News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Sirizarry on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:16PM (#38807479)
“Water can’t be free anywhere” is one of the most dystopian lines I’ve seen this year
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by AlexandrB on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:23PM (#38807563)
It's classic "tragedy of the commons" stuff. Having a "free" input sets up incentives for waste since that resource now exists outside the influence of market forces.

So it's either putting a price on these resources or careful regulation. The latter is not very popular in today's political climate.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#38809913)
> careful regulation

Has never worked very well. Government bureaucracies are very bad at pricing and allocating things appropriately. A case study is in the 70's the government decided gas allocations for every gas station. The result was a patchwork of gluts and shortages across the country.

Reagan ended all that as his first Executive Order, and overnight the gluts and shortages vanished along with the gas lines.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by nickpp on Saturday December 30, 2023 @04:30PM (#38819384)
Very much rooting for Argentina's Milei to provide a similar lesson in modern times but I am afraid that he has very few allies helping him (besides his own idiosyncrasies) and the current laptop class would simply ignore it as they ignored Venezuela's lesson...
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Supermancho on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:39PM (#38807780)
Related to Jevons Paradox
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by acover on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:22PM (#38808350)
> Jevons paradox occurs when technological progress or government policy increases the efficiency with which a resource is used (reducing the amount necessary for any one use), but the falling cost of use induces increases in demand enough that resource use is increased, rather than reduced.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ldoughty on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:27PM (#38807623)
When I lived in a rural area on septic and well, my electric bill was often under $200 in the summer, running AC fairly heavily, and taking care of ~6 dense garden beds full of veggies for ~6 months... and regularly watering 1 acre of grass to keep it from drying too much. We even had a timer to auto-water the garden and parts of the lawn... We'd even let it run overnight on a few occasions (needing to water, but coming home very late)

I hardly considered water a costly resource

On "city" water now in suburbs, I followed a similar pattern for grass on a 1/4 acre lot, and heavily watered the lawn one month, and I had a $300 water & sewer bill -- on top of my $100 electric bill.

Water went from being something I hardly considered to something I am far more careful about 'wasting'.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by pfranz on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:27PM (#38808408)
I'm not really sure what you're getting at. Like others have said, “Water can’t be free anywhere” seems to be inevitable at a commercial level--but dystopian on an individual level. If you had neighbors in your rural area aggressively pumping water out of the ground your well would dry up...and you'd be paying "market price" for it.

Just looking at water usage when I owned a house, irrigation uses a ridiculous amount of water relative to everything else individuals use to live--including laundry, bathing, dishes, etc. If memory serves, sewage costs are significantly more than the water itself (and sewage as metered off of water consumption--so you're likely paying sewage feeds on water you're irrigating with).

The actual cost of enough clean drinking water for people is very small. Enough that drinking fountains are common and people shouldn't need to ration drinking water.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ItsMonkk on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:47PM (#38809381)
Yep, this is why we need a water price and dividend system.

Whenever you use water it is tracked and you pay the market price. All of that is then collected and put into a pot. It is then given back equally to everyone.

Everyone is thus incentivized to use less and those that use less than the average amount of water - a huge majority of people since the heaviest users use so much - will receive more money than they spent.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:42PM (#38809973)
> It is then given back equally to everyone.

Use it to fund the government.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ItsMonkk on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:26PM (#38811437)
Eh, NIT and any sort of UBI are mathematically the same thing given you still have an income tax and can adjust the percentage. This just accomplishes that goal in a progressive way.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:35PM (#38808515)
> Like others have said, “Water can’t be free anywhere” seems to be inevitable at a commercial level--but dystopian on an individual level.

This is why we need a democracy with human rights being protected [1,2].

If not even fundamental things like water (or air) is free, you have to ask yourself how did we get here and how do we leave?

1: https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/human-rights-water-and-s... 2: https://truthout.org/articles/un-declares-water-and-sanitati...

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by skeletal88 on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:54PM (#38807959)
Well.. if your grass would dry out and become yellow without watering it, then watering is a luxury. The water in deep wells will eventually run out. Why waste it on grass?
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by sparrish on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:58PM (#38808843)
Because my HOA says I have to maintain a green lawn or I get fined.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by unshavedyak on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:21PM (#38809090)
Yea but the discussion is around water usage practices. Deciding we have to waste water because HOAs say so is of course silly. They need to change.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by jghn on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:44PM (#38809337)
> Because my HOA says I have to maintain a green lawn or I get fined.

