News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta sued by privacy group over pay up or click OK model by crazygringo on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @11:33AM (#38461560)
Yup, and those three links don't provide a clear answer against it either.

For example, the ICO link specifically states that it's OK to make a customer rewards loyalty card dependent upon tracking -- a clear exchange of allowing tracking explicitly in exchange for cash equivalents. That's still consent freely given.

A lot of the limits around consent are described with regards to employment, because there's an imbalance of power there. But that's irrelevant here.

The clearest prohibition is around "coupling", e.g. you can't make a purchase of an online grocery order contingent on sharing your data with third parties, because there's nothing "necessary" about that to fulfill the purpose.

But it seems pretty easy to make the case that tracking is "necessary" for fully effective advertising (ads without tracking perform much worse). So either subscribe for no ads (thus no tracking), or accept ads (and accept tracking). There doesn't seem to be any imbalance of power here, because you don't need to use Facebook the way you need to keep a job. Your consent is freely given, just like with a rewards card.

Although at the end of the day, the law does seems vague enough that it will be useful for a court decision to clarify it.

Re:Meta sued by privacy group over pay up or click OK model by Retric on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @01:07PM (#38462849)
There’s a major flaw in that argument. Advertising without tracking still generates revenue, so having two different amounts of advertising based on tracking or no tracking is likely permissible.

However, linking the lack of tracking with buying a zero advertising tier is clearly coupling not a discount. Consider the reverse what if someone wants to pay for zero advertising but is perfectly willing to have tracking. Thus we’ve discovered 4 possible decisions and FB is trying to artificially limit them.

Re:Meta sued by privacy group over pay up or click OK model by crazygringo on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @01:30PM (#38463177)
Right, but this is where it just gets unwieldy.

Are the courts really supposed to mandate that FB provide 4 tiers instead of just 2?

We're already in checkbox hell with the various popups. And the notion of "coupling" is notoriously hard to define in practice.

It's precisely the vagueness around what is and isn't coupling, that I could see the courts going either way. I was really just arguing that it's not clear cut according to the law as written.

Re:Meta sued by privacy group over pay up or click OK model by Retric on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @03:41PM (#38465011)
I agree there is some vagueness here, but the number of options isn’t mandated. FB is free to only have 1 option advertising supported without tracking, or 1 option paid without tracking.

They can have 2 options advertising based with and without tracking, or 3 options, paid without tracking, advertising with tracking, and advertising without. Or even as you suggest 4 options.