It’s like selling dates. If you’re selling your time that’s fine, so a lunch dating experience is fine. However, if you bundle sex in with a ‘overnight experience’ that’s considered prostitution and illegal in many areas.
Do you have a source for that? Because that would definitely be the crux of the issue then.
The article itself quotes:
> "In its ruling, the CJEU expressly recognised that a subscription model, like the one we are announcing, is a valid form of consent for an ads funded service."
which suggests that it is not illegal. But of course this depends on whether the "ads funded service" includes tracking.
I can't find any clear answers from a few quick google searches. Of course, the existence of this lawsuit suggests that the law itself may not yet be sufficiently clear, and so the judicial ruling will ultimately provide that clarity.
Source, for example https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/consent/#:~:text=Consent%20must%....
or
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-re...
or
https://www.bfdi.bund.de/EN/Buerger/Inhalte/Allgemein/Datens...
https://noyb.eu/en/pay-or-okay-tech-news-site-heisede-illega...
However, law is slow and it will take a while to propagate to more sites.
It doesn't seem to declare that the model is fundamentally illegal. Also, wouldn't that kind of decision need to be taken at the EU level? Because until then, you could have all sorts of inconsistencies between localities and countries.
For example, the ICO link specifically states that it's OK to make a customer rewards loyalty card dependent upon tracking -- a clear exchange of allowing tracking explicitly in exchange for cash equivalents. That's still consent freely given.
A lot of the limits around consent are described with regards to employment, because there's an imbalance of power there. But that's irrelevant here.
The clearest prohibition is around "coupling", e.g. you can't make a purchase of an online grocery order contingent on sharing your data with third parties, because there's nothing "necessary" about that to fulfill the purpose.
But it seems pretty easy to make the case that tracking is "necessary" for fully effective advertising (ads without tracking perform much worse). So either subscribe for no ads (thus no tracking), or accept ads (and accept tracking). There doesn't seem to be any imbalance of power here, because you don't need to use Facebook the way you need to keep a job. Your consent is freely given, just like with a rewards card.
Although at the end of the day, the law does seems vague enough that it will be useful for a court decision to clarify it.
However, linking the lack of tracking with buying a zero advertising tier is clearly coupling not a discount. Consider the reverse what if someone wants to pay for zero advertising but is perfectly willing to have tracking. Thus we’ve discovered 4 possible decisions and FB is trying to artificially limit them.
Are the courts really supposed to mandate that FB provide 4 tiers instead of just 2?
We're already in checkbox hell with the various popups. And the notion of "coupling" is notoriously hard to define in practice.
It's precisely the vagueness around what is and isn't coupling, that I could see the courts going either way. I was really just arguing that it's not clear cut according to the law as written.
They can have 2 options advertising based with and without tracking, or 3 options, paid without tracking, advertising with tracking, and advertising without. Or even as you suggest 4 options.
I doubt EU lawmakers planned for this approach to defeat privacy laws, it's definitely against the spirit but this will need an update. In FB case if you pay they 100% still track you anyway, they've been pretty clear they don't care even if they get caught.
Another angle against FB moving to a paid access system would be they could be considered public service due to how omnipresent the service is in day to day life, but lately it's probably more true for their other services like Insta or Whatsapp.
> This is one of the dumbest things about GDPR and one of the reasons why the EU has a stagnant tech industry.
If progress means having to exist in a world without the GDPR, then I'm good stagnating.
And it makes sense that there is nothing like that in there. Subscriptions were totally irrelevant to the actual questions that the CJEU was asked to rule on in that case (which was e.g. a claim by the German competition authorities that it was impossible for anyone to freely consent to tracking by Meta due to them having a dominant market position, and a counter-claim that the competition authorities did not even have jurisdiction over a GDPR case).
[0] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...
They just don't get any benefit of the doubt anymore.
Facebook is likely in the same situation as drug dealers, prostitutes, assassins etc the existence of willing customers doesn’t make their business model legal. They can change their business model or change the law.
Of course if it’s possible that they win, but completely baseless lawsuits get dismissed.
I'm using empathy here, as someone who quit facebook 15 years ago. Saying it's easy to quit facebook is like saying it's easy to quit the gas company, or eating meat. You don't have to use natural gas, and you don't need meat.
A) Pay 9.99. No tracking.
B) Ads. No tracking.
C) Ads. Tracking. For that consent is required.
The point is that consent needs to be voluntary to be valid. That is the huge legal difference. Pretty simple concept, but unpopular with advertisers.
So the comparison with A) is a red herring to distract from the lack of consent.
Are we talking 1% or are we talking 50%?