And this is why I don't live somewhere where I'm ruled by an HOA

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by tekla on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:51PM (#38810060)
Any HOA that requires green lawns should be required to pay a tax of minimum $100 per lawn per year it oversees. Its a stupid wasteful policy
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by bilbo0s on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:19PM (#38809058)
No dog in this fight. I moved out of Scottsdale to the Great Lakes region a bit back partly because of the water issue. So I definitely get the natural inclination to not want to have to think about water.

All that said, I mean, if your HOA requires this, is the problem with the city charging for water use to upkeep the infrastructure required to deliver it? Or is the issue really just that your HOA has rules that it shouldn't?

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by cookie_monsta on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:44PM (#38810575)
I would be calculating the fine vs water bill comparison.

Or ripping up the lawn to plant something more sensible.

Or just not living somewhere where an HOA can tell me what to do with my own house

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Dylan16807 on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:20PM (#38812047)
> The water in deep wells will eventually run out. Why waste it on grass?

That's a different regulation issue. We shouldn't be overdrawing from those deep wells at almost any price, outside of extreme emergency.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by throw0101b on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:09PM (#38808168)
> Water went from being something I hardly considered to something I am far more careful about 'wasting'.

Water being "free" from a well probably doesn't help with aquifer longevity, at least at larger scales.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:41PM (#38809960)
I landscaped with native plants that require no water beyond the rain.

It saves me a ton on water bills and lawn maintenance time & expense. As a bonus, the deer won't eat the native plants.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ryaneager on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:28PM (#38807638)
It’s only dystopian if it’s in context of people. Water shouldn’t be free for companies to profit off of but free to individuals to sustain life.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:38PM (#38809927)
The food grown to sustain life requires water.

History also shows us that when the government runs collective farms that have no profit, people starve.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Dylan16807 on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:18PM (#38812037)
> History also shows us that when the government runs collective farms that have no profit, people starve.

Yes? I'm not sure what you're implying here.

The argument isn't "farms shouldn't profit", the argument is "farms should pay for the water they're turning into profits".

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:19PM (#38812803)
How can life be sustained with free water? Who is going to provide it?
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Dylan16807 on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#38812846)
Which life?

If we're talking about basic necessary water for humans, that's a tiny little fraction of use and easy for cities to provide.

For anything else the water doesn't need to be free or actively should not be free, depending on which use you look at.

Water used to grow food goes in the second category.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by panick21_ on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:49AM (#38813286)
Using water hungry cash crops for luxury foods rather then more better more native crops that actually better prevent starvation, is the reality.

Using a scare resource in an unsustainable way results in bad incentives and thus bad outcome for people.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by TulliusCicero on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:04PM (#38808098)
Ehhh, that's a rather cynical take on it.

It's obviously about inefficient overuse by businesses. Having water for individual people free for basic personal use wouldn't be a problem.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:44PM (#38809996)
> Having water for individual people free for basic personal use wouldn't be a problem.

Operating the water system to deliver water is expensive. If you want to put out a rain barrel and collect rain, it's free.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by dukeyukey on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:19PM (#38810928)
Doesn't help with water treatment or sewage handling though.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by notatoad on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:26PM (#38808396)
"paying the water bill" is a pretty normal thing for a large portion of the world. certainly for most of america.

paying for water is not a dystopia. and taking a totally normal part of life and calling it "dystopian" with no further explanation is one of the laziest arguments ever.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by josefritz on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:36PM (#38808530)
Paying for water when you are poor is a threat to life and livelihood that's dystopian. This is the nature of dystopia, it mostly affects the impoverished.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by unshavedyak on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:23PM (#38809107)
Is it not the same for paying for food, as well? I generally agree, but water seems an arbitrary line to draw when we still have shelter and food to consider.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by throwaway44773 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:25AM (#38813191)
Before humans decided to pollute a lot of the fresh water on earth or appropriate it for themselves, humans could just go to the nearest stream and get water. In that sense, it feels right that it should be easily accessible at no cost. Meanwhile, humans have usually had to expand considerable effort to build a shelter and gather or grow food. So i don’t see the line as being arbitrary.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by seanp2k2 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:10AM (#38813597)
For a good time, go read up about Stewart and Lynda Resnick and their impact to water in California.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by mrcrumb1 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:43PM (#38817634)
This is clearly not true in the desert.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by JoshGG on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:28PM (#38808435)
Dystopian is “water was free so the big farming business pumped the aquifer dry and exported the agricultural goods. Now people here have no water and the land is a desert”.

This stuff is economics 101.

