News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by adocomplete on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:46AM (#38613690)
Thanks for sharing. Will def opt out and roll into the class action suits already filed.

Take security seriously people. Especially when dealing with super sensitive data.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by brianwawok on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:54AM (#38613839)
Why did you send them your DNA? It was pretty obvious from day 1 that sending some random startup on the internet my DNA was a bad move.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by 6177c40f on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:06AM (#38614026)
No, I don't think that that's obvious. At least in the US, there are already protections for genetic information (including but not limited to GINA [1]).

In the long run, I think keeping your genetic information private will be untenable- the potential benefits will outweigh the drawbacks. Plus, anyone sufficiently motivated could get your DNA somehow, you shed your DNA everywhere you go, no getting around that.

So what's left is to urge your representatives to maintain and strengthen regulations on how that information can be used, and in the long run we'll just have to trust that that will be enough.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_Information_Nondiscrim...

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:24AM (#38614293)
> In the long run, I think keeping your genetic information private will be untenable- the potential benefits will outweigh the drawbacks.

Can you give an example?

> Plus, anyone sufficiently motivated could get your DNA somehow, you shed your DNA everywhere you go, no getting around that.

That assumes there's someone out to get you specifically. That's like saying there's no point in having 2FA or strong passwords, because the FSB, the FBI and Mossad can get in anyway. Having my DNA because you vacuumed it up off the subway floor is significantly less useful to anyone without it being explicitly tied to me.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by 6177c40f on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:41PM (#38615544)
> Can you give an example?

See my other comment, but in short I essentially mean the true realization of "precision medicine" and gaining a greater understanding of how different genotypes result in disease, information which can be used guide treatment and to develop better treatments.

> That assumes there's someone out to get you specifically.

Not entirely true- the ability to reconstruct genotypes from environmental samples gets better all the time. I'd imagine that even with current technology, a sufficiently motivated organization could sample various locations to reconstruct the genomes of people who often visit there. With enough info, they could start building webs of genetic relation. From there, all they'd need is access to a database of samples from known individuals (which, as we can see, already exists), can chances are they could quickly deanonymize future samples. The only thing that could stop such mass collection is proper regulation.

> That's like saying there's no point in having 2FA or strong passwords, because the FSB, the FBI and Mossad can get in anyway.

Unlike your password, your DNA is unencrypted and gets spread everywhere.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by slingnow on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:52PM (#38616573)
>> That's like saying there's no point in having 2FA or strong passwords, because the FSB, the FBI and Mossad can get in anyway.

> Unlike your password, your DNA is unencrypted and gets spread everywhere.

This doesn't address the point. In both cases, someone sufficiently motivated could get what they want from you. So by your argument, there's no point in maintaining privacy for either piece of information (DNA / passwords).

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by 6177c40f on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:02PM (#38618462)
> So by your argument, there's no point in maintaining privacy for either piece of information (DNA / passwords).

The problem with privacy is that it's fragile. When your info is leaked, you should assume it's out there for good.

I also think that while right now when you do the cost/benefit analysis of having your DNA sequenced, you think the cost outweights the benefit. Clearly my personal calculus is different than yours, and that's ok. But I would caution you that in the future that calculation may be different for you.

So I think people will either lose privacy, or voluntarily give up some privacy for some benefit. In either case, we will need something other than privacy to protect ourselves. I think that well-enforced legislation, legislation that limits the way genetic info can be used and gives the individual more control over their own info, is really the only thing that can help.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by muser8 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @06:00PM (#38619987)
> I think that well-enforced legislation, legislation that limits the way genetic info can be used and gives the individual more control over their own info, is really the only thing that can help.

Absolutely, in theory. But when have politicians respected legislation's original intent over their self-interest over time, especially when monied parties are desirous of changes for those party's own ends?

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by billyoyo on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:14PM (#38616895)
Clearly a bad faith argument. someone with your passwords can do a lot more damage than someone with your DNA.

I think DNA is probably sensitive on the level of someone knowing your name and DOB. Not convinced it's much more dangerous than that.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by rocho on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:46AM (#38623540)
That's only true now. You don't know that DNA leakage won't be a higher risk in the future (and FWIW, my opinion is the opposite of yours regarding the future risks). Moreover you can change your passwords, but you can't change your DNA.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by croes on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:10PM (#38615049)
>Plus, anyone sufficiently motivated could get your DNA somehow, you shed your DNA everywhere you go, no getting around that.

