News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by jasoneckert on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:17PM (#38077318)
I remember each of the architecture transitions (M68k->PPC, PPC->x86, x86->ARM), and perhaps the most vivid recollection I have of each one is that it made perfect sense at the time. In other words, it wasn't a surprise move by Apple, and I remember widespread speculation for years beforehand in the broader community (Apple users and otherwise).

PPC offered tremendous promise in the early 1990s at the same time Motorola's evolution of M68k was lackluster at best - so it made perfect sense that Apple would need to migrate away from M68k, and PPC was the optimal choice so as not to compete directly with hardware used by the PC market.

And when Intel/AMD were innovating tremendously in the early 2000s while IBM was lagging with bringing out aggressive updates to their PPC line, the switch to Intel seemed inevitable.

Even the idea that Apple should heavily develop their ARM mobile chips for future Apple products was discussed heavily in my circles since about 2016 (around the same time Intel started to stagnate their offerings). The earliest I remember was this blog from 2011: https://www.mattrichman.net/apple-and-arm-sitting-in-a-tree/.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by HappyDaoDude on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:42PM (#38077572)
There was that moment when a friend had a Dual G5 PowerMac only to have it trampled in performance by the new Core Duo Mac Mini. That was when we knew Apple had made the right move. I called the G5 tower (Steve's shame), you could just tell that every time those fans kicked into top gear that there was a sense of shame that that thing even shipped.

The M1 felt like that all over again. I didn't really get that feeling during the 68K to PPC era but that also wasn't handled as gracefully.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by leventonportera on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:01PM (#38077781)
The reason the M1 felt like that, is because you keep comparing old crappy apple to new better apple at every step. Here in the real world, when the M1 came out I was using a precision laptop with (if remembering correctly) 128GB ECC RAM, an 8-core Xeon, and a 1TB NVME SSD. I think it was a 4k boarderless screen, and the battery went about 8-10 hours if I wasn't compiling anything. I looked at the M1, and was in no way impressed.

No real ECC RAM - just the in-DIMM ECC, which isn't ECC at all - it's just there because the RAM is so dense you'd get corruption from regular use w/o it. When you have 128GB or RAM, and you work with medical or financial data, you really need ECC from CPU to RAM. I also could only get half the RAM I need for work - this enterprise "pro" laptop had less max RAM than literally every competitor. I ran some GPU-meter thing, and the discrete Nvidia card on my laptop beat the pants off of apple's new toy. I ran a data processing perl script that took over lunch to run on my laptop. The M1 laptop took half the day.

Now, unplugged, the M1 actually did Better than the Dell. When the Dell got fast, is if I plugged in the 180W powerbrick - or maybe it was even 250W - it was big, and it got quite warm. The laptop sounded like a desktop with its fan on max. The M1 was quiet but about the same very warm temp.

Here's the thing - when I want it to be fast to do large data processing, I'm probably going to have it plugged in. For real intensive work, I don't care about performance per watt. And when I need it to be portable in a conference room or cafe, both the Dell and the M1 are insanely overpowered anywise.

So, I agree with you that it "felt like that all over again" - because you were all over again, comparing the last-gen crap Apple likes to sell during the current year, to the absolutely average stuff they sell now. The thing is, for Apple's price, you don't have to buy the average stuff from not-Apple. You could buy top of the line stuff that puts Apple to shame.

I'm not some Intel fanboy - I've worked on and bought lots of Apple stuff for decades for my hobbies. Done lots of photoshop, 3ds max, after effects, protools, etc. That's just what that industry works on. But please don't pretend it's something revolutionary. The revolutionary part of Apple is getting people to believe their absolutely overpriced average shiny toys are revolutionary.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by scarface_74 on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:05PM (#38077832)
And the M1 MacBook was quieter, lighter and I could actually sit it on my lap without worrying whether it would prevent me from having little Scarface74’s.

Apple didn’t come out with high end ARM Mac laptops until later. Yes from a laptop - a portable computer - I loved being able to plug it in overnight and to use it all day at a customer’s site without worrying about battery life.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by jwells89 on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:11PM (#38079303)
> And the M1 MacBook was quieter, lighter and I could actually sit it on my lap

Yeah this is key. In a laptop that’s meant to be used as a laptop, designing for maximum power at all costs isn’t the winning move. M1 was nice in that it’s plenty powerful while also not making the laptop’s fans scream and being able to survive away from an outlet for several hours despite doing “real work”.

