News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by cracrecry on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:32PM (#38510973)
Does it?

I firmly believe that most problems people have with sleep also depend on modern "way of living", that is highly Artificial.

For example, lots of people have Apnea, and Apnea is highly correlated with being obese, and being obese is normal in the Western world, but it was not 100 years ago.

So it is not about being older but about being overweight, something that depends on eating healthy and exercising, that most people do not do.

Another important factor is artificial lighting, again a 100 years old thing, people that have used candles know how dim they are, and people using screens in the bedroom until late, specially social media.

Social Media is addictive, but you don't need to use it, people can stop using it, but they just don't want to.

Also living in the city is noisy, expensive and stressful. Most people are worried about lots of things, and that makes them sleep badly.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by schwartzworld on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:51PM (#38512038)
That's a very simplistic view of apnea. You don't have to be fat to experience it, and this misconception is a bit part of why it's underdiagnosed.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by roody15 on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:55PM (#38512472)
“ Interactions Between Obesity and Sleep Apnea Among the risk factors for OSA, obesity is probably the most important. Several cross-sectional studies have consistently found an association between increased body weight and the risk of OSA.16 Significant sleep apnea is present in ≈40% of obese individuals,17 and ≈70% of OSA patients are obese. Furthermore, in a population-based prospective study of 690 randomly selected Wisconsin residents, a 10% weight gain was associated with a 6-fold increase in the odds of development of sleep apnea (Figure 4).18 In the same study, a 10% weight loss predicted a 26% decrease in the apnea-hypopnea index (Figure 4). Similarly, in several other case-control studies, weight loss in OSA patients led to a significant decrease in apnea frequency.1”

https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/full/10.1161/01.hyp.00001016...

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by schwartzworld on Monday December 04, 2023 @08:40AM (#38517055)
> In the same study, a 10% weight loss predicted a 26% decrease in the apnea-hypopnea index

This isn't as earth shaking as you imagine. The minimum AHI for diagnosis (in the US) IS 5. 20ahi (meaning you stop breathing 20 times per hour on average), is pretty mild. Some people have ahi over 100. Meaning a 26% decrease isn't actually doing much for you.

What I can tell you is that I know several people who seem to have sleep apnea, complaining about the symptoms, who were told by their PCP that they don't need a sleep study because they weren't fat. When your partner complains about you choking in your sleep all night, you probably should a get it checked out regardless of your BMI. I honestly believe that doing a sleep study once every couple of years should be considered routine for everyone. We check our eyes, blood pressure, testicles, skin... Why not check for sleep quality prophylactically?

I'm not saying you're wrong, but the OP using the condition as proof of societal causes of sleep issues is way off the mark. Skinny people can experience it. Children experience it. Bodybuilders are quite prone to it. As tissues loosen and sag with age across the body, old people are prone to it.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by appplication on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:47PM (#38512423)
Agree. While sleep apnea risk does increase with obesity, it has a fairly high baseline. Sleep apnea is one of the most diagnosed conditions in service members separating or retiring from the military, and that is by definition not an obese group.

I have sleep apnea and am one of the most fit people I know. When I was in the military, I encouraged many of my friends who sleep poorly to get a sleep test and many of them - fit and young - were surprised to learn they also had it. I would not be surprised if some significant portion of the population has it and is just unaware. At anything short of severe levels, many people would never even suspect they have it.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by throwaway2037 on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:15AM (#38514197)

    Sleep apnea is one of the most diagnosed conditions in service members separating or retiring from the military
Woah. Why? Is there something specific about the (US?) military that causes it? Or do doctors measure/monitor for it more closely -- similar to the "explosion" of ADHD diagnoses in the last 20 years.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by appplication on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:57AM (#38514390)
It is possible there are legitimate links (I lived and worked near the burn pits and those for sure messed up my respirstory system). But maybe more likely is because you get an automatic 50% disability rating from the VA when you’re diagnosed in service. It’s automatically presumed that if you had no diagnosis before that it is service connected. I.e. you developed it as a result of your service and therefore the VA will compensate you for it.