But these people need to get close to you. 23andme made it easy for someone who could have been on the other side of the globe.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by 6177c40f on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:42PM (#38615565)
I really don't see how this changes the threat model. If anything, I'm less worried about someone on the other side of the globe.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by fkyoureadthedoc on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:08PM (#38615944)
And do what with it?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by quantified on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:53AM (#38614752)
What benefit will there be? And why do you assume that it won't be accompanied by negatives? The problem with all tech is that people direct its use, and the sole agent of evil in this world is people.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by 6177c40f on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:33PM (#38615421)
> What benefit will there be?

Knowing your genetic information is currently of limited value for the majority of people, this I admit. I believe that in the future, however, the promise of precision medicine will be realized, and that having one's genetic information readily available will be crucial to receiving the best treatment possible for many diseases.

For example, take Crohn's Disease (and other inflammatory diseases more generally). The current thinking is that it is highly influenced by genetics, and that a number of different genotypes exist that can result in the phenotype we refer to as Crohn's Disease. It's conceivable that having a better understanding of someone's specific genotype could lead to more precise treatment of their condition.

> And why do you assume that it won't be accompanied by negatives?

I explicitly don't assume this, I said that the benefits will outweigh the drawbacks.

> the sole agent of evil in this world is people.

This is a specious argument. By that same measure, the sole agent of good in the world is also people. But that's irrelevant. Tech can be used both to harm and to benefit, and I'm arguing that personal gene sequencing can and will be used to provide more benefit than harm.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by quantified on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:12PM (#38621334)
Yes, you did reference both, and I lost track in my response.

I expect a few relatively wealthy people to get some benefit, for example when they have real health conditions that can be helped by genetic knowledge. I don't expect benefit for the rest. Across the population, some will have net benefit, some will have net drawback, and it would be very easy for the second group to be an order of magnitude larger than the first.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by mauvehaus on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:01AM (#38613961)
Not everyone opted in as such. My wife has an identical twin who sent in a test.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by midasuni on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:36AM (#38614491)
Presumably neither you, your kids, or your wife, has grounds to sue them
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by hoosieree on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:52PM (#38616566)
You could try the old Monsanto/JohnDeere approach: copyright your own DNA then sue them under DMCA.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by tamimio on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:55PM (#38615751)
Spot on!
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by duxup on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:19PM (#38615223)
For a lot of people it is a health decision.

I go to a doctor, they have a ton of info on me. Who knows what might happen with that data ... but I still go to the doctor because it is a good idea for health reasons.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by gosub100 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:19AM (#38614237)
Fear of the unknown about your own body. Think of how many people would sign up if you sold a service that scoured secret files to "find out what people are saying about you". Forget whether such a service could ever work, just the combination of "unknown" + "about you" is irresistible to a large segment of the population. It's the mother-of-all-clickbait.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by atemerev on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:29AM (#38614363)
Any other way to know the information they are offering? It is hard to own your own sequencing machine.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by alephnan on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:48PM (#38619129)
It was offered as a subsidized perk during my days as a Google employee.

The social aspect of other people at Google doing it made it feel normal.

In hindsight, I drank the Google kool-aid in more ways then one.

The sentiment of distrust towards tech companies and tech companies being yet-another-corporation is really only obvious in recent years. It wasn't the case a decade ago when we were busy being judgemental of Wall Street. Ironically, now it seems that Wall Street is more trustworthy because, at the very least, they are forthrite about their motive to make profit instead of all these lies about "changing the world".

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by krosaen on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @05:30PM (#38619616)
Didn't really feel like a random startup - felt like one of the most innovative startups around, backed by impressive investors including Google, co-founder married to Sergey Brin... So perhaps in hindsight sending DNA to anyone is a bad idea, but if there were a startup one might have trusted, this was it.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by tuwtuwtuwtuw on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:31AM (#38614400)
Which super sensitive data was leaked? I have read contradicting things.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:08AM (#38614063)
Same, excited to receive my check for $0.25 in 3 years (seriously though, I wonder if we should file in small claims court or something as well?)
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by snapcaster on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:02AM (#38613978)
I'm not trying to be mean, but it's hard not to be angry at people like you. Why would you send your DNA to a random startup with no promises or guidelines on how the data could be used? Do you have children? You just caused 50% of their DNA to leak forever without consent. I hope you're reconsidering your decision making around stuff like this now, but too late for any of your descendants in next couple generations
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by Ensorceled on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:59AM (#38614852)
I continue to be surprised at the sheer number of people on HN who are more enraged at the victims for their "stupidity" than at the perpetrators (23andMe for ToS shenanigans and/or the hackers for the hack).
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by snapcaster on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:35PM (#38618065)
How are you getting that i'm "more enraged" at the victims? I'm not absolving the company of anything, I'm criticizing people who give something like their DNA to a random company naive and foolish

edit: I would have the exact same stance (and did and continue to) even if there was no hack

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by Ensorceled on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:09PM (#38618573)
Because your original comment was the only comment you made on the thread.