In short, balance, which is still surprisingly hard to come by in x86 laptops. If you want a 10lb monster desktop replacement, gaming laptop that does the 2016 Apple thing and crams too many watts into too thin of a chassis, or a really weak ultraportable with mediocre battery life you’ve got plenty of options. If you want reasonable performance with great battery life and silence however you’re restricted to a tiny handful of options.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by scarface_74 on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:53PM (#38079651)
On the other hand, if you want balls to wall performance on a desktop computer, Apple has nothing.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by jwells89 on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:04PM (#38079742)
I feel like most people with those needs aside from a handful of corporate purchasers are going to be building their own towers anyway, which Apple is going to have a hard time competing with even if they fixed the current issues with the Mac Pro towers.

It would be interesting if Apple took a crack at an M-series HEDT variant that’s allowed to chug electricity freely though, even if that’d be extremely niche.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by scarface_74 on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:07PM (#38079761)
Apple had an answer for that market with the last generation x86 Mac Pro.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by leventonportera on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @01:24AM (#38080658)
I don't disagree with anything you said. If you not the comment to which I was replying, I am addressing the specific point that the M1 was a revolutionary boost in performance, which it was not. Apple's Pro stuff (Intel) at the time was a year behind everyone else on specs. When their Pro stuff came out - sorry, but even the M2 isn't "Pro" anything.

What I am doing is comparing top of the line from Apple, to top of the line period. And consistently, Apple is always behind on workhorses, to get work done. They are better in your "light quiet slightly longer battery" category. At 50% more cost. The free laptop from work - I want the most powerful portable thing available. For personal life, now way I'm paying the Apple tax. So - no use case in my life. I do always get my wife iphones and macbooks though. She teaches languages to little kids and I don't want to spend my time helping her with tech stuff, so the Apple tax is worth it. But never for the hardware - just for the walled garden and fisher-price UI for kids.

The Precision is not light, but that's because it's thick metal that you can run over with a car, and extremely durable. No one complained about a thinkpad being built sturdy. For the use case you describe, an XPS with an I7 at the time was super light, got about over 10 hours of battery life if you just did regular office work (no compiling or large data processing), and has similar specs. I used to take that with when I'd go internationally. It absolutely did not get hot - the key was to turn off turbo boost if on battery by setting max CPU at 99%.

The thing is, if we compare pricepoints, you could have a Precision for the cost of an M1, and now you have desktop power on the go. It's not super-light, but it's still light and thin enough to put in a shoulder bag and not get neck pain.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:41AM (#38082743)
No one complained about a laptop pre 2020 that had bad battery life, was loud and hot because both Macs and Windows were using x86 laptops.

Just like no one complained about the clunky Nomad before the iPod was introduced. Then only CmdrTaco complained (deep cut. It’s a 20+ year old reference)

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Wytwwww on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:11AM (#38082966)
> They are better in your "light quiet slightly longer battery" category. At 50% more cost.

The cost is/was comparable to higher end XPS and Thinkpads.

> you could have a Precision for the cost of an M1,

It's a perfectly valid choice, that doesn't mean other people can't/don't have different preferences which are just as as yours valid.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by xcv123 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:34AM (#38080360)
> when the M1 came out... I looked at the M1, and was in no way impressed.

The original M1 was released a year before the Pro version and was optimized for performance per watt, and was marketed as such, therefore your rant is pointless, comparing totally different types of machines for different purposes. The original M1 definitely had superior performance per watt than your Xeon at the time.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Wytwwww on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:04AM (#38082908)
> an 8-core Xeon, > and the battery went about 8-10 hours

I find that very hard to believe. Also how much did this "laptop" weight and how thick was it? Presumably it was in an entirely different market segment and not competing with the MacBook Pro. It's almost like comparing the M1 to a desktop...

The XPS was the equivalent Dell product and I don't recall it being particularly better than a Mac back in the 2018-2019.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by flenserboy on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:23PM (#38078814)
My memories of the 68k to PPC transition are mostly watching the new machines reboot, reboot, & reboot some more.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by HappyDaoDude on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @08:12PM (#38093067)
Your memories are spot on. ;)
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by dylan604 on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:00PM (#38079717)
Didn't Apple start shipping water cooled overclocked CPUs just to get some sort of a speed bump when the CPUs topped out? Was that the G5 you mentioned?
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by einr on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @04:08AM (#38081534)
Yes, Apple shipped the top tier PowerMac G5s with water cooling, including the top-of-the-line quad-core (2 x dual core) models. I don't think they were overclocked, they just ran extremely hot at stock speeds.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by xattt on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:17AM (#38082558)
These topped out at 2.7 GHz. The water coolers ended up developing leaks, for which Apple was sued.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by RetroTechie on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:38PM (#38077520)
> PPC offered tremendous promise in the early 1990s at the same time Motorola's evolution of M68k was lackluster at best

Apple entered into a trio with IBM & Motorola to develop the PowerPC in early 90's.

