News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by xboxnolifes on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:44PM (#38808637)
There's a very unambiguously wide gap between water being freely available to every person for sustaining life, and water being completely free to use in quantities of trillions/quadrillions of gallons for profit.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by KeplerBoy on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:00PM (#38808873)
There's not really. You need water for farming. Farming is necessary for survival and farmers sell their produce for profit.

The line between small, local, "good" farmers and large "evil" corporations is all but clear cut.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by ethanbond on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#38808994)
You don't need to farm water-intensive crops in deserts, especially in the modern era of extremely effective logistics. We should be growing crops where they're most suitable for, and applying something closer to normal pricing dynamics will nudge us closer to that.

Agreed there's not a bright line, but we're clearly at one undesirable end of the spectrum.

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by KeplerBoy on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:18PM (#38809043)
I agree, but then we're back at exporting produce from wherever water is cheap and abundant. Which is a good thing and necessary, but it has to be done carefully at the industrial scale we're at.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by unshavedyak on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:19PM (#38809065)
Is it? What about using limited water for crops that don’t have as much value to survival as other crops? Or wasteful locations, etc.

I’m not advocating charging necessarily, but using up a limited resource with reckless abandon seems short sighted. What am I missing? Is it not a very important resource to manage?

Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by seanp2k2 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:07AM (#38813579)
But you see, their family got the land for free through a Homestead Act a few generations ago after they drove the Natives out (and/or murdered them) and now they get subsided water and property taxes through Prop 13 and cheap labor from undocumented workers, so why not do everything else in their power to maximize profits? That is the only mission in capitalism, after all.
Re:Strawberry Case Study: What If Farmers Had to Pay for Water? by Dylan16807 on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:15PM (#38812027)
Farming is necessary, correct. I don't see how this removes the wide gap.

> farmers sell their produce for profit

And that means they can pay for the resources they use!