News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by nicoco on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:16AM (#38319851)
> at least as significant as — if not more than — agriculture

Are there really people out there who believe that? I mean, agriculture was a BIG BIG BIG deal for humanity, it is not unreasonable to thing that this will have been out biggest deal.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:19AM (#38319875)
Yes. Depending on improvement trajectory and implementation velocity, this could replace a material amount of global aggregate knowledge work.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by jowea on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:21AM (#38319891)
I think that may hold true if we put AI as one part of the greater Computer Revolution.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by JieJie on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:33AM (#38321291)
In my estimation, there are a significant number of scholars in the field from Turing to Wolfram, who believe that AGI is the inevitable conclusion of computing.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by DavidSJ on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:20AM (#38319885)
It’s of course hard to directly compare, in large part because the AI revolution wouldn’t be possible without the agricultural revolution. But yeah, a lot of people think AI is a BIG BIG BIG BIG (note: I used one more “BIG” than you) deal for humanity.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by cgoode on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:34AM (#38320055)
comparing chalk and cheese
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by layer8 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:38AM (#38320096)
Which one is the cheese?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by BobbyJo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:49AM (#38320222)
Depends on how you measure the bigness of the deal. AI, over the long term, will render humans mostly useless. We'll basically only be tasked with keeping ourselves entertained. Agriculture, if you disconnect it from the industrial revolution, really only allowed us to stay in on place while mostly not starving to death. Although, when the weather went bad, we did still starve to death.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by apwell23 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:01AM (#38320345)
> AI, over the long term, will render humans mostly useless

Doesn't AI depend on humans feeding it data. how can it be self sustainable.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Ma8ee on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:13AM (#38320451)
It will feed itself data, more or less in the same way as we do it.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by apwell23 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:41AM (#38320726)
novelty is not a probability, i believe. I don't know what it is though. Who knows where thought comes from.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Ma8ee on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:27PM (#38359232)
I meant by interacting with the world.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by apwell23 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:58PM (#38382593)
The world with humans in it?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Ma8ee on Saturday November 25, 2023 @02:20PM (#38415816)
Yes. Humans and birds and rocks and stars.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by BobbyJo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:55AM (#38320869)
No? AI already generates data via interacting with the world. Right now that experience happens mainly by proxy through humans, but, even now, that isn't strictly necessary.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by apwell23 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:46PM (#38322179)
> that isn't strictly necessary

i guess i don't follow what this means.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Vampiero on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:51AM (#38329885)
it means that AI isn't limited to ChatGPT on the web interface. AI can also be a robot with sensors (like a camera) and an internal model that processes sensory information and turns it into knowledge. Humans would only be needed to bootstrap such a robot, at which point it would be autonomous. Give it the ability to replicate and you've just made humans obsolete.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by apwell23 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:08PM (#38338817)
> Give it the ability to replicate and you've just made humans obsolete.

What will they be replicating once humans are obsolete?

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by throwaway290 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#38320449)
> AI, over the long term, will render humans mostly useless.

This statement is nonsensical. Unless you consider the end goal to be something other than humanity, which is obviously silly if you give it 5 minutes of thinking, various applications of ML can be either helpful or harmful but it cant make humans useless any more than a electricity and its application as washing machine can make clothing wearers useless.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by piva00 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:38AM (#38320689)
I understood from the comment, given the remark of "over the long term", the meaning over decades/centuries/millennia.

Which isn't that nonsensical, if an AGI is created and follows similar processes as humans to acquire knowledge, skills, etc. it is a quite logical conclusion that it will be able to render humans useless: a very advanced AGI can imagine and develop technologies just like we do, it can direct resources and machinery to build whatever it creates, including self-replication, given access to resources it can potentially render humans useless.

That's at least what I interpreted from the comment.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by strogonoff on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:19PM (#38321880)
No technology can render humans useless, since technology is the “how” whereas humans are the “why”. Technology can be seen as good/bad/neutral to humans in some ways, but rationally speaking—religious views aside—humans cannot logically be qualified in those terms with respect to technology.

One could say some future technology might be so good that humans need to do almost nothing in order to survive. Perhaps that’d pose some challenges in terms of mental health, but that is a very different issue, assuming it would be a issue at all (and assuming such technology is even possible in theory).

One could say some advanced technology could go out of control, or magically acquire self-awareness and agency (same thing in a philosophically dubious wrapper), or (more prosaically) be (intentionally or not) misused by humans so that it harms humans, but that just puts it into the bad category.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by piva00 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:36PM (#38387509)
I think where we diverge is that you are assuming we will be in control of such technology. I'm in the camp which doesn't think we would be really in control of a superhuman intelligence.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by strogonoff on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:11PM (#38394957)
Well, in that scenario I stand by my comment: if there is some technology that humans are in control of at all (as in, it literally performs in ways we are unable to predict), then it is simply harmful (because no ability to predict could significantly complicate things like survival). However, crucially, in no scenario it can make humans useless.