(What if tracking-based ads are actually less effective, as in: "I'm hesitant to click on an ad that keeps following me around"; "I've already bought this thing, will you please stop showing me this ad?"; etc)
This is more akin to not liking sharp rocks, but choosing to throw yourself off a cliff.
It's not like the sharp rocks at the bottom of that cliff are waiting for you as you live your life frolicking across gentle meadows. You have to choose to go and climb that cliff and throw yourself off the top of it.
No-one is forcing you to use their service.
A) Pay the 10 euros a month, no ads, no tracking whatsoever
B) Don't pay the 10 euros a month, get ads, but no tracking if you don't EXPLICITLY consent to it. Ads != tracking, they can exist without invasive tracking.
C) Don't pay the 10 euros, get ads and assuming you don't care about tracking you consent to it. You get more personalized ads in exchange for this, which for some people I guess is a good deal
Instead, what's happening is:
A) Pay the 10 euros a month, get no ads, but still get tracked (let's be real here, it's Meta we're talking about)
B) Don't pay, you have no option but to consent to being tracked and being shown ads. This is what's illegal. If they don't want users to have a chance to voice their consent, then they should close down shop in the EU and only offer their services to paying customers, but we all know Meta doesn't want to lose out on the 2nd largest market in the world.
Maybe, juuuuust maybe, putting the phrase, "It's free, and always will be," right next to where you log in for eleven years wasn't the smartest of ideas.
Option B is what some German online newspapers have been doing, and so far it's held in the lower courts, but there's been no binding precedent at national or Europe-wide level. If that were confirmed at a higher level, then legally, there would be a very big difference between Options A and B.
A recent ruling on behavioural advertising seems to suggest that Option B may not be in accord with the law either, and that's certainly what the NOYB lawsuit claims.
This isn't entirely true. Companies didn't reduce ticket fares at the same time when they rolled out baggage fees. It was a de-facto price increase for many travelers.
no, it's because of the predatory manner in which these fees are presented. they hook you on the cheap price of the ticket, and then whack you in the head with the fees so that the actual cost of the trip is no where near the advertised ticket price. much like ticketmaster, airbnb, resorts, and any other industry with these additional charges
All fees and taxes posted up front with a grand total below them. And preferably some check boxes to include or remove some fees from the calculation if they are or are not relevant to your particular situation.
At the very least some warning that additional fees exist and will be calculated at checkout or whatever isn't too much to ask.
There are the brokers that operate on a commission basis: you get the exchange price but pay a commission on each trade.
And there's the "free" brokers where there's no commission because it's already included in the spread. That is, the price you see is a resell of the original exchange price with broker's markup. I ain't fooled by "free" which can end up more expensive than transparently commissioned but maybe some people are.
You don't actually need tracking for ads.
There are a lot of business models that are feasible with tracking for ads, but are not feasible to offer for free without tracking.
- "this is free forever" (remember FaceBook moto), killing the market using this and then, when there's no nore competitor (on specific age class for example), saying "OK, now pay"
AND
- "this is a charged service, but you may access it for free as long as you respect some limitations" : in that case, from day-1, you know that either you'll have a basic service or you'll have to pay someday.
Note: in the second case, when a "free tier" is degraded to force people to pay, it's the same problem as Facebook...
In fact, I think that the real problem here - and what people are fed up with - is the bait-and-switch
1) I promise that I'll promise something for free forever 2) People trust me and invest in me... so I kill the market 3) Then, when there's no real competitor, I try to charge
Even for capitalist, this way of doing business is just: how to build a monopoly to evade the market competition
So yeah... let's sue Facebook... and make it a clear example for all businesses around the world that this way of doing things is definetly NOT OKAY
I guess this case will clarify whether that's true.
If the EU really wants to ban ad-supported sites, they should just come out and do it.
A) Facebook is free, but pay €9.99/mo. if you don't want ads or ad tracking
B) Facebook costs €9.99/mo., but will enable a free tier if you'll accept ads/tracking
Option A seems to provoke outrage (like this article/lawsuit), while option B seems... perfectly reasonable. Even though they're the same thing.
People just hate having stuff taken away from them. They feel that Facebook ought to be free because it always has been, the same way a lot of people are still bothered by checked baggage fees on airlines because checked baggage had been included for decades.
But legally, there's really no difference. And companies have to make money somehow. It would be fascinating if EU regulations actually led to the birth of an alternate, optional internet model where you paid $40/mo. extra to your ISP that got sent to Meta/Google/etc. according to your browsing proportions and resulted in no ads and no ad tracking across Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, AdSense, etc.