs who signed off on it.

The Sacklers pretending that their special opioids aren't addictive and causing the opioid crisis? Should be jail for the regulators they bribed, and jail for the people at the company who knew.

Cause the 2008 financial crisis by deliberately mis-grading subprime mortgages? Should be jail for everyone who let that fly.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:19PM (#38870395)
> but rather to share the blame between the regulation writers and the corporations that lobby to have regulations changed in a way that they know is bad for society but good for them.

That's interesting. Everywhere I read (including in HN comments) the focus is on lobbyists and not regulation writers. I've never read anyone ever put the blame on the people who were given free money from taxpayer pockets to be impartial experts, and only ever on people trying to advocate for their companies.

> as a society (in the US) we tend to handwave away companies doing destructive self-interested things as "oh of course they do that", when it's not actually something we need to tolerate

I don't believe "as a society" exists :-) It's one's perception of what happens, but wrapped in an impartial-sounding phrase. I've seen far more tolerance of regulation-writers than I would expect. And there is a clear difference between a company (legally) trying to change hearts and minds and regulation writers allowing their minds to be changed for perks.

> Oil companies in the 70s knowing that they were causing global warming but engaging in a campaign to pretend that didn't exist? Should be jail for the regulation writers, and jail for the oil company execs who signed off on it.

Oil companies don't have a legal responsibility to tell the truth about the climate, I think. Also, the understanding of climate has changed quite a lot since then, so even I might go easy on regulators in this instance.

> Cause the 2008 financial crisis by deliberately mis-grading subprime mortgages? Should be jail for everyone who let that fly.

This is a good example of regulation being to blame, though. You'd go to jail if you didn't allow a certain percentage of subprime mortgages[0].

[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20080928095759/http://www.invest...

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by lesuorac on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:54PM (#38857196)
Originally governments didn't just give out corperations whilly-nilly so if you weren't doing something that benefited the public you just didn't get one.

Which really wasn't a big deal since you could always do business as yourself although you (and not the corporation) also got liability then.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:21PM (#38858512)
I don't see why this matters. Whether they "give out corporations" or they regulate corporations, they can still choose to throw you in jail because they have power. Corporations should obey the law, but they should chase shareholder value.

That doesn't mean short-termism at all costs, which is what some people hear when that is said, but it means, say, if you're Disney don't release a string of movies that all lose incredible amounts of money. Or if you do, then senior management needs changing pronto.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by thinkerswell on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:21PM (#38857596)
Ah so the government got to pick winners and losers
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by mouzogu on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:37PM (#38857818)
laying the ideological foundation for socialising of losses, privatising of profits and destruction of the environment.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:22PM (#38858536)
It's really not. Profits are taxed. Losses are lost by investors. The environment should be protected by regulations, not by relying on good will. That way the boundaries are clear and companies can do what they do best: allocate resources efficiently, towards demand, within rules.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by cwillu on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:57AM (#38864363)
Regulations should be a backstop after decency and goodwill fails. No one facet of the structure society is made of can support all of society, there needs to be safety factors in the building materials.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Thursday January 04, 2024 @05:04AM (#38865221)
> Regulations should be a backstop after decency and goodwill fails

People won't know the implications of decisions without regulations to help them. Of course businesses are populated by people, who will try and do the right thing if that's how they are, but that doesn't mean they know what the right thing is.

> No one facet of the structure society is made of can support all of society, there needs to be safety factors in the building materials.

I can't parse this, sorry. Happy to have a read if you reword.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by cwillu on Thursday January 04, 2024 @06:06AM (#38865609)
> People won't know the implications of decisions without regulations to help them.

That's a pretty expansive view of government; I'll grant that regulations are one mechanism for communicating the implications of decisions, but to say that people can't know the implications without regulations? That just seems silly to the point that I'm unsure if I'm intended to legitimately engage with that viewpoint; is that your actual opinion?