But at that time, there already was MIPS around.

Anyone know why this PowerPC project was started despite that? Especially if -per the article- the main goal was to move from CISC to RISC?

Even if MIPS cpus around at the time had performance/W issues (I've no idea yes or no), then improving technology for existing ISA would be easier than inventing entire new architecture, no? (+ all the software tools)

And there was also SPARC then.

So why invent new wheel, vs. improve MIPS (or SPARC) & use that? Not-invented-here syndrome? Licensing issues?

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by datadeft on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:27PM (#38078036)
Apple at the time of the x86 switch was roughly 3% of the PPC chip market.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:38PM (#38078196)
Huh. What was yet other 97?
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by gumby on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:24PM (#38079418)
IBM and a lot of systems that had been 68K. Though the architectures were different a lot of 68K assumptions were maintained in the PPC so porting was easier.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by philwelch on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:38AM (#38080396)
In part, all three 7th generation game consoles (PS3, Xbox 360, Wii).
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by datadeft on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:35AM (#38081333)
Printers, game consoles, supercomputers.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Someone on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @05:41AM (#38082261)
[delayed]
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Sardtok on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:57PM (#38078496)
This is the 68K->PPC switch about a decade earlier.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by sillywalk on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:12PM (#38078699)
They AIM alliance also wanted to end the Wintel Duopoly. Adopting SPARC would help out Sun Microsystems, which I believe was the leader in workstations at the time.

MIPS was to be used as one of the 'standard' reference platforms for the Advanced Computing Environment[0] or Advanced RISC Computing (?) (the other being X86), that would run Windows NT.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Computing_Environment

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by microtherion on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:33PM (#38078938)
PowerPC was not really an entirely new architecture, it was a downsized implementation of the POWER architecture which IBM had already been shipping in workstations for a few years.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by scarface_74 on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:00PM (#38077774)
Apple was much more open about future plans in the early 90s. Apple talked about the PPC transition long before hardware was available and said they were switching to PCI for the second generation PPC Mac’s before the first generation ones ever shipped or slightly thereafter.

But it seems clear that Apple is going to have the same problem with ARM that it had with PPC. It’s already falling behind on the high end. The ARM MacPro is laughably incapable compared to high end x86 processors and they still have no GPU story to compete with Nvidia on the high end.

I’m sure Apple could design something capable of competing with high end Intel CPUs. They just don’t have the stomach for it because the market for really high end Mac’s are so small.

Whether it matters is the question.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by datadeft on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:25PM (#38078021)
Any time this comes up I try to entertain the idea of using a much faster computer without MacOS and then realize that the OS is ~70% of the complete user experience for me. I am not sure what percentage of users are like that. I have ptsd just thinking about the whole multivendor fuckery what it means to have hardware devices with drivers that barely work most of the time. After using a computer on a daily basis for three decades I have no idea why people wasting time with bad software other than being a work requirement. I still use Windows for work and the amount of time is wasted on that platform is insane. The majority of staff at current co agrees that Windows is a dead end. The most notable ‘innovation’ ms has in win11 is the removal of adjustable scrolling direction. I seriously thought it was a joke that was executed somebody at ms trolling people just to even consider using win11. Apparently this is ok.

Anyways, back to the subject if Apple start to ship Raspberry Pis from tomorrow then I still don’t care and buy Apple until they ruin MacOS, in which case I switch to a job that does not require a computer.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by eru on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:49PM (#38080050)
Linux works pretty well these days, too.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Clamchop on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:51AM (#38081102)
As a happy Mac convert, the drivers are not perfect (video is especially buggy and Sonoma only made it worse). I personally experienced driver issues very rarely mostly on machines I personally built (the story for OEM-qualified configurations is even better) and Windows does plenty better than the Mac UI, in my opinion.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by ashirviskas on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:01AM (#38081152)
> I have ptsd just thinking about [...] what it means to have hardware devices with drivers that barely work most of the time.

Same, but for my macbook pro. Bluetooth implementation is borked and I can't even use a single device properly - I have to constantly unpair/pair my headphones. If I use 2 devices there is some stuttering in sound. But if I use 3 - all devices stutter, unless I kill some bluetooth daemon, then it works normaly for 2-5 seconds and goes into the bork mode again.