This means an extra $1-2 thousand per month for life in most cases. So there is this natural experiment where we have a population with a very high incentive to get tested compared to the baseline population.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by CobaltFire on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:28AM (#38518420)
This is no longer the case as of a year or two ago; they lowered it quite a bit. Even then it was quite hard to fake it; it just encouraged everyone to get tested.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by nonameiguess on Monday December 04, 2023 @11:47AM (#38519571)
It's not like you can just fake sleep apnea. The VA makes you get a sleep study. But it does raise the question of whether it's more common than we think for people to develop it between 20 and 50 or so and we simply don't realize it for non-veterans because they're less likely to get tested.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by CobaltFire on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:26AM (#38518405)
As someone who retired after 22 years in the US Military:

Because the toll that way of life takes on your body is at least a magnitude more than most civilians realize.

Years of little sleep in poor condition while under constant low level stress, being in unfamiliar conditions where you never quite feel safe sleeping, constant interruptions because the military activities don't stop while YOU sleep, poor temperature control (hot or cold), poor hygiene availability, poor sleeping surfaces, odd work schedules, short sleeping schedules...

Those are just the factors that you deal with for decades that relate to sleep. I wasn't a grunt; I did do a lot of move fast and don't break things or people die stuff (Nuclear Power, SAR Aviation, Amphibious Operations) and that was just how life was.

We had a few overweight people, but they were the exception. Those of us who were more senior were just all broken in so many ways. I don't THINK I have sleep apnea, but I do have trouble sleeping from the pain I'm in every night from a back injury and multiple autoimmune issues that cause flareups and pain.

The cost on those that serve is absolutely astounding. I don't recommend service to anyone.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by BenjiWiebe on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:16PM (#38512206)
It is definitely highly correlated, as the commenter said.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by neffy on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:41AM (#38515385)
It's correlated, but the causality may be reversed. That is to say, sleep apnea probably causes and certainly doesn't help, obesity. There is a strong relationship between not getting enough sleep, and appetite control.

There are also a lot of other causes of sleep apnea, physiology being a big one, also obstructions in the nasal canal.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by behringer on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:16PM (#38512208)
he's clearly not talking about the people with apnea who are not overweight in that particular example...
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by mensetmanusman on Sunday December 03, 2023 @09:46PM (#38513173)
I believe that your view and the OP's are correct simultaneously.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by tibbydudeza on Monday December 04, 2023 @08:01AM (#38516714)
The increasing incidents of removal of wisdom teeth seems to indicate the human jaw is getting smaller due to our dietary changes since we moved on from hunter gatherers to pastoral farming.

Sleep apnea is not because you have fat in your neck obstructing your airway but your tongue relaxing at night and the area below the uvula falling backwards then obstructing your airway.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by m0llusk on Monday December 04, 2023 @09:00PM (#38526066)
In particular sleep apnea is extremely common among weightlifters. It turns out that even modest weightlifting tends to increase muscle throughout the body and even a small increase in the size of the muscles of the neck can fundamentally change breathing during sleep.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by letmevoteplease on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:39PM (#38511023)
Also alarm clocks, caffeine, unnatural sleep schedules. This site[1] has lots of good information, with this basic (unfortunately impossible for many) recommendation:

"There is only one formula for healthy and refreshing sleep: Go to sleep only when you are very tired. Not earlier. Not later. Wake up naturally without an alarm clock."

[1] https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Science_of_sleep

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by hermanradtke on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:45PM (#38511078)
> only when you are very tired

The sleep formula article said “truly sleepy” which, to me, is significantly different from “very tired”.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by EA-3167 on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:43PM (#38511059)
Unfortunately for me that would entail staying up until 3AM and waking up at 11AM. That might work for me, but it doesn't work for my professional or social life.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by jedberg on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:21PM (#38511835)
During the early pandemic, neither of my kids had school and my wife wasn't working (and I was running my own company and set the meeting time). So we just turned off all the alarms. Went to bed when we wanted, woke up when we wanted.

The kids would go to bed around 2am and wake up around 11am. My wife and I would go to bed around 3-4am and wake up at 11am. It was fantastic.

Sadly modern life doesn't allow for that, as we have to take them to school at a set time and I have to meet with other people now.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by ClimaxGravely on Sunday December 03, 2023 @11:10PM (#38513655)
That sounds sublime. I'm currently working for a company that allows me to be fairly flexible with my hours and I've found it's been amazing for my productivity.

Some days I wake up late and miss a portion of the work day but I'm able to work later and have a fresh mind for the entirety of my work time. With this routine I've found I'm managing to accomplish way more than I did in a previously more rigid environment.