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Thursday January 04, 2024 @08:53AM (#38866960)
I'd rather stick to the topic of discussion than start discussing the discussion. Do you have a point to make?
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by cwillu on Thursday January 04, 2024 @06:03AM (#38865583)
Relying on one mechanism (say, regulations) as the sole means of making sure that society functions well, is a recipe for dysfunction.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by robertlagrant on Thursday January 04, 2024 @08:53AM (#38866961)
"Society functions well" is far too broad a brush. We're talking about what companies should do.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by mouzogu on Thursday January 04, 2024 @07:39AM (#38866253)
another gift of the friedman neolib era was massive deregulation.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by zzzbra on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:13PM (#38857469)
I am reluctant to say I am glad a comment has been down voted, because I am wary of mob mentality, but in this case I am very glad this comment has been so thoroughly down voted.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by paulddraper on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:45PM (#38858837)
why?
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by dartos on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:40PM (#38859554)
Why not?
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by pjmorris on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:38PM (#38856962)
Think about that the next time you flip a light switch or flush a toilet and consider whether returns should be the only reason.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by rchaud on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:22PM (#38859318)
the Juicero principle.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by zaptheimpaler on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:52PM (#38857154)
Yup companies exist to make money, people work jobs to make money, investors invest to make money, we all just really love to move $s around from one bank to another or trade pretty green bills. No other reason nah.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:14PM (#38857496)
People exist for many reasons. Companies do not.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by itishappy on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:58PM (#38858169)
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by the_gastropod on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:32PM (#38857749)
But also corporations are people, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by paulddraper on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:47PM (#38858856)
In some contexts, yes.

They can't vote, can't get married, etc.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by jen20 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:10PM (#38859158)
They can do better than vote, in the US though.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by dartos on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:42PM (#38859593)
Tbf if you, as a real person, had the same amount of money as a corp you could do the same.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by mempko on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:36PM (#38856919)
What was the reason before 1960s, when this idea of shareholder value, for companies to exist?
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by Kerrick on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:39PM (#38856977)
If I remember anything from my high school social studies class, the reason was the ability to spread investment risk across multiple investors while also shielding the investors and employees from some personal legal liability. I think I even remember that companies/corporations predate stock exchanges.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by Pet_Ant on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:49PM (#38857993)
> Remember that companies/corporations predate stock exchanges.

While not definitive, ChatGPT says that:

> The idea of organizing a group of people to work towards a common goal for profit or mutual benefit has evolved over centuries. The modern concept of a company, with legal structures and formalized business practices, has its roots in the emergence of capitalism during the Industrial Revolution in the 18th and 19th centuries.

Whereas the first stock exchange is somewhere between 1300 and 1600: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_exchange#History

Wikipedia doesn't have a history section on it's page for company, but it says this:

> By 1303, the word company referred to trade guilds. Usage of the term company to mean "business association" was first recorded in 1553, and the abbreviation "co." dates from 1769.

You can tweak your definition by the means you'd like, but I think an honest assessment would be at this point to say they were concurrent.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company#Semantics_and_usage

So your statement seems incorrect. I'm no expert, just curious.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by sdsd on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:33PM (#38857768)
A company isn't the same as a corporation. A corporation is a legal privilege granted by the government to give a company legal personhood. Thus the word "corporation", from latin "corpus", signifying that the state considers this specific company to be a single, legal body.

Corporations aren't a free market concept, it's a way for the state to give special protections to certain companies that need it for some prosocial reason.

A short history: https://newint.org/features/2002/07/05/history

Basically, the original idea is, a corporate charter is granted to create a corporation, which acts on behalf of its shareholders (who the government trusts, have some worthy interest in mind).

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:18PM (#38858478)
But Xerox's returns to investors have been dismal.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by Zetobal on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:56PM (#38858984)
Xerox was a private company at first.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by Waterluvian on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:54PM (#38857191)
Doesn’t this fundamentally guarantee the enshittification of every company driven this way?

If you must grow by x% every year, and infinite growth is impossible, you begin shoving more and more low quality ads into your search results, partake in more legally and ethically grey activities, and eventually rupture?

Are there any examples of large corporations that have said, “we make billions in profit each year. We’re going to focus on maintaining that enormous success. We’re not going to focus on growth.” (I can already hear the spreadsheet squinting logic about how growth is necessary for some reason)

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by SoftTalker on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:11PM (#38857439)
No, I don't see that it does. Basically the idea is that a company should operate in a way that is beneficial to its owners (shareholders). This is what any sole proprietorship or partership also does. Growth is not the only way to measure that. Many companies do focus on maintaining success and return value to the owners by paying dividends. Driving the company to failure by relentlessly cutting costs in the name of "growth" is not in the interests of the owners.
Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by HumblyTossed on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:56PM (#38858123)
> This is what any sole proprietorship or partership also does. Growth is not the only way to measure that.