And you made NO mention of the real villains.

And you accused these people of screwing over their kids and all their descendants.

And you only "not absolving" the real villains even now.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by zlg_codes on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:58PM (#38619248)
With criteria like that, you may as well speak for him. You're complaining he didn't say exactly what you wanted, and then made an assumption on his stance. Stupid tribal monkey behavior.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by dgacmu on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:37PM (#38615491)
Well, let's see - because I wanted to have children, and I didn't know who my biological father was, so I wanted to understand if my wife and I were likely to carry any of the same dangerous recessive genes? And I wanted to know if there were likely any big, detectable gotchas coming up as I got older.

And because, in the process, I discovered a couple of half brothers.

My life is better because of the knowledge I got from genetic testing.

(It also wasn't a "random" startup to me; I had it recommended by someone I trust who knows the founder.)

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by switchbak on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:44PM (#38615598)
Why would you be angry at someone that didn't do anything that negatively affects you? Do you get mad at people that eat unhealthy food?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by snapcaster on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:34PM (#38618042)
Yes actually
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by switchbak on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:37PM (#38633811)
Well that anger (stress) is doing you harm. Do you get angry at yourself that your anger towards others is reducing your lifetime?

Maybe just live your own life instead.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:07AM (#38614049)
Most of the time we're leaking our DNA all over the place by existing
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by croes on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:13PM (#38615099)
So you would be ok if governments around the world have sample of yours and store it in a database?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by drivers99 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:26PM (#38615329)
Yes. What's the problem?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by CyberDildonics on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:01PM (#38615847)
Prove it by copy and pasting your DNA in a reply.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by hot_gril on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:09PM (#38617700)
Someone did it above.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by dekhn on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:23PM (#38617023)
There is no practical way to prevent it, so yes, it's OK because there is no reasonable alternative.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by croes on Thursday December 14, 2023 @03:27PM (#38646788)
So everything you can't prevent is ok?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:19PM (#38618726)
No, the company in question made promises about the security of it and has broken those promises. Now their customer's DNA is potentially available to anyone (not just governments). They should pay dearly for breaking these promises. This is not the point of my original comment.

The person I'm responding to is victim-blaming, and also making the completely silly claim that it's irresponsible to willingly "leak" DNA through some vague lens that it's going to be used to harm your descendants for generations.

DNA sequencing is constantly becoming more affordable and accessible. Unless regulated, this will be data that gets collected and abused en-masse. It's a little expensive now, but I could easily sequence just about anyone's DNA today as long as I have some sort of physical access to a space they use. If that's the commenters concern, they'd be much better off focusing on that rather than blaming people for expecting a company to keep medical data secure.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by kelthan on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:01PM (#38620695)
If the government is providing healthcare, as it does in many countries, then they have it already.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by eimrine on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:22AM (#38614274)
The DNA we are leaking is impossible to copy unlike the DNA we are sending to 23andme.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by dekhn on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:10PM (#38615047)
No; this is factually wrong.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by eimrine on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:35PM (#38616339)
And not even a bit of clarifying? If you can convert the DNA sample into two DNA copies without destroying the sample, probably you are a God.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by dekhn on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:00PM (#38616699)
You said "The DNA we are leaking is impossible to copy unlike the DNA we are sending to 23andme."

I said it was wrong because if people collect environmental human DNA samples and "copy" them (amplify with PCR).

Not sure what you mean about destroying the sample- you typically take part of the sample and amplify it without destroying the whole thing.

I'm just unsure of what you are trying to say here; I'm responding with purely factual answers based on modern DNA technology.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by boringuser2 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:08PM (#38615007)
Why do you care again?

It's DNA, not your BitWarden password.

Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:49AM (#38614707)
Nanpore sequencing can be done with a device that can fit into your pocket, these devices can be found for less than $1000.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by atemerev on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:30AM (#38614379)
You know, you can send other peoples DNA to sequencing services too…
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by eimrine on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:36PM (#38616355)
Probably you can send to them anything else but how it relates to my comment?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by atemerev on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:39PM (#38617252)
Meaning that your DNA is not safe, even if you yourself never send it. DNA is leaking everywhere, anyone could collect it and send for analysis.
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by themaninthedark on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:46PM (#38621126)
Your SSN and credit card number are listed on many documents and are transmitted by you all the time, why do you have a problem posting them in clear text here for us?
Re:23andMe frantically changed its terms of service to preve... by micromacrofoot on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:15AM (#38653849)
what can you buy with my dna