Currently I'm an IC so it's easier to have this kind of schedule. At past jobs when I was in more of a managerial role so this wouldn't have been as easy due to the amount of meetings with various partners and employees.

This experience has been so positive it's made it so that I'm now pursuing a job/career where I can maintain this lifestyle. I loathe wasting time sitting around because I'm tired.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by throwaway2037 on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:17AM (#38514211)
This is a wild post. Thank you to share! Did you write any blog posts about this experience? I would be a fascinating read.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by jedberg on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:00AM (#38514414)
No, I didn't think it would be that interesting. I tell the story from time to time when it's relevant. :)

I mean, my post above is pretty much all there is. We basically lived on that schedule until my daughter started online kindergarten. Then we made her roll out of bed at 8:38 to be online by 8:40.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by angrais on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:40PM (#38520314)
Am I understanding this correctly: you let your 3-5 year old daughter stay up each night to 02:00?

When did the sun set where you lived during that time? I suppose that was a big influence on sleep times?

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by jedberg on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:44PM (#38520369)
Yes, that is correct. And they slept until they weren't tired anymore, which was usually 9ish hours, a totally normal amount of sleep for someone that age.

We live in the Bay Area, so the sun was setting around 8pm since it was spring/summer. Our whole family are night owls, but regular society just isn't designed for that.

Of course now that they have regular school they have a regular bedtime that still gets them 9+ hours sleep (actually closer to 10 hours), but they are still groggy and slow in the morning because it is not when their body wants to be awake.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by sen on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:48PM (#38511102)
Yeah I had a period before I had kids and when I worked for myself where I could sleep whenever I wanted. I’d get tired around 3-4am, go to sleep about 5am, wake up around 12-1pm, and felt great every day. The most energy, motivation, and general good moods I’ve had in my life.

Then kids + career = 10pm-5am sleep schedule and pretty much feel tired (struggling-to-function tired) 24/7.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by gambiting on Sunday December 03, 2023 @05:44PM (#38511538)
In the same cart now. Not sure how you can stay functional as a human with a 2 year old who won't sleep past 6am. Going to bed super early doesn't seem to help either. I can force myself to go to sleep before 10pm so in theory I get a full restorative 8 hours of sleep, but I don't feel anywhere near as rested as I was doing 2am-10am.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by gsk22 on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:13PM (#38512179)
It sounds like you may have delayed sleep phase disorder -- basically, a late-shifted circadian rhythm. I keep similar hours by default and was diagnosed with DSPD about 5 years ago. It explained a lot of issues in my life and was a relief to hear that I wasn't just "lazy" like all the morning people always told me!

As an additional plus, if you are in the United States, sleep disorders qualify as disabilities, which means employers are generally required to make reasonable accommodations, including later working hours. I find that tech companies are generally fine with varying hours anyway, but it's a nice tool to keep in your back pocket in case you have a manager that insists on 9am meetings.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by wkat4242 on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:34AM (#38514998)
I'm pretty sure I have this too. In the evenings I'd always have this invigoration even when I was young. And in the morning I just can't get up. My day is always flexible at the end and never at the start.

I wonder where and how to get this diagnosed though.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by gsk22 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @02:46AM (#38553918)
Tell your doctor about your symptoms and ask them to refer you to a sleep study. They hook you up to monitors and watch you overnight. That's how I was diagnosed.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by fishtacos on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:05PM (#38511710)
In my teenage years, I was a nocturnal primate. It worked with my work schedule (retail, 2pm start), but, as has been noted by others here, as well, that simply will not work anymore. Both due to age and due to work requirements. Social life isn't particularly impacted, but tiredness due to lack of sleep has impacted both work effectiveness and even getting work, where I showed up at interviews groggy and clearly slower in responses and ability to express what was my intent vs. what came out. Haven't figured out a balance yet, but at the very least I have an idea of what causes it, exacerbated by stress and related causalities.

I think the worst aspect of it nowadays is that the cycle seems difficult to break. Thanks to this conversational reminder, I'll try to hit the hay when the body seeks it, no matter how early. Waking up is not a problem. It's the falling asleep part that has caused me to gray severely in the past 3 years, through and post pandemic.