And yet, a bad quarterly earnings report will tank a stock...

> Driving the company to failure by relentlessly cutting costs in the name of "growth" is not in the interests of the owners.

Sure it is. They've maximized their personal revenue and now it's time to get out. The sooner the better.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by FredPret on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:45PM (#38858833)
It doesn’t have to grow %x to give great shareholder returns. It can stay the same size and make the owners very rich.

Further, the best way to grow %x for a long time is to provide quality. Shittification is a short-term strategy.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:12PM (#38857460)
> We’re going to focus on maintaining that enormous success. We’re not going to focus on growth.” (I can already hear the spreadsheet squinting logic about how growth is necessary for some reason)

Where is Xerox going to get the money to do R&D to not be obviated? Replace Xerox with any other business.

All the businesses obviated by spreadsheets, mobile networks, smartphones, GPS? Maintaining success is continuing to make bets and moving forward, and bets require money. More money means bigger bets.

Another example, you have two businesses, one with a 5% profit margin (because they feel like 5% is enough), one with a 10% profit margin. The one with 10% profit margin is going to be able to continue renovating the business, upgrading the facility, buying more land, hiring better employees with higher payrates.

What will happen to the 5% profit margin business? Do you think customers will keep rewarding them (assuming the 10% profit margin business is worth the additional marginal cost)? You can insert restaurant, hotel, retail store, etc in here.

Note that having a higher profit margin is not the only way to survive, having a lower profit margin to better compete on price and gain market share is another way too. Balancing the two and delivering the right product at the right price for your customers is the key skill, but it’s a moving target.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by krebby on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @02:54PM (#38858945)
The issue is that this leads into Dutch Disease. When a single tulip bulb can buy you a house, why bother becoming a carpenter? Society needs carpenters way more than it needs tulip growers.

That 10% growth rate may or may not be factoring in some externalities that the 5% growth has to

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:34PM (#38859466)
I am not seeing the connection to the Dutch Disease as described in Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease

My point was businesses compete with each other, and money is one of the tools used to compete.

And growth rate and profit margins are not the same.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by krebby on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @07:40PM (#38861717)
I think we're broadly in agreement but I'm responding to the bit about "What will happen to the 5% profit margin business? Do you think customers will keep rewarding them?".

If you only ever reward investments with high rates of return it leads to atrophy in boring yet essential sectors of the market. Supermarkets, like you mentioned, have a very low profit margin (usually 1-3%). Can you imagine what would happen if no one was willing to invest in a supermarket?

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by SoftTalker on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:15PM (#38861957)
Investing is about risk vs. reward.

Some investors will seek a 10% return in exchange for higher risk.

Others will be happy with a 3% return that is much lower risk.

Portfolios will include some of both types of investments depending on goals and risk tolerance.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @07:50PM (#38861792)
Yes, well customers evaluate different products and services at different price points. Grocery store experiences and products are fungible enough that it drives margins down that low:

>Note that having a higher profit margin is not the only way to survive, having a lower profit margin to better compete on price and gain market share is another way too. Balancing the two and delivering the right product at the right price for your customers is the key skill, but it’s a moving target.

Re:Xerox to cut 15% of its workforce by milesvp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @06:54PM (#38861404)
Nonsense! You lack imagination!

There are numerous reasons for companies to exist. Off the top of my head I can think of a few. To provide goods to populations. To provide services for populations. To give the owner something to do. To perpetuate themselves. To provide something to do for employees. To do something an individual can’t.

None of these require investors. There are countless businesses that can be started that don’t even require a significant outlay of capital.

On top of that there are differing philosophies that might suggest investors should be last in line for benefits from a business. I could make a strong argument that society allows businesses to exist and as such society should benefit first and foremost. Businesses typically fail to exist without employees, so I could argue employees should come before investors.

Please don’t perpetuate the naive notion that investors are somehow more important than anything else. I am a dyed in the wool capitalist and while I tend to highly value profitability, even I don’t believe shareholder value is some sacred edict.