Are there really people out there who believe that? I mean, agriculture was a BIG BIG BIG deal for humanity, it is not unreasonable to thing that this will have been out biggest deal.
Doesn't AI depend on humans feeding it data. how can it be self sustainable.
i guess i don't follow what this means.
What will they be replicating once humans are obsolete?
This statement is nonsensical. Unless you consider the end goal to be something other than humanity, which is obviously silly if you give it 5 minutes of thinking, various applications of ML can be either helpful or harmful but it cant make humans useless any more than a electricity and its application as washing machine can make clothing wearers useless.
Which isn't that nonsensical, if an AGI is created and follows similar processes as humans to acquire knowledge, skills, etc. it is a quite logical conclusion that it will be able to render humans useless: a very advanced AGI can imagine and develop technologies just like we do, it can direct resources and machinery to build whatever it creates, including self-replication, given access to resources it can potentially render humans useless.
That's at least what I interpreted from the comment.
One could say some future technology might be so good that humans need to do almost nothing in order to survive. Perhaps that’d pose some challenges in terms of mental health, but that is a very different issue, assuming it would be a issue at all (and assuming such technology is even possible in theory).
One could say some advanced technology could go out of control, or magically acquire self-awareness and agency (same thing in a philosophically dubious wrapper), or (more prosaically) be (intentionally or not) misused by humans so that it harms humans, but that just puts it into the bad category.
That said, I do doubt it is likely. What is much more likely is that, more prosaically, some humans will misuse the technology and harm other humans; a story as old as civilisation itself.
If we are talking about some software tool, you can't be unnecessary because the tool exists for you not the other way around. If your tool starts occupying your place in life, getting all the praise, taking away your job, taking away all your purpose of life, living in your family, parenting your children, taking care of your parents, sleeping with your wife (OK I'm joking at this point) then maybe the tool is harming your human rights, bad tool should be banned. Maybe someone who runs this tool now gets paid more and they should answer to the law. Maybe they even trained this tool on your data and you didn't think to object back then.
If you want to take care of your parents and do stuff in your home yourself, why would AGI force you not to? Id classify that as entertaining yourself. With purpose sure, but still.
> people with smarter assistants are indeed deluding themselves by thinking they're necessary
If they were not necessary then they would not be in a higher up position would they?
> If you want to take care of your parents and do stuff in your home yourself, why would AGI force you not to?
Yes. You can't be rendered useless by tech if tech is there for your benefit. (Though you can be harmed by tech if it is harmful or someone uses it against you for own benefit as part of obsolete dog eat dog society dynamic.)
An extraordinary claim needs extraordinary evidence. If you use the word "may", then I agree. But I don’t think it’s a certainty at this point.
I’m bullish on AI but with comments like that I sympathize with people who think it’s just a bunch of rebranded cryptocoin scammers.
If I understand it correctly.
I personally am unsure, but I worry Sam's departure is bad news for our trajectory. (Though I also feared his influence, as I fear anyone with heavy influence.)
Think all hospitals being administered by AI, all logistical chains bringing food to your plates, etc... it is not far fetched to bet on us relying a lot on AI, iff it works as well as some people think
(Possibly dumb) question: OpenAI isn't publicly traded right? Do market hours really matter for this sort of thing for private companies?
Yes, this is likely to be one of the most important events in human history. We are living through a special period of evolution on Earth.
As I understand the growth of chatGPT (both in number of users and capabilities) is only possible with more servers.
I'm right now developing on top of openAI API and I wonder if it's a good idea after all.
Computer energy needs grow exponentially so at some point we will hit a wall. Hard to estimate when. Energy tech is also an evolving field and fusion might arrive some day
It's hard to even argue, cause these things stand on very disparate levels of civilizatory pressure. AI has, no question, potential to deeply change human experience, but even if it does, that will be mostly due to extreme optimization of existing processes, not likely the development of new modes of living.
And it's very, very, very far from getting there. All this hype over Generational AI is, sadly, more of a Marketing stunt than anything else. Generational AI don't bring any great innovation in what AI can achieve, only in how people perceive what AI already does. GPT's biggest achievement is to sound coherent, not to leap forward human knowledge in any meaning full way.
I think about cars as an "extreme optimization of the wheel" and it completely changed the way people live. (See Suburbs)
I do share that AI is quite overhyped, but I think the seeds are juuuuuust starting to germinate.
Electric bulbs are neat, but there was inneficient artifical light before.
On the other hand, a caveman might look at the moon, but he would never land there without modern tools.
GAI doesn't allow us to overcome any Human inherent limitations, it's just an efficient tool (in certain scenarios).
Railways and Ocean Freighters, on the other hand, enable some pretty incredible cases. They allow food and goods to reach otherwise impossible places, regardless of the seasons, which allowed previously impossible developments.
And then there's airplanes
GAI doesn't enable Humanity to do anything that wasn't possible before. Perhaps we can do it more efficiently, but it's not turning the impossible into possible, like many other previous advancements did.
Until the AIs can build better AIs without needing humans. Give it 20 years.
Lol no, CEOs are overated, they don't contribute much to anything. Open AI will be just fine.
This use of "many" refers to HN voters not people in general.
1. It came completely out of left field, at a time when OpenAI has had an astonishingly successful year.
2. It was much more harshly worded than most corporate press releases letting their CEO go, basically accusing Sam Altman of serious wrongdoing.
3. It occurred during market hours and blindsided their investors and partners.
4. It revealed a schism inside the company that the public had little awareness of.
5. It has deep implications for the trajectory of a technology that many see as heralding a revolution at least as significant as — if not more than — agriculture or industry, with truly existential implications for humanity.
6. The revealed schism appears to go right to the heart of heated debates over those existential risks and the right course to navigate through them.