It came on so quickly and strongly, I still feel robbed.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by throwaway2037 on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:24AM (#38514239)
Grey hair is your main concern here? Just dye it. (I assume you are a man. Why? Most women in the developed world start dying their hair to hide grey hair in their 40s.) In East Asia, it is also very common for men to dye their hair to hide grey hair.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by wkat4242 on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:32AM (#38514990)
I think the OP doesn't mean the grey hair part literally but figuratively, like synonymous for worry.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by fishtacos on Monday December 04, 2023 @07:49PM (#38525584)
To reply to you and previous commenter, it's a combination of both. Literally, I've grayed within the past 2 years excessively (or perhaps normal by hittin 40 - it felt rather quick). The worries and stress and existential this and that (without going into details, we all swallow some bullets) clearly made a difference, and CV-19 didn't help.

It's ultimately a synonym for worry - and whatever it entails.

As for literally dying my hair, I did once a while ago. Never again. It felt awkward, impersonal, awkward (x2), fraudulent, and so on. It's good to feel comfotable in one one's skin, even while it whithers.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by hermanradtke on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:46PM (#38511087)
It is worse. The sleep formula article says free sleep often involves 24 hour sleep sessions, which is practically impossible for most people.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by golergka on Sunday December 03, 2023 @05:31PM (#38511417)
One more reason to embrace fully remote work with async communication. I’m in my top work shape at 2am, when slack is dead silent.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by globular-toast on Sunday December 03, 2023 @05:37PM (#38511473)
> "There is only one formula for healthy and refreshing sleep: Go to sleep only when you are very tired. Not earlier. Not later. Wake up naturally without an alarm clock."

I did that for years when I was younger. For me that meant a longer-than-24-hour day which quickly led to being completely nocturnal. Those were dark days, literally and figuratively. I can distinctly remember my first "day" without daylight. It wasn't a nice feeling. I would usually try to correct it when that happened which was like having a 12 hour jet lag.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by tstrimple on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:46PM (#38512005)
Whenever I let my schedule go I usually end up in a similar situation. It almost feels like my body would prefer a 19 hour wake period with 7 hours of sleep which would keep my sleep wake cycle rotating throughout a 24 hour period. Not very conducive to working in a business setting with meetings and such.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by intelVISA on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:51PM (#38513538)
I'm jealous of people who are aligned to the magic 24hr sleep cycle, for me my days feel better as 20hrs awake 10hrs asleep vs traditional 16:8.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by ClimaxGravely on Sunday December 03, 2023 @11:13PM (#38513673)
Absolutely. I often fantasize what a different length day might be like.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by throwawaytemp29 on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:14AM (#38513956)
Me too. I had a 26 hour schedule for like a month once. It seems fine til it isn’t.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by earthling8118 on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:32AM (#38514282)
I did this once. It was great. I still think of it and wish I could go back.

Yes, it causes issues within our society. That's the only thing keeping me from it and I bemoan this on a daily basis. If we were more flexible I could thrive.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by globular-toast on Monday December 04, 2023 @05:05AM (#38515504)
For me it wasn't just about society. In the UK in the winter we only have 6 hours of daylight. So I would be sleeping through that for a week and basically living in a dark world. Not only is it thoroughly limiting as there's so much you can only do in daylight, it just seemed really "wrong" and caused depression to set in very quickly.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by Obscurity4340 on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:19AM (#38518307)
Do you experiment with light at all? I feel like light is an important mediating nexus between depression and lifestyle that is horrificially underexamined and unexplored
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by Obscurity4340 on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:17AM (#38518289)
I feel like if you ensure you get the same blast of waking light every day it doesn't really matter what you do, your appetite for sleep and your circ will ensure you crash when that needs to happen and you will entrain yourself to more or less arise at basically the same timeframe
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by nunez on Sunday December 03, 2023 @08:38PM (#38512762)
That formula does not work if your cicardian rhythm is untuned, which is the case for many people. It takes lots and lots of repetition to get to the point where you can wake up without alarms at a consistent time.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:43PM (#38513498)
Do you have to wake up at the exact same time?

I wake up with the alarm only if I go to bed too late, otherwise I assume I have to sleep for 10 hours, go to bed and my body naturally wakes up between 830 and 930 hours of sleep. Very resting. Also if I gwt 2 days of 9 hours, the next day usually I end up sleeping 8 and still feel rested, so it seems the body naturally adjusts

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by immibis on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:32PM (#38511916)
My monitor's lowest brightness setting is almost uncomfortably bright in the dark. The same on my phone, but the lowest brightness setting is okay, but the second lowest is far too bright.