That said, I do doubt it is likely. What is much more likely is that, more prosaically, some humans will misuse the technology and harm other humans; a story as old as civilisation itself.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by BobbyJo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:56AM (#38320891)
Even if AGI was strictly human level, you'd have human level intelligence that was immortal, never got tired, and was instantly replicatable. Could you compete with a human that never needed sleep, had been studying for decades or centuries, and could make copies of itself on demand? I couldn't.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by mikeravkine on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:09AM (#38321033)
Why would you need to compete with such an entity? What does "compete" even mean here? Can't instead everyone get one (or 10) of these to.. assist them? I don't understand why we are jumping directly into dystopian scifi vs what past tool revolutions actually look like.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Jcowell on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:03PM (#38321652)
who’s going to give everyone one? How? In what world does AGI not end up being in the hands of corporations , wiping out jobs, causing mass unemployment before governments have the ability to enact effective legislation?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by BobbyJo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:11PM (#38321777)
If you have 10 "assistants" who are smarter than you, what are you actually doing that would take more than 5 minutes of your time? How could you convince yourself you're still necessary in that situation?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by throwaway290 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:27PM (#38321952)
Surely it's been a reality for years world over that stupider people end up occupying higher positions. One can have 10 subordinates each 10x smarter than the higher up and all that happens is subordinates get 100x work and the higher up in question gets a promotion. But remember that this is bad analogy because it is talking about humans and assistants have basic human stuff like rights and feelings and self awareness just like their boss.

If we are talking about some software tool, you can't be unnecessary because the tool exists for you not the other way around. If your tool starts occupying your place in life, getting all the praise, taking away your job, taking away all your purpose of life, living in your family, parenting your children, taking care of your parents, sleeping with your wife (OK I'm joking at this point) then maybe the tool is harming your human rights, bad tool should be banned. Maybe someone who runs this tool now gets paid more and they should answer to the law. Maybe they even trained this tool on your data and you didn't think to object back then.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by BobbyJo on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:45PM (#38322175)
Im not actually sure what you're trying to say here. Your first paragraph seems to suggest people with smarter assistants are indeed deluding themselves by thinking they're necessary. The second suggests you cant be unnecessary because we wont want AGI helping in our homes?

If you want to take care of your parents and do stuff in your home yourself, why would AGI force you not to? Id classify that as entertaining yourself. With purpose sure, but still.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by throwaway290 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @04:30AM (#38330858)
You are only confused if you can't distinguish tech and humanity

> people with smarter assistants are indeed deluding themselves by thinking they're necessary

If they were not necessary then they would not be in a higher up position would they?

> If you want to take care of your parents and do stuff in your home yourself, why would AGI force you not to?

Yes. You can't be rendered useless by tech if tech is there for your benefit. (Though you can be harmed by tech if it is harmful or someone uses it against you for own benefit as part of obsolete dog eat dog society dynamic.)

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by huijzer on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:56PM (#38323048)
> AI, over the long term, will render humans mostly useless.

An extraordinary claim needs extraordinary evidence. If you use the word "may", then I agree. But I don’t think it’s a certainty at this point.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by naveen99 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:03PM (#38323114)
Yeah, why not a mix of carbon and silicon ?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by civilitty on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:51AM (#38320250)
Yes, people that delusional actually exist.

I’m bullish on AI but with comments like that I sympathize with people who think it’s just a bunch of rebranded cryptocoin scammers.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by thom on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:21AM (#38320532)
I’ll say it as pithily as possible: agriculture was the beginning of work, AI will be the end of it. Those are some significant bookends!
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by haizhung on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:37AM (#38320678)
There will never be an end of work, no matter our technological advancements. At least not while we have capitalism, it just goes straight against its core philosophy.

If I understand it correctly.

Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by Obscurity4340 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:55AM (#38320882)
Do you think its possible to have universal income/"plenty" and not have insane inflation?
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by moralestapia on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:50AM (#38320831)
@DavidSJ's exaggerating. I'd put AI almost on par w/ the invention of the internet but still WAY off agriculture, come on.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by slotrans on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:00PM (#38321620)
It's obviously absurd but yes, people believe it, especially around here.
Re:Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal? by tim333 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:13PM (#38324513)
Yeah, I believe it's bigger than agriculture. Agriculture was just food. AI may be immortality if we kind of merge.