The full quote is:

“”Soren Bjorn, a senior executive at Driscoll’s who in January will become the chief executive, said in an interview that he “absolutely” sees the region as a model of water pricing that could be replicated in water-stressed regions from Texas to Portugal. “Water can’t be free anywhere, because you can’t run a sustainable water supply without pricing it,” he said. “That would apply to the globe." “”

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by intrasight on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:52PM (#38810065)
Water is free. What we pay for is it's delivery and it's treatment.

I remember learning in elementary school that you're not allowed to charge for water.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by wmf on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:35PM (#38811489)
The article directly contradicts this. Farmers are paying water tax even for their own wells.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ninkendo on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:11PM (#38817289)
As they should, because there’s no such thing as “your own well.” A well lets you pump water from a shared aquifer. If 100 parcels of land were on one aquifer and one resident pumped all of it, leaving none for anyone else, it would be a misleading lie to say they were just pumping “their own well.”
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by intrasight on Saturday December 30, 2023 @10:59PM (#38821635)
Then farmers aren't purchasing water - they are being taxed.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by irrational on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:07PM (#38809583)
Where I live it rains for the majority of the year. We could put out buckets and easily capture enough to care for our needs, but then you have to deal with making sure what we are going to ingest is clean and deal with no water pressure and hauling water around the house. It is so much easier to pay someone else to deal with it. So, water could be free some places, but…
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by atrus on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:22PM (#38809774)
Nothing of what you described is free though? It's going to take some sort of resources no matter what.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by irrational on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:16AM (#38813630)
You mean like buckets to hold the water? Those would cost money, but would be a one time purchase.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ta1243 on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:16PM (#38810293)
You don't live in Arizona
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by xboxnolifes on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:44PM (#38808637)
There's a very unambiguously wide gap between water being freely available to every person for sustaining life, and water being completely free to use in quantities of trillions/quadrillions of gallons for profit.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by KeplerBoy on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:00PM (#38808873)
There's not really. You need water for farming. Farming is necessary for survival and farmers sell their produce for profit.

The line between small, local, "good" farmers and large "evil" corporations is all but clear cut.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ethanbond on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#38808994)
You don't need to farm water-intensive crops in deserts, especially in the modern era of extremely effective logistics. We should be growing crops where they're most suitable for, and applying something closer to normal pricing dynamics will nudge us closer to that.

Agreed there's not a bright line, but we're clearly at one undesirable end of the spectrum.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by KeplerBoy on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:18PM (#38809043)
I agree, but then we're back at exporting produce from wherever water is cheap and abundant. Which is a good thing and necessary, but it has to be done carefully at the industrial scale we're at.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by unshavedyak on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:19PM (#38809065)
Is it? What about using limited water for crops that don’t have as much value to survival as other crops? Or wasteful locations, etc.

I’m not advocating charging necessarily, but using up a limited resource with reckless abandon seems short sighted. What am I missing? Is it not a very important resource to manage?

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by seanp2k2 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:07AM (#38813579)
But you see, their family got the land for free through a Homestead Act a few generations ago after they drove the Natives out (and/or murdered them) and now they get subsided water and property taxes through Prop 13 and cheap labor from undocumented workers, so why not do everything else in their power to maximize profits? That is the only mission in capitalism, after all.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Dylan16807 on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:15PM (#38812027)
Farming is necessary, correct. I don't see how this removes the wide gap.

> farmers sell their produce for profit

And that means they can pay for the resources they use!

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by j4yav on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:48PM (#38808694)
You can take my Mojave desert almond farm when you pry it from my cold dead fingers.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by seanp2k2 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:16AM (#38813628)
It was ostensibly pried from the cold, dead hands of a Native American not so many decades ago, so at least there’s precedence. A bit more about that: http://mojavedesert.net/mojave-indians/traditional-territory...
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by inamberclad on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#38808995)
Limited natural resources shouldn't be free for industrial exploitation. Unfortunately, money is the best mechanism for incorporating these concerns into a product.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:43PM (#38809987)
Mining rights are expensive.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by zx8080 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @09:30PM (#38821231)
Those with money can lobby for more profits. Civil population lose. That's how money works: money for more money.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by kardianos on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:13PM (#38809000)
So... Let me tell you about Natural Asset Companies the SEC is considering approvnig: https://www.nyse.com/introducing-natural-asset-companies

So yes, dystopian. Not a trial run.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Ekaros on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:45PM (#38811546)
What type of water are we talking about?

A bucket of water from river or lake somewhere can likely be free in many places. Even ground water if you exclude building a well.

It is not unreasonable to charge everyone using water when it is treated, delivered and sewage is taken care of. As long as the price paid for minimal daily use is not exploitative.