News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by spaceman_2020 on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:15AM (#38431926)
How soon - if ever - will AI tools be able to replace or at least reduce the demand for these offshoring companies? I've seen the code some of them put out. Even chatGPT 3.5 can be better than them.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by pjmlp on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:19AM (#38431955)
Beware of one wishes for, it starts with offshoring companies, juniors will follow and eventually only the AI druids will code.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by thejackgoode on Monday November 27, 2023 @11:05AM (#38433946)
prompt shamans, yes
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by HenryBemis on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:22AM (#38431982)
Nope it cannot.

I have been using 3.5 to write code. I wrote a 'simple' app (200-300 lines) that although 'simple' it took A LOT of back and forth with the 3.5. In the end I had to spend a couple of days combing through it to add some key features (i.e. set values to zero so you don't see old data, etc.). Basically crude (but smart?) coding (I am not a professional developer).

When I finished the code and the app was performing EXACTLY as I wanted (v1.0), I thought to start planning for the v1.1 and when I pasted my code to the 3.5 and asked it to 'work on it on the new features' it was a shitstorm :)

Perhaps it was me feeding the requirements 'wrongly', but it was like pulling teeth 'guiding' it to correct even the simplest mistakes.

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by eddtries on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:36AM (#38432102)
I think you'll find the most succinct requirements for a program is the code itself - you can add more and more logic to guide GPT to generate something but eventually you're just writing code yourself anyway.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by spaceman_2020 on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:48AM (#38432192)
This is far too flippantly confident about a piece of tech that's barely a year old, and the inferior version of that.

I'm surprised by the inability of people in tech to extrapolate the advancement of this particular tech.

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by GabeIsko on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:28PM (#38435187)
I think there is a difference between mastering fluid dynamics to the point where you can have sustained power flight, and building a machine that arranges words next to other words based based problematically in training data.

But even if you want to torture this analogy, LLMs are a godsend to techncial service Companies. It's like saying "Oh, planes are faster so I guess people won't be spending as much time traveling and there will be less of it now".

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by eastern on Monday November 27, 2023 @11:44AM (#38434518)
It's like showing up at Kitty Hawk in 1903 and, "You mean this thing can't even fly me to New York? Useless!'
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by Semaphor on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:54AM (#38432235)
They replied to this:

> Even chatGPT 3.5 can be better than them.

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by spaceman_2020 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:12AM (#38443528)
I maintain that ChatGPT 3.5 can be better than entry level Infosys engineers.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by IggleSniggle on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:31AM (#38432062)
This is also how it is with offshoring.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by lacrimacida on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:30AM (#38432052)
GPT can sew snippets of code and see patterns but it has no understanding of coding and such. But even without this ability it could work amazingly well if you know what to ask for and accept its limitations.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by financltravsty on Monday November 27, 2023 @09:01AM (#38432311)
Try 4.0. I use it a lot for tedious glue code, and I couldn't be happier to have my time back to focus on more important things.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by BoorishBears on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:34AM (#38432090)
Someone who's not a professional developer was able to take the weakest model OpenAI offers today and get exactly what they wanted for a V1.

Have you actually worked with a consultancy? Have you priced out what the back and forth you had with 3.5 would have cost with a real human with a similar level of depth?

_

I personally don't think AI's effect on offshoring will be so cut and dry, since it's not like offshore developers can't level up with it too, but your example is showing how badly people are underestimating the impact AI will have on programming.

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by gosub100 on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:39AM (#38432128)
Didn't people ask that back in ~2000, "how soon before offshore employees take our jobs?". The devil is in the details. Can AI solve a linker error and fix a visual studio project file? Sure, if you train it with a million samples. I think the reason AI won't work for anything more than wireframe is that there are too many edge cases to adequately train it.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by ChrisMarshallNY on Monday November 27, 2023 @09:27AM (#38432577)
> Sure, if you train it with a million samples.

I am not an AI guru, but, from my limited understanding, LLMs use trillions of inputs, and that's one reason why they work so well.

What we have now, is barely out of the playpen. I am quite sure that specialized LLMs (like troubleshooters) are well under way.

Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by kfk on Monday November 27, 2023 @08:57AM (#38432269)
You are looking at this the wrong way. Moving IT to offshoring companies is a risk mitigation strategy, now if critical systems go down it's someone else's problem.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by dmatech on Monday November 27, 2023 @09:27AM (#38432583)
It's someone else's fault. It's even their problem. But it's still your problem too so long as it affects your business.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by tonyedgecombe on Monday November 27, 2023 @09:07AM (#38432363)
chatGPT will likely improve the standards of many low skilled developers.
Re:Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in co... by GabeIsko on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:15PM (#38435013)
A machine that doesn't actually understand anything, but is able to generate a ton of coherent text anyway? That's an offshore technical service company's dream.

What did you say? That it is also complicated to deploy properly? And there is no objective way to measure its success? Christmas keeps coming early.