Hardware designers reading this: add darker brightness settings FFS.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by CodeLikeHell on Sunday December 03, 2023 @06:43PM (#38511981)
If you have an iPhone, you can lower the brightness even further by going to Settings > Accessibility > Accessibility Shortcut and enabling “Reduce white point”. Then you can triple press the power button to toggle it.

But I agree with your overall point. It shouldn’t be hidden under accessibility, and more devices should have lower brightness settings.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by marc_abonce on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:41PM (#38512385)
I assume it's hidden to stop users from accidentally setting brightness to its true lowest and then being unable to revert the change because the screen would now be too dark for most users to see anything at all.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by danielscrubs on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:14AM (#38514492)
Ive set that to guided access so my child can play with the phone. If anyone from Apple are reading this consider it a feature request to start this and guided access from the top right control panel. I need both.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by wkat4242 on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:37AM (#38515010)
Yep and actual low brightness settings. Not mess with the contrast so it reduces colour depth, which is what most screens do for low brightness levels :(
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by burjui on Monday December 04, 2023 @07:40AM (#38516536)
I use sunglasses for that.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by Izkata on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:31PM (#38522629)
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by SantalBlush on Sunday December 03, 2023 @05:10PM (#38511233)
All of these other factors you've mentioned do nothing to rule out age as a factor. These things aren't mutually exclusive.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by edmundsauto on Sunday December 03, 2023 @09:23PM (#38513044)
Another important factor is pain. Pain prevents sound sleep. My mom, who has bad rheumatoid arthritis, says that a regular strength Tylenol will knock her out.

This is because it reduces her baseline pain to a point where she can rest.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by throwaway2037 on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:29AM (#38514268)
This is a great point. I remember having my wisdom teeth removed in early university. The pain was unbearable at night. I would take pain killers... then wake up 4-6 hours later after they wore off. Waking up from pain is an incredible experience. I can still clearly remember it. And, to state the obvious: After surgery, good sleep is important for healing!
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by tqi on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:36PM (#38513458)
Respectfully, "I firmly believe" followed by an assertion from a non expert passing as "facts" is a pox on our modern society.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by tempmac on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:16AM (#38513962)
ditto this... "100 years ago" just seem to imply a lot of missing data points (and/or anecdata with lots of mislabeled data)
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by AB1725 on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:01AM (#38514430)
The real "pox" is shutting down someone giving their opinions in good faith.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:44AM (#38518651)
The phrase "shutting down" here is doing a lot of work.

Why don't we characterize it as "challenging" them?

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by glitchcrab on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:31PM (#38520208)
But they're not challenging them, are they? If they were challenging the opinions then there would need some sort of rebuttal. Instead they're essentially saying that OP worded it wrongly and therefore their points are invalid.
Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:11PM (#38520743)
Call it what you want, pushing back on someone's opinion is acceptable, fine, and should be encouraged.

What we need to stop doing is making arguments that something being an opinion means it shouldn't be pushed back on.

It's one thing if someone says I like broccoli better than pizza, it's another when someone makes a statement that is not about their own preferences. Many of those opinions are bad and should be challenged.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by brightlancer on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:44PM (#38521233)
> pushing back on someone's opinion is acceptable,

They didn't push back on the _opinion_, they pushed back on _expressing an opinion_:

¨Respectfully, "I firmly believe" followed by an assertion from a non expert passing as "facts" is a pox on our modern society.¨

Nothing in there is "challenging" the opinion or "pushing back" on the opinion -- it's criticizing _expressing an opinion_.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:22AM (#38527703)
this is slicing and dicing of words to try and weave a narrative.

The poster reacted to an opinion negatively and pointed out that people need to stop that behavior.

Can you imagine if someone said "raping children should be ok" and someone else tried to argue that saying people should stop raping children means they attacked the person and not the opinion?

right, they challenged the opinion, stop with the wordplay.

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by pfannkuchen on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:51AM (#38514721)
Doesn’t the preface “I firmly believe” clearly indicate a (strong) personal opinion?

Consider: “I firmly believe that fire is hot”. Sounds a bit odd, no?

Re:Why does sleep becomes more elusive as we age? Shifts in ... by vGPU on Monday December 04, 2023 @07:30AM (#38516469)
I am neither fat nor obese. In fact, I’m a former amateur bodybuilder. I have sleep apnea. It’s not so much weight as size of the neck.