But then the software is awful too:

1. Switching between workspaces takes up to a full second before the new workspace becomes active even after disabling all animations

2. Some windows just randomly decide to not show the three control buttons and it becomes impossible to close them without messing with the process.

3. For simple screen recording I have to open Quicktime player. Then the screenshot tool becomes screen recording tool with no apparent way to return it back to the screenshot tool.

And these are just the ones I experienced this/last week. Don't get me started on mouse getting stuck in a secondary monitor or disappearing completely and other shitty UX experiences I've had being forced to work with macos for the past 2 years. Can't wait to move away and not look back.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by 0xdb on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:02PM (#38088876)
Can't comment on the Bluetooth issue, since Apple devices have the least BT issues for me by far. But for screen recording there's the cmd+shift+5 shortcut (or the Screenshot App) to do the same thing without opening Quicktime player.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by ashirviskas on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:17AM (#38126265)
It is the only platform giving these bluetooth headaches and the reason my nice BT headset sat in the closet for almost a year.

Regarding the screenshots, I've just learned these shortcuts, but if I open the screenshot tool using CMD + Spacebar + "screenshot", it often just defaults to screen recording and I see no option to switch that.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by sillywalk on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:15PM (#38078723)
In terms of maximum RAM, I also wonder if their Unified Memory is also a factor. there's only so much you can cram into a single SOC. I suppose they could support off-chip stuff, but something something bandwidth.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Clamchop on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:31AM (#38080994)
If they developed a competent eGPU implementation (currently entirely unsupported in Silicon Macs as far as I know), then that and another tier or two of CPU options fitted into the Studio line sounds more like Apple's style. The trashcan, for all its misgivings, was still pleasantly small and a small, quiet workstation bolstered by exclusively external expansion strikes me as ever-so-Apple.

And of course we keep the Mac Pro above that, meant for almost nobody.

You're right, they don't appear to be chasing these markets aggressively right now, but some of the stuff they're doing suggests that might change.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by ngcc_hk on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:33PM (#38078115)
The Intel is a surprise.

Others are natural evolution as the original cpu is a seemingly deadend, even though powerPC did move on and still some embedded 68k. But the salesmanship of steve can bring you that long n that platform is a miracle. Having the struggle later with wintel is hard as intel is really improved a lot.

Still a surprise as even steve said we have a secret project keeping next sorry osx I meant on intel as an option.

Love his presentation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JcHQXMAd0c0

Btw he said the osx transition will last us next 20 years. Just dong it and by 2025 intel no more!

Wonder what is the next transition.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by ksec on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:03PM (#38078583)
Oh it started way before 2016, I remember it was somewhat discussed within some circles in 2009 / 2010 already. At least in the hardware industry enthusiast forum. Remember Apple brought P.A. Semi in 2008. Partnered with Samsung Foundry. And Mac Tablet would come in 2009 before we know it as iPad in 2010 . There were talks / rumours and push of Intel becoming a foundry in 2011, and later 2013 they announced Intel Custom Foundry. [1]

There were lots and lots of signals in the background that Apple is serious about their chip strategy all the way back in 2009. It wasn't so much about switching to ARM as an ISA, which is somehow what most people focused on. But switching to self designed and fabbed SoC for cost efficiency. And that was before the internet knew anything about TSMC or Semiconductor Foundry.

[1] I still remember I gave another year to Intel to see if they improve their strategy but BK was simply a complete failure. Decided to bet against Intel and bought AMD at below $3 a share.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by sillywalk on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:29PM (#38078882)
Ironically(?) PA Semi was working on a POWER ISA processor[0], after Apple made the switch to from PowerPC to Intel.

Though it look like those working @ PA Semi helped design both the Alpha and StrongARM processors.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PWRficient

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by tambourine_man on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @09:23PM (#38107771)
Yes, we were all speculating PA Semi’s PWRficient PPC chips were the future of laptop chips on Macs. I remember being very exited about that on MacRumors and ArsTechnica forums.

Apple always wanted to make their own chips (see Alan Kay’s famous quote), they just lacked the volume.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Clamchop on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @01:18AM (#38080627)
To my memory, it was known that Apple had been maintaining an x86 build of OS X for some time, so it wasn't completely out of left field.

But, it still felt surprising, if only for their intense marketing painting Intel processors as slow and their PowerMacs as "supercomputers," which still hits for its brazen absurdity. Then to turn the narrative on its head in one keynote!

That's marketing for you.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by pasc1878 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @04:12AM (#38081556)
Early versions of OSX (well Rhapsody) were release on x86 and the underlying OS ran on several other chips so really well known.